• Share:
  • Send to Reddit
  • Send to StumbleUpon
  • Send to Facebook
  • Send to del.icio.us
  • Send to digg

Matching Wine with Food?

Which wine goes with:

Pork
Beef
Lamb
Poultry
Fish
Shellfish
Vegetarian

I always have Pinot Grigio with chicken or seafood and merlot with any red meat, but I don't know much about wines. I never spend more than $20USD; will this hamper my attempts to match good wine with my meals? Please weigh in.

35 Comments:

@BITTER - Have you tried Smoking Loon Pinot Grigio? PA Wine & Spirits has it for $10.99 and it is delicious! It goes well with almost all of the items on your list.

Not much of a red wine drinker, I cheat when I eat beef or lamb, and drink white. *Ducking from the swinging fists* Coppola Chardonnay, Robert Mondavi Fume Blanc, Bonny Doon Pacific Rim Dry Riesling are terrific and an old standby at our house is Kendall Jackson Chardonnay. All are under $20. Closer to $15 for the most part.

I highly recommend the book What to Drink with What You Eat by Andrew Dornenburg and Karen Page. They have an extensive list of pairings, and it isn't just wine but also things like beer and water!

http://www.amazon.com/What-Drink-You-Eat-Definitive/dp/0821257188

@lliang: a subtle hint for me to buy a book LOL; it's cool. I think I will do just that.

@izatryt - I've seen that wine you've mentioned; where does it come from.

And I always have white wine with pizza, no matter what my toppings are.

@BITTER - There is also "Wine for Dummies". ;-) It is bottled in Napa. There is a website. www.smokingloon.com. I just looked at the bottle. I bought some today. We are BYOing in Ambler Sunday.

$20 is plenty of money to get great wines. I'm no expert, but I do love and drink wine very much. Here are my suggestions:

Pork & Poultry - light reds, like barbera d'asti, or whites with lots of fruit, like gruner veltliners or reislings, depending on how you have sauced and seasoned the meat.

Beef & Lamb - big reds: bordeaux (merlot and cabernet sauvignon,) burgundy (pinot noir,) cotes du rhone (up to 13 different grapes,) syrah/shiraz, zinfandel

Fish & Shellfish - all the whites, with their differing characteristics depending on the sweetness or brininess of the protein and the sauces: pinot grigio, sauvignon blanc, reisling, gewürztraminer, verdejo, chardonnay, semillion...... Don't forget the sparkling wines, champagne, cremant de bordeaux, cava...

Vegetarian - this too will vary depending on the spices, the sauces, etc etc. For example, eggplant in tomato sauce would be great with a light italian red or a cotes du rhone, an indian veggie curry dish would be great with a really warm barbaresco, but with a primavera you would want a sauvignon blanc.

There are certain specific don'ts. Asparagus is high in sulfur and it reacts with red wine, and some people really dont like that. I dont mind it, but whites are preferable with these veggies (asparagus, artichokes.)

These are obviously really loose guidelines. Sommeliers make big bucks coming up with, sometimes extremely specific, food / wine pairings. As you learn about wines you love, you will make connections to the foods you love. It's all about experience, and in the end, the rules don't matter, it's really about what you like. But this would be a good place to start. Hope this helps! Get drinkin!

@simon - thanks so much for the info. I will take it to heart and I also will purchase the book that izatryt sent.

I was kind of ambitious tonight; tilapia stuffed with herbed shrimp and deep fried w/buttermilk, cornmeal & flour. Washed it down with pinot grigio. Good times.

Red wines tend to give me headaches, so I tend to drink whites unless I've carefully experimented with the red in question. So I'll drink a white wine -- or beer or water or whatever -- with any meal.

If I was doing a fine meal and trying to pair a perfect wine with it, I'd ask the wine guy. And yeah, I know a wine guy. He knows way too much about wines, and will not only ask about what the meat is, but how it will be prepared, what spices will be in it. And then he will suggest several wines at different price points, and very often the one under $10 will be his favorite of the two or three he will suggest. There are some very affordable wines from lesser known wineries that are quite good.

a Late Harvest Riesling is a great dessert wine, I find it goes particularly well with something containing berries, peaches or white chocolate. Its a very sweet wine, but not as sweet or viscous as an ice wine.

As a general rule, I try to avoid Pinot Grigio's and Merlot's for any meal pairings. They are all too common and eliminating them will force you to expand what you would normally try.

With that in mind, $20 is plenty to spend on a good bottle of white and still leave a great selection of reds. Most whites should be enjoyed young within 2-3 years. For the majority of whites, if they are 'old and gold' it means their probably broken. Suggest you try some Italian whites such as: Gavi (recommend Gavi di Gavi) or Vernaccia (Vernaccia di San Gimignano). If you want a specific recommend, Geografico makes a Vernaccia di San Gimignano that is a great every day white for around $10-$12.

For basic pairings try to either compliment the flavors or contrast the flavors. Contrasting is easier to achieve, choose sweet wines with spicey foods, etc. The white with seafood/poultry and red with meat is an okay guideline, but it really depends on what the flavors your are cooking/eating. I've enjoyed a fantastic reasonable pinot noir with seafood at Blue Water Grill, etc. Sweet reislings or gerwurtztraminer go very well with most spicey good whether it is chicken curry or beef curry. It's better to compliment stronger flavors. A good steak au poivre will overpower most merlots/pinot noir and may demand a cabernet.

Most important, recognize that a proper food and wine pairing can only "enhance" both the wine and food, but this requires you enjoy the components individually, similar to cooking with wine you will drink. If you don't enjoy a strong cabernet or roast mutton, there really are not many pairings that will change your opinion of them.

Some people may disagree with me on this point, but I never really hears someone say, 'you know, i never did enjoy sweetbreads until i tried it with the Amarone'... Unless, you drink the entire bottle!

@BirdDoggie I agree with you. I have had marvelous pairings in my life and it makes all the difference. You didn't mention the French chablis which is totally unlike American chablis. I'm not a pink wine person because I believe one needs to get off the fence and pick red or white, however, having had a fine glass of French chablis...I'm on the fence. Chablis is wonderful with veal dishes and light pasta entrees. My favorite pinot grigio is Santa Margarita ($22.00). I love big big reds such as bordeaux with steaks and lamb. @BITTER buying a wine guide is a very good idea to get you headed in the right direction. Then you need to experiment with a home wine tasting/pairing of your own. Have a small dinner party, buy three bottles you feel would compliment your meal then have your guests rate the wines. Sounds like big fun! By the way, I, too, like the Smoking Loon label (especially their new label with the earmark). It's a good value for the $.

Lots of great suggestions here, but the sweet wines don't appeal to me, regardless of how they're paired (or pear-ed ;D). I've had Rieslings that were wonderful and others that were too sweet for words. Haven't tried Smoking Loon, but plan to look for it.

@BirdDoggie ~ Thanks for the chuckle!

@Perky ~ The SL Pinot Grigio is really delicious and I am generally NOT a fan of Pinot Grigio. And for $10.99? No brainer.

@izatryt - you're serious about that price?? I love pinot grigio and my brain could use a break, as well as my wallet! Headed to the State Store! You may be my new bestest friend. ;-D

Both South American and Australian wines offer great value for the money. A strong recommendation to utilize your local wine merchant. The tastngs can be very helpful and the salespersons are usually delighted to deal with rookies and teach them. Few of them are on comission - it's like the folks who clerk in yarn shops; they're there because they love the stuff. DON'T HESITATE to discuss your budget. These days it's much easier to find good wines for less money than it was 15 or 20 years ago.

And the same is true on wine lists in restaurants. Many times, especially in a spot that's known for its wine, an off-beat wine that's not very expensive is there for a reason: The person who makes up the list likes it and wants to share the fun.

I am not in the business, but I've been around wine people, from grape-growers to salesmen and sommeliers, for 15 years, and I gotta say, these people are not in it for the money, they're in it for the fun of it all. You're not apt to be shoved off to one side or steered to something more expensive because they'll make more money. It just doesn't work that way. There may be a few exceptions - I suppose there always are - but not many.

@Perky ~ Yes! I just bought a bottle. I am visiting my brother in Doylestown and it is not on sale. $10.99 and what a yummy wine!

@lemons ~ You must not be in PA.

@izatryt - have you been to that wine store in New Hope? I don't have the name, but they sell fruit-based wines.

@BITTER ~ The only PA wine I will drink is from Sand Castle in Erwinna. It is on River Road.

@izatryt - this place is in New Hope?

If you get to New Hope, might as well cross the river and buy wine in NJ. Better selection and more competitive prices, as a general rule. That's where I grew up - my old stomping grounds!

@BITTER ~ Is is beyond New Hope by about 20 minutes. They had an open house last weekend for their 20th anniversary. I got to try all of their wines paired with food. Good Stuff. If you are thinking about the New Hope Winery, that is owned by Chadds Ford Winery now. I am not familiar with any other wineries up there. Or is it a tasting room?

Pork- pinot noir

Beef- Depends...if marinated steak or braised I'd look for a full bodied meritage or cabernet sauvignon. Hamburgers or steak salad/ stir fry, a merlot or lighter blend.

Lamb- cabernet franc, for sure.

Poultry- Again, this depends on how it is prepared. I almost always do a light red, like a pinot noir, w/ duck or heavier chicken dishes. For lighter poultry, go with an oaked chardonnay.

Fish- flaky white fish tend to pair well with unoaked chardonnays or pinot grigios. Basically, light, clean and refreshing whites with a lot of acidity.

Shellfish- Sauvignon blanc

Vegetarian- If spicy look for something to balance out the heat, like a semi-dry riesling. I find that dry roses also pair well with roasted and sauteed vegtables.

As for price range, don't be afraid to ask for help at your liquor store! One of the most common questions I get at work is "what do you have that's good under $____?"

Another view, courtesy of Vinography: Food and Wine Pairing Is Just A Big Scam. It's worth a read, if only to remind yourself that this isn't a science.

But what do I know? $20 is quite a bit more than I ever spend on a bottle of wine. I find the boxed shiraz/cab blend from Target pairs very nicely with everything from shrimp & grits to lamb chili. A cold can of Schlitz has also been known to enhance many a bowl of homemade tom yum gai.

I also like What To Drink With What You Eat and agree, it isn't a science, it's an art. Something fun. Keep in mind in warm weather the pinks (dry roses) go with many, many dishes.

@climalene ~ Truly NOT a wine snob here. In fact I pride myself on having a casual approach to wine as well as choosing to break the "rules" of wine and food. But I have to draw the line at wine in a box. Sorry.........

@iz - my mom was, shall we say, frugal. And Lord, did that woman love her daily wine. She only drank Burgundy (unless somebody else was buying) and the bigger the bottle or box, the better she liked it - less chance of running out. By her 9 pm bedtime she was slurring her words pretty good, but was up & at 'em by 5 am. The family called her wine, "Her Box o' Happiness". Nobody else liked it, an added bonus for her! I might buy one in her honor.

@Perk ~ NNNNOOOOOOOO!!!!!!! :-O. I need some now myself. Not being in my own home (ready to get back there!), I have to hook up my pups to take them for their walks. So I go out the gate, which has a tension spring, and just took a whooping 1/2 deep amount of my heel off! Sista, I am a hurtin' over here and bleeding like.....like a rich red wine. I asked DH if we could skip dinner and head home. His answer - notsatutely. Thank goodness for flip flops!

@iz - you poor baby!!!! hope you have some relief from the pain. did they set you up with some bandages? i've got some of that paint on bandaid.

Which restaurant gets to host the family reunion?

I finally got an offer on my house. Been sitting by the phone today. If all works out, I might not be looking for a box under a bridge and cooking on a cinder block. I truly wish that was a joke. What a nightmare. Today could be a very good day. Yupsalutely! Feel better!!!!

@Perk ~ DH has properly dressed my wound. I couldn't even look at it. (Plus I was crying like a big baby) Dinner is taking place at La Cava, a BYO and supposedly upscale Mexican. I don't recall reading you were selling your home, but then again I can't remember what I did yesterday. Congrats on getting an offer! I hope it all works out for you.

Lots of "good" wines come in boxes, too...it's not all Franzia chablis. There are some mighty pricey and trendy wines in boxes these days. But yeah, I was half-joking about pairing Target wine with anything. Except that I do so all the time, because the shiraz/cab is kind of unassuming and pleasant and wonderfully affordable. I like a complex, exciting wine as much as the next person, but I'll stand up for the honor of the humble Target Wine Cube any day. Highly recommended for assuaging the pain of foot injuries...

Back on topic: BITTER, like everyone else here, I'm just saying $20 is plenty for good wines (with allowances made for my slummy tastes).

@climalene ~ I am just sayin' LOL.

Lots of great suggestions here, especially the ones about "getting out of your comfort zone" and trying new things. I have been doing this. I know virtually nothing about Italian, Spanish and South American wines. Instead of always going for my trusted Saint-Emilions, Pomerols, Tavels, Cotes du Rhones, Pouilly Fumés, Napa Valleys, etc., I am consciously deciding to try new stuff. Sometimes it's not what I'm looking for, but more often than not, I am pleasantly surprised and happy to have learned something new. And in the end, it's wine. Delicious wine :)

A couple suggestions on cheap yet totally respectable bottles: Goats Do Roam and Goat Roti, from South Africa. Very good, and about $8 per bottle...

If you are trying to learn about what goes best together I have a recommendation for you. Every time you open a bottle of wine... open TWO bottles. Taste each wine first then taste the food with it. It is the best way to learn about wine and about pairings. If you are concerned about "wasting" the wine look into a simple soda pop lug and a can of air such as Private Preserve. You then can extend your open bottle life a couple of days.

I think it is time you move beyond Pinot Grigio. There is a world of wine waiting to be explored. You have some great adventures ahead of you. Have fun.

Cheers,

Angela
author of The Wine Wheel® and owner of Wine Unleashed

Add a comment:

Comments can take up to a minute to appear - please be patient!

Previewing your comment:

 

HTML Hints

Some HTML is OK: <a href="URL">link</a>, <strong>strong</strong>, <em>em</em>

Comment Guidelines

Post whatever you want, just keep it seriously about eats, seriously. We reserve the right to delete off-topic or inflammatory comments. Learn more at our Comment Policy page.

If you see something not so nice, please, report an inappropriate comment.

Start Talking!

Need a question answered? Have advice to share? Start a Talk topic now!

Sign up to start a talk topic

Sign up to get your questions answered and share advice.