• Share:
  • Send to Reddit
  • Send to StumbleUpon
  • Send to Facebook
  • Send to del.icio.us
  • Send to digg

stick blender v. food processor

I've been making pureed soups lately, and I've noticed that my food processor (much like when making smoothies) can only do so much. I know blenders do a proper puree (or maybe I'm just not running my food processor long enough?), and I've heard good things about stick blenders, but I'm just not completely sold on its plusses warranting the addition of a new gadget to my kitchen. (I am in fact anti-gadget, but I am sick of not quite pureed soups).

So do stick blenders really trump the food processor for a smooth, creamy puree? Also, could I use a stick blender for beating egg whites? I don't have enough need for a hand mixer, but I'm wondering if a stick blender would be able to serve that function for me - especially since I've seen some that have whisk attachments.

Thoughts?

35 Comments:

I've got the Cuisinart Smart Stick, which comes with a mini food processor and whisk attachment and I love it! It's so much smaller than a regular blender, and comes apart to fit nicely in a drawer - great for those of us who do not like to collect kitchen gadgets.

I use it every morning to make smoothies with frozen fruit, and about twice a week to puree soups (so much easier than transferring to a blender or FP!!). I've had it for 4 - 5 years and it's still going strong.

As for the egg whites, you can use the whisk attachment to beat them, but you have to use a deep bowl or you'll have a mess on your hands. Also beats cream into whipped cream. Highly recommend :)

I use my Braun immersion blender all the time, mostly for pureed soups. The advantage is that the soup doesn't have to be cooled before blending. It's also easy to clean up, and less dangerous, too. Yesterday, I used the immersion blender to blend ingredients for sesame-almond sauce in a measuring cup. Since I was using the measuring cup to measure out coconut milk, anyway, it saved the hassle of cleaning yet another bowl. My Braun came with a whisk attachment (I use it often) and with a chopper attachment (not very impressive performance).

I love my immersion blender- a Braun also. It does whipped cream, soup, etc...and does not take up much room at all in my cabinets. I do have a more basic model-no attachments. But it does everything I want it to and I've never been disappointed. Oh, and be careful of what type of bowl you use for things like whipped cream/egg whites....as bitchincamero said, it will spatter if your container is too shallow. Between my immersion blender and my regular blender, I never miss having a food processor.

@juliec - I use the little chopper to mince garlic, it does a great job! I often mince a couple of heads of garlic at a time, and store it layered with extra virgin olive oil in small glass jars (I use one from Marmite and one from Colman's mustard, they are perfect) - this way, I have flavourful minced garlic on hand (I can't tell you how much better it is than the bland store-bought stuff). I also use lots of fresh garlic daily, so a small Marmite-sized jar rarely lasts for more than a week.

I, too, use my Braun stick blender all the time, for soups, sauces and lots of other things and I'm very pleased with its performance. I find pureeing soups or sauces in a regular blender or a food processor to be way too messy, so the stick blender is the only way to go as far as I'm concerned. As regards egg whites, as juliec mentioned, this Braun stick blender comes with a whisk attachment, so there you go.

I love my stick blender; convenient, inexpensive and versatile. I barely ever use my regular blender...food processor though--that's a must!~

I have a $30 stick blender and while it takes longer to use than the processor, I find it gets thing a little smoother. For the same price, more or less, you can, I believe, try a blender. Or borrow one from a pal to try it. To me, the pleasure of the stick is that I can put it into a simmering pot and break up just some of the vegetables, thickening it somewhat, while retaining most of the original texture. And that's faster, and with less to wash than either a blender or a processor.

The immersion blender is the appliance/gadget I'd keep if someone made me choose from among it, my food processor and my regular blender. As others have written, I've got the model with a small chopper attachment and a large blender jar attachment. I use all of them regularly. It will do a decidedly better job than a food processor and is quite a bit safer than transferring soup from pot to processor and back while hot.

For really smooth soups, you'll also want a mesh strainer. Puree the soup in the pot with your immersion blender and then strain it into serving bowls or a large bowl (or another pot if you need to do more seasoning or add more things).

Stick blenders trump FPs for liquefying soups but I would never forego my FP to own a stick blender. I use my FP for far too many things vs. the occasional liquefying of a soup which I could just as easily do in my regular blender. Luckily, stick blenders don't take up that much space so I wouldn't be put in that awkward position of choosing! :D

I use my cuisinart for different things than my stick blender, however the one I grab when pureeing a soup is the stick blender. I don't have to dirty another container, and I can blend as little or as much of the soup as I want.

My stick blender is probably at least 20 years old now, a krups my mom bought when I was a kid and let me take when I moved out. It's going strong. I've used it for everything from soup to whipping cream to smoothies.

I have been thinking about a stick blender for a while. I have decided I want to make soup this winter. I just checked out bitchincamero's corn chowder recipe because the photo on the SE home page looked fantastic. I will own a stick blender by the weekend! I really think I am getting my food mojo back!!

I too, love both my KitchenAid stick blender and food processor. I agree that using the stick blender for soups is the way to go. You don't have to worry about transferring hot soup, and you have total control over the consistency.

Also the "footprint" of a stick blender, even with attachments, is pretty small. I think it's much more than a one-trick pony. I can't remember the last time I used my regular blender.

Immersion blenders are great. I use mine (actually it's my GF's) all the time.

It's also great for making quick and easy mayo. Just drop one whole egg, lemon juice, salt and a bit of oil in a cylindrical container and blend away adding one cup of oil as you move the blender up and down. It's lighting fast and it'll never break.

i have all three and use all of them for different things. i use my blender mostly in the summer because i live on coffee frappes {a tray of ice cubes, a few spoons of instant espresso, a big splash of milk, a pinch of cardamom, and a big spoonful of sugar, buzzed for a couple of minutes until the ice no longer crunches.} i do love my braun immersion blender and use it quite often in the winter when i am making soup. they're not very expensive and well worth it.

i'll have to try that mayo trick, squeezebottle.

add the stick to your garage! I dont use alot of gadgets either because my apt kitchen is too small to open the dishwasher and fridge at the same time. If SO comes in to help with the cooking we have to leave the room to change our minds. Anyway, the stick i have is an old one i bought for about 25$ 12 yrs ago, i dont use it alot, but when i need it, there is nothing like it! you may be surprised at how many uses it has. i even use mine to make hummus, as well as do the deed to creamy soups.

I love my stick blender. It's the Williams-Sonoma--it was pretty expensive a few years ago and I would not foot that pricetag again--I saw one for $20 the other day which would be sufficient for the amount it's used.
But when I want to use it, it's great.
LOVE it for pureeing soups (carefully) right in the pot. (Of course, I'm always convinced I'll electrocute myself).
I also use it for whipping cream or egg whites with the other attachments.

I definitely thought of it as the other way around. We only have an immersion blender which is great for milkshakes and smoothies but I've been wanting to make pesto and I assumed the food processor would do that job much better.

Hillary
Chew on That

Okay, I am new to the immersion blender world and I have what many of you will probably think is a stupid question, but so be it.

I've only used it once so far, to puree a tomato gravy. Is there supposed to be a vacuum thing that goes on between the stick and the bottom of the container? Because I had to fight the thing to keep it off the very bottom and then I would overcompensate and wind up with gravy all over me and the stove. What am I missing here?

@ Regrettable mine does the same thing if i hold it straight up and down, just try to keep it tilted and wear an apron ;-) I am in the middle of cleaning pureed sweet potatoes off my ceiling, cat+dog+mom in kitchen= new ceiling art. (wonder if they'll believe it was there when we moved in ;-)

@huney ~ You keep your kitchen tools in your garage? Is it because you have a small kitchen? I would think they would smell funny being out there.

I also love my cuisinart with the other attachments, very handy and cleans up easily.

I love this tool and find it great for soups as well as quick salsas (this takes a delicate touch!).

A great use for an immersion blender: if you're making a hollandaise or bearnaise sauce and it breaks, don't throw it out. Pour the sauce in an appropriate container and blend it with the immersion blender while putting in another egg yolk. Then return to the pan to thicken as needed.

It's also great for "cream of X" soups, just reserve a portion ahead of time if you want some full-size chunks of asparagus, broccoli, whatever.

i find food processors make really nice puree only if there is very little liquid. so for a soup strain out the solids, puree them, then whisk the liquid back in.

i would give up my FP before my immersion blender. it is great for all of the pureed soups i love. milkshakes are much easier. scrambled eggs (love me some bacon, eggs, and biscuits) are light and fluffy.
for the record, i have the kitchen aid 9 speed immersion blender. don't bother with a knock off brand, as they are not worth the money. make sure that what you are considering has a removable blade housing (much easier to clean).

@izy LMAO i wish i had a garage! actually that was a very lame joke stick=manual trany=car=garage. i'm sorry i'll go sit in the corner now :-(

@huney ~ ;-D Sorry. Couldn't resist. My last kitchen actually had an appliance "garage". You wouldn't want to see the beautiful appliances you spent a fortune on, right? I never used it. Well, that is not exactly true: if I wanted to mess with DH, I would take something he was using when he tuned his back and hide it in there. hahahahahah!

@izatryl LOL i can see you doing that! as i said before my kitchen is to small for a garage, heck its to small for a shed! Ex had an appliance garage and i used to stash dishes in it. (clean)

Yes, they generally do want to suck the bottom. I tend to angle mine at the spot between the side and the bottom of the pan after some up-and-down passes to break up the larger things. My original one somehow had one of the plastic "teeth" that are around the blade broken off, and that made the bottom grabbing less of a problem and the whole thing more efficient, but I haven't had the nerve to try to repeat the defect with the one I got after the first one died of old age and much use.

I prefer the food processor. It may be larger, but it does the job in less time.

I have a stick blender, but I rarely use it. I prefer the food processor or a regular blender. The regular blender is what I use for pureeing soups. If I ever used the stick blender enough for it to wear out, I wouldn't replace it.

My immersion blender is my favorite kitchen gadget.

This may be just me, but I feel that they have totally difference uses. Although if I must have a preference, I'd probably choose a stick. I know that there is nothing faster than shoving it into a pot to puree something. On the other hand, I love tossing a few ingredients into a blender (VitaMix for sure)- a nice tomatillo salsa comes to mind...

(for some reason I thought this was between stick blenders and a bar blender)... I think that food processors tend to tear food bits instead of pureeing them. I think that a good example of this is making a mayonnaise- I would rather use a food processor, on the other hand, the salsa I mentioned... it's all about the consistency!

I do love my stick blender. I especially like it for breaking up the tomatoes for my spaghetti sauce.

@HappyHoarFrost -- ME TOO!! I'm always convinced I'll electrocute myself!

My hubby laughs at me because I'll very carefully unplug it before putting it in water to wash it.

Here's the thing with the stick blender - Check the number of watts.
Most of them are only 200 or 250 watts which means not much power.

I bought a Wolfgang Puck Stick Blender with an bowl, whisk, blades etc.
It is 500 watts and it can probably power a small boat.

It's fast, efficient, easy to clean and I use it alot.

It's great for so many things from your own garlicy vinaigarettes, to creamy soups (without the cream), pates, to even your own hamburg.

Power is everything !

Of course, for larger portions, I still use the food processor, but day to day, I find I use the stick blender or chopper bowl attachment much more often.

I spent a week wrestling with eBay and finally scored a "vintage" Bamix (model M122). It only had the puree blade and the original instruction/cookbook of ghastly 1950s recipes :) Had to buy replacement whisk and blender blades elsewhere, but even so I saved about half the current retail price. The first thing I made with it was a beautiful, velvety potato/leek/broccoli-stem soup.

My Bamix is only 85 watts, and believe me, that's PLENTY. It'll still make mayonnaise in 10 seconds, puree a pot of soup in a minute or two and over-blend mashed parsnips or potatoes if you're not careful. I admit I have not yet tried to grind raw meat with it. I did accidentally puree a raw carrot, though, so it might stand up to raw meat.

I still prefer my food processor for chopping, grating, slicing lots-o-stuff and for kneading bread dough. But anything too liquid for the food processor is just right for the Bamix. Right now I'm looking for an excuse to whip egg whites.

Add a comment:

Comments can take up to a minute to appear - please be patient!

Previewing your comment:

 

HTML Hints

Some HTML is OK: <a href="URL">link</a>, <strong>strong</strong>, <em>em</em>

Comment Guidelines

Post whatever you want, just keep it seriously about eats, seriously. We reserve the right to delete off-topic or inflammatory comments. Learn more at our Comment Policy page.

If you see something not so nice, please, report an inappropriate comment.

Start Talking!

Need a question answered? Have advice to share? Start a Talk topic now!

Sign up to start a talk topic

Sign up to get your questions answered and share advice.