• Share:
  • Send to StumbleUpon
  • Send to Facebook
  • Send to del.icio.us
  • Send to digg

Another KitchenAid Question

I am not sure if this has been asked before but I couldn't find the question. I am buying a stand mixer as a gift (partly for myself) and I am wondering if people have suggestions about the different sizes and wattage. Price is of course an issue, but I would much rather spend the money then get something that does not do the job I want or breaks in a year. we wouldn't use it a ton, mostly for pizza dough and some candy and cookie making. some wattages ive seen are 275, 325, and 350 Is the low end model good enough?

8 Comments:

If you are going to be using your mixer for dough I suggest getting the highest wattage you can afford. Furthermore I personally (as a novice bread maker with muscular dystrophy so the kneading ability certainly saves me A LOT of energy) highly recommend a model with the SPIRAL dough hook and not the one on lower end models.

I got a new KA this year, after several months of research on what kind is right for me, I chose a 5-quart Pro Plus, it's 450 watts and has worked like a dream every single time. I have read that anything under and around 300 watts is not good on the machine if you make a lot of dough. And some attachments are highly stressful or may not work on a lower wattage machine.

However you need to consider whether you want bowl-lift or lift head, we had a lift head for 18 years, after switching to bowl I find I like the bowl lift much better, but I also have a wider bowl which makes adding ingredients very easy without stopping the machine.

Pricewise I suggest QVC if you're looking to buy new, if KA is featured they have an easypay option, usually 4 or 5 interest free payments. If you want refurbished check Amazon or the KitchenAid website, just be warned I had some issues with Amazon getting their descriptions mixed up and was told they would not guarantee which one you receive, and since I only wanted the spiral dough hook I chose to buy a new model through QVC.

But I will say if I were to get an Artisan I probably would've gone through Amazon as if you scroll through color options, prices can vary by almost a hundred dollars so if you aren't too attached to a specific color you can probably get a phenomenal deal.

Kohls.com has a comparison chart of the mixers they sell that was helpful to me in finding what specifications I needed, also browse around the internet for what people have to say, the KA website also has a discussion forum with specific posts about "what mixer is right for me?" and I found that very helpful as well.

There are rebates this time of year and please bear in mind you will (hopefully) have this machine for decades so that's why I suggest getting the best model you can afford. Good Luck!

I've been looking into stand mixers lately. If you do a lot of dough, you should go with the highest wattage you can afford.

That said, it seems a LOT of people have been really unhappy with the newer Kitchenaid mixers. Apparently the quality has gone way down, and people are reporting lots of break-down and convenience issues, especially when working dough. My kitchen is fully equipped with Kitchenaid "professional" appliances. If my experience with their quality and performance is any indication of what can be expected of the stand mixer, I absolutely wouldn't buy it.

That's why I've asked Santa to bring me a De'Longhi 7-quart stand mixer. The DSM5 has a 750 watt motor; the DSM7 has 1100 watts. Both have a 10 year motor warranty. It's not perfect, but seems by far to have the best overall user satisfaction of all the models I've looked at, including the Viking and other more expensive makes. Of course, it's not nearly as cute as the Kitchenaid, but oh well.

http://www.delonghi.com/Int/USA/prodotti.html

I'd love to hear others' experiences.

Before dropping a whole lot of cash on any appliance -- especially one you cannot simply replace if you don't like it -- I suggest you so some research. Go to Consumer Reports and similar sites and look for reviews and comparisons. Cooks Illustrated has an article on stand mixers. It's is part of their subscription site though. (You sign up for a free 14-day trial membership.)

I'm an old KitchenAid fan. I know there are stronger mixers (like the Viking) but I'm a sucker for my KA.

You want to look at horse power...Bowl capacity...Available attachments (KA shines here)...And what kind of warranty the manufacturer offers.

I'll definitely second the recommendation to visit Cook's Ill and read the reviews. Frankly, they'd be the final authority if I were looking to make this type of purchase. Consumer Reports can offer me all kinds of info about cars and washing machines but I want a cook to tell me what type of mixer I should buy - look for opinions from kindred spirits.

Check www.ConsumerSearch.com for reviews, too. They consolidate reviews from multiple sources, and always include Cooks Illustrated's tests if there are any available. My only concern with CI reviews is that they don't seem to address overall durability issues, just performance (but I could be mistaken). Here's some of what was said recently about mixers:

Cook's Illustrated rates the KitchenAid Professional at the top of its list of kitchen mixers. They say the wide bowl spews flour more readily than tall-bowl mixers, but that it makes a smoother job of scraping and adding ingredients. In addition, the KitchenAid Professional 600 combines dough faster and more easily than other models tested. If you want to make bread dough in your mixer, reviews say the KitchenAid Professional 600 should be your first choice. We did read some sporadic complaints about durability, but most owner reviews are positive. The latest user reviews continue to praise this machine for its last-a-lifetime quality and performance, although some say it's noticeably louder than smaller KitchenAid mixers. A few remark that if you don't plan to mix bread and heavy dough, the Artisan is a much better value.

We did find some good reviews for stand mixers other than those manufactured by KitchenAid. Reviewers say the DeLonghi DSM5 (*est. $295) , which is known in other countries as the Kenwood Chef Classic, is on par with the KitchenAid Professional 600. One review in a New Zealand-based Consumer magazine gives it top billing for overall performance, noting that the pouring shield is a perfect fit. Cook's Illustrated says, "Watching this compact mixer expertly cream butter and sugar into a uniform consistency was a thing of beauty." Like the wide-width bowl of the KitchenAid Professional 600, the DeLonghi's bowl helps keep ingredients "low in the bowl" which cuts down on the need to scrape, say editors. The KitchenAid Professional scores a notch higher because the DeLonghi shimmied and made loud noises while mixing heavy ingredients. Customer reviews at Amazon.com are mixed. A few reviews say the DeLonghi mixer is better than a KitchenAid, but others complained that the machine is simply average in overall quality. The DeLonghi DSM5 does have a streamlined modern appearance, in contrast to the more traditional-looking KitchenAid machines. The 5-quart DeLonghi mixer has dishwasher-safe parts, a splash guard, dough hook, whisk and beater. Optional accessories include a juicer, potato peeler, slicer, grain mill and pasta maker.

I search sites like Amazon for volumes of consumer feedback about quality issues, ability to get things repaired, etc.

http://www.cooksillustrated.com/images/document/testing/ND05_StandingMixers.pdf
the kitchenaid out performs anyone else time and time again for the money or else I would have something else. (cost is not an issue)
I recently toyed with getting the Viking but agree its kind of bulky.

If the link doesn't load CI (which does not take any advertising) says:
RECOMMENDED:
KitchenAid Professional 600
With 18 models tested, a KitchenAid still came out on top—though just barely edging out the DeLonghi. With 575 watts (the median for the group), it plowed through 4 cups of dough almost two minutes faster than most “super-wattage” models. Ideal 6-quart capacity distributed wide (rather than tall) made for easy scraping and additions, if a bit more flour spray.
DeLonghi DSM5
Watching this compact mixer expertly cream butter and sugar into a uniform consistency was a thing of beauty. Flared bowl and well-sized attachments kept ingredients “low in the bowl” and minimized scraping. A bit more composure during heavy workloads might have broken the near-tie for first in its favor.

RECOMMENDED WITH RESERVATIONS
DeLonghi DSM7
The DSM7 suffered the plight of tall, cavernous bowls—difficulty whipping small amounts and awkward scraping of sides. (“The hardest part is keeping yourself clean,” noted one tester.) Despite huge-sounding wattage, more shaking and screeching with heavy loads than many other models.
KitchenAid Artisan
Kneading caused audible strain on the motor, as did adding heavy dry ingredients(oats) to cookie dough. Creamed and whipped like a pro—an economical choice for infrequent breadmakers. Narrow bowl mouth hindered tidy addition
of dry ingredients.

I recently bought a KitchenAid Professional 600 Series from Amazon for $210 after a rebate (choose the 'merigue' color). I probably don't need that much power, but it was cheaper than most of the Artisan models. If you don't mind a white mixer, it's a great deal. Works great so far, but as someone else mentioned it is rather noisy.

I got a great deal on my artisan mixer last year (amazon, low price at the time and two rebates). Have put it through its paces quite a bit with pizza dough, lots of cookie doughs, ice cream (maker attachment is wonderful!) and much more. Is holding up well. I'd recommend it.

Add a comment:

Comments can take up to a minute to appear - please be patient!

Previewing your comment:

 

HTML Hints

Some HTML is OK: <a href="URL">link</a>, <strong>strong</strong>, <em>em</em>

Comment Guidelines

Post whatever you want, just keep it seriously about eats, seriously. We reserve the right to delete off-topic or inflammatory comments. Learn more at our Comment Policy page.

If you see something not so nice, please, report an inappropriate comment.

Start Talking!

Need a question answered? Have advice to share? Start a Talk topic now!

Sign up to start a talk topic

Sign up to get your questions answered and share advice.