'american' cheese
what are your favorite cheeses made in the US?
small, local dairy.
big, well known company.
dirty little secret like kraft or cracker barrel.
Add a comment:
Previewing your comment:
HTML Hints
Some HTML is OK: <a href="URL">link</a>, <strong>strong</strong>, <em>em</em>
Comment Guidelines
Post whatever you want, just keep it seriously about eats, seriously. We reserve the right to delete off-topic or inflammatory comments. Learn more at our Comment Policy page.
If you see something not so nice, please, report an inappropriate comment.
Start Talking!
Need a question answered? Have advice to share? Start a Talk topic now!
Sign up to get your questions answered and share advice.

27 Comments:
I actually don't mind grocery store "block cheese". I even eat singles once in a while. (kill me!) It surely doesn't compare an amazing smoked cheddar or tangy, creamy Bleu though.
I love all cheese!!
The name escapes me, but those mini cheese wheels that are sold in a mesh sack and covered in red wax are SO yummy! Bonbell? Oh man I wish I had some right now!
Korea has a disgusting cheese shortage.
smile at 1:24AM on 05/30/08
cooper sharp I buy it all the time.
Fond memories of my mother making sandwiches with it.
JerzeeTomato at 1:26AM on 05/30/08
Land'o Lakes American Slices, and a commercial sliced American in a 5-lb block from GFS Marketplace. On the Land'o Lakes cheese I like how, at the end of the ingredients, it says in all caps, "CONTAINS: MILK". ;-)
LunaPierCook at 7:08AM on 05/30/08
There's a farmer that lives near my grandparents in upstate/central New York who makes his own sharp cheddar. SO GOOD. I buy a pound or two every time I go up...It's a good thing my visits have become far and few between
machellebelle at 8:03AM on 05/30/08
I never met a cheese I didn't like...Except Swiss. It's the worst.
I do have a thing for Monterey Jack though-or a marble of Colby and Monterey. Mmmmm. I want a block of it right now.
It's a good thing I do not live in Wisconsin. I'd be in some serious trouble.
Butrflygirly at 8:30AM on 05/30/08
I love pretty much every cheese myself....including the store blocks, depending on what I'm using them for.
I tend to be loyal to NYS Yancey's Fancy cheese....they make some great horseradish cheddar, and peppadew cheddar...along with other varieties of cheddar. I also am partial to Point Reye's blue cheese....the best I've ever tasted...it is so absolutely creamy and fresh tasting.
I do buy the plastic wrapped slices...it's the only cheese my hubby will eat on his burgers. :-(
mepolo at 8:47AM on 05/30/08
Hard to pick only one as a favorite - - top contenders include Union Jack Mozarella with Hickory Nuts, Swiss, Blue, Colby, Guda and the list goes on.,.. :)
bubbamom at 8:49AM on 05/30/08
I totally buy shredded cheese (esp. Jack and cheddar) when I'm making something and am too lazy to grate it myself. And you know what? I love it.
I won't touch American though, those slices taste like bland rubber to me.
embolini9 at 9:14AM on 05/30/08
Can't remember the name, but I recognize the package. It's a super young chevre, with some fresh herbs. It was my first "real" cheese, about 13 years ago (I was in my late teens). Don't think I'd ever had cheese from anyplace other than the grocery store. This one was a local deal, and I remember making a meal out of it- smeared on crackers from the health food store. It's a good memory, and I think I'll head to the cheese shop this weekend and get some for old times' sake.
I also like Land o' Lakes white american sliced at the deli. Makes the best grilled cheese sandwiches. It's been a favorite since...um...forever.
Kerosena at 10:14AM on 05/30/08
All of the Cabot cheddars are pretty delicious - even the reduced fat versions. It's the only reduced fat cheese I'll eat.
bitchincamero at 10:22AM on 05/30/08
For "American" processed cheese - Land o' Lakes from the deli.
For cheeses from America, I'd have to go with Cabot cheeses. I also get their butter. The Vermont Butter and Cheese company also makes a fresh goat cheese that I really like. There are also some blue cheeses and brie style cheeses that are from Pennsylvania and Vermont that know by label rather than company that I like to purchase.
Amandarama at 10:52AM on 05/30/08
Polly-O whole milk mozz for my pizzas and Boar's Head White American for my grilled cheese.
grampart at 11:03AM on 05/30/08
For basic cheese purchases, anything and everything Tillamook.
jcmeloni at 11:09AM on 05/30/08
Maytag blue cheese- from Iowa and if you're in Wisconsin those cheese curds that squeek when you eat em..yum!
bisbee at 11:15AM on 05/30/08
Anything from Cowgirl Creamery.
And I think my favorite to just slice and eat without any crackers or fruit or anything is Sonoma Jack's Meditteranean Jack. It's got bits of garlic, oregano, basil, kalamata olive and sun-dried tomato in it. Tastes like "pizza cheese".
rosezilla at 11:20AM on 05/30/08
There's a fantastic cheese stand at my local farmers market that sells amazing cows milk cheeses made in CT (I think it's Cato Corner Farm). Man, that stuff totally re-defines "american" cheese.
(PS - I'm not above Kraft singles now and again...they do melt really well!)
jlbrach at 12:11PM on 05/30/08
I'm not sure if it's domestic, but DH has been buying TJ's blue cheese.
We love it for snacking with wine.
I do have a weakness for both the Kraft and Cracker Barrel Extra Sharp Cheddar--vestiges of college and homemade nachos--sigh. Though the Cabot Ex Sharp works for me these days, too.
wookie at 12:15PM on 05/30/08
I'll second bitchincamero. For a "big, well known company" cheese Cabot is good.
bobbob at 1:43PM on 05/30/08
Here in Missouri, Goat's Beard Farms makes some great goat milk cheeses. Quality is sometimes variable in their soft ripened (camembert-like) cheeses, but to be fair they've always warned me if I was buying a slightly under-ripe one. They also make a washed rind, a blue, several styles of fresh goat cheese, a fairly mild semi-soft cheese, and a harder aged cheese (this last one I have yet to try). All of the ones I've tried have been delicious, except for a couple of the soft ripened ones that seemed a little high in ammonia.
I'm not sure about availability in other states, but I know you can find them in Columbia and St. Louis, possibly Kansas City as well.
Nicholas H at 3:51PM on 05/30/08
Mmmm...I just love cheese! Not too picky, except the really cheap brands of sliced American or Velveeta...other than that cheese is fair game.
Good goat cheese is probably my fave though....yummy.
sadiepix at 4:05PM on 05/30/08
@LPC - Do you have any recipes for cheese and mint weed?
izatryt at 4:29PM on 05/30/08
I am not a fan of processed cheese and I don't consider block cheese processed. (But if I am mistaken, somebody enlighten me) My favorite thing to do is go the cheese section and pick out a special cheese to enjoy with bread or crackers. I am not fickle, but can't name a particular cheese as my favorite. I do always try to buy cheese crafted in America.
izatryt at 4:34PM on 05/30/08
Maytag Blue
Cabot Cheddar (any of them)
Coach Goat Cheese
chiff0nade at 5:28PM on 05/30/08
@izatryt: Hilarious my friend.
Butrflygirly at 6:00PM on 05/30/08
*curtsying here*
izatryt at 6:33PM on 05/30/08
San Joaquin Gold by Fiscalini Farms (Modesto, California). The Gold is straw colored, mildly crumbly, reminds me of Parmesan Reggiano, but a bit smoother and less salty.
Bandage Wrapped Cheddar by Fiscalini Farms (Modesto, California). It has a nice tang and crumbly-ness, is perhaps on par with some English cheddars.
Pleasant Ridge Reserve (Wisconsin). Somewhat like Gruyere..
St. George (Santa Rosa, California). A Portuguese-style cheese, somewhat soft, airy, mild in flavor.
Marc at 12:19PM on 06/01/08
i used to go through stages with cheeses, gryuere is and probably will always be my fav but the last tic was manchego. Unfortunatly these days I stick with prepackaged individually wrapped pseudo cheese (soy) the taste and texture are awful and it dosent melt well, but its the only way I can quit cheese I am not a cold turkey type.
huneybumper at 7:31AM on 06/02/08