• Share:
  • Send to Reddit
  • Send to StumbleUpon
  • Send to Facebook
  • Send to del.icio.us
  • Send to digg

I've never really understood the appeal of ...

I'm sure there are foods whose enduring popularity leaves you baffled. In my case, it's fruit pies and blue cheese.

What about you?

59 Comments:

Lobster. To me, it's just an expensive way to eat lobster. Don't get me wrong, I love shellfish and seafood in general, even enjoying a sandwich of Chesapeake Bay soft-shell crab, legs and claws included. But lobster? I don't understand the popularity.

Wow, do I ever need more coffee ... I meant to write, "To me, it's just an expensive way to eat butter". Anyone have an espresso IV pump?? :-(

Holiday Green Bean Casserole. I can't imagine the appeal of overcooked green beans, cream of mushroom soup topped wth fake fried onions. I know I'll get pelted for that one but I just never understood why this was such a beloved dish.

Pudding... I know this sounds mad, but I am very sensitive to textures, and the texture of pudding is so incredibly unappealing to me. By the way, everyone from my grandmother to my husband thinks I'm crazy for this!

Lobster and fried eggs. I agree, definitely, that lobster is usually just an excuse to eat butter. On the other hand, I like lobster most of the time when there's minimal butter and other flavorings added (like in soup, as lobster salad, on a roll). I also had never eaten a fried egg until last spring, and even then, I couldn't get over my fear of runny yolks. They just gross me out. I'm fine with raw egg yolk in a homemade mayo, or something like that where it's totally emulsified and hidden, but when its oozing all over the bread and sides and your face....just not appealing.

PsychSarah - for a friend of mine, it's Jell-O or for that matter, anything with gelatine, including Bavarian creams. She just wretches at the thought of putting a wiggly block of food in her mouth.

Oddly, I agree with all of the things mentioned above. ChristineB, I don't much like fried eggs either, although it's not because of the yolk, but instead because they are usually dripping with grease. In the retro spirit of the green bean casserole comment, I really don't get the appeal of jello 'salad'. Particularly the kind that involves mayonnaise. Jello is never a salad! It's a contradiction in terms!! Get with the programme!!!

I've never understood the appeal of grapes in chicken salad. I put a bite of chicken salad in my mouth expecting something savory. If I get a blast of fruit in there, it just grosses me out. Living in the south, I have to be very wary of this kind of thing!

Sushi. Although I have had wonderful, fresh sushi to me it always tastes well raw.

@chiff I agree and I never make it, I make my green beans wth olive oil, garlic and shallots for turkey day, althought I did try the green bean recipe with yellow summer squash and it was good, one year we had a huge crop of it and the family got kind of tired of it so I hid it on my version of greenbean cassarole minus greenbeans.

Pimento cheese having lived in the south I think it is a salty processed cheese food mess, thank God the south is coming a long.

Eggs over easy or soft boiled eggs, egg yolk raw or hardly cooked grosses me out.

Scrapple ever since I was a kid the thought of that mouth full of dust with the pig taste, ewwww

Brut or extra Brut champagne. Not my thing at all, My husband who lived in France assures me that brut champage is an export thing and there is good champagne they just do not export it here. I also heard there is good champagne on Air France. I will will keep tasting anything with a champanois grape but I prefer an Asti or Prosecco.

Asparagus, I make it but I don't eat it.

Bitter chocolate, I bake with it, it's not for me.

Cooked fruit, fruit pies, again I make them all the time cobblers too but I don't eat them the mouth feel and flavor are not pleasing to me.

Anchovies, except as an ingredient in Green Goddess dressing. And sardines. Tiny salty, oily fish hold no appeal here; or raw fish, for that matter, and steak tartare. Octopus and mahi mahi. (Does anyone see a theme here?) On the other fin, absolutely love shellfish, and, yeah, give me lobster with extra butter, please.

I second the votes against blue cheese and undercooked eggs. Robyn's front page post about her friend eating store-bought poached eggs made me want to hurl.

I will freely admit that I adore the green bean casserole my dad makes but can't stand anyone else's version. I'm not sure what he does to it. Perhaps it is because he's my dad and no one else can measure up?

Oysters- snot on the half shell? No, thank you
Mussels- chewy, gritty, icky. But my only experience with them was at culinary school. They were cold and I have no idea if they were prepared correctly so I probably shouldn't judge them so harshly.

-Pie crust, phyllo, any sort of flaky pastry thing.
-Honey. Possibly my least favorite flavor ever.
-Oysters, lobster, and crab. All other seafood, I love.
-Raspberries. They just taste rotten to me.
-Nutmeg in savory foods.

I agree with a lot of the comments:

Anything with pastry--savoury or sweet
Undercooked eggs (although overcooked eggs are pretty gross, too)
Seafood in general
Jello (I can handle about three bites of pudding but then the texture of that gets to me, too)
BBQ flavoured chips/crackers/ etc. The seaosoning doesn't taste like bbq, it just tastes fake.
Fake strawberry flavour

-Retro junk food that always appears on foodies' guilty pleasure lists: Wonder Bread, Hostess products, iceberg lettuce with blue cheese dressing, soda. That stuff doesn't taste good and never has.

-Risotto: A waste of good stock. Always sounds like something show-off foodies make.

-Lettuce-based salad with fruit. (Especially spinach with strawberries.)

-I agree about fruit pies and cobblers. I don't have a problem with the texture, but I can never bring myself to use good fruit that's in season for baking.

On the other hand, I *love* runny poached eggs.


Yulinka Cooks

I can't stand bleu cheese either - for the same reason I can't eat mushrooms - they taste like mold, like I'm being poisoned. Shudder.

I love a lot of the stuff on other folks' lists though!

Aunt Jone said: "Oysters- snot on the half shell? No, thank you."

ROFLMAO!

Wow, there are so many that I agree with!
Luna- I'm with you. Why eat lobster when there's crab to be had?
Chiff- No green bean casserole! Ever!!!
ChristineB- Yolky eggs= yuck
Jerzee- I'm not especially fond of any champagne or bubbly wine. I always try it because it seems nice on a special occasion, but never drink more than a sip.
blush- fake flavors are no good. I'd also add fake watermlon to your list.

Also, I don't understand the appeal of white pepper. To me, it tastes like something rotting. I can "taste it a mile away," and it ruins a dish for me. Anyone else have this experience, or am I alone on this one?

I'm sure I'm in the minority here, but mine is potatoes. (I know, I know, even my own mother thinks I'm insane.) They just don't taste good to me, in any form. I'll eat a few fries if you put them in front of me, but only if they're completely non-soggy and have plenty of salt (bonus point for malt vinegar). You can keep your baked or mashed potatoes, and your chips. I could live the rest of my life without ever eating anything potato and be perfectly happy.

I do love sweet potatoes though.

And... you all can pass the shellfish (especially lobster -- no butter, please -- and oysters), runny egg yolks (not runny whites - eew), mushrooms and blue cheese right over here! :)

A chef friend of mine is fond of saying "you've just never had it prepared correctly" whenever someone tells him they don't like something, and I tend to agree. But, there ARE a few things I don't understand their appeal.
1. Coconut. I'm sorry, this is NOT food although it does quite well as a flavor in some tropical drinks.
2. Oysters.
3. Grits, especially if shrimp is thrown in. Why waste a perfectly good crustacean by putting it in a bowl of grits?

And yulinka, while I don't mind risotto there's nothing "show-off" about it. It's really not hard to make... that's just a mind trick your friends are playing on you!

Oh, and one more thing... will you "genius" chefs out there please quit putting crap like lobster in mashed potatoes?

I've never appreciated calves liver, but I like chicken livers and pate. I'm not sure I fully appreciate foie gras, either. But I have to admit, many of the items listed in the comments before this one are very near and dear to me. Lobster, oysters, blue cheese, pastry... I have to hope that the reason why you all hate these things is because someone in your past didn't properly prepare them.

Only thing I really don't "get" is foie gras. I've tried it a few times now. I just don't get it. I read people rave on and on about the magical qualities of foie, but meh. I got nothin'. I don't dislike it, I don't think. I'm just sorta ambivalent. It definitely wasn't the palate-altering experience I've had described to me before.

Oh, and maybe the newfound infatuation with offal. I'm not sure I get that either. I don't know that I've eaten enough to really pass judgment, but you can't open a magazine, book, or site without someone extolling the virtues of candied veal eyebrows or some such.

I think a lot of these food dislikes come down to what you ate during childhood. For example, I never really ate any red meat growing up, and now I'm the only one among my friends who doesn't see the appeal of steak. I don't enjoy the taste or texture of beef in general. I feel the same way about pork. I can and do enjoy these meats in their ground forms though (in chili, burgers, and Asian food, for example).

You green bean casserole haters should try making it from scratch. It certainly makes you feel better about it and it actually tastes good.

My wife hates all cooked fruit. Me -- I'll try (and usually enjoy) everything. Except raw tomatoes...yuck! And it has nothing to do with my upbringing -- I'm the lone wolf in my family on this one.

Dominic
the zen kitchen

stinky cheese (especially feta and blue), any and all seafood, mayo, relish on hotdogs, anything pork-related, mushrooms.....I'm such a picky eater.

Those "artifical foods"---Jello, Cool Whip, artifical sweetners, fake fat...I need the real deal!

ONIONS! I hate onions and I've been chastised for it way too often.

Hillary
Chew on That

I'm like psychsara- no pudding. I try to avoid anything with a gelatinous, slimy texture. Especially pre-made chocolate milk that's been thickened with carrageenan... ARGH! I do understand why other people like pudding etc., but that dreadful slimy chocolate milk turns my stomach.

@corycm - candied veal eyebrows... hysterical! No offal for me either, TYVM.

Interesting how many of these comments are about texture rather than taste.

Too funny! I was just thinking about this the other day.

TASTE -- I truly enjoy almost everything, but a few flavors can turn me off to an entire dish. A few that come to mind are chipotle/adobo, lemon grass, and anything more than the subtlest suggestion of tarragon. Too bad for me that chipotle and lemon grass have become oh so trendy. I just don't get it :-(

TEXTURE -- I dislike almost all things foamy or airy. E.g., cotton candy, whipped cream (unless it's whipped till it's almost butter), meringue, foam on coffee drinks, marshmallows, etc. I'll consume 'em to be polite, but I'd rather not! There are a few odd ones that I can't eat, like tongue, fat (as on steak, etc.), semi-raw egg whites.

Oh. And menudo. I don't know how anyone can eat tripe... that stuff is beyond revolting (taste and texture both). Actually, the only innards I'll eat are sweetbreads -- they are heavenly!!! I'll give the rest to the dog.

Ew. What about fried pork rinds? That one's always been beyond me!

Pasta salad. Does anyone really *like* slimy, cold, flavorless noodles tossed with unappealing random stuff? or is it just a convenient picnic/potluck item?

I second deeoh's vote for grits. Why? Fried are ok, but boiled, you need to throw in a lot of butter, cheese, etc. for them to taste like anything.

the two things that are really sticking out to me right now are runny egg whites and fish/seafood of any kind.

escargot! my parents ate them on their first date so they have a special place in their hearts for them, but... SNAILS! shudder at the thought.

Caviar - probably because I first tried it while pregnant. Haven't eaten it since and the boy's 23 years old!

Filet Mignon and lobster are played out!!! And I would rather have a ribeye and lump jumbo crab meat if I really wanted to go that route.

Liver, including Foie...because I don't understanding eating (besides I don't really like the texture or feel of most cooked livers in my mouth) an organ thats main purpose is to clean the toxins out of the body.

I am a chef, and let me tell you I have yet to ruin some perfectly decent mashed potatoes by putting lobster in it.

tyronebcookin

okra.... eeeeeew!!!!!! like eating mucus.

Undercooked egg yolks, they look gorgeous but just taste bleh.

I dislike meringues.

Nutmeg grosses me out too...the smell is enough to make me lose my appetite.

I never liked meat, seafood, eggs or dairy products- hence my transition to veganism was practically instinct.
I also never liked honey, meringues, potatoes, bread, yeast or wheat products and nearly all nuts
Cant stand 'snack' food- like chips and cracker or maggi noodles. Avocado tastes too mushy and bland.
There's a whole lot of stuff I don't like I cant be bothered listing
I think I'm just an extremely picky eater

Pasta salad, blech.

Smoked foods. They just taste like they fell into the campfire and someone fished them back out..

Also, tofu.

chocolate. i used to just not eat it, but the whole culture of chocolate has made me really hate it.

a) the whole love-romance-sex-courtship-chocolate thing bums me out.

b) the way that people talk about chocolate bugs me, with the wink-wink, nudge-nudge, everybody-loves-it, hallmark-card-ness of it all.

c) the cutesy-pootsy chocolate therapy vibe is ridiculous.

c) i don't like foods that make me thirsty

I will try just about anything once....but I too have my limits. I absolutely hate cloves and nutmeg. You see something very appealing, take a bite and ewwwwwwwwww gross, spit and politely sputter into a napkin!! Its ruined by the use of nutmeg, It can ruin any entree or dessert. I love cinnamon, but not on savory items. And cloves, grossssssss. I once bit into one by accident and actually vomited. I actually hate the smell of them now in potpurri. Please, please leave out the nutmeg and cloves if you entertaining!!!!!!!
as for the others mentioned about,
love over easy eggs on top of hashbrown potatoes!!!
love grits with jam
love love loooove boiled okra with tomatoes!!! perfer boiled over fried,
love all types of shell fish, but emmm..can keep the raw, dont care for hepatitis.....dont care for sushi and the possible microbes either....
Not a big fan of brat sausages either, possiblly the spices arent appealing to me. Cant stand the taste of fake flavorings either, I want the real deal or nothing at all. If you cant "cook" a real meal, lets go out for dinner. :)

Mole sauce, fake banana flavoring, and dried coconut.

Pieds Des Anges: I agree, I don't see what the fuss is. After eating chocolate I feel sick, bloated and thirsty

Pieds Des Anges, I agree about chocolate culture. I like chocolate fine, but I hate that people act like chocolate eating is a bit naughty in a saucy sort of way. It isn't. It's just chocolate.
Kerosena, I too hate white pepper, and my boyfriend is always trying to sneak it in to things. I can taste it even if there is a minimal amount, and to me it tastes rancid.
Stumbler02 - I hear you about the meringues. What's the point? They're not bad exactly, they're just utterly useless.
Cybercita, I too dislike okra. The taste may be lovely, but I am turned off by the snotty consistency. Ugh.
I think my least favourite flavour of all time is fake 'purple' flavour. In the UK it is called currant, in the States it's grape. Even smelling it is enough to make me gag.

and here's another: those nasty flavored coffees. when i walk into a cafe and am hit with the chemically enhanced artificial hazelnut filling the air, it makes me ill.

I thought of another: cilantro! I know it's because I'm one of those people to whom it tastes like soap, but...I really can't imagine that it tastes so good to everyone else that it belongs in every single possible dish.

Also, any dessert involving peanut butter is repulsive to me. Peanut butter cup candy is okay (though close), but things like peanut butter cake, cookies? Ugh. Also can't stand sweetened, shelf-stable peanut butter like Skippy.

Interesting point about taste vs. texture. My dislikes are all about taste, while some others feel more strongly about texture. I can't really think of a food I dislike due to its texture...bring on the pudding, okra, cappuccino foam, and especially grits! (Though I am with you, caley, meringues are pretty pointless.)

Marshmellows, and anything marshmellow-ish, like meringue.

Cole slaw makes me want to puke, but I think it's just because my dad once forced me to eat a bite of Long John Silver's slaw when I was little "just to give it a try".

Also, for some reason I can't get into pickles, which is weird because I love both cucumbers and vinegar.

choc_puddin - so sorry... but out of curiosity, what *do* you eat?

cyber cita - totally agree with you about hazelnut coffee... yuck, what an awful smell! I'm at the point where the only ways I'll eat hazelnuts are whole and toasted, or maybe chopped up in chocolate. Nutella, hazelnut truffles, etc., frangelico - can't handle 'em.

My sister hates cumin. And I sort of understand why - in some forms, it tastes/smells like sweat.

I should've added that, even when I ate meat, I never understood the appeal of corned beef or pastrami - I'm as big a fan of fat as anyone, but fat and all that salt is just too much.

Goat cheese!!! It completely erases any other flavors out of your mouth. Too overpowering and tastes rancid. Every few months I try it again thinking maybe I've developed a taste for it . . . but no, still disgusting!

Texture-wise I can't stand water chestnuts. They are like eating bugs - your teeth feel every cell of them bursting as you bite through. Ewwww!

Truffles (the fungi not the sweets)! They just make everything taste so heavy and ... weird.

I also cannot figure out how people can like Sea Urchin. I've tried and enjoyed some pretty bizarre foods in my lifetime, but the color and texture of urchin is just about the most repulsive combo I've ever put in my mouth. Maybe it just wasn't fresh enough, but I'll *never* dare try it again to find out.

I had to think and think about this one. On accounta because I like most everything (except celery--blech!). But count me in on the raw shellfish and on anything bitter: angostura, frisee, radicchio, you name it. I just don't like bitter. I like sour--but I don't like bitter.

I agree with lobster. I was excited to try it for the first time when I was on a cruise, and I was disappointed that I didn't like it and didn't want to say so to my table mates, who seemed to enjoy it. It is overrated though. I agree crab is better.
New and specialty drinks are overrated, such as Coke Zero, that coffee Coke soda, weird colors of Pepsi, bottled teas, energy drinks, etc. I haven't tried most of them, but marketing all these specialty products when the basic stuff is best -- that makes them overrated.
Fennel. I find it tastes like black licorice, and I despise it. Once I got a bagel with fennel on it (which I didn't know until after I bought it), and even after I picked it all off, the flavor was still there in parts. Yuck.
I agree that the popularity of dark chocolate is enough to make you gag, but it doesn't stop my desire for chocolate!
I also don't get why innards are so popular. I've never tried them, so I can't judge them by taste, but the idea of eating certain parts like kidneys and tongue really bothers me.
I have to say, though, that I love fried eggs, especially dipping toast or hash browns into the yolk. Perhaps it is because I liked fried eggs when I was a kid.
I don't jump on any food bandwagon. I just eat what I like and don't care whether or not all the "cool" people like it!

I hate beets. I will eat almost anything that isn't a beet. And pickled beets? Sick.

There are things I just don't like (mushrooms, coconut), but things I don't 'get' are:

Arugula: That stuff is vile and chefs use it in everything!
Lobster: It taste like dirty water.
Reuben sandwiches: Just ew. Don't like rye. Don't like 'kraut. Don't like pastrami or corned beef.

Soft cooked eggs. Yech. I can't even look at a white that isn't rock solid without getting queasy.

Roe of any kind. It's like little disgusting fishy eyeballs popping open in my mouth.

Any form of liver. I don't care if it's fois gras or pate or plain old calves/chicken liver - it's disgusting.

I find a lot of these pretty shocking--especially coming from food-o-philes! Egg yolk, mushrooms, blue cheeses, arugula (!!!), grits (!!!!!). I feel that many people have had run-ins with bad versions of these foods, e.g. there are a LOT of bad grits out there, but good ones are really something special. Maybe I'm just into things that are "acquired tastes" but I count most things listed here among my favorite foodstuffs (green bean casserole, a notable exception).

RE: Sea urchin

The first time I tried it, it was one of the most repulsive things I've ever eaten--in retrospect, I think it just wasn't very fresh. It was probably 5 years before I would try it again. I've got to say though, it's now one of my favorite foods. I had some recently at Uchi in Austin, TX, and the taste/texture were somewhere along the lines of a creme brulee with a hint of ocean. In a word: wonderful.

Summation: if you ever find yourself in a high-end sushi restaurant, and everything else is hitting the spot, you might want to at least consider the urchin.

Add a comment:

Comments can take up to a minute to appear - please be patient!

Previewing your comment:

 

HTML Hints

Some HTML is OK: <a href="URL">link</a>, <strong>strong</strong>, <em>em</em>

Comment Guidelines

Post whatever you want, just keep it seriously about eats, seriously. We reserve the right to delete off-topic or inflammatory comments. Learn more at our Comment Policy page.

If you see something not so nice, please, report an inappropriate comment.

Start Talking!

Need a question answered? Have advice to share? Start a Talk topic now!

Sign up to start a talk topic

Sign up to get your questions answered and share advice.