Seriously Delicious Holiday Giveaway: Two Peter Luger Steaks

Required Eating

Seriously Delicious Holiday Giveaway: Two Peter Luger Steaks

Posted by Ed Levine, December 26, 2007 at 12:00 PM

Today we're giving away a package of two prime, dry-aged ("longer than four weeks") porterhouse steaks, thanks to the generous folks at Peter Luger. These steaks are not small. Each weighs more than two pounds. The steaks come with two bottles of Peter Luger steak sauce and a bag of chocolate coins.

To win, just answer this in the comments below: What's your favorite cut of steak?

You have until noon ET tomorrow (Thursday, December 27) to enter. One winner will be chosen at random from among the commenters. The standard Serious Eats contest rules apply.

PS: If you just can't wait for this contest to be over and want to order steaks right now from Peter Luger, you may do so here. You will make any serious carnivores on your list very happy.

Comments are Closed. | Tags: Peter Luger, Seriously Delicious Holiday Giveaway

Comments are closed: 847 Comments:

cowboy rib eye

hicoffice at 12:17PM on 12/26/07

Porterhouse.

floretbroc at 12:18PM on 12/26/07

t bone

gidget at 12:19PM on 12/26/07

porterhouse

brooke29 at 12:20PM on 12/26/07

Filet mignon

Cheran at 12:20PM on 12/26/07

Porterhouse!!!

whippingwater at 12:21PM on 12/26/07

porterhouse

eatnutmeg at 12:21PM on 12/26/07

filet or porterhouse or tbone or sirloin or ribeye. :-)

jbfrommi at 12:22PM on 12/26/07

Porterhouse

ranya112 at 12:23PM on 12/26/07

filet mignon!!! What a great Boxing Day treat!

Teri at 12:24PM on 12/26/07

Filet mignon.

rffoodie at 12:26PM on 12/26/07

Carpaccio!!

ianmoore at 12:26PM on 12/26/07

ribeye

bhforc at 12:27PM on 12/26/07

Poterhouse.

LindaY at 12:28PM on 12/26/07

Filet mignon

scentednights2002 at 12:28PM on 12/26/07

bone in ribeye

goodbyeohio at 12:30PM on 12/26/07

Def the Porterhouse!!! mmm...

mmmichele at 12:31PM on 12/26/07

filet mignon!

parkercat at 12:32PM on 12/26/07

Gotta be porterhouse.

kmg365 at 12:32PM on 12/26/07

ribeye

marelsa at 12:33PM on 12/26/07

Bone -in- Ribeye

smythbr at 12:33PM on 12/26/07

Bone in Rib Eye, Black&Blue!

bessfour at 12:33PM on 12/26/07

Filet Mignon is the best!

iamcdron at 12:34PM on 12/26/07

filet mignon

celticbikerbabe at 12:35PM on 12/26/07

filet mignon, natch.

weeblet at 12:36PM on 12/26/07

New York Strip

BeauRivage at 12:37PM on 12/26/07

Porterhouse of course!!!!!

courtneyp at 12:39PM on 12/26/07

I LOVE A THICK JUICY SIRLOIN.

lawman228 at 12:40PM on 12/26/07

Filet!

PattyCho at 12:40PM on 12/26/07

Luger's Porterhouse rocks! That's my favorite cut. I also love a rare strip steak from time to time.

Rosetta at 12:42PM on 12/26/07

T-bone--definitely--grilled or barbequed to medium rare--YUMMY!

kathyb53 at 12:43PM on 12/26/07

filet

balanese2001 at 12:43PM on 12/26/07

filet

carcon at 12:44PM on 12/26/07

Porterhouse. Definitely.

Cheesewit at 12:46PM on 12/26/07

Filet mignon...... rare, smothered in sauteed mushrooms. (That's probably more info than you needed to know, but I'm seriously hungry right now!)

mincognita at 12:48PM on 12/26/07

ribeye.

mango at 12:48PM on 12/26/07

A big, thick ribeye, medium rare and nice 'n salty!

Nesie at 12:49PM on 12/26/07

My Fave - Porterhouse steaks !

jsicolts at 12:50PM on 12/26/07

Porterhouse...Yummy!!

Thank you!

tmim123 at 12:51PM on 12/26/07

Porterhouse, please!

jbernet at 12:51PM on 12/26/07

I love porterhouse steak I hope I win

animanni1 at 12:51PM on 12/26/07

ribeye

raspberryberet at 12:53PM on 12/26/07

Gotta be Porterhouse!

jenberger at 12:53PM on 12/26/07

filet

susan1215 at 12:54PM on 12/26/07

Porterhouse on the grill of course.

daveg227 at 12:54PM on 12/26/07

new york strip

shay77 at 12:54PM on 12/26/07

Prime rib is my fav, with lots of horseradish sauce, but I like all kinds of steak. Yummy Yum Yum!!!

kycejo at 12:55PM on 12/26/07

Porterhouse

Orono1 at 12:56PM on 12/26/07

T-bone

Suesur at 12:56PM on 12/26/07

Ribeye

mbtmom at 12:57PM on 12/26/07

still love the porterhouse

threedogkitchen at 12:57PM on 12/26/07

porterhouse, all the way.

aburke6666 at 12:58PM on 12/26/07

porterhouse

paryjeja at 12:58PM on 12/26/07

bone-in ribeye

TheJTrain at 12:59PM on 12/26/07

ribeye

kathyvegas at 1:00PM on 12/26/07

ribeye

ride&cook at 1:01PM on 12/26/07

dry-aged ribeye

foodiegirl71 at 1:01PM on 12/26/07

ribeye

feep at 1:02PM on 12/26/07

I love a filet!

bargaingirl at 1:02PM on 12/26/07

Filet mignon

Teddy at 1:03PM on 12/26/07

Filet Mignon

marlmuck at 1:03PM on 12/26/07

Porterhouse

CVilleBilly at 1:03PM on 12/26/07

Porterhouse hands down

jphillips776 at 1:04PM on 12/26/07

Filet all the way.

tanners12 at 1:04PM on 12/26/07

filet mignon

mhgatti at 1:05PM on 12/26/07

Porterhouse

gscherr at 1:07PM on 12/26/07

Sirloin. Yum steak and chocolate. They each deserve to have their own tier on the food group pyramid.

angelfish at 1:09PM on 12/26/07

New York Strip, rare

dadekian at 1:10PM on 12/26/07

T-bone

crashers525 at 1:13PM on 12/26/07

I'll take a hanger.

calamityjake at 1:13PM on 12/26/07

I Love Sirloin Steak

Mur6950 at 1:13PM on 12/26/07

I love a great New York strip.

ceriously at 1:16PM on 12/26/07

definitely the ribeye

dewayne at 1:16PM on 12/26/07

ribeye

catmint12 at 1:17PM on 12/26/07

porterhouse are my fave

jblue at 1:17PM on 12/26/07

filet mignon

myfflyn at 1:17PM on 12/26/07

FILET MIGNON OF COURSE

pcbdolphins at 1:21PM on 12/26/07

Porterhouse rules! You people who say filet mignon -- yeah, it's tender, but you're missing out on a whole lot of flavor!

Gwenelle at 1:21PM on 12/26/07

filet mignon

izackcarson at 1:21PM on 12/26/07

filet

jtennantwise at 1:22PM on 12/26/07

Um...porterhouse?!

EmmaC at 1:22PM on 12/26/07

porterhouse

cmarro19 at 1:22PM on 12/26/07

Porterhouse

curmudgeon at 1:22PM on 12/26/07

Porterhouse, all the way! Especially if it's smothered in sauteed onions & mushrooms

dbaxgirl51 at 1:22PM on 12/26/07

porterhouse. A good hunk of steak is MY favorite food!

kris_1492 at 1:22PM on 12/26/07

Hard to pick a favorite, I like them all! -- Filet mignon

HSlater351 at 1:22PM on 12/26/07

Grilled bone in ribeye!!!

mdashkin at 1:23PM on 12/26/07

Filet Mignon :)

LusciousJ3 at 1:25PM on 12/26/07

Ribeye

gotrootdude at 1:25PM on 12/26/07

Gotta be the NY Strip, but I also like filet mignon.

SonjaK at 1:26PM on 12/26/07

T Bone!! YUM!!

bfox74 at 1:26PM on 12/26/07

Midwest Prime Rib. So soft and lovely.

Sarajahii at 1:27PM on 12/26/07

Ribeye, if you please

omnivore at 1:27PM on 12/26/07

Filet

GoldenEel at 1:27PM on 12/26/07

Hanger steak

tartetatin at 1:28PM on 12/26/07

strip

mverno at 1:28PM on 12/26/07

Bone-in ribeye, for sure...and MAN, am I craving one right now!

bettyjoan at 1:29PM on 12/26/07

wow! ribeye for me please...

cook eat FRET at 1:30PM on 12/26/07

ribeye

angi261 at 1:30PM on 12/26/07

a new york strip steak. in pepper corns. no sauce needed

bigbob1958 at 1:30PM on 12/26/07

ribeye!

sadiellen at 1:31PM on 12/26/07

Ribeye for taste but sirloin for mouth feel.

Nabozny at 1:31PM on 12/26/07

porterhouse

kevlney at 1:31PM on 12/26/07

rub some cut garlic over a thick porterhouse steak and throw it on the barbeque!

Dianalah at 1:32PM on 12/26/07

New York au poive (I can't spell). Hope I win!

thaddius at 1:32PM on 12/26/07

Has to be T bone steak.

chrochlin at 1:32PM on 12/26/07

My fav is Ribeye!

janetfaye at 1:34PM on 12/26/07

Filet mignon

zekks at 1:34PM on 12/26/07

skirt steak

carusoc at 1:35PM on 12/26/07

Porterhouse for sure!

therealpotato at 1:35PM on 12/26/07

Porterhouse

tradertiki at 1:35PM on 12/26/07

Porterhouse

kktwins at 1:35PM on 12/26/07

porterhouse

mepolo at 1:37PM on 12/26/07

rib(@)

wapiti7777 at 1:37PM on 12/26/07

nothing but ribeye....best in the world

zman1858 at 1:37PM on 12/26/07

T-Bone for me :-)

fluegas5 at 1:38PM on 12/26/07

RIBEYE,OH YEAH!!!

jeleigh99 at 1:38PM on 12/26/07

Can't get any better than rib eye for me. Mmmmm

jlc123 at 1:38PM on 12/26/07

FILET MIGNON!!

saxoman at 1:38PM on 12/26/07

ribeye

Tomas at 1:39PM on 12/26/07

Filet

Twipey at 1:39PM on 12/26/07

ribeye

mdv1410 at 1:39PM on 12/26/07

Bone-in Ribeye, medium rare, crusty on the outside, covered in sauteed mushrooms and, of course, a fine cabernet.

Grifola frondosa at 1:39PM on 12/26/07

It's a tie between Filet Mignon and New York Strip. I also love a really well-prepared Flank Steak... tender yet slightly chewy, and oh so flavorful...

LoCo at 1:40PM on 12/26/07

A seriously rare prime rib.

TrayMona at 1:40PM on 12/26/07

porterhouse

joanne117 at 1:41PM on 12/26/07

rib-eyeeeee

curse at 1:42PM on 12/26/07

Ribeye is the BEST................

shawn at 1:42PM on 12/26/07

Porterhouse!

JeffsInTheKitchen at 1:44PM on 12/26/07

New York Strip

hoping4amiracle at 1:44PM on 12/26/07

definetly RibEye .... yes.

toyota at 1:45PM on 12/26/07

chuckeye!

anaheim at 1:46PM on 12/26/07

Filet

robotbill at 1:49PM on 12/26/07

I love them all - porterhouse, t-bone, rib eye - just point me to a steak and I'm happy.

willitara at 1:50PM on 12/26/07

filet mignon does it for me!

JMCilento at 1:50PM on 12/26/07

The Porterhouse--it is the King and Queen of Steaks!!!

bespo81 at 1:50PM on 12/26/07

Ribeye

paintime at 1:53PM on 12/26/07

My favorite cut of steak is one that is cooked medium rare with a nice bernaise sauce.

greenfield at 1:53PM on 12/26/07

T-Bone

cgeo2000 at 1:54PM on 12/26/07

Fillet mignon

x86cpu at 1:54PM on 12/26/07

Hanger steak. Medium rare. Red wine reduction.

cdegel at 1:55PM on 12/26/07

Rib Eye

pemabuk at 1:56PM on 12/26/07

i love ribeye!

berwyn at 1:57PM on 12/26/07

filet and ribeye. Oh, ok, porterhouse.

msecondo at 1:57PM on 12/26/07

filet mignon

kingsinister at 1:57PM on 12/26/07

well, i'm a vegetarian - but my wife and kids love steak and i'm in charge of grilling them. kids have not yet had a porterhouse, i'd be thrilled to grill them some!

stevea at 1:57PM on 12/26/07

PORTERHOUSE!!!!!!!!!!!!!

cdziuba at 1:58PM on 12/26/07

T-bone!!

rubyneko at 1:58PM on 12/26/07

filet mignon

umassfen at 1:59PM on 12/26/07

It's a tie between porterhouse & filet.

kwenzel at 2:01PM on 12/26/07

T-Bone

shel704 at 2:02PM on 12/26/07

as I said before, porterhousefilethangerstripskirtribeyecubechickenfriedflank.

rps at 2:02PM on 12/26/07

New York Strip.

jenkins at 2:03PM on 12/26/07

Porterhouse!

robnolen at 2:03PM on 12/26/07

Porterhouse

SelimaCat at 2:03PM on 12/26/07

Ribeye Charred on outside, Rare on inside.

attgig at 2:03PM on 12/26/07

Porterhouse

elysek at 2:04PM on 12/26/07

New York Strip. Filet. I love red meat.

lo82070 at 2:04PM on 12/26/07

Filet mignon

lightkeeper54 at 2:05PM on 12/26/07

porterhouse

mamamouse at 2:07PM on 12/26/07

ribeye

brandonphx at 2:09PM on 12/26/07

Porterhouse all the way baby!

jnjn123 at 2:09PM on 12/26/07

medium rare, filet mignon. I like the pinwheels that have the filet spiralled with spinach and cheese

mellaw1124 at 2:10PM on 12/26/07

Sirloin for flavor, hands down

Jrlobo at 2:10PM on 12/26/07

Anything with lots of fat.....I know, I know

eyzofblu63 at 2:11PM on 12/26/07

Porterhouse, for me.

dcoates at 2:12PM on 12/26/07

ribeye

pdxirishman at 2:14PM on 12/26/07

T-bone medium rare

drming5k at 2:16PM on 12/26/07

Filet mignon

redron at 2:16PM on 12/26/07

London Broil........Medium rare

vetstadium at 2:17PM on 12/26/07

New York strip medium rare. :) What a delicious giveaway!

mom24girls at 2:18PM on 12/26/07

Ribeye, flatiron a close second

judyob at 2:20PM on 12/26/07

tenderloin

bev1132 at 2:20PM on 12/26/07

Depends on the wine (or the beer) and the sides, But NOTHING beats a medium rare porterhouse, baked potato and baked beans! Git 'er done!!!

talkingtex at 2:20PM on 12/26/07

Delicious, delectable filet mignon.

schorel at 2:23PM on 12/26/07

Porthouse steak

furman1144 at 2:24PM on 12/26/07

Grilled Steak is Great!

Stephen1969 at 2:24PM on 12/26/07

yum...t-bone

mozart23 at 2:26PM on 12/26/07

Ribeye. This is a cool prize for my hubby whose hobby is cooking.

harmonden at 2:26PM on 12/26/07

filet mignon

cev426 at 2:28PM on 12/26/07

Prime Rib - we had the best prime rib for Christmas with a red wine peppercorn reduction. We used an Australian Merlot, mmmmm!

janthecarnivore at 2:29PM on 12/26/07

Porterhouse please!

alicat68 at 2:29PM on 12/26/07

ribeye, rare.

fsmchang at 2:29PM on 12/26/07

Porterhouse

plhill2000 at 2:30PM on 12/26/07

ribeye

disgustingfoodie at 2:32PM on 12/26/07

New York Strip Steak - RARE

MrTechno at 2:32PM on 12/26/07

Filet Mignon...for sure!

icebox36 at 2:32PM on 12/26/07

Prime rib would be my favorite choice, but T-bones, porterhouse and ribeyes rank right up there at our house too. We just love Beef !

goodthunder at 2:33PM on 12/26/07

Ribeye, definitely.

digitalfish at 2:34PM on 12/26/07

ribeye

llinda29 at 2:35PM on 12/26/07

Rare ribeye!

michba at 2:35PM on 12/26/07

ribeye

vixita at 2:36PM on 12/26/07

porterhouse :)

skalobster11 at 2:36PM on 12/26/07

NY Strip

betty at 2:36PM on 12/26/07

Cowboy cut Ribeye!

tripateam at 2:37PM on 12/26/07

yum! new york strip!

friedom at 2:37PM on 12/26/07

ribeye

n5rat at 2:38PM on 12/26/07

ribeye

brunjaune at 2:40PM on 12/26/07

Porterhouse and NY Strip

rugbyspartan at 2:41PM on 12/26/07

Porterhouse

jessejames819 at 2:42PM on 12/26/07

Filet Mignon

Das615 at 2:42PM on 12/26/07

Ribeye

utahups at 2:46PM on 12/26/07

ny strip

jellosheriff at 2:48PM on 12/26/07

Porterhouse

jkershen at 2:48PM on 12/26/07

Ribeye, please!

gduran at 2:48PM on 12/26/07

Porterhouse

Suekey at 2:50PM on 12/26/07

Filet Mignon!

wufferhund at 2:50PM on 12/26/07

It really depends on my mood--usually a ribeye, but I have a hard time saying no to an offer of a hanger steak.

beano at 2:53PM on 12/26/07

porterhouse

gpadav at 2:53PM on 12/26/07

Would love to try this for the New Year!

Teeeveee at 2:54PM on 12/26/07

Porterhouse!

schnitzel at 2:54PM on 12/26/07

filet mignion,sirloin,ribeye, then porterhouse

ddyddy at 2:57PM on 12/26/07

Porterhouse

someguy at 2:58PM on 12/26/07

delmonico

royny23 at 2:59PM on 12/26/07

Porterhouse always.

jpq123 at 3:00PM on 12/26/07

In our house, we love any steak.... period. Given the choice, I always choose a porterhouse. Usually we eat them at about an inch thick so they cook up real nice on the grill, we prefer them med. rare.
Our brother-in-law buys them from a popular meat freezer plan and pays a fortune for them, and they are nothing to write home about....I prefer to go to the store and pick them out myself, choosing ones with lots of marbling for that tender, juicy taste.
Ok, now you've got me really hungry for steak.....

ababe28 at 3:02PM on 12/26/07

My summer as a butcher taught me that a porterhouse has the highest quality-to-cost ratio, but when I'm craving beef, I want flank steak, marinated for hours in garlic and mustard.

jasonbaldwin at 3:03PM on 12/26/07

I love a great T-bone grilled with fresh garlic.

drala625 at 3:04PM on 12/26/07

Filet Mignon

lovercas at 3:04PM on 12/26/07

rib eye

billygoat at 3:07PM on 12/26/07

Rib-eye

sjwoodin at 3:07PM on 12/26/07

Porterhouse

witchy64 at 3:08PM on 12/26/07

Prime rib, but if it comes off a cow, we'll pretty much eat it.