Your "house" salad dressing
I'm looking for a good, go-to, reliably delicious, crowd-pleasing vinaigrette-type salad dressing that can be made with pantry staples. Every time I want to make a vinaigrette, I scramble through cookbooks (always at the last minute) but haven't found one that has quite become my "house" dressing.
I'd love to be able to find one (or a few, even) that's easy enough to memorize and use for when I don't want to think too hard (end of the day exhaustion and all that...). Does anyone have a recipe they use and love?
Add a comment:
Previewing your comment:
HTML Hints
Some HTML is OK: <a href="URL">link</a>, <strong>strong</strong>, <em>em</em>
Comment Guidelines
Post whatever you want, just keep it seriously about eats, seriously. We reserve the right to delete off-topic or inflammatory comments. Learn more at our Comment Policy page.
If you see something not so nice, please, report an inappropriate comment.
Start Talking!
Need a question answered? Have advice to share? Start a Talk topic now!
Sign up to get your questions answered and share advice.

27 Comments:
my two current favorites are marrukan rice vinegar, extra virgin olive oil, and bragg's aminos whisked in the bottom of the bowl with a little grind of pepper and tossed with the greens, or dijon mustard, sherry vinegar, and extra virgin olive oil, same prep.
cybercita at 9:52PM on 05/16/08
P.S. If you could suggest proportions, too, that'd be great! Thanks!
moibec at 9:55PM on 05/16/08
Well, my whiskey salad dressing is popular here:
I don't really "measure" per se, so this is approximate. Naturally, add more/less of things to taste.
1/4-1/3 cup whiskey (I use Irish most of the time, but good ol' Jack is great too..any would work)
1/2 cup olive oil
4-6 tbsp balsamic vinegar
1/2-1 tsp brown sugar
1/2 tsp kosher salt
1-2 tbsp chopped fresh thyme OR basil/lemon basil
1/2 tsp fresh cracked pepper
dash of cayenne or crushed red pepper or Tabasco
1/2 clove of garlic VERY finely chopped or mashed to paste
Dash of soy or worcestershire
I also just like to do oil and vinegar with some stone ground mustard and fresh herbs..any kind really, with salt and pepper.
My fall fave is apple cider-
**Apple Cider Dressing
1/2 cup cider
1/3 cup olive oil
3-4 tbsp apple cider vinegar (or white vinegar)
2 tsp. dijon or brown mustard
2-3 tsp. honey
pinch of salt and pepper
Shake all together well in a jar and pour over salad...can serve cold or warm it up a bit for better flavor.
sadiepix at 10:10PM on 05/16/08
I don't have exact portions as I just eyeball it, but I'll guess... but my quick homemade dressing is:
1 tablespoon-Grey Poupon dijon mustard,
1/4-1/2 cup balsamic vinegar,
2-3 teaspoons garlic juice (I use Garlic Valley Farms garlic juice for a smooth dressing)
1/4-1/2 cup extra virgin olive oil,
fresh ground black pepper to taste
a little fresh ground smoked sea salt to taste
I add all in an old empty Grey Poupon jar and shake until well mixed, taste a little, see what needs to be added, usually more mustard for me, but I prefer it a little tart and a little thicker than a regular vinaigrette so it coats whatever you put it on. Makes my jaws pucker just thinking about it.
Southern_bella at 10:26PM on 05/16/08
Not so much a recipe as a how-to is my basic salad dressing. I blogged about it here:http://stlouiseats.typepad.com/st_louis_eats_and_drinks_/2007/11/dressing-a-sala.html
No recipe needed and variations are infinite.
lemons at 12:23AM on 05/17/08
For the longest time my favourite simple dressing was just olive oil with garlic, salt, freshly ground black pepper, parsley and balsamic vinegar or, sometimes, lemon juice instead of the vinegar (as far as proportions go, I'd say one part lemon juice or balsamic vinegar to 2 parts olive oil, about a tsp of minced garlic, everything else to taste). Another variation included red wine or pomegranate vinegar, fresh rosemary, shallots, salt, pepper, garlic and olive oil (this one is very good on a salad of roasted red potatoes, green beans and kalamata olives).
But several months ago I came up with ginger sesame dressing that has become such a hit that I'm asked to make it on a regular basis (and send a bottle over to my in-laws weekly, believe it or not). Like everybody else, I eyeball it, so the measurements are not exact but this will give you an idea:
about 1 tsp freshly grated ginger
about 1 tsp freshly minced garlic
*2 tsp brown sugar
about 1 tbsp toasted sesame seeds
1/3 (to 1/2) cup soy sauce
1/3 (to 1/2) cup rice vinegar
1/3 cup water (optional - I add it when I want a lighter dressing)
2/3 cup neutral oil (e.g. canola)
about 2-3 tbsp sesame oil
It's brilliant over mixed greens, and like I said, I am now asked to bottle it:-).
*at the "trial" stages, I used honey and it wasn't bad, but I certainly like brown sugar better...partly because I didn't have the patience to wait for the honey to get out of that bottle:-).
brooke29 at 1:25AM on 05/17/08
I have a half dozen - or so - kinds of vinegar, but mostly fall back on olive oil, sherry vinegar, a bit of mustard and some salt and pepper. I like adding a smitch of ranch dressing mix at tiimes. and also like a 1000 island, especially with seafood mixed in with the greens. This goes with my favorite dinner - a Crab Louis with a hard cooked egg and French bread. I live in the Bay area and can buy snall crusty sourdough baguettes that are wonderful made into garlic bread.
suegsf at 4:16AM on 05/17/08
I make this often. It comes from one of Mollie Katzen's books.
1 part white wine
1 part half & half
2 parts extra virgin olive oil
a couple spoons of Dijon mustard
salt & pepper
taste and adjust
ride&cook at 7:03AM on 05/17/08
Classic Vinaigrette
I make this in the bowl where I plan to serve the salad.
1-3 Cloves Fresh Garlic
1/2 tsp. Salt
1-2 Tbsp. Dijon
3 Tbsp. Vinegar
Freshly Ground Pepper
1/3 (ish) of a cup Olive oil
I'm going to try and explain this as well as I can because I do it so often that I rarely pay attention...LOL.
On a cutting board, begin to chop the garlic. When the garlic becomes small dice, sprinkle it with the salt. Continue chopping through the garlic and salt another few seconds to combine the garlic and salt. With the side of your chef's knife begin to smear the garlic over the board. You will need some force to do this so really lean on it. Repeat until the garlic and salt become a paste. It usually takes me four or five passes but if you still see garlic dice, you're not done. With your chef's knife, scrape up the garlic and salt paste and place it in the salad bowl.
Your triceps workout is now over.
Whisk in the dijon and vinegar, and grind in the pepper (to taste). At this point, in the finest stream possible, drizzle the oil into the bowl, whisking furiously so it emulsifies. Let the dressing fully emulsify before adding more oil. After the oil is added, taste and adjust seasoning if necessary. If it's too vinegary tasting for you, add more oil, making sure to whisk and keep the emulsion.
Place the salad bowl in the fridge. Wash and spin the greens and dump them on top of the dressing but DO NOT combine until just before service.
Some variations on this theme:
Shallots (not mashed but finely minced) replace garlic
Grainy Mustard or honey mustard replace Dijon
Vinegars can be:
Raspberry (goes great with the honey mustard and shallots above)
Rice Wine Vinegar
Balsamico
Champagne Vinegar
Fig Infused Vinegar (my newest obsession)
Oils can be:
Extra virgin OO
Pure OO
If using rice wine vinegar, vegetable oil complemented with toasted sesame oil (and honey mustard)
If using raspberry vinegar and shallots, vegetable oil complemented with hazelnut oil or walnut oil.
chiff0nade at 7:20AM on 05/17/08
I often just splash vinegar on my greens, or mix vinegar and dijon together. Or use salsa or hot sauce.
KarynMC at 10:31AM on 05/17/08
I have a huge variety of vinegars and I mix them with extra virgin olive oil (3-4 parts oil to 1 part vinegar). Add-ins vary, depending on what type of meal and salad, and my mood. I always add s&p, often a chopped fresh herb, and sometimes shallots and/or garlic. I rarely add mustard (which helps emulsify), because I'm not that fond of it in dressing, although I like it in marinades and often use a similar recipe. If I want to add sweetness, I use honey or maple syrup or brown sugar. I've even used molasses, but that has an overwhelming strong flavor.
I decide which vinegar and add-ins almost like a wine pairing. What meat or fish will this accompany. If having a green salad, what greens and veggies and fruits? What might taste good with grapes or strawberries and lamb? It's fun and tastes so fresh.
PerkyMac at 10:35AM on 05/17/08
Vegan Caesar, using silken tofu in place of the egg yolk for everyone but myself.
My favorite is good olive oil in a classic vinaigrette! Yummy.
Brownie at 10:51AM on 05/17/08
My mom made this salad dressing pretty much daily when I was growing up:
lemon juice
olive oil
salt
pepper
Shake these in a salad dressing shaker, or whisk them in a bowl.
Rub the salad bowl with an open clove of garlic and toss the greens with the dressing.
I make it frequently now too. It's nothing special, but I love it. It's clean and light for a side salad. While the rest of middle America was developing an obsession with ranch dressing, I was eating this.
The beauty of this simple dressing is that it's ridiculously easy and good on a daily basis. You could very easily add in fresh herbs, dijon, shallot, or whatever else (I add lemon zest much of the time). To be perfectly honest, as plain as it is, I seldom look for ways to make a fancier dressing because I'm so happy with this one.
blackolive at 12:58PM on 05/17/08
@blackolive
We used to make that EXACT same dressing. Adjusting the separate measurements to taste. Our salads were always complex. As a child my favorite place to eat was, and I kid you not - any place that had a salad bar. So salads at home have everything in them because it wasn't a salad to me without the chick peas and the light vinaigrette. (Light meaning not drowning out the tastes of the veggies within.)
And like you, I now add other things as desired, shallots, garlic, herbs, etc. and in the winter we change up the citrus because we have 4 different varieties in our yard. The Oro Blanco Grapefruit dressing is our favorite!
bodaciousgirl at 2:38PM on 05/17/08
1 clove garlic + 1/2 tsp. kosher salt - put in a mortar and pestle and mash into a paste. Put the paste into shaker or a bowl, add 2 T balsamic vinegar and 5 T olive oil, freshly ground black pepper and shake or whisk together.
You can adjust the proportion of vinegar/oil to your liking; I like a rich balsamic taste so I do 5/2.
I also sometimes add 1/2 tsp. mustard powder or dijon mustard, and/or fresh herbs, typically thyme or parsley.
This dressing is particularly yummy with mixed greens, walnuts, dried cranberries and feta or bleu cheese - yum!!!!!
Jeana at 4:35PM on 05/17/08
white balsamic vinegar, olive oil, spicy brown mustard, honey, salt, pepper
YUM
slograffiti at 4:47PM on 05/17/08
1) Dijon mustard and a finely chopped shallot, left to mellow with a little sherry vinegar for a while; equal parts olive oil and toasted hazelnut (or walnut) oil whisked in
2) Bowl rubbed with a cut garlic clove; Dijon and balsamic vinegar mixed in, olive oil whisked in until emulsified, smashed garlic added, left to cogitate until ready to serve, garlic removed and dressing rewhisked
3) Michael Lomonaco's mustard shallot vinaigrette, the dressing recipe I am asked for most often:
1/4 cup champagne vinegar
3 T Dijon mustard
1 T clover honey
4 large peeled shallots, thinly sliced (about 1/4 cup)
1/4 tsp salt
1/4 tsp ground white pepper [I use black - don't tell Michael]
3/4 cup extra virgin olive oil
In the bowl of a food processor fitted with a sharp blade, process the vinegar, mustard, honey, shallots, salt and pepper until the shallots are finely chopped. With the processor running, add the oil in a small stream until all the oil has been incorporated and the dressing has achieved a silky, smooth texture. The dressing may be stored, covered, for up to one week in the refrigerator, but should be brought to room temperature before using.
Cathy at 6:15PM on 05/17/08
If you want something really quick and easy, just make Good Seasons Italian, according to instructions, using good quqlity vinegar and olive oil, and add a healthy (figuratively speaking) squirt of Ketchup.
srhcb at 8:39PM on 05/17/08
My favorite stand-by:
3 T oil
1 T vinegar
1 t mustard
Juice from 1/2 lemon
3/4 t cumin
1 T sugar
Shake or whisk and you're all set! I accidentally made this up when I was 12 and my family still loves it!
embolini9 at 9:56PM on 05/17/08
MOMS oil and vinegar Two tablespoons red wine vinegar, one tablespoon balsamic, one quarter cup veggie oil (canola or olive) salt , freshly ground pepper, one teaspoon sugar, dash garlic powder, dash marloram ,tablespoon parma reggiano. all ingredients into a closed jar shake well and serve
Kenzo at 12:15AM on 05/18/08
blackolive, that's our go-to dressing as well, except with a sprinkle of oregano. My Sicilian grandmother would also marinate her steaks in it before grilling. It was delicious.
BangieB at 2:23PM on 05/18/08
drizzle olive oil, lemon juice salt and pepper over greens... it can't be easier or more delicious. Check it out...
Madelyn
KarmaFreeCooking
MadelynRodriguez at 10:14PM on 05/18/08
Here's the salad dressing I've been making pretty much nightly for about forty years! Everyone loves it. No measurements involved.
Pour a little good olive oil directly on the salad greens and toss until all the greens are lightly coated. Then mix some fresh lemon juice and a little Dijon mustard together in a separate bown or little jar. pour on the salad, sprinkle on some salt and pepper and toss again. Eat.
chomsky at 9:36AM on 05/27/08
Well, so many minute variations on a theme, but I still have not seen this approach and I get good cooks asking me how I make this dressing all the time. I learned it from my french room mate over twenty years ago. The secret is the order in which you deploy the ingredients, and that is what causes it to emulsify so wonderfully. It takes less than a minute and simply could not be easier.
In the correct order - in the bottom of a wooden type salad bowl:
Shake and grind salt and pepper into the bottom of the bowl. Be generous with the salt -maybe a 1/4 t.
Spoon out a hefty dollop of mustard - she used, I kid you not, French's, and I use an herb scented dijon - maybe just shy of a T. Any mustard will do.
Gingerly pour in the vingegar - I use the non-seasoned rice wine vingegar - she used a generic red wine. I use maybe 1/2 - 3/4 of T of vinegar - not too too much or it will be too tart. You can also use lemon juice in a pinch, but only 1/2 a lemon.
At this point you stir up the 4 ingredients you have so far, just for a few seconds to incorporate the liquid and seasonings into the mustard base.
Then you add a couple of T's of olive oil - again, the french woman just used corn oil which was always surprisingly good! Then you stir it up with the mustard spoon, until it is thick and well blended.
Add your mix in's - avocado, tomato, feta, leftover steamed veggies, whatever, and then put your lettuce on top of that - then toss. Le voila!
It is so simple but divine, and works every time.
It is exceptionally good with the addition of avocados. And I just read that avos, cheese and oil based dressings help your body to absorb the vitamins and nutrients in a salad much better than a low fat or no fat dressing does! LOL. Maybe there's some cosmic justice after all.
Tobey at 12:48PM on 05/27/08
Do not limit yourself to one dressing, just learn the basics and whatever is in your pantry can make a great vinaigrette. The important ratio is 3 parts oil to 1 part acid (vinegar). Start there and then explore your spices, mustard, and citrus juices to find different accents on your basic recipe. Then have fun with different vinegars - after you explore red wine, white wine, Balsalmic, and rice wine vinegars then play with the flavored ones, raspberry vinegar, tarragon vinegar, and so on.
I do not often make the same one twice - I tailor mine to compliment the rest of the meal I am preparing.
rebdawg at 1:44PM on 05/27/08
chiffonade, I love the garlic and salt technique.
However, for newbies and those who are cooking in someone else's kitchen (like I am...my MIL's...pray for me), please be warned that the "smear" does NOT work if you use any other kind of knife besides a chef's knife! You do get a nice mixture of chopped garlic and salt, but you need a knife that is broad enough to push down on in order to "smear" it without cutting off your hand.
I've heard recommendations to use a food processor instead, but I'm afraid I'd lose all the flavor in the processor.
akk328 at 2:52PM on 05/27/08
I do the standard balsamic/olive oil/grainy mustard/salt/pepper/brown sugar mix
but
instead of mincing garlic I crush a large garlic clove under a big knife and chuck it in a jar full of dressing and refrigerate overnight, pulling it out just before serving.
rhinny at 4:09PM on 05/27/08