Pasta - Storebought vs Homemade !
Thinking of buying a pasta maker. Is there a big flavor difference between typical store / dehydrated pasta vs. homemade ?
Thanks
Add a comment:
Previewing your comment:
HTML Hints
Some HTML is OK: <a href="URL">link</a>, <strong>strong</strong>, <em>em</em>
Comment Guidelines
Post whatever you want, just keep it seriously about eats, seriously. We reserve the right to delete off-topic or inflammatory comments. Learn more at our Comment Policy page.
If you see something not so nice, please, report an inappropriate comment.
Start Talking!
Need a question answered? Have advice to share? Start a Talk topic now!
Sign up to get your questions answered and share advice.

17 Comments:
There are absolute differences. For dry pasta, I get Barilla. For chicken noodle soup, linguini for fish, etc., the Kroger near me carries Amish handmade pasta from Das Dutchman Essenhaus, which is better than Barilla. And while I don't have a pasta maker myself, I swear by the handmade uncooked & undried stuff from Ohio City Pasta in Cleveland, which also makes orders for better restaurants within about 100 miles. Theirs is what's best around NW Ohio/SE Michigan.
LunaPierCook at 11:32AM on 10/11/08
LPC and I rarely agree on ANYTHING, but homemade pasta is the bomb! I personally do not make it. I have a local Italian market that offers a fantastic selection of fresh made pastas. My absolute favorite is tagliatelle. If I ever add an attachment to my KitchenAid, it will be the pasta attachment.
izatryt at 12:31PM on 10/11/08
get the pasta maker. It is a different and more complex pasta than you can buy at the store. make sure you use semolina flour and good eggs. You can make homemade pasta by hand and skip the machine.
pecorino at 1:05PM on 10/11/08
Oh yeah, I'm with izzy about the KitchenAid pasta attachment. After making my usual lasagna bolognese with homemade pasta sheets (courtesy of my sister's ex-boyfriend) I'm a convert. Now, if I don't have the homemade pasta sheets, I don't want to make the lasagna.
wookie at 1:12PM on 10/11/08
Don't get a Ron Popeil style of pasta machine, the kind that extrudes malformed macaroni. Get one with the rollers or the Kitchen Aid attachment and you will be very happy.
LearP at 2:03PM on 10/11/08
@LPC: I didn't realize Ohio City Pasta distributed outside of Cleveland. I always look at their pasta when I go to that farmer's market that I rarely go to near my house (West Side Market). Their cajun ravioli, as well as their lobster ravioli are really good.
I used to make pasta a lot back when I had an automated pasta maker. *sigh* I fear those things don't exist anymore.
Aside from flavor, there is a really major texture difference between storebought fresh made versus storebought dried. Now think of that difference and you have the difference between homemade versus storebought fresh pasta.
You can create ANYTHING and any type of pasta at home. There's some tinkering you might need to do depending on type of flour and all that fun stuff.
A side benefit is that you can save money when you create your own versus buying the exact same pasta (if your creation even exists) in the store.
Cassaendra at 2:15PM on 10/11/08
Yes you should get one it is simple and easy and the taste is great. You can also use the rollers for other things like rolling out crackers thin enough and fondant for decorating! I didn't get the KA attachment as i like the kind that go on the counter. I like mine so much I just leave it out all the time! You might want to know what you will use it for as different one have different attachments, mine does spaghetti,angel hair,lasagna,ravioli,fettucine and something else that i can't think of. If you do want the machine that you dump it in and it does everything including extruding it like cassandra mentioned above then check ebay- they have a ton of those.
">http://luv2cooktoomuch.blogspot.com/"> luv2cook
love2cook at 4:16PM on 10/11/08
Homemade with the KitchenAid is the way to go.
http://nujoikitchendiary.blogspot.com/2008/01/channeling-lidia.html
NuJoi at 5:56PM on 10/11/08
My dad and I used to make ravioli together when I was a kid. I guess we're just going to have to do that this weekend now.
Alton Brown did a great show on stuffed pasta, and the way he did it was really simple. He used a manual pasta roller, rolled out one long sheet of pasta, placed spoonfuls of filling along one side and then folded it in half and cut it into squares after they were sealed. I can tell you there is nothing in the world like homemade ravioli, and the beauty part is you can stuff it with just about anything imaginable--squash, eggplant, crab etc.... As long as it's not too watery it's fair game!
buffy at 5:59PM on 10/11/08
@Cassaendra, Ohio City will do that within reason, but someone from the restaurant I deal with makes that trip every couple weeks to save on shipping. I've actually made the trip myself for them ... Have you ever seen their manufacturing kitchen? It's in a building with no sign, so you wouldn't have noticed it ... photos they allowed me to take that day are here.
LunaPierCook at 8:18PM on 10/11/08
My grandmother always made her own macaroni - by hand. We used to help, but it was very time-consuming, and our little hands were not terribly practiced. THis wasn't really a problem w/ cavatelli, but you could spot the ravioli we kids made from across the room: so pathetic-looking! (We were all under 9 @ the time!) Taste-wise, on the other hand, what a difference! Each of her grandchildren - there are 6 of us - now has a pasta machine of one type or another.
I've got a very good one that you strap to the edge of the table/counter, but it's a manual. Since it's still extremely time-consuming and arm-intensive, we only have homemade on special occasions.
Every time I use it, I think that there must be a way to put a small high-torque motor on it. I tried rigging power-tools to it - three different electric drills, over the years - but it's nearly impossible to regulate the speed properly. I know they sell electric motors for it. but I'm not prepared to spend $75 to $100 on it. (Same problem, btw, as my 30-year-old Squeezo Strainer: works great, but it kills your arm over time.)
Robbo at 9:06PM on 10/12/08
I prefer fresh for stuffed pasta like ravioli & tortellini. For all other types of pasta, De Cecco is my hands down favorite for dried. I like the texture of the De Cecco pasta when cooked al dente much better than fresh.
gibson at 11:27AM on 10/13/08
I have an Italian friend in Italy and she NEVER eats anything other than dried, store-bought - usually penne.
snowmoonelk at 11:38AM on 10/13/08
HANDMADE IS SO MUCH LIGHTER AND NOT CHALKY. MY DAUGHTER (AGE 8) MAKES ALL OF OUR PASTA. SHE SITS ON THE COUNTER NEXT TO THE KITCHEN AID WITH ATTACHMENT AND FEEDS IT THRU. IT IS HER FAVORITE THING TO MAKE. MY WIFE HAS THE FONDEST MEMORIES OF HER GRANDMOTHER MAKING PASTA AND LAYING IT OUT TO DRY ON THE BED IN THEIR STATEN ISLAND HOME.
pksmash at 1:06PM on 10/13/08
@ LPC and Cass
if you are ever near Columbus, check out the north market, in the Short North area of downtown. its a big "open air" market located inside this huge warehouse. they have a wonderful home made pasta company, with every kind of ravioli you can imagine. its delicious.
listener at 2:08PM on 10/13/08
I tried making pasta by hand once thinking it would undoubtedly be better than the boxed stuff, but I was wrong. Or at least, I need more practice. But the machine/pasta maker may have better results!
Hillary
Chew on That
Chew on That at 5:17PM on 10/13/08
I have spoiled my wife with my fresh pasta. She doesn't want store bought dry pasta anymore. Get the pasta roller attachment for the Kitchenaid. You will be amazed. Making pasta is simple, cheap and for me the big difference is the texture - smooth and silky.
Bunnyman at 11:56PM on 10/13/08