• Share:
  • Send to StumbleUpon
  • Send to Facebook
  • Send to del.icio.us
  • Send to digg

New Thanksgiving Recipes - a hit or a miss?

I posted a link in the Thanksgiving Recipes! thread earlier to a recipe for Sweet Potato Gnocchi with Apple Cider Sauce. Some one asked me to report on the results, so here goes:

I started late (mistake #1) making a recipe I had never made before (mistake #2). I hadn't cleared my counters (mistake #3) and my pastry bag was too small (mistake #4.) Then my food processor broke mid-puree. (Not really a mistake, call it mishap #5). I had to dig out my potato ricer to finish the dough. In spite of that, the gnocchi were actually pretty darn good!

This dough is very soft--a lot more potato than flour. You need to pipe it into boiling water since you could not possibly roll it. (You could spoon or scoop it though.) It cooks fast and overcooks very easily. 45 seconds is all it took, 60 seconds and the gnocchi turned to mush. I browned them off ahead of time and then packaged up the sauce, sage and gnocchi separately to travel. I crisped them up and sauced them right before dinner. They were very tasty, not overly sweet. The apple came through nicely, the sage wasn't overpowering. Nice fall flavors and pretty colors.

All in all, I'd say it was a hit; I would make it again. Any else try a recipe for the first time on Thanksgiving? How did yours turn out?

Cheers,
Karen

10 Comments:

I pulled a recipe off of http://kitchen.apartmenttherapy.com/ for a Ginger Pumpkin Pie that I thought sounded wonderful (I love both), esp b/c of the graham cracker crust. As I just posted on their site, I used the Trader Joe's ginger spread in the custard, and despite adding some ground Ginger Snaps to the crust to boost the ginger level even more, I can't believe how UN-gingery this was! That's my only complaint. Other than that, I thought it was really easy to make and a great consistency--I'll just add a lot more ginger next time and/or make a ginger snap crust instead of a combo with the graham crackers. It was my first time making a pumpkin pie of any type (I cook far more than I bake), and I was pleased with the overall results.

Made the sweet potato puree with vanilla that was posted here a while back, and used about 3 pounds sweet potatoes, upped the other ingredients more-or-less accordingly, and used tangerine peel rather than orange (use what you have on hand, you know). Quite successful, and I kept it warm in my rice cooker for 2 hours since the turkey took far longer than I expected.

I made my first all-butter pie crust. I'm very proud of it - it came out just as flaky as my mother's version, which she made with shortening,

I also made stuffed pumpkin and two dressings entirely from scratch. I though the pumpkin terrific - but no one else wanted to eat it (they're scared if lentils, which I didn't expect). They also preferred my traditional cornbread dressing to one I made with root vegetables, almonds, and apples (uh, what's in it again?). How did I end up in such a new-thing fearing family? Le sigh.

I'm going to have to try that gnocchi soon! Thanks for the tips. :)

We had two new dishes this year. I made the pies (sis had dinner this year). Did the usual apple and pumpkin and a new one - chocolate chip. The ones who had it loved it and wanted the recipe so it was a success; however, it was a bit too sweet for me!

Mom made a new corn recipe she found in a woman's magazine which was really good and slightly spicy. Not sure what it had in it but we all really liked it.

I made the cheese-straw apple pie from this site. It was pretty tasty, and not too hard; I kept the butter and then the dough very cold, which helped manage the crust. There is *a lot* of fat in that crust - butter and cheddar cheese - and it came out nice and crispy, and really did taste like a cheese straw. However, the granny smith apples I used were sour and otherwise tasteless; next time I'll use a somewhat sweeter apple and/or use more brown sugar, for a better contrast with the completely savory crust. Also, I imagine 2 teaspoons of cayenne would be way too much; one was plenty.

I made Daniel Boulud's Chestnut Soup from Dorie Greenspan's blog:
http://www.doriegreenspan.com/dorie_greenspan/2007/11/i-know-how-hard.html

Everyone absolutely loved it, even self-professed chestnut haters (like my mom). I must admit to using chestnut puree instead of fresh, but the soup was still sublime.

Dominic
the zen kitchen

I made the Mushroom Pie from the November 2006 Bon Appetit, and it was extremely well recieved. Instead of using only 1 3/4 pounds of cremini mushrooms, I used about 1 pound cremini, 1/4 pound oyster, 1/4 pound hen of the woods, and 1/2 cup of dried wild mushrooms soaked in a cup of hot water. The sour cream crust was the perfect flaky complement to the savory filling, and I'll definitely use it again for other savory tart recipes! The only change I would make to the recipe is to use mascarpone or heavy cream instead of 8 oz cream cheese in the mushroom filling, since it was a little overpowering for my taste.

Carrot Souffle is a relatively new addition. I made it sort of in a hurry and didn't like the outcome (not servable to guests, anyway) so I re-made it. Muuuuuch better. Everyone loved it and when I'm left with an empty serving bowl (after the "take your leftovers!" sweep), I consider it a success.

The Mushroom & Green Beans I added at the last second disappeared too and that was utterly simple. Sauteed some chopped shallots in a little butter, added the shrooms, allowed them to give up their water, added a splash of wine, added the green beans.

I made 2 new recipes as well, I was in charge of the squash & the sweet potatoes.....I got both recipes online, although I don't remember where. I made an acorn squash & nutmeg puree....which turned out wonderful, and was very well received.
I also made a sweet potato gratin....forgetting to carmelize the onions because I got distracted.....it turned out good, even though the onions were alittle stronger than they should have been because of the lack of carmelization. Unfortunately though, this dish didn't go over as well with the family, who wanted a more traditional sweet potato dish. Next year I guess it's back to candied or mashed sweet potatoes!

i used the vodka pie crust from cooks. it really was a snap to make and tasted wonderful. i used it for a pecan pie. next time i'll blind bake it first {the recipe called for an unbaked pie shell and the crust, which has an extremely high fat content, sort of melted into the pie on the bottom, which made it hard to serve}.

Add a comment:

Comments can take up to a minute to appear - please be patient!

Previewing your comment:

 

HTML Hints

Some HTML is OK: <a href="URL">link</a>, <strong>strong</strong>, <em>em</em>

Comment Guidelines

Post whatever you want, just keep it seriously about eats, seriously. We reserve the right to delete off-topic or inflammatory comments. Learn more at our Comment Policy page.

If you see something not so nice, please, report an inappropriate comment.

Start Talking!

Need a question answered? Have advice to share? Start a Talk topic now!

Sign up to start a talk topic

Sign up to get your questions answered and share advice.