• Share:
  • Send to Reddit
  • Send to StumbleUpon
  • Send to Facebook
  • Send to del.icio.us
  • Send to digg

"uncommon" ingredients in dressing/stuffing

I've always been fascinated by the millions of variations in dressing (or stuffing, if that's your preferred term). A friend of mine, who's the same way, reports that her family's dressing includes milk as part of the liquid. She's never heard of anyone else doing that, but it turns out that another friend's family dressing uses milk, too. (Same part of the state, interestingly.) I'd also never heard of hard-cooked eggs in dressing until I was having a nce conversation with a lady in line waiting for a cashier early one Black Friday morning in Plano, TX. I believe she thought I was a little wacko, when I questioned her further about the egg.....

Other odd ingredients? Thoughts on how they get in there?

18 Comments:

I posted this on another thread but I will repeat it here. My Mother's dressing includess stale bread crumbs (she buys the bread a couple of weeks in advance and lets them dry out before grating into crumbs - and believe me, nothing else will do!) She adds lots of lemon zest & a bit of juice, chopped onions lightly fried in a bit of bacon fat, raw bacon pieces, salt and lots of pepper, and the surprise - crumbled summer savoury - we always use the savoury from Newfoundland - Mount Scio (I believe it is online, but summer savoury is available on spice racks) - no sage or other spices needed - th bacon pieces helpd to keep the dressing moist whilst adding flavour, and, oh my goodness, it is always delicious and always a big hit. She dresses the cavity of the turkey and then fills the "other end" with sausage stuffing. There is never any left for the next day.

Wow. That sounds great, but it also sounds like a double batch would be even greater. So where's Mom from? And is that what she grew up with?

dried cranberries and pecans

Oysters! I've heard that this is a Pennslyvania thing (where my grandma is from), but here in Oregon, I used to get straaange looks for making oyster stuffing.

Hi "lemons" - I am Canadian but my Mom was a British war bride - she learned to cook from her Mother, who was "in service" - she was a cook in the kitchen of a wealthy family. We have benefitted from a wealth of cooking knowledge!

cheap wine, not sure how atypical this is, but I love it!

Oysters are really pretty common, but they're a very controversial addition, too. My grandmother, who was raised in rural Missouri, used them, and we have No Idea of how on earth they got into her cooking repertoire.

My classic oyster story has to do with many years ago in my earlier marriage, and my MIL's dressing. "Yummy," I commented the first time I ate it. "Are there oysters in it?" "Oh, no," came the reply, "I just use mushrooms." Well, okay, fine. A couple of years later, same table, sme dressing, and I said, "I thought you said you didn't use oysters. But here's a piece." "Oh, no. That's a mushroom." Later on, doing dishes, my SIL said, "Oh, of course there's oysters in it. But my husband insists he hates them, and we just don't tell him."

BF's family puts raisins in their stuffing. I've never heard of such a thing. When he tried mine the other day, he was thrilled that there were no raisins to pick out.

Mashed potatoes. About half and half with the usual dried bread cubes and onions/herbs. Pretty heavy. Apparently Pennsylvania German. I have moved on. Will try bread cubes with onions and lemon this year.

One year my former MIL (I was still married to her son at the time) put apples and sausage in the stuffing. He balked but I loved it- something new!

And speaking of oysters: My current husband's grandfather (may he R.I.P.) was the only one in their family who liked oyster dressing so he'd make a small dish of it for himself. He lived on an Indiana farm his entire life and did not openly embrace alot of foods so this was an amusing surprise to me. He'd eat oysters but hated cheese of any kind- go figure!

I was, oh, about 22 years old before I found out that people stuffed their birds with meat - like, just meat. My bf at the time was telling me about how his family made sausage stuffing, and I said, "oh, we use bacon." He said, "No, I mean, it's stuffed with sweet sausage, mozzarella, and sometimes some pepperoni." I'm Italian, but I was blown away by this.

Since I work for a recipe website, I've seen all kinds. From pineapple to rice, to spinach and artichoke, there are certainly some 'untraditional' stuffing recipes out there!

Hillary
Chew on That

I do not do this at Thanksgiving but I have made White Castle Hamburger dressing (when I lived in Chicago). It was actually really freaking good. Of course now I have to buy them in the freezer section of the local Albertson's... so it is way pricier. If you are lucky enough to live in an area where they have a White Castle - order the hamburgers with no pickles and extra onions.

10 White Castle Hamburgers
1 1/2 cups chopped celery
1 1/4 teaspoons ground thyme
1 1/2 teaspoons ground sage
3/4 teaspoon ground black pepper
1/4 cup chicken broth

Tear the hamburgers into small pieces, and place in a bowl. Toss with celery, thyme, sage, and pepper. Pour in the chicken broth while stirring to moisten the stuffing. This makes enough to stuff a 10 to 12 pound bird.

My father's parents were from Montreal. We called my grandmother's dressing "meat stuffing" (it was fabulous). Ingredients: ground beef, ground pork, onion, small pieces of potato, small amount of nutmeg, cooked on the stove and then the bird was stuffed....delicious! This is basically the same recipe she used for meat pies, the crust for the pies were greasy and heavenly.

My family's stuffing includes:

crumbled ritz crackers
onions (cooked down for a long time in a healthy amount of butter)
ground ham
chopped pecans
heavy cream
parsley

I might be forgetting something, but i think that's it. I think my grandmother clipped it out of the newspaper back when my dad was a kid and we've been making it ever since. I was grown up before I realized that most stuffing involved bread, stock and celery (ick!) People always think it sounds odd...until they've tasted it. AMAZING!

I forgot to mention that my favorite stuffing is: pumpkin sausage cornbread jalapeno stuffing :)

Hillary
Chew on That

My mother put eggs, heavy cream (along with stock), parsley in her stuffing. I do the same but I like to add green peppers and carrots as well. But I like everything in it except the gizzards.

@bareneed - once again, your fellow Canadian (and there are more of us on here too) chimes in - my former MIL, an Acadian from NB, used summer savoury in both stuffing and her meat pies (distinct from the tortiere from Quebec - these were shredded meat filled pies). Interestingly she also used mashed potatoes in her stuffing as mentioned above. Do you still hail from NFLD?

Add a comment:

Comments can take up to a minute to appear - please be patient!

Previewing your comment:

 

HTML Hints

Some HTML is OK: <a href="URL">link</a>, <strong>strong</strong>, <em>em</em>

Comment Guidelines

Post whatever you want, just keep it seriously about eats, seriously. We reserve the right to delete off-topic or inflammatory comments. Learn more at our Comment Policy page.

If you see something not so nice, please, report an inappropriate comment.

Start Talking!

Need a question answered? Have advice to share? Start a Talk topic now!

Sign up to start a talk topic

Sign up to get your questions answered and share advice.