• Share:
  • Send to StumbleUpon
  • Send to Facebook
  • Send to del.icio.us
  • Send to digg

Goat Farming: A More Ethical, Healthier Dairy?

I was wasting time surfing food blogs, and I found mention that some people who fill uncomfortable with the in-and-outs of bovine dairy farming (separating calves from their mothers, keeping cows continually pregnant) prefer goat dairy products.

How is goat farming different? Does anybody know? I imagine that goat farmers are more likely to be independent, organic, etc., and that they probably operate on a much smaller scale, resulting in less pollution, etc.

I'm very curious. I'll eat my local chevre and crottin regardless, but it would be nice to know the practices behind my delicious salad toppings, pasta mix-ins, and lasagna fillings .

4 Comments:

We are generally small enough not to be able to afford a lot of chemical /antibiotic/ hormone inputs like rBGH.

I was wasting time surfing food blogs, and I found mention that some people who fill uncomfortable with the in-and-outs of bovine dairy farming (separating calves from their mothers, keeping cows continually pregnant) prefer goat dairy products.
How is goat farming different?

The questions you've come up with to ask, Karyn - prove that your surfing expedition was no waste of time.

I look forward to hearing thoughts on this, too. :)

I decided to do some googling.

I think the blog post I saw referred to the fact that goats are seasonal breeders. Does are bred in the fall to give birth in the spring, resulting in less milk production through the late winter. Some people are concerned that keeping cows continually pregnant results in unhealthy sex-hormone levels in their milk. The goats' natural reproductive cycle makes forced milk production a little harder. Goats spend less time pregnant, too (5-6 months instead of 9, like a cow).

Like cows, does are bred to produce one baby per year, but does are supposed to go through a two month "dry" period, in which their milk production is deliberately reduced or halted. I'm not sure if cows do the same thing (google "dairy cows," you get some dubious sources).

I read that cracked corn is considered an appropriate food for dairy goats, but that goats should be fed a mix of grains and roughage (i.e. high quality hay or grass). So I don't think too many goats eat mutant American corn (a food that leads to health problems in dairy and meat cows).

I also read that goats are milked on stands, which might imply that dairy goats spend more time outside than dairy cows, because you don't need a large barn to milk them. Might imply. But you can no doubt box-stall a goat, too.

Kids, like calves, are separated from their mothers after they receive "first milk." They are raised on cow milk or formula.

Goats produce much less milk than cows, averaging 3-4 quarts a day. Holstein cows can produce 30 liters a day. I'm guessing that goat bodies go through less stress during milk production, simply because they're not producing huge yields).


Goats are not supposed to be milked if antibiotics are in their system.

In summary, goat dairy products might be a healthier option than factory-farm cows’ milk, although small, organic, free-range cow dairy producers are probably a good option, too. Environmentally, goats might make less impact because they’re usually raised on smaller farms.

If “animal rights” are your cause, drink non-dairy milk, because goats don’t make enough for kids and humans to share.

Also, according to the American Goat Dairy Association, does don’t smell.

Add a comment:

Comments can take up to a minute to appear - please be patient!

Previewing your comment:

 

HTML Hints

Some HTML is OK: <a href="URL">link</a>, <strong>strong</strong>, <em>em</em>

Comment Guidelines

Post whatever you want, just keep it seriously about eats, seriously. We reserve the right to delete off-topic or inflammatory comments. Learn more at our Comment Policy page.

If you see something not so nice, please, report an inappropriate comment.

Start Talking!

Need a question answered? Have advice to share? Start a Talk topic now!

Sign up to start a talk topic

Sign up to get your questions answered and share advice.