• Share:
  • Send to Reddit
  • Send to StumbleUpon
  • Send to Facebook
  • Send to del.icio.us
  • Send to digg

Turkey Stuffing/Dressing

My family has always gone the traditional route. Bread croutons, celery, onion, butter, sage, poultry seasoning, stock. Some is cooked in the bird and the rest in a casserole dish. We like it with gravy and also cold in a turkey sandwich. I'm even a little squeamish about putting any in the bird these days - Alton scared me.

I've never even tried cornbread stuffing or additions such as sausage, chestnuts, apples. If I were to make such a drastic change, I think there might be mutiny.

If you make stuffing, do you vary or get creative? Care to share your recipes? How do you feel about stuffing the turkey?

37 Comments:

I love country sausage, pine nuts and dried fruit -- cranberries, apricots, or a combination and some times some apples. No real recipe -- just add enough. I cook the meat, then add the fruit and nuts to the bread along with cooked veggies and stock.

I tend not to stuff poultry because it makes it harder to cook the bird. The breast is overdone by the time the stuffing gets hot enough to be safe. But I prefer the flavor of cooking the stuffing in the bird.

SO, when I want a roast chicken with stuffing , I like to pile up the stuffing in the center of the pan and cover it with the butterflied bird. (Just cut out the back bone then flatten the bird.) Then roast it till it's done. Best of all worlds -- the stuffing absorbs the chicken juices, gets nice & crusty on the bottom and the split bird cooks faster and evenly. Never tried that method with a turkey though.

Maglio italian sausage (always), W italian loaf from Wegman's cubed and left out to stale. Onions, celery, shallots, garlic, poultry seasoning, chicken stock, 2 eggs, stick of butter a handful or a parmeggiano/romano mix. Baked outside the bird so there is a crunchy top for those who like crunchy top.

when I used to cook for lots of people I would always make one batch with linguica and chorizo (portugese) and another batch with quahogs(large clams) they didnt get cooked in the bird, because it was just easier to go the caserole route. these day I dont think I would stuff a bird, Alton scared me too, plus if i remember right the stuffing used to get a little gummy tasting in the bird.

Perky--since you're already cooking half in the bird and half out, why not do a different dressing--the ingredients you listed sound great. Why not use cornbread for stuffing, and add some butter, apples, dried fruits like satsumas (golden raisins), sage, thyme, and so forth? Probably any bread you like other than white would add extra flavor.

I guess I'm the only one who isnt scared off by AB. Then again my family has been making it in the bird for decades prior to Good Eats, or, for that matter FN. We use pepperidge farm, jimmy dean regular suasage, celery, onion, butter, chicken stock and, SHHH.... bells seasoning.
Jerzee yours sounds great I think I'll try it in the future. Will any good quality italian sausage do?

As most of my Thanksgiving have been had in the Southern half of the US, we make cornbread stuffing. My grandmother always makes a pan of basic cornbread (self-rising cornmeal, buttermilk, and that's about it), and we crumble it up with some cubed dry bread, chicken stock, sage, and celery and onions softened in butter. My favorite thing is that when my grandmother makes it, she literally doesn't measure anything and can tell when it's just moistened enough with her hands.

Ours is pretty much like Perky's with the addition of mushrooms (we all like them). It is my dad's favorite part of the meal and if there is any left the next day he gets dibs. And prefers the leftovers cold. Delicious. It has to be the mass quantities of butter, which is hilarious, because in a Jewish home (or at least my Jewish home, hehehe) you don't make things with butter to go with meat that often, even if you don't actually keep kosher. Like I find the British and Canadian practice of buttering cold meat sandwiches completely repulsive. But we do love our buttery stuffing. And mashed potatoes!

HoG - sultanas. ;)

I try to vary my "stuffing" year to year. But the one thing that I have been doing consistently for the last 5 is to bake it in large muffin tins. This allows EVERYONE to have the "crunchy" bits.

Last year, I made a sausage based bread stuffing. This year, i might do a pancetta and mashed potato base for it.

Alan

I stuff the turkey between the skin and the breast - makes for a nice moist breast. Then I make stuffing balls to go round the bird. Recipe varies every year, though!. I do like sausagemeat in the balls.

I would like to point out to PerkyMac that cornbread dressing is just as "traditional" as white bread stuffing--whether one or the other is considered traditional depends on which side of the Mason-Dixon line you're on...

Anyone ever use croissants as their base? A friend of mine raved about it but I can't find a recipe on it. Our normal tradition is a sausage based bread stuffing with shrooms and mirepoix.

I typically use a recipe that calls for calvados brandy and apples- it is always a big hit. Last year though I tried a variation and used cranberries and a blackberry brandy that I had on hand which was just as great.

Mine consists of: homemade croutons (I use 9-grain bread from Atlantic bread bakery and whole wheat baguette, small cubes), sweet Italian turkey sausage (the last couple of years, I've made my own maple turkey sausage for the stuffing), crumbled and sauteed with chopped Spanish onions, grated carrots, finely diced celery (which I sometimes omit), diced red and green bell peppers, garlic, dill, parsley, smoked paprika, salt and freshly ground black pepper.

Since I always make two large trays (I have to), I make the second one slightly different - I add pine nuts and sage and omit parsley and smoked paprika. Naturally, eggs and chicken stock are added to both versions, tiny pats of butter dropped on top.

@Lilla ~ by traditional, I meant my own family traditions, and the line we cross is the boundary between the US and Canada, since my mother was Canadian. I love cornbread and always have it with ham, but have never tasted cornbread stuffing. I'm sure it's delicious, just not sure my family would approve it with turkey. I'm also really tempted to at least add a couple of eggs to the dressing casserole. Maybe the next time I'm cooking a turkey breast for just me, I'll experiment a little more. Afterall, I love fruit and sausage is one of the best foods on the planet.

Does everyone use Italian sausage, if they add sausage to their stuffing?

brooke, I'm drooling over your descriptions!!

I keep mine very traditional b/c that's how my husband prefers it. Croutons, diced onion, celery, and carrots, garlic, chicken stock, sage, etc. I was thinking of adding some sausage this year. :)

PerkyMac: your bread stuffing ingredients are pretty much identical to our cornbread dressing (aside from the bread, of course and the cooking vessel). No fruits or sausage or any "weird" additives. No eggs, either, though I've had it with. Eggs just make the dressing more cohesive, which is fine if you want it that way, but no more necessary in dressing than stuffing, imho...

I always do cornbread dressing with butter, diced sweet onions, bell peppers, celery, apple, dried cranberries, chopped walnuts, and a mild sage country sausage cooked and crumbled in, wet it down with chicken stock till it gets to that right consistency then bake it off in the oven to get a crusty browned top to it.

I tried to make stuffing once many years ago. It was SO bad! It was so sloppy, I dumped it down the disposal and never tried again.

as a vegetarian who loves stuffing, i make it with vegetable stock and outside the bird, so that others like me can enjoy it, and all the omnivores are still pretty happy :) other than that, fairly traditional - mire poix and bread crumbs, parsley and thyme and whatever other herbs seem to look good. no matter how much i intend to follow a recipe, my cooking usually ends up being a sort of grab and add and taste and repeat process.

We make a bread and potato stuffing which I presume is Pennsylvania German. We cook potatoes, onion, celery, and red bell pepper in chicken broth. Put that through a food mill and mix with dried bread cubes; marjoram; thyme; sage; chopped parsley, onion and red bell pepper; and lots of butter. Use enough dry bread to keep it from getting sloppy. Bake in casserole.

My mom got a great recipe from a great-aunt on my dad's side that is a zucchini "stuffing". I always seem to make 500 lbs of it. It's super good, but 75% of it seems to end up going down the disposal just because of the sheer volume.

It uses almost equal parts of sauteed zucchini and dry dressing (packaged, but not instant) and some onion that was sauteed w/the zucca. Mix in a bunch of broth and a can of cream of chicken - though I guess cream of mushroom would work really well and some grated carrot. It's probably twice as good as it must sound.

Hi Perky!
We make our stuffing just like yours. My mom used to put raisins in it too, but since my sister has been doing Thanksgiving last year & this year, and she doesn't like raisins, those are out now. I like it just the way it is...with lots of Bell's poultry seasoning for flavor!

Apple, onion, celery, lots of fresh sage and fresh poultry seasoning. I use half cornbread and half French bread. We always cook the dressing in a separate dish.

I think I might try NuJoi's method of combining bread and cornbread stuffings and adding some apple. That would be a good beginning for change without being too drastic.

@izatryt ~ if your stuffing is too wet, just cook it longer or add more bread to soak up the stock. It's all trial and error, not scientific, to get it to how you and your family like it. Add your seasonings carefully and taste. It's a lot easier to add more than compensate for overdoing it. I've never heard anyone complain that there was too much stuffing!

The Pennsylvania Dutch do mix stuffing and mashed potatoes. I had never seen that before I moved here. It tastes great, but I wouldn't want it in place of either on Thanksgiving.

Thanks to all for your suggestions. I can't wait to try sausage, but I'm still not sure what kind of sausage would taste best.

@Perky - you absolutely should try sausage, it's delicious! As I mentioned, I usually use sweet Italian turkey sausage (or homemade turkey sausage), since you know, it is a Turkey day:-). Plus, it goes perfectly with my both version - parsley & smoked paprika and sage & pine nuts. But frankly, I think it depends on your personal taste, whichever you like will work if your seasoning compliments it.

Thanks brooke! I've had chicken sausage and loved it, so turkey should be wonderful, too. I always use sage in my stuffing, so I'd tend toward that one. I'd have to have someone pick it up for me - I think the chicken sausage came from Trader Joe's. I'd want extra for other dishes too. Thanks for the suggestion!

I LOVED the stuffing my aunt made last year. It was sausage pumpkin cornbread stuffing, how good does that sound? Here is the recipe:

Ingredients

3/4 lb. sweet Italian sausage, casings removed
2 jalapeƱos, minced (with seeds)
12 corn muffins or two 8 1/2-oz. corn-bread mixes, prepared and crumbled (10 C.)
1 15-oz. can pumpkin
1 14-oz. can chicken or vegetable broth
1 C. dried cranberries
1/4 C. chopped fresh sage or 1 heaping Tbs. dried sage

Directions

In a large skillet over medium heat, cook the sausage and jalapeƱos, breaking up the meat and cooking until it is no longer pink. Drain the fat. Add the corn bread. Fold in the pumpkin, broth, cranberries, and sage. Cook for 45 minutes in a 350-degree oven.

This can be made up to 1 day ahead. Cover and refrigerate. For drier stuffing, omit the broth.

Hillary
Chew on That

I have a lot of vegetarians in my family, so I make my stuffing outside the bird (don't like how slimy it gets when stuffed in the bird, anyway). I use potato bread, celery, onions, sage, thyme, apples, cranberries, and veg stock. Sometimes an egg or two in the mix. And sometimes I'll boil just a couple of potatoes and mash them up and add them in. It gives it a great consistency. Oh, and of course enough butter to make Paula Deen proud.

Oh, and I always use fresh bread, not croutons.

I'm a purist when it comes to dressing (I'm from the South) and nothing but traditional cornbread dressing (homemade of course) will do!

I do the usual crap that you listed in the stuffing but I also add eggs, aand cream. I always make my "private reserve" that includes oysters

Dressing only, no stuffing here in New Orleans, unless you are having Turducken. My family would revolt if there were no oyster dressing. It's basically oysters, french bread, the trinity and some seasoniing. However, my favorite is Bruce Aidells Andouille and Cornbread dressing. I have brought double recipes to many potlucks and it disppears instantly. The recipe is available at epicurious.

Hey Pam, come on ovah, and bring me that dressing!

@PAM we are planning to order from LA a turduncken this year, never had it b4, do you have a place you order it to share?

I just put my turkey in the oven - with potato bread stuffing - onions, celery, poultry seasoning, egg, stock, butter, and a bit of garlic. Can't wait!

@pjracz10. i've noticed a few markets in seattle are carrying them, cajun grocer is the best place to order on the web, but you have to get express shipping now.
http://www.cajungrocer.com/fresh-foods-holiday-dishes-turducken-c-1_15_24.html

I second (third, fourth, ..) the use of sage sausage in dressing. We make two kinds, traditional bread with just the seasonings and sauteed vegetables, and a bread-cornbread stuffing with toasted pecans, sauteed vegetables that include garlic and carrots, plus some chopped cranberries that also are sauteed. I make the bread and cornbread myself because I prefer the way it tastes. Oh, both have eggs and butter.

Yummy!

Add a comment:

Comments can take up to a minute to appear - please be patient!

Previewing your comment:

 

HTML Hints

Some HTML is OK: <a href="URL">link</a>, <strong>strong</strong>, <em>em</em>

Comment Guidelines

Post whatever you want, just keep it seriously about eats, seriously. We reserve the right to delete off-topic or inflammatory comments. Learn more at our Comment Policy page.

If you see something not so nice, please, report an inappropriate comment.

Start Talking!

Need a question answered? Have advice to share? Start a Talk topic now!

Sign up to start a talk topic

Sign up to get your questions answered and share advice.