Paula Deen Is Trying to Kill Us, Part 5: Butter, Mayo, Whiz Cheese Spread

Summer is the time for sequels, and that's also the case here at Serious Eats, as we present the latest in the venerable franchise that is Paula Deen Is Trying to Kill Us. Here, the Divine Ms. Deen unleashes her recipe for All Purpose Cheese Spread on a holiday weekend–weary public.
After the jump ...
LISTEN as the sound of butter, mayo, "jarred cheese," and garlic powder squish under the wire beaters of an electric mixer!
WATCH as Paula samples the fruits of her madness!
FEEL your cholesterol skyrocket through the roof!
Link: PDITTKU [RedLasso]
Previously in 'Paula Deen Is Trying to Kill Us'
Part 4: Bacon, Donut, Egg Brunch Burger
Part 3: Velveeta, Butter, and Cocoa Powder Fudge Balls
Part 2: Bacon-Wrapped Fried Mac and Cheese
Part 1: Deep-Fried Butter Balls
Add a comment:
Previewing your comment:
HTML Hints
Some HTML is OK: <a href="URL">link</a>, <strong>strong</strong>, <em>em</em>
Comment Guidelines
Post whatever you want, just keep it seriously about eats, seriously. We reserve the right to delete off-topic or inflammatory comments. Learn more at our Comment Policy page.
If you see something not so nice, please, report an inappropriate comment.



56 Comments:
Paula Deen is a truly reprehensible person. She promotes the products of Smithfield, one of the countries largest operators of pig CAFOs, and she encourages people to make crap like this. Glad that the Food Network promotes the hell out of her. Very responsible.
Fillippelli the Cook at 2:39PM on 05/27/08
Dear God, this woman must be stopped. I caught a bit of Paula's Party this weekend, where she made the atrocity known as the "Big Mike Burger." It has two patties, one of which is referred to as a "butter burger." After I saw her make that patty, my arteries impelled me to change the channel. FWIW, here's the recipe.
nowonmai11 at 3:06PM on 05/27/08
Can someone please create "Paula Deen is trying to kill us" t-shirts? I will first in line to buy one.
puppychao at 3:15PM on 05/27/08
I think it would have turned out better if she used vegetable shortening and Miracle Whip in place of butter and mayo.
Asado at 3:19PM on 05/27/08
Seesm to be a trend lately to load up on butter and fat in your recipes. One of the contributors here - the pioneer woman - does the exact same thing. Makes me cringe everyh time I see one of those recipes, however the fun part is to tweak it to the extent where you do have full flavor, but not all the calories.
Jayden at 3:27PM on 05/27/08
Arguably, this is the healthiest recipe in the Paula Deen is Trying to Kill Us series
Raphael at 3:34PM on 05/27/08
t-shirts, great idea!
mrsadm at 3:38PM on 05/27/08
I'd wear that t-shirt.
Christina at 4:19PM on 05/27/08
Well, at least it doesn't contain any Smithfield Farms pork. So, you see, Paula Deen IS trying to kill us AND help kill the environment. ;)
ExpatChef at 4:42PM on 05/27/08
" a dish that you're not embarrassed to show up with" - ummm, right...
Watch it and pay attention at around 49 - 52 seconds - she makes this weird look with her face like she'sgoing to be sick! Then as she's spooning the viscous, sticky glob into a bowl, it seems she's having a hard time trying to find words to describe the slop. 2-funny!
GingerSnap at 4:48PM on 05/27/08
mmmmmm butter!
finsbigfan at 4:58PM on 05/27/08
here is a Paula Deen t-shirt:
http://www.cafepress.com/cp/customize/product.aspx?clear=true&number=%20269695768
spartana07 at 6:53PM on 05/27/08
I made it, but added some heavy cream and velveeta and covered with chocolate syrup and whipped cream (in her defense, Paula never uses fake whipped topping). YUM. Tastes good on everything from mashed potatoes to bananas to pork chops to coconut cupcakes!
T-shirts now available for parts 1-5. Sizes 3X up to full-size bed sheets with sleeves. Order now, while you're still able (alive).
I don't care what y'all say - I LOVE Paula. And some of her food.
PerkyMac at 6:54PM on 05/27/08
I agree on all counts. I also agree about the pioneer woman, who in my opinion is making a Paula Deen/Sandra Lee combo of food faux pas that just fall short on my scale of taste and skill. Don't get me wrong, I think Ree is a great blog writer and storyteller but her food (except for that cinnamon rolls dough recipe which I got from her blog and adapted my way) makes me screech at the monitor. The same way I yell when SLop is cooking on tv. Anything covered in butter, my big toe, my left shoe, is going to taste better and good. Covering things in butter is not building flavor. Anyone who cooks knows this.
Interestingly enough I agree to disgaree, since I am a long time food snob and not everyone is going to understand my approach to food or "get" my point.
JerzeeTomato at 8:26PM on 05/27/08
hey, jerzee, i have a question about that cinnamon roll recipe. it uses both baking powder and yeast. did you make it using both or did you skip one? how did it turn out?
ree's recipes don't appeal to me either but i'm an apartment dweller with a white collar profession in manhattan and have to go to the gym if i want any exercise. she's cooking for people who need to ingest a lot of calories due to the nature of their work.
cybercita at 11:42PM on 05/27/08
I did the dough verbatim. Then I made the filling with brown sugar instead of regular sugar. The dough made for me near 70 big buns. My filling recipe has been scaled in case you decide to scale the recipe back.
My Filling per 12-
8 ounces (approx 1 cup packed) brown sugar
1 TBSP good cinnamon
Pinch salt
1 1/2 TBSP unsalted butter melted
Multiply this by 4 or 5 for the whole recipe of dough and make sure you have 6 or 7 cake pans or big half sheets for the second rising. (I cut mine to 1.5 inches and made them BIG buns)
The dough itself I assume is a inherited recipe since inherently it is an overnight fridge riser. It was very forgiving.
The icing I did cream cheese style and not with the coffee extract. Some cream cheese and vanilla and wee bit of milk. They were a hit and for that alone I have respect for Ree.
My icing enough for the whole recipe of dough
11 1/2 ounces cream cheese softened and whipped then add in
1/2 cup milk
2 tsps vanilla
1/4 cup melted butter (cooled)
pinch of salt
1 bag of powdered sugar (sift it it will look better) about 7 cups total
Keep the milk handy to thin as you might like it pourable, not too runny but drizzle consistancy. Use your judgement
some people like to spread this on, I like to drizzle like Ree did
I am often snobby with food, my mother says my whole life. Examples I never took a liking to tang but wanted orange juice and the pulp had to be strained out. So no one should be offended since it is my opinion and I agree to say hey that is what it is. Speaking of orange a little splash of orange juice or oil in the icing would be good too.
Let me know how it goes.
JerzeeTomato at 12:38AM on 05/28/08
Sorry correction when made regular 3/4 inch per the recipe made near 70 buns at 1.5 inch made about 42 buns
JerzeeTomato at 12:42AM on 05/28/08
I think I just threw up a little.
"And you won't be embarrassed to bring this to a gathering" ARE YOU KIDDING ME?!?!?!?!
embolini9 at 9:14AM on 05/28/08
I love Paula Deen. I wish she were my neighbor so that I could go to her barbeques and eat all of her delicious, mayonnaise and butter-laden creations.
ultraviolet79 at 10:13AM on 05/28/08
In that case, ultraviolet79, you should move to one of the neighborhoods in North Carolina near one of Smithfield's pork operations. The smell of the huge, pink waste ponds is to die for, and the workers are treated so well. Mmmm, mmm. Life-threatening pollution and worker cruelty, a tasty recipe indeed!
Fillippelli the Cook at 2:17PM on 05/28/08
jerzee, my butt got bigger just reading that. thanks!!!!! i'll have to have a brunch party and make those.
cybercita at 12:17AM on 05/29/08
I have always wondered how the likes of her, Emeril, Batali, and all the other 'big chefs' are still breathing! They have to be on blood pressure and cholesterol medication. There's no way Paula can cook and eat like this without her numbers flying off the chart!
suburbangourmet at 4:27PM on 05/29/08
Paula and Ina Garten are very bad with the butter.... heavy cream etc.
I agree with the comment about being on meds. I feel sorry for their husbands eating all that fat laden food.
They probably sneak off to salad bars every chance they get.
rlwycoff at 3:05PM on 05/30/08
Hey, hey, hey don't bring the Barefoot Contessa into this.
lovesomething at 6:04PM on 05/31/08
Cream cheese is a pernicious ingredient, made up from some milk product and coagulated with gums (arabic, guar, carrageenan, other bean gums). I love it when somebody boasts they made "cheese cake" when it was made from cream cheese, eggs, etc. The true foodie knows cheesecake is really made from pot cheese or ricotta cheese (light cream curds) and not the "Philadelphia" brand of opaque white gummy bear product.
By the way, has anyone anywhere ever found "creme fraiche" (with all the required uppity diacritical marks) in any American market? I went to several supermarkets and they didn't know what I was talking about.
NEARENOUGH at 8:24PM on 05/31/08
Hey. Dont diss real butter till you try it. :) and for what it's worth... Some people eat more butter than you care to imagine all their lives and NEVER have issues. It's a fact.
jdshd at 8:42PM on 05/31/08
@nearenough: If you can't find it in a store, it's a pretty easy process to make your crème fraîche (diacritical marks included) on your own.
Raphael at 1:17AM on 06/01/08
There's creme fraiche at my local Von's and of course they have it at Trader Joe's.
onedrummer at 10:51AM on 06/02/08
I'd eat this, and hate myself.
cinnarose at 12:01PM on 06/02/08
I can't watch her anymore(or any of them)...foodtv has made her into an exaggeration of herself with the continual y'all's. And I am embarrassed for her on paulas party...the only thing missing is a clown suit!
AG4JAZZ at 12:29PM on 06/02/08
Stifle! you health insurance company pandering accolytes of the "Healthy Food Ad Nauseum." Even the insurance companies know that you can't live forever--if they could MAKE you they WOULD!--that would be just yet MORE money for nothing for them-- which their true business--getting ever more money out of people for less and less benefit.
After seeing the mess that the economy of this country is in, (thanks be to W), seeing the wars that this country is currently in--TWO (thanks be to W), seeing the country I love engaged in torture of prisoners (thanks be to W), seeing a Nobel Prize winning leader of our country castigated on national TV for caring about the "environment," all of which I have no say in.
I DO NOT CARE ANYMORE! I would rather spend an artery closing HOUR with someone of the character and personality of Paula Deen than even one minute with some cereal "flake" of a health nut/fanatic. We CANNOT live forever--period. And Ilike what I like--and I'm gonna eat it too--no more apologies!
If my arteries clog and so on--so be it! I will have enjoyed the time I had eating things that I LIKED--not what I was TOLD to like by those only interested in the "political correctness" of preserving the bottom line of health insurance companies.
LadyW8tn41 at 6:05PM on 06/02/08
I especially enjoy her audience's reaction as she brings out the inevitable pound of butter for the dish of the day "Yeahhh!!!! Another pound of butter!!!!! Yeahhhh!!!! A quart of heavy cream!!!!!"
wandams at 8:31PM on 06/02/08
too bad no one here seems to know proper nutrition. butter is good for you. plain and simple.
cheesemagic at 9:59PM on 06/02/08
I love Paula.. don't love her recipes, but I love Paula. Wait, I take it back, I do like some of her dessert recipes. I leave the high calories and 'bad' fat out of my everyday meals and save it for desserts. But even if I didn't like a single one of her recipes, she's just too damn fun lol
Control at 10:33PM on 06/02/08
Paula Deen loves life. She makes no apologies for what she creates and she enjoys every bite of it. If I have to choose between being a health nut and being like Paula Deen, I choose Paula. Since I don't have to choose, I enjoy her concoctions sometimes and sometimes I simply have salad. Thank God this country and our family circumstances allow me those choices. Maybe I'll die earlier than I normally would, but I'll die with a smile on my chubby face.
TryPrayer at 10:34PM on 06/02/08
Do some of you people just watch these shows because you've run out of everyday things in your lives to "crab" about. I agree with "turn the channel" I'm a Paula fan, no I don't fix everything she creates. She is pure entertainment though. And.... which one of you are such a perfect specimen of human figure that you feel the need to even comment on the physical features of another human being? Your jealous the women is successful while seeming to enjoy life. Get over it. Cook her recipes or don't. Watch her show, or don't. Get your own life, you might be happier.
prepress2300 at 9:42AM on 06/03/08
Don't make it personal! If someone doesn't like something they have just as much right to say so as you do to say you like it. What people eat or watch is an agree to disagree. If you don't like that maybe you should close the window by clicking the X. We will always state our opinions like it or not. If I want to say something is not good I am going to say why I think so. Welcome to freedom of speech. Would you like your pie humble or otherwise?
JerzeeTomato at 6:26PM on 06/03/08
Hey, yall....Wah not jest load up yer hypodermic and shoot this into yer arteries dye-rect? Or bettah yet, jest apply it righ to yall's rear ends cause thats where it's all gonna end up.....
RichardCrystal at 1:09PM on 06/04/08
Oh and yall need to make shur those Ts come in XXX.
RichardCrystal at 1:10PM on 06/04/08
My favorite Paula Dean quote and she uses it often as she presents her potato soup riddled with cream and festooned with bacon crumbles and shredded cheddar cheese and winks, "Today's not a day for cutting back!"
thedish at 4:43PM on 06/04/08
Why am I fascinated with watching this woman? It's like a car wreck, you just have to slow down and look! I will never actually make any of these meals. I find myself saying "Oh my God!" and catching my breath every time she plops another huge glob of fat some kind into a bowl. Yet, I have to watch, and there's something intriguing about her direct and totally unencumbered delivery of fat. She just throws it out there without even a consideration for making excuses. I do confess that I am not a keeper of margarine - which actually does more damage than butter. However, I do strictly minimize the number of dishes I cook with it. Mayonnaise is just pure evil. But I would love to know what Paula really does eat on a daily basis, because I do believe she's been slimming down!
Hot Tomato at 6:00PM on 06/04/08
Hot I understand this concept. It is better to watch the fat being delivered from the granny looking, sing songy southern lady then the fake breasted, chatty cathy, sacchrine Sandie SLOP Lee. Your granny is supposed to give you things that taste good but are bad for you.
I love train wreck cooking shows it is like watching roller derby. You feel compelled to yell out OH NO, Thats got to hurt, OH MAN!
Food is a spectator sport now. Paula is fun to watch. It is all about delivery. She delivers more calories in a short time and giggles right through it.
JerzeeTomato at 9:10PM on 06/04/08
I love Paula, especially the way she says "stick of butter." Now that's food porn! I'm not really interested in many of her dishes (except the trifle I once saw her put together), but I find her entertaining.
kathy in oakland at 2:14AM on 06/05/08
Do y'all renmember the Two Fat Ladies? Somehow when they added butter and fat to everything it wasn't so offensive. I guess the English accent had a good deal to do with it, huh?
RichardCrystal at 9:40AM on 06/05/08
@RichardCrystal: LOVED them. They cracked me up. But, I love all things English. Mmmm, chocolate.
I have to say, I like/enjoy watching Paula. She is what she is and makes no bones about it. I love it. I don't make any of her recipes, but whatever. I always laugh/gasp/smile when she's on.
I would like to say one thing though: Pioneer Woman (Ree) is a heck of a blogger and her pictures are amazing. She is out in the middle of nowhere and is feeding ranchers that believe there is nothing else in the world but meat and potatoes. She used to be a chef in Chicago (I believe, or somewhere like that) and knows very well the many ingredients that are out there. But why cook with them when she can't get them or has no need to since they won't be appreciated. I think she's great and is just trying to help others that aren't so fancy about food get into the kitchen to cook with ingredients that can be found at a regular grocery store.
Butrflygirly at 12:03PM on 06/05/08
I love both Paula and Ree! But what do I know? I'm just an Okie who loves to cook, read, and watch interesting recipes from interesting personalities. ; )
Seriously though, have any of you made Ree's olive bread? It's just about one of the tastiest things to touch my lips... Butter, cheese, and olives. Yum!
Tara Tot at 1:36PM on 06/05/08
@Tara Tot: I'm with you...:) So, you've made the Olive Bread I see...I've always wanted to, but my BF HATES olives. I figured I would eat the ENTIRE thing-it looks that good. Maybe I should have my best friend over for dinner and make it. We LOVE olives. When we used to frequent the bars, we'd ask the bartender for just olives.:)
Butrflygirly at 1:54PM on 06/05/08
I'm new here, and don't know Pioneer Woman. I am intrigued. If she is cooking up this stuff for people who are not living a corporate, reticent life style and are physically active for 8+ hours a day, then she may be doing a good thing. You need carbs and fat to run on if you truly do the daily physical labor that our grandparents and great grandparents did. My grandfather would have collapsed on a South Beach diet while he walked to the coal mines! However, if the title of Paula's show was something like "Cooking for Your Cowboy" I wouldn't have the same problem. She's presenting this fare as a daily routine to the average American family!
Hot Tomato at 5:46PM on 06/05/08
RichardCrystal: I DO remember the Two Fat Ladies on BBC and I absolutely adored them showing up in their little delivery van and setting up parties.. The were constantly bickering about each other to the camera! They were so entertaining in their delivery. Their show was precious, not because of the recipies and entertaining tips, but because of the way their personalities played off each other, and because of the whispered quips the camera picked up on as they bantered. I miss them. This show was the closest thing to a real small-scale catering experience!
Hot Tomato at 5:59PM on 06/05/08
Check that: Clarissa and Jennifer rode up to every venue in a motorcylce with a sidecar. The white van showed up later with their provisions in it later. Sorry - senior moment!!!
Hot Tomato at 6:02PM on 06/05/08
Jerzee: I hear you. I have a problem with Giada who is now "Boob Girl" in my household. Watch the early shows, then look at what's been filmed in the past 2 years. Food Network is trying to make her look sexy where ever she goes and wherever they film her. The center of the camera image is not on the dish she is preparing, but on her chest 100% of the time. And it's clear that they have a fisheye lens on her because her forehead has become enormous! OGM what would Julia say!!!
Hot Tomato at 6:39PM on 06/05/08
I have not made Ree's olive bread, why you ask? From Ree's Blog quote "The Cast of Characters: French bread, green olives, black olives, green onions, butter, real (not low-fat or fat-free) mayonnaise, and Monterey Jack Cheese." That is why! It is a Paula Deen recipe. Sitck a buttah, mayo, cheese....comprende. All recipe deal breakers for me.
Now I lived in rural NC, and I was not near anything that resembled a good grocery store other than the freaking piggly wiggly. I managed to get good ingredients. How did I manage that? Survey says, I got in the car and drove (sometimes for over an hour) to them. Some I ordered by phone or catalog and some kind people (bless you) shipped to me. I do not accept that she cannot get good ingredients. I will not accept that as an excuse. In the early 90's there was not an "internet" and I got them in Cow Patch North Cackilacky.
The piggly wiggly had three kinds of cheese grated kraft, yeller and owrenge.
Giada doesn't appeal to what I would cook because like her I am italian and I cook those things all the time. I am the everyday italian. Everyday I am "italian".
JerzeeTomato at 12:39AM on 06/06/08
OK, OK..we certainly want to eat a bit healthier and be honest: do y'all eat this stuff every day? Once in a while all this fat and cholesterol is good for your soul..but that's about all it's good for. My grandmother, rest in peace ate full-fat everything; half & half, sour cream, cheeses, an occasional piece of red meat and lived to 95.
So a LOT of this is genetic and hereditary.
BTW..Jerzee; My mom is from South Cackilacky and they just got an IGA!
RichardCrystal at 12:19PM on 06/06/08
Paula Deen???? I don't get it!!! Her incessant cackling, sticking her tongue into chocolate fountains, and please, stop with the y'alling.
The worst thing?... her recipes. Soooo bad.
She's Food Network's performing monkey and... they love her. Apparentley, so does the audience. Yeesh.
You can fool some of the people some of the time...but Paula Deen fools all of the people all of the time.
Paul Deen, please, just go away....and take Guy Fieri with you.
cher128 at 9:08AM on 06/16/08
I like to watch her show just to see how she's going to top herself from day to day. Bacon wrapped mac and cheese in a deep fryer. I missed the fried butter balls episode. Too freakin funny!
cocosmom at 5:49PM on 07/08/08
No wonder she's a tubber! Dean, and many people who eat her fat-laden recipes, is at risk wind up having a massive coronary. The Fred Sanford variety, chest-clutching et al, "Elizabeth, I comin' to meet you darlin'. I ate a deep fried butter ball and deep fried mac and cheese!"
bmcc9498 at 7:16AM on 07/12/08