• Share:
  • Send to Reddit
  • Send to StumbleUpon
  • Send to Facebook
  • Send to del.icio.us
  • Send to digg

Who has the BEST cooking show on TV and why?

Moving beyond the Foodnetwork and finding complete enjoyment in watching Lydia's Italy, Daisy Cooks, Test Kitchen etc reveals who we are and where we are in relation to the level of cooking we seek. Who inspires you the most?

60 Comments:

My passion is baking, so "Baking with Julia" has always been my all-time favorite cooking show. I just loved it.

But, I have also made no secret of how much inspiration I have gotten from Ina Garten's "Barefoot Contessa". I think this will always be THE emotional favorite of mine. After watching her show for a couple of years, I felt I had the courage to cater my daughter's wedding as a wedding present. And, I did, using only tips and recipes I learned from her show. I also used the tips on flower arranging from her "Barefoot in Paris" Special to do the flowers for that same wedding, and used her recipes for both cake and buttercreme for the wedding cake. I felt she was right there beside me the whole time. And, it went spectacularly!

I don't think I would ever have found the courage to do that if I hadn't had her calm and sure demeanor, her simple but elegant recipes, and her classy tips memorized. It was one of the best days of my life, and Ina will always be part of the memory of that day.

@Brownie Inspiring passion in us is what makes a successful cooking show. When there is too much "hollywood" it's hard to find anything relevant to take away. I, too, loved the Barefoot in Paris special. Using all the same color flowers to make an exquisite arrangement was something to think about! Congrats on a memorable and successful wedding for your daughter. I love success stories like yours!

@dianeb -- Thank you for the nice words!

I will always feel that Ina empowered me to do something that, to me, was terrifying, and the experience not only made me grow as a cook, but as a person. And, it is one of those family memories that, to this day, is still talked about by everyone that was there.

I can't tell you how special that day was for me. And, I wouldn't have dared it without "The Barefoot Contessa".

I'd have to go with Jamie Oliver - even though I sometimes raise an eyebrow at some of his recipes, he approaches cooking (and fresh ingredients) with such zeal and appreciation that it really makes you just want to get into the kitchen and start "bunging things into a bowl"! (Also makes me wish I had a garden like his...).

I'm also a huge fan of Good Eats - as far as cooking styles go, Alton Brown and Jamie Oliver are at opposite ends of the table, but this only goes to show that even though food means different things to different people, at the end of the day we're all in pursuit of the delicious!

Anne Burrell followed closely by Ina Garten.

America's Test Kitchen--I love the humor and geeky science of the show, the only one to hold a candle to Julia Child's unpretentious seriousness!

I love Ina Garten too. She makes things look easy because they really are. I also like watching Nigella, not really for the cooking but her cheeky remarks.

@brownie: you should check out Julie Powell's book Julie and Julia. She channels Julia Child kind of like you channeled Ina!

Ditto, Ina Garten!! Best cookbooks, recipes that work, and through her program gives her devotees confidence.

Everyday Contessa's Secret Lydia.

Sorry, that's what happens when four shows crash together in my mouth.

I love Everyday Food because the recipes are doable and for the most part, healthy. I love Barefoot Contessa because Ina's food is wonderful, rich, celebration food. Her FM DJ voice doesn't hurt, either and she doesn't have the babble gene. I like the way she fusses over Jeffrey. I love Anne Burrell's show because she pretty much defines real at this point and she's a much needed breath of fresh air (respirator?) for TVFN. And Lydia's my homegirl and her food tosses me back to my childhood and my culinary roots.

Sorry I couldn't pick one. I tried.

Lydia, definitely and america's test kitchen.

jamie oliver's voice annoys me...just can't watch him i have no idea why i have nothing against people from england.

my fave has to be good eats

Wow Wow Wow....you folks are hitting on all of my pistons. I love the shows you declared as your favorites. There are reasons why certain people are drawn to shows like these. I believe those of us who constantly want to learn, that we gravitate towards people we would actually like to cook with! They bring us inspiration, confidence and an overall awareness that they are cooks who truly want to share their knowledge. It's not about being ultra thin, photographical, or clever. It's all about really good meals. They certainly deliver! Anymore favorites? How about Daisy Cooks?

Alton Brown's Good Eats. I just love learning about the science behind it all, and his demanor and appearance remind me of me: a little quirky.

Jamie Oliver. He makes things look really easy, and I enjoy his Englishness.
Alton Brown. I love his out-of-the-box thinking (making his own smoker out of cardboard boxes, etc.)
Tyler Florence. He, more than most on FN, cooks food that I'd really want to eat.

America's Test Kitchen, Good Eats, and especially Barefoot Contessa. Ahhhh, summertime in East Hampton.

Alton Brown. Final answer.

Well, let's see who I have Season Passes set for: Alton Brown's Good Eats, Ming Tsai's Simply Ming, Jacques Pepin's The Complete Pepin and the most recent one - Anne Burrell's Secrets of a Restaurant Chef. I like Ina Garten and Sara Moulton.

I agree - come to think of it, these are all people I'd actually like to cook with. To me, it's always a good measure when my husband says, having watched one of them cook a dish, says to me, "I could certainly cook it myself now!" It's not just the matter of good recipes though. You can look up recipes online or find them in a cookbook. These people teach you more than just a recipe, they give you food knowledge that goes way beyond one particular dish, and that, I would think, is a true purpose of any good cooking show - not just to teach you to cook any particular dish, but to give you enough tools to eventually enable you to cook just about anything.

Hello..! Well me personaly i like Rachel Ray, Tyler Florence, Emeril, Bobby Flay & a chef out of Atlanta name (ALI), he has his own show down in ATL.

I love Nigella Lawson's shows - if only because she looks like she is having such a wonderful time, and enjoying her food! Also her baking is always delicious...

I enjoy watching Ina Garten, Jamie Oliver, America's Test Kitchen, Everyday Food, and Everyday Baking.

This doesn't mean I actually use their recipes, rarely in fact, but I love watching them on the weekends.

Alton Brown is my favorite I LOVE Good Eats and the Feasting on Asphalt. He has made me laugh so hard I started crying and had to pause the show till I calmed down and was able to continue watching. When I was learning to cook when Good Eats first came on the air it helped me understand what I was doing wrong and show me in other aspects the were many ways to do thing not that one "right way" I was always looking for.

I miss david rosengarten's old show on FoodTV, where he cooked everything from hot dogs to fois gras. I like when Bourdain cooks, but that's rare on TV. Alton Brown is a good entertainer and got a lot of people to cook. Then there is Emeril....not talking the big audience show, but the original essence of emeril. Then the original "How to boil water". I really don't see how Tyler is entertaining, Jamie is, but most of the chefs aren't.

I like Rachel Ray. She's not classically trained but she still manages to cook realistic foods most of the time. I admit that her "Chili-dog-burgers" are kind of a joke, but she's the only cook show host that I've actually learned from. I love making "stoups". Rachel Ray doesn't follow by-the-book recipes and encourages people to cook what they like (even if they aren't the best cooks).

I noticed how many pick Jamie Oliver and Ina Garten. I do too! What a contrasting pair they are: one so rambunctious and the other so elegant. On the other hand they have in common their ability to inspire our confidence in their recipes and in ourselves -- they are both good teachers. And their home kitchens, their references to family and friends, their personal warmth and caring, remind us that sharing is a big part of why we cook food.

Iron Chef Japanese, Great Chefs Great Cities, Taste w/ David Rosengarten, Justin Wilson.

I've learned more from Good Eats than any other program, and I love all of AB's tips. However, my sentimental favorite is Barefoot Contessa, because Ina looks exactly like my mother. It's a little creepy actually. They dress alike, have the same haircut, and have similar facial structure. My mom was never much of a cook, so watching Ina is like having my mother teach me how to cook.

We need a bit more than 22 minutes of Secrets of a Restaurant Chef before it becomes a favorite...

I'll pick a favorite from recipe's i'll actually used. Simply Ming and Bobby Flay use too many exotic (not in a typical pantry) to be a true favorite. I've done extremely well with recipes from Good Eats, Everyday Italian, and Napastyle.

If you've ever had the pleasure of watching Rick Bayliss latino cuisine you will know how exciting it is to cook with simple ingredients enhanced with heat! His show is on PBS on the weekends. Daisy Cooks, also on PBS puts out a very interesting show on latino food as well usually featuring pork dishes. She draws from her old family recipes. I've made several of her recipes and they were stellar! Tip for the day: "Never trust a skinny cook.: j/k

Jamie Oliver for sure. I've been working through his "Jamie at Home" cookbook every weekend (it airs Saturday mornings). His enthusiasm is infectious and the food has been terrific!

Although Bobby Flay's cooking matches my own style, lots of grilling and Mexican influences, I don't really like his shows, he comes off really cocky. I love watching Jamie and Nigella but it's rare that I will actually use their recipes. I've made a couple of that new latina girl's (name escaping me, on the simply delicioso show) recipes and I've been happy with those. I also like Alton, but trying his recipes is hit or miss. He made coq au vin look really easy, but when I tried it, it was a lot of work for some chicken. And although Rachel Ray has a bad rap, I like that instead of trying to teach you just how to make one particular dish, she encourages you to think about how to makes to food you like simply and quickly. I haven't really made her meals, but I've learned a lot from her. I guess what I'm saying is that there is no cook that I'm 100% behind, but each one of them has bits and pieces that I like.

I notice that the majority of the favored shows are shows where people actually cook food. Real food. How shocking is that! Thank GOD!

Am I the only person on the planet that finds Alton Brown annoying as all get-out? I feel so alone...

Definitely Jamie Oliver- Jamie At Home is wonderful- and I can't wait for the US version of the book to be released. I also have garden envy- but I imagine my garden would be similar if I was able to hire a full time gardener too. ;-)

As a second, I would have to go with another chef from over the pond, Chef Ramsay and his "F Word", shown on BBC America. I've learned so much from watching him, and he really is nothing like the way the Americanized versions of his show present him.

Mexico one plate at a time is one of the few that are consistently good.

Maybe a different category, but Top Chef is the best food show on TV.

I love Rick Bayless too, but I haven't seen his show on PBS for awhile. Is his show still on?

@carosone Yes he is still on! Usually on Sats on PBS in Virginia. He has a nice cookbook. I'm not Latino but I like latino food because basic ingredients are used. I want to learn more about peppers and their heat as well as new ways to use the spice "cumin." When I roast corn on the grill or in the oven I prepare a cumin butter to slather on the corn before I cook it (either under the husk or cleaned and wrapped in alum foil.

I love Mario Batali - Molto Mario - fun facts and great food. Also Bobby Flay - at first I found him to be very cocky, but he has grown on me tremendously and I really like his style.

Ellie Krieger (for simple, healthy recipes) and Giada DeLaurentis in addition to Jamie, whose At Home I have really been enjoying.

My DVR is always 80% full because I never delete a Lidia show. Her recipes are always perfect and amazing.

I didn't at first, but I've learned to love Bobby Flay. Especially after a Boy Meets Grill episode when I swear he was wasted.

America's Test Kitchen is my favorite, Everyday Food and Everyday Baking--ok really all of the PBS cooking shows! Gordon Ramsey's F word, and Good Eats.

And people really should check out Julia Child's French Chef series from their local library, I have watched those episodes over and over and wish there were more dvds!

Lately my favorite is probably The F Word on BBCA. I like the mix of doable recipes, competition and other food related snipets that are so much more educational than the non-cooking food programming that Food Network seems to think is acceptable television. I make Gordon Ramsey's Rabbit Fricassee every year for Easter.

However, I think my favorite cooking program was the little 5 or so minute Get Stuffed programs that used to air late at night on ITV when I lived in London. Those were great easy recipes for anyone living on a budget and quite entertaining to boot!

I wish both HGTV and FNTV would put there shows online like the networks have done. I no longer have cable as i am a true tv junkie and if it is on i HAVE to watch.:) but it would be nice to see some of the shows online.

I used to love Ace of Cakes but i am unsure if it fits as a "cooking" show. Alton Brown is so infomative.

Jamie and Nigella most inspiring me. Their attitudes make me feel like I can do everything they can. Or maybe I just have a thing for Brits? Who knows!! ;)

eek -- I meant "ARE most inspiring TO me." Sad that I am a native English speaker....

I am a fan of Nigella, even if she does make cooking look like porn. And i think I would leave my fiance for Tyler! Alton brown is singlehandedly responsible for making me the new "Queen of Gravy" in my family, the man is a genius but I fast forward thru a lot of the scientific parts, cooking in my house is a little less science and a little more whatever I have in the fridge tonight. Emeril turns me off, he wipes his nose WAY to much-gross.

Alton Brown, sometimes Ina when I can find a new episode and always Mario and Michael Chierello.

Yes, yes. Alton, Ina, Jamie, Nigella, Tyler

For me, it's a tie between Alton Brown and America's Test Kitchen. Both shows explain the science behind what you're cooking, and understanding why something cooks the way it does leads me to almost always cook it correctly. They also both offer excellent, simple recipes that form a great platform to start experimentation. They're also both incredibly geeky, which might be another reason I like the so much.

Ina Garten, Jacques Pepin, America's Test Kitchen, Tyler Florence, Emeril Lagasse (Essence, not Live), Everyday Foods (Martha Stewart), Lidia Bastianich, Jamie Oliver, and I like to watch Paula Deen's Home Cooking (not party). .I learn technique and recipes from these shows. Alton Brown teaches me things I wouldn't learn elsewhere. I want to get Julia Child's DVD's. I love her cookbooks. Jury is still out on Anne Burrell, but I have high hopes.

I like Bobby Flay and Michael Chiarello and watch occasionally, but their food is too spicy for me to eat, for the most part. Both are very talented chefs and pleasant personalities. I've seen some comments about the younger Bobby, but I didn't have cable then. I like him.

I'll even give Rachael Ray a shout-out, because I think she might appeal to someone who has never cooked - especially college kids. Personally though, she annoys the spit out of me and I can't watch her at all. Same with Giada DeLaurentis - uses mostly fresh ingredients and can teach a beginner. Hopefully, they'd learn enough to want to move on to more quality, and even more hopefully, they'd know that Sandra Lee is like watching a train-wreck. Maybe you can't look away, but you sure don't want to be there in the middle of that mess.

Well as someone who's done some bad low budget *Public acess" cable TV food shows himself ( Stone soup and Sandwhich "Lord Nelson" being my gold standards) the worse the host is and the the poorer the production values are the the more entertaining I find them.

So I'll list a few in no particular order of subaltern standards I give you:

"Art of food"
http://www.wendybrodie.com/
(Her voice is like nails on a chalkboard her hubby is a horribly annoying sot not to mention they've even fed thier dog scraps on the show!)

"Miss Lucy's cajun" nightmare
http://www.lpb.org/programs/lucy/classroom/index.html
(Just awful, she once smashed grapes with her feet :-(

"The kitchen diva"
http://www.divapro.com/
(Soul food is good hers is not and she has a staff the helps her and it still looks awful...mind numbing enhancement with *Diva cam*)

"The chef's kitchen"
(All at once a horrible vehicle for shilling a multitude of mediocre to bad products doing recipies that very few would try at home with a blabbermouth big boobed J.A.P. that simply won't shut up. Her signature phrase is *Wow*)
For all your video torture:
http://www.veoh.com/videos/v6972068z8qT7TCN

I think that's enough to inflict on you all for now....oh yes I have more (:=

I have learned loads and loads from Alton Brown/Good Eats. He explains everything, and he does it in a very entertaining way. I have laughed out loud many times!
Mario Batali does yummy uncomplicated Italian.
Bobby Flay in Throwdown.
The entire group on Ace of Cakes - especially Duff.
They are all creative. They all have fun doing what they do. Did I mention the creativity factor?!
I feel so much better about having fun and being creative with my own cooking/baking!

Semi-homemade! That's MY favorite :)

Okay, okay. Just kidding. keep reading...

I love Ina--she gives even the most fattening recipe appeal and class. She just has this lovely demeanor and experience that makes me enjoy watching her show even when I don't love what she is baking.

I also like Giada, despite her cleavage...'nough said.

at Love2Cook--I also like Ace of Cakes--it's something i can always flip to if nothing else is on!

Ina Garten and her books are wonderful.

@luswim06 - I nearly had a heart attack!

There was a "SLop marathon" of sorts over the weekend. Glad I was busy...LOL.

It's time for me to fess up....I have enjoyed Tyler Florence from day one. He is my favorite and then Ina Garten for the foodnetwork people. On PBS, I actually like to watch all of them except Nigella...she's way too painful to watch ..too busy trying to be clever with the english language for me! Jamie is a breath of fresh air and does, indeed, have interesting recipes. Everyday Food is great for young/new cooks because it is clean and straightforward. And, of course, the Test Kitchen is always great fun to watch because of all of the work that goes into presenting their final recipe.

Alton Brown, no contest.
I have learned so much from all of his shows. I considered myself quite a cook because ever watching Alton. But after I started watching Good Eats (long. log time viewer here) I realized I didn't know what much about how and why food cooks. Watching Alton has greatly improved my cooking. He also really inspires me to try new things because after watching the show I feel like I have the knowledge and skill to actually make the dish. He inspired me to smoke salmon (but not in a cardboard box), make soft pretzels and brine a turkey. I would have never done that if I hadn't watched his show. :)
And I love Good Eats from an entertainment stand point, it is always funny!

Tyler Florence without a doubt. Even though his frenetic presentations sometimes get on my nerves, he cooks real food that is absolutely delish. I've never made one of his dishes I didn't thoroughly enjoy.

Close second is Ina for all of your above reasons. She inspires confidence and never pronounces that her way is the only way.

I originally found Alton Brown VERY annoying...could NOT watch an entire episode. The, there was one that I was very interested in the topic and became hooked. I've learned so much from watching Good Eats - the science behind everything helps me understand and be a better cook.

I loved Jamie Oliver in his "Naked Chef" days...simple, few ingredients.

And...I truly miss Justin Wilson...

STIV61, you list the website for THE KITCHEN DIVA! show but obviously you've never read about the show or the host, Angela Shelf Medearis. She isn't cooking "soul food" which I guess you place in the fried chicken and barbeque category or assumed she'd be doing since she's African-American. Mrs. Medearis via THE KITCHEN DIVA! show is trying to address the need for healthier eating by preparing locally grown, organic, and often-times vegetarian dishes. The program is sponsored by a non-profit organization called Book Boosters, so if you have a problem with the production values I suggest that you make a donation as they operate on grant funds and donations so that they can provide the program at no charge to PBS stations in the hope that viewers who are suffering from food related diseases can use her recipes to prepare traditional favorites in a healthier way. I also looked at the photos, video clips from her shows and recipes on her site and I thought the food looked delicious!

Add a comment:

Comments can take up to a minute to appear - please be patient!

Previewing your comment:

 

HTML Hints

Some HTML is OK: <a href="URL">link</a>, <strong>strong</strong>, <em>em</em>

Comment Guidelines

Post whatever you want, just keep it seriously about eats, seriously. We reserve the right to delete off-topic or inflammatory comments. Learn more at our Comment Policy page.

If you see something not so nice, please, report an inappropriate comment.

Start Talking!

Need a question answered? Have advice to share? Start a Talk topic now!

Sign up to start a talk topic

Sign up to get your questions answered and share advice.