'I Drank your Milkshake!'
Lately, I've gleaned way too much amusement exclaiming the quote above. It's source? Daniel Day-Lewis. He's magnificient in the film _There_Will_Be_Blood_, which I saw a few weeks ago.
What's your favorite milkshake flavor? I'd like to know if I'm going to drink it. Heh.
Add a comment:
Previewing your comment:
HTML Hints
Some HTML is OK: <a href="URL">link</a>, <strong>strong</strong>, <em>em</em>
Comment Guidelines
Post whatever you want, just keep it seriously about eats, seriously. We reserve the right to delete off-topic or inflammatory comments. Learn more at our Comment Policy page.
If you see something not so nice, please, report an inappropriate comment.
Start Talking!
Need a question answered? Have advice to share? Start a Talk topic now!
Sign up to get your questions answered and share advice.
46 Comments:
Ha! I love this post. Well, I can't say I've ever met a milkshake I didn't like, but I think I would go first for a brown cow malted -- vanilla ice cream, chocolate syrup and malt powder. If you want to drink mine, you'll have to catch me first! :)
CookiePie at 10:01AM on 02/18/08
Cute Susquehanna! I'll make ours with whole milk, good vanilla ice cream and tons of hershey chocolate syrup. Do you want whipped cream on top?
I like Dairy Cream's milkshakes (haven't had one in years), but I've had others that stayed solid in the refrigerator for days. What's in them......gelatin?
Do I get a sip before you sneak it away?
PerkyMac at 10:09AM on 02/18/08
I'm a huge fan of the simple vanilla milkshake (shut up!) made with a really good vanilla ice cream. To my mind, nothing else even comes close. Yum. Damn these boards. Well, I guess today's lunch has been decided.
chisai at 10:16AM on 02/18/08
Chocolate peanut butter. Seriously. There was a drive-in in my hometown called Pinney's (Clarence and Beverly, please come back to us! This town hasn't been the same since you left!) and they had a zillion milkshake flavors. Chocolate peanut butter was my favorite and I'd LOVE to have one again.
AuntJone at 10:33AM on 02/18/08
Hot Fudge & Peanut Butter milkshake...I used to work in an ice cream parlor in high school and probably made this milkshake almost every shift. It's amazing I didn't weigh a ton then!
earlybirdkate at 11:31AM on 02/18/08
Very few things beat a good old milk chocolate Swenson's (burger drive-in in Ohio) milkshake in my world!
And I can't wait for "There Will Be Blood" to come out on dvd, there were so many of Daniel Day Lewis' lines that I can't get out of my head--such a performance!
bobcatsteph3 at 11:37AM on 02/18/08
Butterscotch malt, all the way. Mmm...
sheeats at 11:47AM on 02/18/08
coffee. or chocolate malted. and i can remember the last time i had one, too. in a diner in brooklyn, about 12 years ago. with a grilled cheese sandwich.
now it's a dairy free jamba juice, size small. if i'm lucky. sigh.
cybercita at 11:51AM on 02/18/08
The milkshake that Australian Homemade makes with real Belgian chocolate ^_^
Yum...
jenneke at 1:28PM on 02/18/08
uhhhh........I want it back?
PerkyMac at 1:31PM on 02/18/08
caramel milkshake at the Shake Shack!
Robin Bellinger at 2:15PM on 02/18/08
chocolate cinnamon from cold stone
beth1 at 2:18PM on 02/18/08
Vanilla with oreos. The best.
KitchenKore at 2:20PM on 02/18/08
Just about any flavor as long as it's homemade & thick enough for the straw to stand straight up.
JEP at 2:21PM on 02/18/08
Mocha. Or good vanilla. And I'm with JEP, it has to be homemade.
brooke29 at 2:29PM on 02/18/08
my very favorite of all-time.... chocolate milkshake.
And if it's fruity, Frutabomba Milkshake, more comonly known as a papaya milkshake... mmmmm.
Madelyn
KarmaFreeCooking
MadelynRodriguez at 5:08PM on 02/18/08
mmm a good coffee milkshake, though choc bananna is yummy too so is strawberry with fresh berries, or or OMG milkshake overload!
huney_bumper at 6:24PM on 02/18/08
It's got to be eggnog with a little nutmeg ground on top.
PlanetChaos at 6:41PM on 02/18/08
black and white!
I hate chocolate milkshakes when made w/ chocolate ice cream, love them when made with vanilla ice cream and choc syrup. go figure. I've never been able to figure out why. with or without a banana in them.
My dad and I used to make milkshakes with vanilla ice cream and homemade boysenberry jam- those were pretty good too. I should try that again sometime.
no whip cream on mine please- that totally ruins them.
karenita at 8:38PM on 02/18/08
A cookout Vanilla Peanut Butter milkshake!!!
pbisNOTmyname at 10:13PM on 02/18/08
the best milkshake i ever had, was made with toasted almond ice cream and it was thick enough to eat with a spoon.
almondjoy at 10:49PM on 02/18/08
Shamarock.
Or Peanut Butter
churchka at 11:00PM on 02/18/08
Chocolate malted all the way. Why is it that shakes taste so good with hamburgers? Is it a sweet/savory thing like chocolate covered pretzels? Don't know, but it just works.
haneway at 1:38PM on 02/19/08
Mmmm peanut butter and oreos blended with vanilla ice cream would hit the spot right now. Sometimes I have to be a purest and go with vanilla or strawberry.
Stufsocker at 1:52PM on 02/19/08
Vanilla Oreo shake, chocolate, mint choc. chip (as long as it's well-blended, so as not to choke me while I'm drinking it!). And maybe I'm weird, but I love the neapolitan from In-N-Out. It's always a surprise what flavor is going to come next -- vanilla, chocolate or strawberry.
misseditor at 2:06PM on 02/19/08
This sounds completely disgusting in theory, but in reality, it's completely crave-worthy. My favorite flavor milkshake is called the "Shakin'(sp?) Jesse", made at Rudy's Can't Fail Cafe in Emeryville, CA. It's a chocolate, espresso and Guinness milkshake, and it's divine.
Tactful_Cactus at 2:29PM on 02/19/08
I thought it was "I drink your milkshake." Drink or drank, make mine mint chocolate chip from Baskin Robbin's! It's the only ice cream I'd use to make a mint chip milkshake, those little chocolate flakes fit up through the straw.
Grub Street's take.
LizNYC at 2:54PM on 02/19/08
I occasionally enjoy a good, thick milkshake with french fries at a local diner. As a meal. The combo hits a savory/sweet and hot/cold spot. Opposites really complement each other sometimes.
Does anybody else do this? I even dip my fries in the shake sometimes.
I've done it since I was in 4th grade, when I'd rally up a posse to go ride our bikes up to the nearby Wendy's to get fries and Frosties. I once stole my older sister's babysitting money so I could buy for everybody. Just imagine the fallout on that one. She still tells the story.
Susquehanna at 3:01PM on 02/19/08
@LizNYC: I Googled the both phrases and I think you are correct. Thanks for pointing that out.
Susquehanna at 3:09PM on 02/19/08
the artificially flavored strawberry stuff, reminds me of childhood at foster's freeze.
foodiegirl at 3:50PM on 02/19/08
Oh man. I'm nine months pregnant and simply MUST have a chocolate milkshake today. The only problem is I don't remember the last time I had a milkshake, and don't know where to find one!
I think it's time to haul out the blender I hate using.
francie at 3:55PM on 02/19/08
It really depends on what mood I'm in, but I've always liked vanilla, chocolate and black and white (chocolate ice cream, chocolate sauce and marshmallow cream). Peanut butter also sounds tasty. And, even though I like Oreos, an Oreo milkshake does not sound appealing.
beatle9 at 5:58PM on 02/19/08
My current favorite is a custom Peanut Butter / Date shake from Blenders in the Grass:
Non-fat milk, peanut butter, dates banana, ice milk
delicious and nutritious!
pixelist at 8:54PM on 02/19/08
Was that not the most incredible movie? And the most incredible actor in the most (you know it)...incredible scene!!
beatle9, if you like Oreos, I am quite confident you'll love an Oreo milkshake. Even the ones made with Tasty D-lite (an edible food-like substance I am not fond of) are delicious! Give it a try.
Also, I really want to try the Brown Cow Malted shake. Where do I get one of those?
I prefer to stick with classic flavors when it comes to milkshakes and would be hard pressed to pick a favorite among vanilla, chocolate, and strawberry. That neopolitan sounds just the thing!
jbeach at 10:39PM on 02/19/08
Vanilla malted/chocolate malted/coffee malted.
I even like the malt powder all by itself.
Bakerloo Line at 9:26AM on 02/20/08
Ben and Jerry's mint oreo milkshake. RIP:(
Kerosena at 9:53AM on 02/20/08
Any milkshake from Amy's Ice Creams in Austin!
paintchipgirl at 10:29AM on 02/20/08
Peanut butter and chocolate, or if that's too rare, peanut butter. Or if that can't be had, strawberry with real strawberries. Or else chocolate. Heck, just give me a milkshake now, please.
OneWallKitchen at 10:33AM on 02/20/08
Avocado milkshake with vanilla ice cream. Creamy avocado, mmm... Sometimes added a handful of pistachios, too, for salt and even more fat.
eater at 11:43AM on 02/20/08
A caramel malt shake from Dairy Queen. Or a chocolate mint shake from Steak - n- Shake. We used to get a rootbeer milkshake from a small mom and pop place when I was a kid. They were great.
dallimomma at 2:15PM on 02/20/08
@Susquehanna..........after drinking all these milkshakes, your tummy should be feeling a might full and your brain frozen?
PerkyMac at 2:48PM on 02/20/08
Peppermint, from Peterson's Ice Cream in Chicago
meganaw at 3:06PM on 02/20/08
@PerkyMac: Heh. I'd probably have expired by now, dying from hypothermia. And I doubt I have the ability to metabolize that much lactose. I'd bloat-up and then die of *embarrassment* from the uncontrollable effects. LOL.
Susquehanna at 8:13AM on 02/21/08
We had a Dip and shake party a while back and the shake part of it was all custom. I had fruits and candy bars and PBJ and desserts of all kinds out. Ppl got to custom make what they wanted. We had a PBJ shake made w milk. We had one girl do a white chocolate rasberry shake w mango top. We had an Elvis shake w PB and banana mixed w ice cream. But by far the best of the night was the apple pie shake. He took a piece of my homemade apple pie, threw it in the blender with a huge chunk of cinnamon ice cream. MY GOSH, it was so good!!
colonendparentheses at 10:00AM on 02/21/08
I want to see this movie! In terms of milkshakes, up until the other day, I would have shamefully said I love Shamrock shakes....from McDonalds. Maybe it was something about them being around for a limited time but I used to love them, until I had one the other day and it was nastiness in a cup.
Hillary
Chew on That
Chew on That at 4:32PM on 02/22/08
Ok, I am from Eastern Massachusetts. We, and those in Rhode Island and southern NH and Maine, consider a milkshale to be milk and syrup processed in a drink blender, Thats is right, no ice cream!
If ice cream is added, it is a FRAPPE or, In Rhode Island only, a CABINET.
I feel sorry for those in less civilized parts who have never enjoyed a REAL milkshake.
CapeCodBob at 5:17PM on 02/22/08