Fruit Desserts. Acquired taste or bluffing contest?
Occasionally, I'll try some kind of compote or fruit based cream pie, but they really never scratch my dessert itch. I noticed a lot of people over the age of 30 seeming to enjoy them over the holiday. So, my question: Are fruit desserts an acquired taste, like coffee, or a mere bluffing contest, like Scotch?
Add a comment:
Previewing your comment:
HTML Hints
Some HTML is OK: <a href="URL">link</a>, <strong>strong</strong>, <em>em</em>
Comment Guidelines
Post whatever you want, just keep it seriously about eats, seriously. We reserve the right to delete off-topic or inflammatory comments. Learn more at our Comment Policy page.
If you see something not so nice, please, report an inappropriate comment.
Start Talking!
Need a question answered? Have advice to share? Start a Talk topic now!
Sign up to get your questions answered and share advice.

34 Comments:
I don't personally like cooked fruit. I will use preserves and conserves on tarts and pastries and cookies. But cooked fruit to me is nasty. I will however eat a nice warm apple pie, go figure.
JerzeeTomato at 10:43PM on 11/30/08
Wait, you think Scotch is a bluffing contest?
wookie at 10:52PM on 11/30/08
Honestly, to me stewed fruit compote is more a curiosity, something reminiscent of old Russian dining rooms, where you wish babci had maybe instead baked something instead of boiled the living daylights out if it.
A fruit compote might be ok OVER something, like pound cake or good ice cream. But I'd still prefer something baked, with chocolate. And I'm wellll over 30.
moibec at 10:58PM on 11/30/08
@ wookie. yes. I just had some 32 year Lagavulian and it tasted, to me, like band-aids. Everyone else was saying "petey" and "oakey" and "mossy" so, I said "band-aid." It got a good chuckle, and I left before I was suckered into the cigar portion of the evening.
Keight at 11:17PM on 11/30/08
Fruit dessert? Lemon mousse? Blackberry cobbler? Strawberry shortcake? For that matte, strawberries, sour cream and brwn sugar? What's the problem?
lemons at 11:18PM on 11/30/08
I cannot eat cooked or dried fruit at all, not on their own, not in pies, not in any other shape or form. The only jams and preserves that I eat are those that don't contain chunks of fruit (other than orange marmalade - but those orange rinds aren't really cooked fruit, are they now?)
However, I do love fresh berries with zabaglione for dessert, always have. So even to me, an enjoyable fruit dessert is certainly possible.
brooke29 at 11:20PM on 11/30/08
I love fruit desserts...especially after eating a really heavy meal, when I can't even think about chocolate. I never even knew anyone had a problem with them! Lemons - I'm with you!
KateRuby at 11:28PM on 11/30/08
@ brooke. are you 29? Just wondering if, at midnight on our birthdays. . .
Keight at 11:29PM on 11/30/08
I just know I'm giving myself away as unrefined when I say "Hork City!"
Keight at 11:33PM on 11/30/08
@Keight - nope, I've already turned into a pumpkin or whatever it is one turns into at midnight on their 30th birthday (my birthday is on the 29th though, hence the number I reckon). Yet, no cooked fruit for me!
brooke29 at 11:44PM on 11/30/08
@keight--Lagavulin 32 year? Nice. I like your pronouncement of "band-aids" during the tasting. Lagavulin, and Islay malts in general, seem to me to have a large component of iodine, both on the nose and the finish (in addition to alot of peat). So, "band-aids" work for me.
As for the cooked fruit for dessert...I've always loved a great apple pie a la mode. It was my breakfast of choice when I was in high school. But then again, I've been told I have an old soul.
Like @brooke29, I love fresh berries with zabaglione. Heck, I'm a fan of fresh fruit in general. Especially during the warmer months when so much fruit is spectacular.
And it's really hard for me to turn down chocolate, unless it's chocolate mixed with raspberries...never been a big fan of that combination.
Mostly, though, I go through phases where I'm insane about something like Key Lime Pie for a few months...then back to chocolate...then onto creamy desserts...
wookie at 1:41AM on 12/01/08
my mouth waters at the mere mention of a crumble, cobbler, buckle, grunt ...
any combination of fruit, butter, sugar (usually brown) and some nice warm spices, baked till gooey, is a sure hit with me.
i'm way below 30, so i don't fit that stereotype, but i do happen to be canadian - is it the cold winter factor that drives us northerners to warm, comforting desserts? just a hypothesis ...
jojojo at 2:03AM on 12/01/08
@Keight: I personally agree with your assessment of whisky, but there are those who genuinely love it; my boyfriend is one of them, and he's the sort who simply will not eat or drink something if he doesn't like it. There's just no explaining tastes for things (e.g. I love licorice, and so do plenty of others in the EU countries, but in the States, it is generally loathed)
I personally like some fruit desserts, and have since I was little, but it has to be the right sort of fruit, and the fruit has to be really good too often, crap fruit is used for fruit desserts, with the idea that 'it won't matter'... HAH! A mealy apple is a mealy apple, and it will make a horrible compote. Also, you can't just take a bunch of fruit, and cook it with added sugar, and hope it will make a fantastic dessert (and I can think of no reason to make a less-than-fantastic-dessert). Stewed fruit and many compotes and leave me wondering what the cook was thinking... Let's not forget that fruit pies are fruit desserts, too, and can be brilliant. And cherry-chocolate pie strikes me as a sound argument for the existence of a benevolent god.
But I'm not certain why a fruit dessert has to involve cooked fruit; if someone says 'fruit dessert' to me, I find myself thinking (and hoping) 'fresh alpine strawberries'. With nothing.
mongoose at 4:37AM on 12/01/08
Nothing beats a good strawberry shortcake, mojito fruit salad, or meringue nest filled with mixed berries during the summer. During the cooler months, I'm partial to a fruit crisp with a dollop of vanilla ice cream or warm custard sauce. Does a crepe filled with a slathering of nutella, a dash of Grand Marnier, and a mixture of sliced strawberries and bananas count as a fruit dessert?
Esmeralda at 5:31AM on 12/01/08
I love cooked fruit desserts and yes, I'm over 30. Summer Pudding is one of my favorites but I'll do any kind of fruit pie or crisp. Crisps and cobblers are especially attractive to me because guests can help themselves to as much (or little) as they like and not be limited to a portion size that's doled out on a plate.
As a matter of fact, it's got to be 102 in the shade before I'll crave a piece of cold fruit.
therealchiffonade at 6:29AM on 12/01/08
Who doesn't love tarte tatin, or strawberry shortcake?! I love them, I just don't love them in my Scotch... Speaking of.... @Keight, if you get a chance to go back where the tasting was... Grab me a bottle of 32 yr. old Band-Aids!
Now I do believe Scotch is an aquired taste. When I began my long and sometimes illustrious and not always distinguished drinking career, I couldn't stand Scotch... In fact I used to mix blended scotch (Johnny Walker Black) with coke! Now I'll take my scotch (single malt Lagavulin)with a little water or a good sized chunk of ice. As far as blended scotch is concerned.... well it's just that.... blended scotch and by it's very nature, not true scotch.
As for Fruit desserts, I'm not quite sure what to think. I have always loved fruit desserts, and I can't imagine that changing anytime soon. I think that may just be a personal preference. Perhaps you are more of a chocolate fan...hmmm.... chocolate covered band-aids maybe?! Or... Perhaps not.
Pavlov at 8:20AM on 12/01/08
I love fruit desserts, and I'm under 30. Apple pie and applesauce, any sort of fruit jam, cobblers, tarts, fruit sauces, compote, berry pie, lemon meringue or key lime pie, poached pears...heck, fruitcake. I'll eat 'em all. Fruit desserts are probably my favorite type of dessert, but they haven't always been. I definitely remember preferring chocolate or cream-based pies, etc., when I was younger...apple pie is definitely my favorite now. But I also eat piles and piles of fresh fruit when it's in season - cooked fruit desserts are only for fall/winter.
producestories at 8:46AM on 12/01/08
I like my fruit fried and dipped in chocolate.
juliebugsmama at 9:42AM on 12/01/08
I'm 23, and I love fruit-based desserts. Pies, shortcake, crisps, cobblers, shortcake, baked apples - count me in!
KarynMC at 10:04AM on 12/01/08
Everything fruit is good.. except figgy pudding.. that was kinda gross. Fresh peach pie??? Banana? apple cranberry.
seikel at 10:16AM on 12/01/08
Heh. I still don't drink coffee and I do like Scotch. I also like fruit desserts, but not the awful ones like the packets of mixed dried fruit cooked until they are DEAD. I do like baked apples, and Peach Melba, and most pies. I have also done fresh fruit pies where you bake a sweet crust, add a layer of pudding or sweetened cream cheese, and then fresh fruit in a design. A light glaze (such as heated and thinned apple jelly) and it's fantastic.
Being from the south, I also eat things like ambrosia, and with relatives in Hawai'i we learned about grilled pineapple. So it might be a locality thing. It's a lot easier to get fresh fruit more of the year in those places, and so I grew up eating fruit for dessert more than Northern people might.
morgancain at 10:47AM on 12/01/08
I love most fresh fruit desserts but cooking RUINS, kills, maims and destroys fruit's texture, and so I hate almost all cooked fruit anythings. Exceptions: things in which the fruit is completely mashed or pureed (banana bread, applesauce), or the texture is not ruined (lightly grilled pineapple).
wellred at 11:46AM on 12/01/08
I love fresh fruit, but really don't like fruit desserts. For 'dessert calories,' I spend them on chocolate.
I've always hated fruit-flavored syrups and ice creams, even as a little kid--then my palate was less discriminating, so I would eat pie if offered, but given the choice between pie and chocolate, usually I'd go with the chocolate.
HeartofGlass at 12:17PM on 12/01/08
I've adored fruit desserts since I was just a tot. Nothing got between me and my mom's peach cobbler. I get excited by what many consider mundane desserts: apple crisp, cherry clafouti, blueberry pie, apple pie...I could wax rhapsodic all day about the joys of cobbler but I'll just leave it at that. :)
holdthemayo at 12:39PM on 12/01/08
I'll take my fruit dessert with coffee followed by a nice single malt. Thanks!
VerasTastyFreeze at 1:20PM on 12/01/08
I will agree in the sense that I absolutely can't eat fruit tarts that have that weird glaze which makes the fruit look like it was shellacked into the tart shell. I just really wouldn't even bother wasting the aforementioned "dessert calories".
As for cobblers and crisps and baked fruit or berry desserts, I will go so far as to say I am in love. A well made peach/berry cobbler, apple crisp, blueberry pie with vanilla ice cream is absolute heaven. However, I think I just may be partial to dessert in general...I also consider myself a bit of a key lime pie and chocolate cake connoisseur...
I guarantee if you try to make something yourself and really do some research into homemade baked fruit desserts, you might learn to like them. I don't exactly think they are an acquired taste, it just depends on how you grew up with them. (For me, my mom was all about desserts from scratch...so I'm rather biased)
decemberain27 at 2:21PM on 12/01/08
I get where you're coming from, but can you really not be satisfied by a gooey peach cobbler or an extra-tart key lime pie?!
kazoinker at 2:27PM on 12/01/08
actually i would far rather eat something citrus based than chocolate for dessert after dinner. i'm a sucker for lemon tart or key lime pie.
and as far as peach, apricot, apple, blackberry, cherry or rhubarb pie, in season, yes oh yes oh yes.
cybercita at 2:37PM on 12/01/08
I agree about the Scotch, but I just don't know what to tell you about the fruit desserts. It really depends on the mood for me, so perhaps it is an age thing? Although, I'm only 21, so I don't know which way that leans on the age thing ...
@Pavlov -- mojito fruit salad?? Do tell!
kfarrel3 at 1:05AM on 12/02/08
Mmmmmm poached pears with vanilla and saffron. Need I say more?
vegemite at 1:58AM on 12/02/08
For me to enjoy a fruit dessert it needs some kind of dairy or other creamy decadent element. IE pie a la mode, or berry pavlova with whipped cream.
ag3208 at 3:23AM on 12/02/08
I like anything fruit pie , but if you make it with cream cheese or whipped cream even better. Always have been that way.
pjracz10 at 12:56PM on 12/02/08
Fruit desserts: a retrospective.
I'm a northerner.
I detest cinnamon.
And scotch. But, I DO like Dewar's, for mixing with soda.
I hate all cooked fruit.
But, I love fresh fruit.
Oh, and I love bourbon and coffee.
Yet, detest chocolate.
I think I've learned a lot about myself. Thank you, serious eats.
Keight at 8:40PM on 12/02/08
@wookie, Thank you! Finally someone else to share my dislike of chocolate and raspberry. I hate it when restaurants ruin a perfectly good chocolate baked good by dumping a nasty raspberry sauce over it. Is it me, or does raspberry taste like cough syrup?
I'm also not a big fan of cooked fruit desserts, either. Wow. I sound REALLY picky. I promise I'm not!
TheCheapChick at 11:17PM on 12/02/08