Serious Eats - seriouseats.com

You're not alone. I haven't watched Giada for about a year because of her lack of judgement regarding her attire. Of course, I don't really like her cooking either. I am Italian (I came to the United States when I was five years old), and I make authentic Italian food (as does my mother). Giada's recipes are basically American with a bit of oregano or basil thrown in so she can call them Italian.

Do you just love Giada's phony Italian accent when she talks about an Italian food? That's the only time she has an accent. It got so annoying to me that I had to turn it off. But, yes, the tops are way too revealing for a day time TV cooking show.

I have also not watched her in a very long time. Her cooking is something any child could do, and it's not true Italian cooking. She always calls it "my version" of the Italian dish. That's because her version isn't Italian at all. I would honestly like to see some real Italian cooking like Mario did. I miss him!

Giada's accent when saying Italian foods is so phony, it truly makes us laugh. But, yes, I believe Giada is very insecure and she thinks she can hide her lack of talent and looks with the low-cut sweaters and blouses. If any of the food network people are reading this, please bring us some real Italian cooking and forget the food porn. If we wanted porn, we'd go out and get it.

It's called RATINGS, people. Personally, as a male, I find her, uh, hypnotic. And yes, her Italian is a bit over dramatic, but at least she pronounces the words correctly and doesn't butcher the language.

I am sensing a lot of player hating here, so, just to remind you all, dont hate the player, hate the game. It's the Food Network. If you're looking for quality cooking instruction on TV, you're in the wrong place to begin with, and that's nobody's fault but your own. (hint: PBS)

As a man, I have to agree with just about everyone above. There is a time and place to show off the boobs, and a day time cooking program is not the place. I am in my 30s and I have small children who question everything, including bobbling boobies. While there is nothing about breasts to be ashamed of, I believe a cooking show is not the place.

Frankly, men who find her hypnotic need a real woman in their lives. Trust me, I know the type. I have a few friends like that. Anything with boobs is hypnotic to them.

Sex sells.

I just think that Giada should stop selling herself. If her cooking was as epic as her cleavage, she'd have nothing to worry about.

If you think Giada's blouses pass for porn you need to get out to the movies more often.

But phony accent? Big head?

Geez, you guys are harsh! If you don't like it, don't watch it. But being an average cook -- lets face it, she's not really awful, I've never seen her haul out any cheese whiz or taco seasoning -- since when is that a capital crime? These personal attacks are not really called for.

I've heard these arguments before. I don't think she sucks, and in fact, I kind of like her. Never realized I was in the minority and don't have any issue with her wardrobe on the show.

Anybody else ok with Giada?

If you look at Giada's early shows she wore a lot of turtlenecks and there was hardly any cleavage. One has to wonder if she modified her style over time because of her own choices or at the urging of the evil empire. I lean towards the idea that it was a suggestion made to her by FN in order to gain higher ratings = more advertising dollars.

The cleavage bothers me too, and I agree it isn't really appropriate for a cooking show. There's nothing really special or educational about her cooking either, but in spite of both of these things I would take her over Rachael or Sandra Lee any day. Her recipes may be simple, but they are miles above the mostly unhealthy 30-minute gloop or the Cool Whip laden crap (complete with vomit-inducing tablescapes!) that these other women on FN serve up.

I'd also rather Giada pronounce words correctly in Italian (even if it sounds exaggerated when she switches from English) than butcher the terminology. She IS Italian, after all. Sandy says MARS-CA-pone and it drives me crazy because there's only one "R" in mascarpone and it's not where she puts it!

I call it the cleavage network.

I like the recipes on "Simply Deliciouso" with Ingrid Hoffman. But she does the cleavage thing too. I think it's the network giving the direction.

Wow! There's a lot to absorb here. I love to cook and I've watched the food network. I've also seen Giada, and quite frankly, I always thought she was quite the little actress. She does come off as being phony, and I can't really say that I like her or her cooking.

The reason I'm writing is because I have a good friend who came to this country from Italy ten years ago with his wife. He is now 35 years old. I talked with him last night, and I mentioned Giada to him. He and his wife also love to cook, and I've had many wonderful Italian meals at their home. He knows of Giada, and he told me that her recipes are not, in any way, authentic Italian. He also tells me that her accent, while sounding Italian, is as phony as they come. Either you have an Italian accent or you don't. You don't just select the words you want to place the accent on at any given time. We all, of course, agree that the Food Network is simply for entertainment and should not be taken seriously, so Giada's attempt to cook Italian food is strictly for entertainment.

As far as her breasts are concerned, I would have no problem with the showing of cleavage every so often. However, because she and the network feel it's absolutely necessary to show the cleavage on every single episode, I believe it's a strong statement about her lack of any other talent.

Caley, welcome to the pathological repressiveness of American puritanical culture. And yes, you are right, it is completely misogynistic. We publicly celebrate violence and ostentatious displays of wealth here, sensuality (or what is perceived as such) is for sluts with no talent, class, or brains.

Personally, I'm sick of it. I'm seriously considering moving to Europe, where they celebrate art, food and sex instead of violence, money and power.

Because her personality isn't the only thing that's perky.

This in no way is to be construed as a culinary slur. She obviously knows her way around the Italian kitchen. I love her food and think she's one of the few remaining valid reasons to watch TVFN at all.

What a bunch of prudes. Unfortunately, I often have to see more skin on my morning commute on the 1 train, and they're not lookin' like Giada above the shoulders, either. Get out a little. She dresses no differently than other young women these days. If it's a distraction for you, you're the one with the issues. What is this, Qatar?

I don't think the people here in support of the idea that GIada shows too much cleavage are misogynistic or prudes. I am a woman and am far from prudish. The question in my mind is really whether the cleavage is a ploy by Food Network to gain higher ratings and sell more ads. It is about why they are not putting on shows with hosts who can really cook and are not just a pretty face or cute personality. Food Network has strayed farther and farther from food and culinary education in the past few years and now leans heavily towards pure entertainment with food as the common demoninator. There are only a handful of shows I still watch.

If you see my previous post I'm actually one of the Giada supporters. She can actually cook, even if her recipes are fairly simple. And as far as daytime TV appropriate for kids, she certainly does not show any more cleavage than the soaps. But soaps are *supposed* to be about drama and sex; a cooking show is (ideally) supposed to be about food and it is sad that FN chooses to focus on her chest more than her skills in the kitchen.

Based on the rapid-fire 28 comments posted on this topic, on a site that is about cooking, I'd say that Giada has a long career on television ahead of her.

Goodness knows what would happen if she was given the "Dress for Success" book. Would her ratings improve?

Looks good from my angle. Chris Rock has this routine where he talks about his greatest duty as a father is to keep his daughter off the pole. If the food network makes parents' responsibility greater, that just means the challenges of parenthood are dynamic and challenging. And I can't help but be a little snarky because there's a lot worse out there than the FN. Seriously, just flip over to Lifetime. You'll go from low-cut top to anorexia. Super.

Really though, if you wrote a snail mail letter to the FN, I think they would take note.

OK folks, while this may be a topic many of us enjoy discussing, I don't think there's much more to say so we're closing comments now. Let's get back to discussing all things delicious.