Milkshake: make mine______
Fill in the blank.
The 3 pillars of shake making are: premium quality ice cream, thick consistency (a straw doesn't fall over) and creamy texture. Make mine chocolate & top it with whipped cream!
Add a comment:
Previewing your comment:
HTML Hints
Some HTML is OK: <a href="URL">link</a>, <strong>strong</strong>, <em>em</em>
Comment Guidelines
Post whatever you want, just keep it seriously about eats, seriously. We reserve the right to delete off-topic or inflammatory comments. Learn more at our Comment Policy page.
If you see something not so nice, please, report an inappropriate comment.
Start Talking!
Need a question answered? Have advice to share? Start a Talk topic now!
Sign up to get your questions answered and share advice.

32 Comments:
Vanilla!
Vitello Tonnato at 11:33PM on 07/23/07
I love blended Coke floats.
kendraburt at 11:37PM on 07/23/07
I'll kill for a good vanilla malt!
SAMiller at 3:07AM on 07/24/07
passionfruit and vanilla! I love the mix of tangy and creamy. yum!
B
Hand to Mouth
Making Stock of the Situation
A blog for penniless gourmets
handtomouth at 7:15AM on 07/24/07
Mostly vanilla, unless I am in a chocolate mood. Every now and then vanilla and orange sherbert for a cremesicle.
JerzeeTomato at 7:40AM on 07/24/07
usually vanilla but sometimes when i feel decadent its chocolate and bananna! yummmmm
huney_bumper at 9:03AM on 07/24/07
with vanilla ice cream and chicory stout (schnack style). i also like strawberry when i'm feeling girly.
j at 9:22AM on 07/24/07
Chocolate: made with rich chocolate ice cream, good chocolate syrup and not too much milk.
blush at 9:52AM on 07/24/07
Vanilla.
K at 10:01AM on 07/24/07
thick and chocolatey!
AuntJone at 10:11AM on 07/24/07
Strawberry.
or vanilla. its tough. depends on food pairings.
steept at 10:42AM on 07/24/07
Strawberry with no toppings. Yum.
ceforrester at 12:03PM on 07/24/07
black & white malt!
YumNYC at 12:05PM on 07/24/07
Vanilla
Sarahrm at 2:02PM on 07/24/07
The best shakes and malts in the world (no joke): Yellowstone Drug Store, Shoshoni, Wyoming. As a kid I always got either vanilla / chocolate, strawberry / banana, or coffee / chocolate. They just opened a sister store about 3 blocks from where I live in Casper, Wyoming, and I've been avoiding it like the plague (don't want to be addicted to malts!)
lo82070 at 2:40PM on 07/24/07
I once had a well known food writer tell me that candy in ice cream was for children. I whole-heartedly disagree. I vanilla ice cream smashed with cookie dough, Oreos, and Heath bars. Bring it on.
sawyerriley at 5:05PM on 07/24/07
Chocolate malt, of course.
Lippy at 9:40AM on 07/25/07
Chocolate malt, of course, not that I've had one in 25 years, but I can remember.
Lippy at 9:41AM on 07/25/07
Toasted Marshmallow from Stand on 12th in NYC!! Delicious!
Recipe4Living at 11:27AM on 07/25/07
Make mine a thick strawberry with one or two pieces of strawberry on top and don't forget the whipped cream....yum!
flakevanille at 11:37AM on 07/25/07
peanut butter and jelly in vanilla ice cream with malt
goodbyeohio at 12:13PM on 07/25/07
I'll do a coffee cabinet or an Awful Awful. The THREE pillars are met!
JoeA at 4:48PM on 07/25/07
Coffee malted. Always.
maggiesara at 6:25PM on 07/25/07
Vanilla. Classic. Though I recently had a chocolate chip milkshake made with vanilla ice cream that was great - and it came, as all great milkshakes do, in a tall frosted glass with the extra in the metal container it was mixed in.
woodenspoon at 9:18PM on 07/25/07
Make mine a chocolate peanut butter smoothie from Blenders in the Grass in Santa Barbara.
Or a mango lassi.
I'm easy to please. :D
AdamH at 9:40PM on 07/25/07
Either a thick strawberry or a vanilla malt
jpark107 at 12:23AM on 07/26/07
Babe Ruth or Peanut Butter from the Nifty Fifty's diner in/near Chester, PA. I haven't had one in about 6 years and I'm still craving them ...
LondonM at 12:10PM on 07/26/07
Thick and rich chocolate malt served in an old-fashioned drug store glass with two straws. And not for sharing, either!
hatlady at 12:47PM on 07/26/07
Chocolate with cinnamon. The specialty at Goode Co. Hamburgers in Houston, TX,
mrbadideas at 1:30PM on 07/26/07
I usually order a vanilla malt, but whenever I visit someplace that serves a "boston shake" I order it -- a milkshake on the bottom with an ice cream sundae on top. Health, be damned!
You can usually pick your shake and sundae flavors -- sometimes I go complementary and sometimes I go with odd combinations. My favorite one is a coconut shake with a scoop of roasted almond gelato and smothered in hot fudge -- kind of like a frozen Almond Joy :-)
Dominic
the zen kitchen
dvchurch at 4:33PM on 07/26/07
I am a big fan of mint blended with peanut butter and malt... Or a good Black and White...
pbisNOTmyname at 7:41PM on 07/26/07
mint chocolate chip ice cream shake! You get to scoop out all the dark chocolate chips from the bottom when you are done!
ThatGirl153 at 1:59PM on 07/27/07