• Share:
  • Send to StumbleUpon
  • Send to Facebook
  • Send to del.icio.us
  • Send to digg

Yeah. Pittsburgh.

Do you have a culinary impression of Pittsburgh? Have you eaten in or visited da 'burgh? Interested to hear from residents, those who've visited and those who've never been.

Please be gentle. Thank you.

34 Comments:

When I visited for work, we mainly ate at chain restaurants. But I have heard amazing things about Primanti Brothers.

Probably any impression I have of Pittsburgh is from Lindy of Lindy's Toast.
http://www.lindystoast.com/around_pittsburgh/index.html

I visited Pittsburgh a few years back for a college graduation and was pleasantly suprised! The city has some wonderful dining and entertainment options. Don't miss the cocktail hour at the Warhol museum (do they still do this?). And yes, Primanti Bros is worth a stop. French fries IN your sandwich. Enough said. Also, try a yeungling beer (not sure about spelling). We enjoyed several good meals around the Pitt campus.

I loved Pittsburgh when I was there for three days. We managed to eat at Primanti Bros (of course) as well as have dinner at the Brew Church (decent food, excellent atmosphere), eat a pretzel on a sandwich, and drink Yuengling from morning until night and back again. Maybe it was the company, but I loved it.

It's not fancy like Philly, but satisfying and filling. I consider moving there all the time.

I have only visited, but I think pittsburgh has excellent food.

"The Strip" has every kind of grocery store you can imagine, the Pennsylvania Mac. Company has an astounding cheese counter, fresh bread, imported Italian goods, and next door to a sausage maker and butcher shop, had some of the best drycured soppresetta. Shadyside market has fine butchers.

the "big burrito group" owns and operate some excellent fine dining establishments, I have eaten at Eleven and Casbah and had excellent meals and they were most kind and helpful in preparing equally exciting and delicious food for my vegan girlfriend no problem. Nine on Nine was great as well, but I don't think they are affiliated with that group

some good thai food around (silk elephant? maybe I can't remember)

Zenith Tea Room has great veg. food

La Prima, excellent coffee and pastries.

Penn Ave. Fish Company for a fishmonger and some good food

I dig the Primanti Brothers but I think it was overhyped for me and ultimately a disappointment (BUT you should still go there). Fries on a sandwich is great but the sandwiches are too damn big and ultimately weighed down and too greasy.

plus the city is quite lovely, the hills the rivers and the stairs, I love the neighborhoods, the lack of obnoxious hipsters, and some fine rock music.

pittsburgh gets a bad rap but I have found the sources of negative pittsburgh comments to be fools.

A very good friend of mine lives in Pittsburgh and I asked him for recommendations. He loves Italian food and is a better than average cook.

He loved Buca di Beppo. There are two in Pittsburgh. It's a chain but it's supposed to be good. He's also been to Palazzo's which he loved.

More recommendations... Mad Mex, Taj Mahal for Indian, Eleven for continental/fusion; and perhaps your salvation... Lidia Bastianich has a place in Pittsburgh.

Report back and let us know where you went!!

If you like German food and interesting brews, you MUST to go the Pennsylvania Brewing Company. Even if you don't like German food or interesting brews, it's worth a look.

Somewhere up near the top of the hill that the brewery sits at the bottom of is an old church that contains a multitude of relics of saints, which is a bit creepy. And the hill boasts the steepest street in town, nicknamed "pig hill." I'm sorry, but I don't know the actual name of the street, but if you ask someone local, they will tell you. It's only a block or so long, paved with cobblestones, and when you're at the top of the hill in your car, you actually can't see the street surface until you start going downward. And then you pretty much stand on your brake the whole way down. Ya gotta do it at least one, but preferably not after you've been to the brewpub. Oh yeah, and that street lets out onto a rather busy one, so you'd better have good brakes.

There's a good restaurant on Washington hill -- I think the big draw may be the view, because I don't remember what I ate there, or even what the cuisine was.

The strip district is worth a half-day of browsing, and just wander around until you find an eatery that interests you.

born, breed, and lifelong pittsburgh girl here and i'm happy to say that pittsburgh is a gem of a city for foodies but no one recognizes it!

Primantis IS a staple, i can see how one might not be impressed with it.. its just a "pittsburgh" thing... but i love it and crave it...amazing with an iron city...

Ceviche is an awesome kind of cuban flair restaraunt specializing in of course Ceviche... which is kind of unexpected in town...

I do love Buca Di Beppo... it is a chain but very tasty...

for Thai there is the lemon grass cafe which is very good for resonable prices.

Olive or Twist has a tasty little small plate menu with even tastier martinis!

the cultural district right in the heart of town has some really good bistro style restaraunts and alot of other types to pick from

I HEART Pittsburgh and everything there is here!! go pens!

Folks should be aware that Primanti Bros puts both fries AND cole slaw on your sandwich! But don't expect "serious eats" there. It's sorta like Pgh's version of the Philly cheesesteak: it's local "diner" fare -- nothing fancy. In fact, it's downright sloppy.

Also, please be advised that the "Strip District" is not at all what it sounds like! It's a "strip" of land along the Allegheny River where all the wholesale markets are (Penn & Smallman streets). The dry goods in the Asian markets are as varied as we have here in north Jersey. There's also a local coffee roaster there who does a heckuva local and internet business. "Lydia's" is indeed in "The Strip," but don't expect anything like the Bastianich places in NYC.

And I can't believe nobody's mentioned the South Side! To the extent that Pittsburgh has a "happenin'" neighborhood, that's it. Just drive along E. Carson St., about 10 blocks or so either side of 18th. Go much further to the East and you'll be in a "new" area where it's all chain stores & restaurants. I can particularly recommend "Nakama" for sushi (and the wonderful chocolatier 1/2 block east) and "Le Pommier" for French.

While in the South Side, go west along Carson until you reach one of the 2 inclines that will take you up to the top of Mt. Washington. It's cheap, fun, and you get stunning views of Pgh. While up there, you can enjoy a number of more formal restaurants. "Monterey Bay Fish Grotto" is always a good place to take your parents!

And, if you go through the Liberty Tubes and into the South Hills (not to be confused with the South Side), go on to Mt. Lebanon and have Minneo's Pizza. My Dad used to bring us take out from there onceinawhile when I was a kid -- and I'm talkin' 30-some years ago! It was right by the trolley stop, and he could walk to our house in Mission Hills. Mmmm, nice memories!

The coolest thing about Pittsburgh is that you can park centrally and walk to all these places. The Strip and the South Side are at opposite ends of the city, but it's no more than a 30-40 minute walk -- and a very nice one, right through the city center.

Good luck!

I moved to Pittsburgh 9 years ago, and I have come to love this funny, green, friendly, unpretentious group of neighborhoods that we call a city. The Philly folks mock us, and the NYC and Bay Area folks consider us below condescension, but there is a lot of good food to be had in the Burgh, at prices that can't be beat. Here are my recommendations.

1. Groceries: any ethnic ingredient from Middle Eastern to Korean can be found in the Strip district stores and stands. Produce is abundant, tasty, local and often organic at the Pgh City Farmers Markets, open from May to November every year. Farmers@Firehouse is an organic farmers market in the Strip, with veggies a-plenty and locally raised, hormone-free, etc. meats. We have a Whole Foods and a Trader Joe's as well, and the Giant Eagle grocery chain has put a valiant effort into broadening their selection.

2. Local specialties: Pierogies from Pierogies Plus in McKees Rocks cannot be beat. The Primanti's sandwich is a classic, best sampled drunk at 3 am with a side of Iron City. Halushki, galumpki, and kluski can be found all on one plate at Bloomfield Bridge Tavern's Polish Platter. Natural casing hot dogs by Silver Star Meats in Coraopolis have a great snap and spicy flavor and are the official hot dog of the Pirates and Steelers.

3. Holes-in-Walls: Josza Hungarian Restaurant in Hazelwood requires you to walk through the kitchen, endure the worst decor ever visited upon restaurantkind, pee in a cubbyhole in the cellar, and eat whatever the owner decides to cook that night, but you won't regret anything once you start eating. The Park House on the North Side is a Pittsburgh bar that seems like it never left the 1940's. The chicken-on-a-stick lady in front of SamBok on Penn Ave. in the strip makes irresistable kabobs and mung bean pancakes. Tram's Vietnamese Kitchen makes great pho, and the owner will shout at you if you choose poorly from the incomprehensible menu.

More to come...

Ok, to further "pimp my town" with Pittsburgh recommendations:

1. Italian: please, god, do not go to Bucca di Beppo. If you MUST have red-sauce Italian/American/huge portions/deep-fried cheese, go to Pleasure Bar in Bloomfield. For interesting Italian food, you can taste Dish on the South Side, Piccolo Forno in Lawrencville, Alla Famglia (sp?) in the South Hills, Vivo in Bellevue (my personal fave), or Girasole in Shadyside. Bona Terra in Sharpsburg is sort-of-Italian, but always delicious, and is nationally recognized for their locally-sourced seasonal menu. As a plus, they are BYOB, as is Vivo, due to Pennsylvania's psychotic liquor laws.

2. "High-end" dining: The Big Burrito group has Eleven, Kaya, Casbah, and Soba, all of which are consistently good and occasionally outstanding. I am particularly fond of Kaya, which is less expensive and a bit more adventurous than the other restaurants. I have found that the other places in this category are serviceable if boring, catering as they do to the expense-account crowd downtown. Hyeholde is a unique experience though it is out in the boondocks.

3. Sushi: the only two decent sushi places in Pgh are Chaya, in Squirrel Hil, and Umi, in Shadyside (above Soba; Umi is also owned by Big Burrito).

4. The rest: Local restaurants we just like include Sassy Marie's and Muriel's on the North Side, Thai Cuisine in Bloomfield, Tazzo d'Oro in Highland Park, Kazansky's Deli in Squirrel Hill for knishes and awesome matzoh-ball soup, Pamela's for breakfast and yummy crepe-style pancakes, Fathead's for wings and good microbeer selection, Point Brugge Cafe for moules frites and Belgian beer, Mineo's and Napoli for pizza, Eat Unique for meaty and vegetarian soup, Zenith Cafe and Quiet Storm for vegetarian cuisine, Joe's Rusty Nail in Bellevue for breakfast and Turkey Devonshires, Tessaro's in Bloomfield for the BEST hamburgers (they are always mentioned in national "best burger" lists from Esquire and the NYTimes), and 21st Street Coffee for Clover-brewed joe that will literally give you caffeine-tingles and heart palpitations for hours.

For a friendlt, delicious, inexpensive vietnamese meal- try Tram's in bloomfield.

I think I'm going to copy this whole thread and e-mail it to my friend who lives in Pittsburgh! He goes to the same places all the time and I think he needs to broaden his horizons... :D

@chiff: I moved to Pittsburgh two years ago. I don't know how long your friend has been here, but I submitted this question to broaden my horizons. There is more culinary depth here than I ever imagined.

And Bourdain will be in town next week for his Drue Heinz lecture. I couldn't help but wonder what both culinary professionals and amateurs think of our city.

Living in the Philly area for three years lead me to include that "gentleness" caveat, as some Philly and Cleaveland folks ferociously cut-up the 'burgh. Luckily, those contingents on S/E seem most benevloent.

Hell, we've recently driven ~3 hours (includes getting lost) to go to Pittsburgh to eat at Sonic and visit IKEA.

True story.

We don't have a closer Sonic or IKEA. :)

Don't miss breakfast at Pamela's in the Strip district. (they don't take credit cards though, so be prepared). Also...great Thai food at a little hole in the wall called Sweet Basil--2 locations--one on Murray Ave in Squirrel Hill and also one in Lawrenceville-both are BYOB as well...another up and coming neighborhood in the Burgh.

I live and work in the Squirrel Hill neighborhood of Pittsburgh and don't often move beyond a 3 mile radius for dinner. Fortunately there are dozens of good, cheap to moderately priced restaurants in my little slice of the world. Here are a few that haven't been mentioned: For nice Italian food La Cucina Flegrea is usually quite good. The Noodle Hut in Regent Square is cheap, and addictive. Likewise for Rose Tea Cafe, if you enjoy Taiwanese food. I think Sun Panang is pretty good too. People's India in Garfield is cheap and tasty, you guessed it, Indian food. Have you noticed cheap is a big thing with me? There's a Pamela's in Squirrel Hill too - for breakfast all day. Bona Terra in Sharpsburg has already been mentioned and is not cheap, and is more than 3 miles from my house, but I like it enough to highlight it again anyhow.

@StripeyChef: The Andy Warhol Museum still has Good Fridays, including a cash bar from 5 - 10 pm and half price admission. On the second Friday of every month, I believe, The Warhol Cafe & Big Burrito Group have a wine-tasting and snacks.

Last time I was in the The Warhol Cafe, I saw John Waters having lunch with some museum board members. Exciting!

@Susquehanna - as much as my friend prides him self on some culinary adventurousness, he does tend to dine frequently at the same places. His comfort zone is Italian so I'm excited to see all the other prospects for him to try. If I ever get to Pittsburgh to see him, I'll enjoy all these discoveries as well!

I'm surprised no one has mentioned the Grand Concourse in the Station Square area over the Smithfield St. Bridge. I believe the building is an old railroad house. It's a steak and seafood place with a very extensive yet expensive menu. I went there with my girlfriend for our one-year anniversary last summer on a vacation to Pittsburgh, and they even printed a 'Congratulations' to us at the top of our menus, which we got to keep. I remember the food gave us multiple yumgasms.

CC's Cafe and The Gran Canal in Sharpsburg are two of the best Italian restaurants in Pittsburgh. Also, Lunardi's in Beechview is excellent Italian food. For locally sourced food, try Iovino's in Mt. Lebanon.

I'm probably the only Pittsburgher who doesn't like Pamela's. It's really greasy and their home fries are odd. I haven't been impressed by bonna terra (also in sharpsburg and previously mentioned).

For lunch, try Colangelo's in the Strip (Tuesday is spinach pasta day). It's right by La Prima Espresso - some of the best coffee in the city.

After reading the previous sharings, I thought I'd add my 2 cents to the discussion. I live about 15 minutes from dahntahn, in Oakmont. There are so many great places to eat in Pittsburgh. I have to admit though, that I do NOT like Yuengling beer, but give me a Rolling Rock especially with a great big fish sandwich, and I am a happy "yunzer".

I think the person who wrote about the Brew Church might have meant the Church Brew House in Lawrenceville. You have got to try their pierogies - they make new kinds all the time, including a black bean with salsa, etc.

I side with the person who did not like Buca di Beppo - my hubby and I have been there twioce, and both meals were horrible. I do not eat salad that has brown or plain out dead lettuce in it. Chicken should not be dry. It's sad that a pasta sauce tastes burnt...'nuff said.

I love Monteray Bay up on Mt. Washington. Their grilled scallops or the crabcakes - TDF. Yes, it's pricey, but sure worth it when it's your anniversary (and they gave us a free dessert for the occasion.) Howver, their other restaurant in Monroeville cannot compare. I had lunch with 2 friends there. The only thing that all 3 of us ate that was the same, was the sweet pea pods. We all got sick that night.

If you are going to the Strip, do go to Klaven's old fashioned ice cream parlor. Wonderful treats, atmosphere...they even make their own flavored whipped creams. The banana split is decadent. forget your calories and enjoy!!! Oh, and it's on Penn, I believe, but a few blocks away going towards Lawrenceville and beyond.

L a Prima coffee? My first visit there some yrs ago, I had no clue as to what all the sizes were etc. The staff treated me as though I were totally stupid, one woman said every word of her explanation very slkowly,as though I were deaf and dumb. And now, their coffee is being used at the former Oakmont Coffee Company on Allegheny Boulevard in Oakmont. Do not care for their coffee at all - it's just like Eat & Park's - always tastes s though it's been burned.

BUT if you want fantastic coffee, where the beans are roasted fresh, go to one of the Coffee Tree Roasters in Fox Chapel, Squirrel Hill, or - argh - can't remember where in South Hills...the Sumatra blue linton, the peaody...their estate Kona (they buy the entire crop that one Hawaii coffee plantation grows. And they roast their own!!! If you go to Squirrel Hill, and Jon is working? Ask him for a cup of black cat. It's his mixture, and you will want to buiy a couple pounds to take home for yourself.

Some more suggestions in next post...

Pittsburgh, part 2

Over around Greentree-Crafton, go to Angkor. It's in a small strip mall area (2350 Noblestown Rd), and dthe same folks who own the Lemongrass downtown own it. The food is primarily Cambodian-Thai, with a few Chinese dishes added. We have never had anything bad there. My favorite is Lock Lack, beef tenderloin pieces marinaded and cooked, served with lemon pepper sauce. oh, and don't forget to try their version of fried ice cream

Moroeville - go to TaiPei Tokyo. Wonderful sushi and sashimi, and you can choose Japanese or Chinese dishes. The whole fish in black bean sauce is all there is to one dish, but each bite gets better and better...Again, everything we have had so far there is better than the last. Bento box lunches are fun also...salad, soup, California rolls, and tempura veggies - nice, healthy and delicious.

LuLu's Noodles, in Oakland, near Pitt University - yes~~~a must go place.

Also in Oakland, (if it's still there), The O for chili hot dogs, fries and onion rings...

Back to Oakmont, choose between Hoffstot's, or the Chelsea Grill. I prefer the old fashioned, elegant Hoffstot's, even when I get a dark beer and fish sandwich. But if you are going for dinner, their scallops or shrimp in the orange and lemon butter sauce are well worth it. My first choice is usually one of their specials OR a dish I have never seen or had elsewhere - Veal Miceli - created by a former chef there. slices of veal, coated with crumbs and fried, wrapped up in deep fried eggplant slices...cheese, sauce...5 **** or better. BTW...sometimes, if you are lucky you will get to see current or past Steelers there.

Desserts, except for Italian cheese cake and their own version of deep fried ice cream with either amaretto fudge sauce, or cherry pie filling or fresh strawberries, the other desserts are not made on site. So before you leave, and if the Oakmont Bakery (in between the 2 restaurants) is still open, check out their Oakmonter or Almond tort (buy a large one, or small 2 person one), or one of their exquisite designer cupcakes. My son and his new bride had the cupcakes at the wedding instead of a wedding cake.

There are folks who don't live here think we still have steel mills blasting away, or that we are all newcomers to the country...but we have tremendous food in Pittsburgfh, inc. the South Siide which now has several new restaurants (try a corned beef sandwich with your Guiness at the Cladagh...)

There are little known places like Jimmy's (brand new) Thai food in Verona...

Darn...I am now so hungry

Yes! Pittsburgh is more than halupki or haluski (both of which I cook at home ... I think we are waiting for Gourmet or Bon Appetit to discover us! But maybe that wouldn't be a good thing.

Hugs from OrigCyn

@OrigCyn: Food writers seem to be turning an eye to the culinary underdogworld already. For example, Andrew Knowleton - you may recall him from TVFN's "Next Iron Chef" - wrote a _Bon_Appetit _ article a few months ago called "Humble is Hot," where he profiled exceptional restaurants in small towns. If it isn't already, Knowlton's profiling article should be a permanant part of B/A's monthly magazine. It encourages small town chefs to improve and innovate when they're getting big-time kudos like that.

Just curious, but why wouldn't it be a good thing to have Pittsburgh profiled?

I am so glad this thread is new!

My DH and I are going to a convention in Downtown Pgh in two weeks. We will NOT have a car, and need recommendations for eateries reachable by foot or inexpensively. We are staying at the Commonwealth Hilton and the maps look pretty bleak.

We would rather not eat at the hotel the whole time, and would love some local flavor!

Primanti's is awful so don't bother.
Must visit Pamela's for breakfast.
Tissaro's for burgers.
Fiori's for New York style pizza. It's the best by far.
Mineo's for sicilian style pizza.
Sesame Inn for Chinese.

I can't believe how late I'm coming to this post, but I also live in Pittsburgh and can't say enough about the food scene. Everyone has really wonderful suggestions, so I'm only going to add two places that I dont' think were mentioned:

Udipi Cafe in Monroeville - South Indian diner, amazing dosas and uthappam
Legume Bistro in Regent Square - french/italian country cooking, with a commitment to the local and seasonal

The Strip, as mentioned, is the mecca of food in the city.

I just came back from the Bourdain lecture and I am so happy to read this post and see all the connections to Pittsburgh on SE. Now I want to go and have a meal with you all!

I used to live in Pittsburgh in my 5 years at CMU and I just have to toss in my 2 cents about some of the places already mentioned:

1) Church Brew Works: Take the trip. Beautiful atmosphere, some very good food (I really enjoyed their venison meatloaf the one time I went), and some excellent beer as well. For me that's really something because I really don't like most beers!

2) Chaya: I went there numerous times with my friends when we decided that Friday night meant emptying our wallets and eating big. While you may have to wait for seating at dinner hours (usually crowded) it's worth it. Absolutely magnificent food, spot-on every time. The sushi boats are quite a sight to behold and are quite fresh.

3) Lulu's: Yup, a fine place for the collegiate crowd to go for some good Pan-Asian eats. Very reasonable prices, some excellent takes on old classics. I still miss their wonton soup quite a bit, mostly because it involved bonito broth instead as well as many other veggies and ingredients I usually don't expect. Quite flavorful!

Great, now I miss the ol' place. Guess I'll have to go back eventually to catch up with friends and food!

@Littlebluesiren: I was at Bourdain's lecture. Up in the second balcony. Weren't you frustrated with the audience's lame questions? Nobody asked about projects he may be developing, Top Chef, his best frenemy Ruhlman, or what it's like being a new dad. Shyness kept me from the Q & A mike. Wish I wasn't that way.

Anyway, the Pgh line cook contingent was out in full force! Can you believe how they were begging the man to go out for drinks with them or to "come back to my restaurant"? Do you think he was genuinely amused with this -- 'cause he was laughing pretty hard -- or was he just smitten with how pathetic the quality of the Q & A had become? Maybe it's a common thing at his public appearances.

@anybody: Did anybody else go to Bourdain's Drue Heinz lecture?

please, for the love of all that is holy, visit Uncle Sam's Subshop in Oakland (near Pitt campus). I lived in Pittsburgh for 5 years, and now live in Philly, and I have to say Uncle Sam's steak and their fries kick Philly's "authentic" variety to the curb.

Spice Island is also in Oakland, and has pretty good Burmese/Thai/Chinese food. Tip: skip the noodles and get a curry or the 5 spice chicken, very very good and you won't pay more than $10 for a big meal. Also extensive tea menu.

Southside (Carson St) is great, lots of energy and interesting people, and amazing restaurants. Perfect place for a night on the town.

@Susquehanna:

My husband and I were at the Bourdain lecture last night too. I was also seated in the second balcony, right in front of a group of restaurant folk who were so rowdy they made it hard to hear his responses during the Q&A. I think anyone who has read his books or watched NR fairly often has heard what he had to say before, though he certainly has his schtick down pat! We did enjoy the lecture despite the lame Q&A.

Thanks for the recommendations, I hope we can find some of them.

@susquehanna, regarding Bourdain:

Yes, I was really frustrated too. I guess that it was to be expected, with a young crowd of line cooks. Though I probably wouldn't mind having a beer with Tony, that is for sure! I think that he was probably slightly amused but I'm sure he thought it was a little obnoxious and was being gracious. I also, was a little too shy - the girl next to me asked a question. Although, after I got home, I thought of the perfect question: "Was the photo shoot in My Last Supper your idea?" :)

I moved to pittsburgh 2 years ago and as a vegetarian, haven't always had the most exciting choices when dining out. For the first time in a long time, my own (retched) cooking has been more exciting. I know I can't compare it to New York, but either I need vegetarian suggestions or the city has an need and opening for this corner of the market.

Anyway some friends dragged me out this week to a bar/lounge called the Firehouse for a cocktail and appetizers and I was very excited by my options on the menu. I wasn't stuck with grilled cheese, a salad, or a veggie patty. The menu was tapas style, but I would have to say some of the best food in the city ( and a beautiful, extensive wine list to boot).

Add a comment:

Comments can take up to a minute to appear - please be patient!

Previewing your comment:

 

HTML Hints

Some HTML is OK: <a href="URL">link</a>, <strong>strong</strong>, <em>em</em>

Comment Guidelines

Post whatever you want, just keep it seriously about eats, seriously. We reserve the right to delete off-topic or inflammatory comments. Learn more at our Comment Policy page.

If you see something not so nice, please, report an inappropriate comment.

Start Talking!

Need a question answered? Have advice to share? Start a Talk topic now!

Sign up to start a talk topic

Sign up to get your questions answered and share advice.