• Share:
  • Send to Reddit
  • Send to StumbleUpon
  • Send to Facebook
  • Send to del.icio.us
  • Send to digg

If you you had a food show on TV what would it be?

When I watch The Next Food Network Star, I ponder how I would answer the questions and how I'd handle the challenges.

As far as the theme, that's easy. It would be making food from scratch. All sorts of things. Some complicated, like puff pastry, some simple like salad dressing. Some of these things, people wouldn't be all that interested in making, but they might be interested in knowing what's really in there, and what it takes to make the item. some things that seem mysterious are really pretty simple.

The challenges on the show would probably cause me problems. On a 30-minute TV show I could make lovely cinnamon bread, because there would be swap-outs. But so many of the challenges on FN Star are timed, and while I could make a salad and a steak and a side dish, it really wouldn't represent what I'd want to demonstrate on a show. So I probably wouldn't do all that well...

Sigh. But I'd love to see a show like that on FN. Good eats is kind of like that, but on mine it would be more about tasting and creativity and much less about the science.

25 Comments:

There are many types of cooking I enjoy doing but for a show, I'd concentrate on how real food can be prepared at home in short order. More like Everyday Food than RR's show.

People are squeezing the most out of every possible minute. Good eating generally falls by the wayside and fast, unhealthy options seem like the only way out. I'd let people know they don't have to sacrifice taste or caloric value because of time crunches.

I'd have great chefs guest and teach me and the viewers methods, techniques and share recipes. There would be no yelling or story telling (unless it had to do with the dish or method), or tablescapes or dumbing down the food. I'd want it to be like free culinary school - sometimes for beginners and sometimes for advanced. I'm somewhere in the middle, so sometimes I'd be just observing and asking the occasional question. Others times I'd be following along or helping. It's not about me or even the chef, it's about giving the viewers great advice and inspiring them. Kind of what Julia did for my grandmother and mother and me.

WOW Perky there use to be such land that you speak of... then then they kinda went south way way south......

I'd love to see a show featuring the cooking secrets of ethnic grandmothers. Exactly how DO you make that pierogi dough stick so it doesn't explode in the boiling water? Believe me, there are tricks to the fillings that can't be taught from the recipe books.

Moving from East Europe to, say, Asia, I want to see someone authentically making fried rice, or spring rolls, or whatever, the way they learned it from THEIR grandma. It would feature a native saavy for foods and their prep that make our understanding of how to make the same dish seem like the mainstreamed Americanized version. These shows would have no celebrity host or wanna-be chef-star - they'd be almost more of an instructional documentary on real in-home native cooking. In other words, a limited palette each show but a huge depth of quality and authenticity.

@PerkyMac...You're right. We're all thirsting for this.

@moibec - I love your idea. I'd include grandmothers and cooks on my show too. Anybody who can demonstrate their genius is welcome - most of my favorite cooks aren't chefs. That includes my own grandmother, mother and Ina. If you don't like Asian cuisine, tune in next week - could be Swedish or African or Irish or French or Cuban.

And who is this Aida they are touting for August? Somebody help me, PLEASE!!!!

There would be no cooks, no chefs, no pots and pans, and it would not take place in a kitchen.

Instead, the show would be filmed in a living room, with large plush couches, leather reclining chairs, and a big screen plasma TV with an awesome sound system.

Hooters girls would serve cheeseburgers, chicken wings, tacos, french fries, onion rings and milkshakes from various fast food places, to the contestants seated comfortably.

Voting for the best burgers, tacos, fries etc. without any wrapping or packaging (removed by hooters girls before serving) to identify which chain they came from.

With a simple snap of the fingers, a hooters girl would jump up and down for a minute, then refill your milkshake, bring the next round of burgers and tacos, and walk away slowly without ever speaking.

That's as far as I've got... still working out details. :)

@FFC ~ Spoken like a real guy.

I was just kidding about that.

There would be no milkshakes.

Thank goodness.

In my defense... It's Sunday, and I'm watching sports on TV.

So I apologize for letting my testosterone get the best of me.

Can you ever forgive me Izzy? :)

@FFC - how did I miss your post? I'd come hang out on three conditions. You need some male Chippendale waiters and the food has to magically be calorie free, even though it has lost none of its characteristics, such as fat and sugar. I like the menu and the ambiance, but only chick flicks on the plasma. Guys with earphones can listen to sports, but need to be respectfully silent - estrogen makes us cry sometimes, especially when eating .tacos, fried chicken, fries and milkshakes (my eyes are overflowing at the thought). And, you have to let us win or we'll be grumpy. ;)

I'd make a show about food guys like to eat. But it would have to be reasonably simple. Guys are reasonably simple beings and usually don't like doing anything complicated unless it involves a machine shop instead of a kitchen. I would want to make a show that would make the guy watching put down the phone he's using to order his pizza and instead, go to the kitchen and make something healthy, but that a guy would want to eat.

I know Guy Fieri usually tries to focus on "guy food", but his recipes are usually so damn complicated that they're intimidating. So my show would be like Fieri's show, but more laid back and with less actual dicing of vegetables and other things that look like work. And less tequila, but more beer.

My show would run about six or eight episodes, and that's it. Guys can't handle more recipes than that, anyway. And the reruns would be very popular.

I'm kidding, of course, only just sorta ...

I had an email exchange with Sara Moulton on the subject of a show featuring grandmothers cooking. (remember Sara having Martin Scocese's Aunt Fanny on her show as a guest cook?)

She said she'd mentioned the idea to several producers but found no interest ar all.

Well, so much for "Cooking With Gamma/Nana/Nona/Opa/Babba ...."

Perky.. lol.. I make a deal with you, whoever finds the secret for calorie free munching first, SHARES with the other.

Lord knows I could use a little less handle in my love handles.

:)

@moibec, (I want to see someone authentically making fried rice, or spring rolls, or whatever, the way they learned it from THEIR grandma.)

Our local PBS station does exactly what you are describing. They put out a call for recipes (C is for Chicken, P is for Polish, etc.). Then they compile a cookbook and sell it as a fundfraiser. During their pledge drives, certain contributors are invited to come on the show and make their dishes for real. Many are ethnic specialties, and Grandma herself is whipping up the food. It's not only entertaining, it's charming. (Makes me miss my Gram.) The only problem: You need to interpret what is a pinch, smidgeon, dash... you get it. One drawback is that the recipes are not tested, but through a little trial and error, I've managed to re-create some real keepers. THANK GOD FOR LOCAL PBS!

@Josdean, that sounds awesome! I would love to watch a bunch of real grandmas make food on TV. Wow - you are lucky.

My cooking show, in addition to being unwatchable for more than five minutes due to my forgetfulness and tendency to giggle too much, would be all about cooking with local produce in season - each show, I'd highlight a fruit and a vegetable, making a couple of dishes with each. I guess it would have to be a locally-broadcast show, so that it could really be local and seasonal food.

@BITTER - I frequently refer to Hooters as the one single restaurant where the waitstaff is more important than the food.

I would have my version of Iron Chef America- the secret ingredients would be things like Velveeta, Twinkies, hotdogs, Kraft Mac n Cheese, can of tuna, olive loaf, fishsticks, cream of mushroom soup... the chefs would be an Iron Chef vs regular home cooks who have to cook with this stuff every day...

I'd probably do a "Best of" or some kind of travelling show where I can eat local specialties.

@oddcouple- That is a pretty good idea!

Maybe a cooking program with kids in which mothers cook w their kids and look up for great recipes that appeal to the "little stomachs". The program should focus also on teaching little kids how to cook. Those beginners will amaze us w their super creations and twice the fun!!!

Love the ethnic grandma idea. Any chef looking for a few minutes of fame will blurt out recipes but that elusive orancini or pierogi or babka recipe would certainly be a prize - not to mention getting to watch technique (frequently things that don't get written down on those heirloom recipes).

Okay the idea of having grandmothers in the kitchen is great, as that is exaclty what inspired me to start cooking and baking in the first place.

I have been thinking lately that I would have something like "Oven Love" and spend the time bringing people back to baking, everything from cookies to yeast breads, fancy to simple. I think that people (at least my friends and colleagues) all seem to have this fear of their oven and baking in general and look at my food in awe (things like chocolate chip cookies, nothing that spectacular), when they could easily do the same in their own homes, but instead buy theit baked goods from supermarkets or petrol stations. I just would love to show people how easy it is.

And considering how many things are in even the most basic breads in the supermarket, like HFCS and hydrogenated oils, these would be much simpler. And (here's a little trivia that I learned while living abroad), did you know that there is too much sugar in McDonald's buns to be considered bread in the EU? Funny, I thought.

I wish any of the established shows (i.e. Rachel, Giada, Tyler) would give a "kosher" substitution for the non-kosher ingredients they use. Or I would like to see a show featuring American cuisine that happens to be kosher.

Add a comment:

Comments can take up to a minute to appear - please be patient!

Previewing your comment:

 

HTML Hints

Some HTML is OK: <a href="URL">link</a>, <strong>strong</strong>, <em>em</em>

Comment Guidelines

Post whatever you want, just keep it seriously about eats, seriously. We reserve the right to delete off-topic or inflammatory comments. Learn more at our Comment Policy page.

If you see something not so nice, please, report an inappropriate comment.

Start Talking!

Need a question answered? Have advice to share? Start a Talk topic now!

Sign up to start a talk topic

Sign up to get your questions answered and share advice.