• Share:
  • Send to StumbleUpon
  • Send to Facebook
  • Send to del.icio.us
  • Send to digg

Are You a Fennel-Phobe?

My spouse has such a strong aversion to fennel, anise,and licorice that he cannot stand to be in the same room with it. He swears that it has to be the most hated/feared smell and flavor for more people than anything else. I really like it, but can only have it when dining out and downwind from him. He has had several meals at fine restaurants ruined for him by the small omission on the menu mentioning the fact that fennel was an ingredient. He swears he can smell it a mile away and can't get the taste to leave if a morsel makes it's way to his mouth accidentally in a dimly lit restaurant.

Fennel seems to be quite popular on menus currently and I tell him that other people must like it or it wouldn't be included in so many dishes. He vehemently disagrees. We are going into perilous territory here, but I need to know how many others are out there. I need to validate or dispute his argument once and for all.

33 Comments:

I LOVE fennel, always. i buy it just to snack on raw.

I love fennel too. Thinly sliced raw in a salad or roasted in the oven. When it's cheap at the market I stock up.

I think your husband has a strong case. Most Americans I've met are disgusted by fennel/anise/licorice in virtually any incarnation. I had to deliberately train myself to accept it, and I'm now very fond of fennel seed.

I can do very thinly sliced raw fennel and like it. My husband juiced some the other day, though, and i don't think anything has ever even remotely revolted me so instantaneously and dramatically as that juice.

I tried cooked fennel, not crazy about it.

With raw fennel, and with pastis, I enjoy the first few tastes of it (so refreshing) but get fatigued toward the middle/last 1/3, and by the end I start to resent it.

I never met anyone who genuinely liked licorice, and if something is described as such, everyone I know makes an icky face and dismisses the thought.

Hated as it is, though,, fennel or its cousins appear in some of my fennel-averse family and friends' favorite foods: Italian sausage, and ]I believe] root beer and Dr. Pepper.

I like it, but I can take or leave licorice. I loved black licorice when I was a kid, and red was fine with me too.

I'd watch out for tarragon as an ingredient for your husband - I think it smells very much like licorice.

I don't mind fennel seed, particularly in sausage, or fennel bulb. I do hate licorice candy - I think it is levels of intensity (don't like ouzo either). If fennel were the only flavor in a dish then I would probably avoid it.

More to answer your question - my husband likes basically ALL food. And he loves meat beyond almost anything else (chocolate wins). Once in a brunch place he tried my turkey sausage which had quite a bit of fennel seed in it and didn't like it. I think he got scared. It can be very strong, I agree that fennel disclosure on menus would be nice.

I know people who love licorice but I've always hated the stuff. I am learning to appreciate fennel but it will never be my favorite.

I love love love fennel, but licorice (or ouzo, or sambuca) absolutely repulses me. I guess the licorice-like taste is subtle and refreshing in fennel, but overpowering and oppressive in candy.

mmm fennel ravioli...

I like fennel, cut thin and dressed with olive oil, garlic and shaved parmesan cheese. It's also good shaved thin and lightly browned in butter to accompany lobster meat. As said above, fennel seed is great in italian sausage. It's essential for making stocks.

However, I can't stand black licorice candy. The flavor is too strong and the aftertaste lingers for ever.

Pastis and absinthe are tasty every once in a while, specifically on a hot summer day or a warm breezy early evening, preferably in the south of France. Proper context definitely makes it taste better :)

I'm with your husband - I hate fennel, anise, and licorice. Let me revise that - I can tolerate small doses of thinly sliced fennel, but nothing beyond that. Keep the Sambuca away from me, please.

I think licorice-love is kind of a European thing, maybe. My mom always made cookies with anise flavoring and I loved it. We had it and anise seed in the spice cabinet all the time. I used to make mandelbrot (a sort of biscotti flavored with anise seed) for my mom and gram for tea dipping.

@Perky - I love growing fresh herbs and do tarragon and basil every year. I am allowed to use tarragon in very small increments in dishes. Surprisingly, he likes basil and loves pesto, so I really push that envelope when I have a lot. We did, however, have an issue when I planted bronze fennel in the butterfly garden. Unfortunately it reseeds itself very well and I always had a bumper crop. Well, the anise swallowtails loved it.

Also he finds fennel seed in sausage barely tolerable, but I like lots of it!

@frederika - I grow tons of herbs too, but the tarragon is like mint - takes over! I grow them where my tractor won't fit and they choke out the weeds - haha. I've never grown fennel though. I love cooking with tarragon, but sprinkled raw it does retain more of a licorice flavor. Will he eat it that way?

Basil, oh how I miss thee! Soon, soon, soon, soon..............

I agree with your husband. Ew, never, under no circumstances. It ruins everything it touches.

I'm with him- I love so many foods but fennel is yucky. Some thinly sliced braised fennel is the most I can do. I hate tarragon.

I don't like fennel or anise either, though I try to tolerate them at times. The only time I really liked fennel was when it was carmelized and put in a dish with rice. Whenever I have biscotti with anise, I am sure to dip it in hot chocolate to calm down that strong flavor!

@Perky - I totally had the same situation with the Russian tarragon. It has these runners that really want to go in your neighbor's yard. It has no flavor, anyway and it's mostly ornamental. Fortunately, they are really easy to pull up (not my experience so much with mint - but I've licked that problem!). It's the French tarragon that I love so much and is quite tempermental. I always plant it in pots and bring them in the garage before winter. A plant seems to only last me two years, but the one from summer '07 has it's buds all set for this spring. Any time now!!!!

I use tarragon in sauces, mostly. It's a must for hollandaise on eggs benedict, but it must be sparingly. Before it goes down for the count in the fall, I usually cut a bunch and dehydrate it in the microwave so I have enough for the looooong winter here. It isn't the most recommended method for drying herbs since a lot of the essentail oils are lost in the process, but for our purposes it works well enough and the potency is somewhat subdued for the SO.

BTW, Perky, do you have Japanese beetles where you live? I never had more than a few in OH, but in MI this past summer the buggers dined quite well on my basil crop. They wanted to decimate it! I think I need to raise my basil in a greenhouse! They got more of it than we did.

I thought I had French tarragon, but it certainly runs amok. I'm selling my house and will be doing everything in containers from now on.

I live in SE PA and the beetles are just terrible. I also have problems with groundhogs and even doves and hummingbirds, which I feed, love and attract. They suck every bit of juice out of a tomato the day it peaks! I buy a lot of netting to protect my herbs and plants, especially tomatoes. The birds stay away from it, and the beetles aren't nearly as successful in ruining my crop. One year, I accidentally touched the netting with my lawn tractor and it immediately wrapped around the blades. You can't even imagine the mess and trouble and expense getting that fixed.

I grow most of my basil outdoors, but also have a couple plants in my sunroom. Protected from pests, but I can't get it to grow all year like some other herbs.

Hate anise. Hate fennel, unless it's very, very mild, then it's barely tolerable. Hate licorice. Tarragon is usually okay in small quantities.

I grew up hating black licorice and having a strong aversion to fennel seeds and tarragon. I still can't stand star anise.

However, I've grown to enjoy fennel bulbs, cooked. Preferably tossed with carrots and onions and roasted with a whole chicken until soft and carmelized. Those are lovely. They are also wonderful braised in heavy cream, white wine and garlic with a little parmesan cheese.

I really like anise-like flavors in savory foods, like Italian sausage, or meats braised with star anise. I never seemed to care for it in candy, such as licorice, and other sweets.

Fennel = crazy delicious

I put it in my lasagna. I grind some fennel seed in my coffee. I even have fennel flavoured toothpaste (Crest extreme herbal mint).

I understand that it's not too popular. Fennel is the jazz of flavours. It requires a bit of understanding to be appreciated.

Most people today do not want to be challenged by a flavour. The "tongue tastes" (sweet, sour, salty, meaty, fatty) are winning out over nose flavours. People drink out of straws so that they don't have to smell their beverages. Boring brown food is king as proven by the popularity of the failure pile in a sadness bowl.

A coworker explaining his hatred of black licorice compared it to the similarly shaped red candy. "With the red stuff I could eat it through the whole movie".

Well who said you were supposed to eat licorice like that? One is enough. Somehow our internal gluttons demand for us to eat only that which can be continuously stuffed into our guts without waking up the part of our minds that appreciates flavour. It is a sort of willful ignorance.

If you don't like fennel, please consider that maybe you are wrong. As much as you are entitled to your own opinions, in this case, you are just being picky. Please go to the bulk store and buy one tiny piece from the licorice allsorts bin. Try to remember the first time you tried a really hot chicken wing. Harness that sense of adventure and try this little candy. It's not bad for you. It's not even bad. It is flavourful. It is interesting.

I like fennel seed. But try as I might, I can't tolerate fresh fennel. It seems to overwhelm the flavor of everything else on the plate.

I am definitely one of the non-fennel lovers.... i just don't like the taste of fennel/anise/licorice at all.... i always get the weirdest looks at butcher counters when I ask how fennelly their italian sausage is. My aversion to fennel even lingers over to basil, some of the basil just has too much of an anisey flavor to it... so, yeah, tarragon is out too. LOL....

and drastic... I don't think I'm being picky, I have tried to like fennel on many occassions, but I just can't do it... it's one of the very few herbs/veggies that I just don't like.

Oh yeah, and I forgot about the star anise and Pernod aversions, also. And Chinese 5 spice!
I'll never forget the road trip when I had a bag of jelly bellies to munch on. I wasn't paying attention and popped a black one in my mouth. We had to open the windows and stop for gas to air the car out. I felt so mean.

@Perky - that is what I did at the new house last year. We just moved in the spring and were landscaping until Nov. I took my mint out of the terra cotta pot on the porch and transferred it to a big plastic one and sunk it in the ground in the herb garden in Oct. That has worked for me pretty well before.

@frederika........i have the same aversion to WHITE jelly beans. a thread for Easter perhaps?

Fennel is one of those things like cilantro - you either love it or hate it, there's rarely a middle ground.

I am Italian and we had it after every holiday meal, served with the fruit and nuts, as a digestive aid. Later in life, I discovered that some people actually cook fennel! Wow! That was a revelation. I now make it baked with cheese in a type of gratin dish, and I like to mix it with other veggies but the truth be told, it's an overpowering flavor.

Rather not eat foods with fennel or anise. I do like licorice, tho'

I think Frederika may be on to something; liquorice is very popular in northern Europe, and most Americans I know dislike it, apart from, perhaps the red stuff, which isn't liquorice anyway (they're plastic cherry or strawberry flavour, and liquorice isn't a colour/texture, but a flavour). Although my mother, who never cared much for sweets at all, always liked liquorice as a child.

I've always liked liquorice very much (although I'm not always up for salmiak), and fennel and anise, too, although I really don't like fennel in sausage. The combination seems wrong, and it smells like a wet dog, to me.

I omitted a detail: I've lived outside the US a lot, but I am American, and my solid affection for liquorice developed when I was a child in Western NY state.

i like fennel both raw and cooked, albeit in small amounts, and i adore fennel seeds in sausage and on bread. i have never cared for licorice.

i'd guess that your husband's strong aversion is an allergy or sensitivity.


Perky - what flavor ARE white jelly beans supposed to be anyway? Pineapple, cream soda, the absence of color, absence of any discernible flavor or what? Mashed potato, marshmallow, milk? We definitely have to remember that one for an Easter question. It's an enigma.

cybercita, I think it could be plain loathing, even without a sensitivity or allergy... I cannot stand cooked eggs in any form (scrambled eggs can make me sick on the spot), but can swallow a raw one without flinching (but seldom do, what with salmonella running rampant).

mongoose - You can actually swallow a raw egg? Why do you do that?

I am beyond addicted to fresh, delicious raw fennel. I think it all staretd with cravings for celery - which I was never a huge fan of before. For a few months I couldn't get enough af fresh celery every day. Then one day I picked up some fennel instead, and now that's all I want. I now go through 2-3 bulbs a week, and I stalk the poor produce people at the supermarket. I seriously know what day they restock fennel on, and I get seriously perturbed if their is none or it is in bad shape when I visit. I really hope it doesn't go out of season b/c I don't know what I will do. I have heard that there is some compound in fennel that can give a euphoric effect, but not sure ifthere is any truth to that? I do really feel addicted.

BTW, Hubby won't even try it, not that he has a specific aversion to it. More for me! I just love the fresh juicy taste.

Add a comment:

Comments can take up to a minute to appear - please be patient!

Previewing your comment:

 

HTML Hints

Some HTML is OK: <a href="URL">link</a>, <strong>strong</strong>, <em>em</em>

Comment Guidelines

Post whatever you want, just keep it seriously about eats, seriously. We reserve the right to delete off-topic or inflammatory comments. Learn more at our Comment Policy page.

If you see something not so nice, please, report an inappropriate comment.

Start Talking!

Need a question answered? Have advice to share? Start a Talk topic now!

Sign up to start a talk topic

Sign up to get your questions answered and share advice.

Sponsored Link

Recipe

Mango Bean Salad

Fresh fruit and hearty beans make a refreshing side for our Morningstar Farms® Southwestern Style Veggie Cakes.
Get this recipe »