• Share:
  • Send to Reddit
  • Send to StumbleUpon
  • Send to Facebook
  • Send to del.icio.us
  • Send to digg

Myths in the Kitchen

Sometimes cooks just do things without really thinking them through. They heard or read somewhere that such-and-such was true, but they never really checked to see if there was any basis in fact. For example, for years and years, people always said that you should remove the germ / sprout from a clove of garlic because it tends to be bitter. But when then you realize that it's not bitter, but actually kind of tasty, and all these years, you've been throwing it away.

So, what kitchen myth have you seen perpetuated that you've since found to be completely off the mark?

24 Comments:

kind of off topic, but in regards to the garlic sprout, i'm all for it. i usually put garlic cloves that have started to sprout in a pot full of potting soil, and water like you would any other plant. eventually, the sprouts grow tall and you can cut them and use them like chives, with a nice light garlicky flavor.

but the myth of rubbing your hands with something made out of stainless steel under running water to get rid of the garlic smell? doesn't work for me and never has.

Any tip on cutting an onion without crying- like chewing on a toothpick while you slice or running the onion under water. Totally bogus. I think a scuba mask is the only way to stop the tears.

One kitchen trick that does work is rubbing your hands on a stainless steel item after handling onions- takes the smell right out!

Putting salt in the water will make pasta, potatoes, whatever cook more quickly. Uh, no. Putting salt in the water lowers the boiling point of water. That means that the water will boil at a lower temperature. Lower temperature = longer cooking time.

I'm not sure that anyone puts enough salt in their water to actually have a noticeable affect on cooking time, but it still bothers me that I've seen this advice over and over and over!

Putting oil in the cooking water for pasta. Leads to slimy pasta, and a wadteof good cooking oil

I don't know about how it affects cooking but adding salt to water INCREASES its boiling point...CHem 101.

french tart, try saving your coffee grounds from the morning if you are going to cook with garlic and rub your fingers in them!

As to the myths about tricks to avoid tears while cutting onions-- the one I most hear in my family is to light a candle and place it nearby. Could be psychosomatic, but it's always worked for me. (Thank god.)

Christina, I'd read that trick somewhere and the explanation seemed to make good sense. I relayed it to a friend who nearly burned off her long hair. No tears though!

For the onions we always used the big saran/plastic food wrap around our head to cover our eyes (kind of makes you feel like a ninja turtle, and silly like one) thats the only one I have really found works.

The change of degrees (in water) from adding salt is 1 degree, at max 2, so using the old salt cliche for cooking faster doesn't really play into any serious cooks mind.

Want to read something that really blows your mind? Look up fruits that ripen (and those that don't) - online with the United States Department of Agriculture...Why? Because things like this= Pineapples DO NOT ripen after being cut or picked from the tree! It's also a myth that you can tell a fresh pineapple by a yellow color.

Just as in reverse, Avocado's do not ripen on the tree.

You would be surprised at what actually does not ripen after separating from the plant.

...cook, chef, culinary sponge, traveler, volunteer, missionary.
tyronebcookin

The one sure thing I found for tears and onions is contact lenses. In the many years that I wore contacts, never once had a problem, but now that I've gone back to glasses.... wow, I miss my contacts LOL.

I didn't cry when I cut an onion recently, but my eyes stung badly, and I was wearing contacts. So, I would say that contacts are not a good solution. Then, what was worse: I cut a jalapeno pepper and then had to go into another room without having a chance to wash my hands. My nose itched because of allergies, and I scratched it. Then my nose burned! It was not a good night for my nose and eyes.
My mom said when onions make your eyes sting, drink chocolate milk. I like to have choc. milk nearby. It helps, somehow. Perhaps it's just mind over matter!


Onion tears are the worst. I remember I was cutting up onions for a something (not sure what; something that required lots of onions) and a friend unexpectedly dropped by. I came to the door with tears rolling down my face, and it took me awhile to convince my friend that I wasn't having a breakdown in the kitchen.

And here's a funny link for different methods of avoiding the problem, from holding bread, matches, and a toothpick in your mouth to holding just your wrist under cold water while slicing the onion. Hmm. What would science say?

Tyrone, I liked your comment. Never knew that about fruit/veggies, but it certainly makes sense.

As for onions, I "whistle while I work." Placebo effect? Probably. And now I have this mental link between onions and the seven dwarves.

keep your onion in the fridge for a couple of hours before cutting- it slows the release of chemicals which make your eyes water. Always works for me :D

I add salt to pasta water for one reason and one reason only - it's tasteless without salt.

Myths run rampant due to old wives tales.

My mother used to make me throw a quarter in the pan while I sauteed portobello mushrooms (when they first started being available in supermarkets). Her logic was that "the quarter will turn black if the mushroom is poisonous." I think all it accomplished was giving me my daily requirement of heavy metal.

Raw Garlic is poisonous if you cut your finger with a knife that you used to cut raw garlic. Mom said the mafia used to rub their bullets with garlic so if the bullet didn't kill you the garlic would finish the job. (Ridiculous but colorful.)

Spicy foods and/or stress causes gastric ulcers. A virus causes ulcers.

Onion tears? Scuba mask is the only way I've been able to avoid it but you can bet I'll be trying Tyrone's Saran Wrap tip. Tyrone, you should send that tip in to Fine Cooking or Cook's Illustrated.

Hahaha!

Thanks, maybe I will...

tyrone

The myth about choosing male over female eggplant for fewer seeds drives me nuts.

And the myth about cooking dried beans and salt. Salting beans during cooking does not keep them from softening.

I wasn't going to comment on the onions, but I second that refrigerating them does help. Also, use your sharpest knife. Now on to steak.

Salting steaks before cooking does not dry them out as some chefs suggest. It does make then taste a whole lot better than salting them afterwards. It brings tasty proteins to the surface of the meat which gets caramelized for further flavor. Also, searing does not keep in juices - it only caramelizes proteins, but I don't hear that one so much anymore.

Tyrone, a good myth to expose. Jeffrey Steingarten has an entire chapter on the topic in his book The Man Who Ate Everything. I posted a summary of that for Eat Local Challenge. Add to the list of ones that will NOT ripen after picking: Blackberries, cacao, cherries, dates, grapes, grapefruit, lemons, limes, lichi, mandarins, olives, oranges, raspberries, strawberries and watermelons.

Juice from an onion releases a gas that creates hydrochloric acid when it mingles with the liquid of your eyes. That's why they burn and tear.

I used to open a kitchen window nest to my table I worked at before I knew this and let a draft carry away the onion air (a fan will do also) until my wife bought me onion goggles. A pair of glasses with rubber that keeps your eyes protected from onion gas.

Every now and then I chop a shallot and don't bother to get the goggles from the drawer and I start to tear up and wonder why I think I would be so quick as to avoid the burning eyes. (I'm no super knife skilled Iron Chef.)

Buy the goggles. They work great or chop onions before a breezy window.

How about the use of the word "caramelize" to mean "brown"?

Everyone is caramelizing everything nowadays. Caramelization refers to the oxidation of sugar, so since onions have a lot of sugar, we can get away with the use of that word.

Because it's become common usage, it's not like it bothers me, but while sugars can caramelize, proteins undergo maillard reactions when they brown.

In the salted, seared steak example, the great thing about salting a steak and letting it sit before cooking it is that the salt draws out water from the flesh and with the water comes dissolved amino acids, which, when exposed to heat, undergo maillard reactions and become delicious and brown.

With onions, breaking the cell walls allows enzymes in different parts of different cells in the onion to intermingle, creating gases that, when they meet the water in your eyes, create sulfuric acid. Ouch. The best way to protect yourself is to protect your eyes, refrigerate the onion and use a sharp knife. This minimizes exposure to and intermingling of the chemicals.

And the story of the flame and the onion is if you put the flame near the onion, it creates convection currents, and the fumes from the onion move with the air toward the flame and when they reach it they are incinerated. I'm not sure how well it works or how exactly to position oneself to minimize exposure, but it's worth a try.

What about adding salt to the water when hard boiling eggs? There has always been a controversy about that - is there any validity? I always add salt but really only because my mother did it that way!

frederika: I don't add salt to water for boiling eggs...never knew there was a controversy ? That one is news to me...either Harold McGee or 'The New Kitchen Science' can bring you up to speed quick with things like that.

I haven't had problems with graying yolks or problems peeling eggs once learning science behind it...which is just usually consistent methods or understanding the food itself.

ExpatChef: It drove me nuts trying to convince my 'bosses' that those fruits did not ripen after picking! Finally had to break them down with the old USDA site!

...cook, chef, culinary sponge, traveler, volunteer, missionary.
tyronebcookin

Thanks Tyrone - I have actually been hard-boiling my freaking eggs according to Tony Bourdain's freaking directions in LesHalle cookbook and they are so freaking perfect every time! But I must admit I snuck in a pinch of salt - what can I say? Creature of habit.
I am now egg-ucating myself on Harold McGee's basic egg dishes pages 87 thru 89!

Add a comment:

Comments can take up to a minute to appear - please be patient!

Previewing your comment:

 

HTML Hints

Some HTML is OK: <a href="URL">link</a>, <strong>strong</strong>, <em>em</em>

Comment Guidelines

Post whatever you want, just keep it seriously about eats, seriously. We reserve the right to delete off-topic or inflammatory comments. Learn more at our Comment Policy page.

If you see something not so nice, please, report an inappropriate comment.

Start Talking!

Need a question answered? Have advice to share? Start a Talk topic now!

Sign up to start a talk topic

Sign up to get your questions answered and share advice.