Weekend Book Giveaway: 'The Amateur Gourmet'

If you're a Serious Eater, you've gotten to know Adam Roberts, (aka The Amateur Gourmet), here and on his own blog. A couple of weeks ago, we kicked off Adam's blog book tour with an amusing Q & A (Adam is almost always amusing, diverting, and downright entertaining). His book, The Amateur Gourmet: How To Shop, Chop, and Table Hop Like a Pro (Almost), is all of the above, with more than a little bit of useful information thrown in for good measure. So for your weekend amusement, we're giving away five copies of Adam's book. To enter, describe your worst culinary disaster.
Winners will be chosen at random from among the comments, and the contest will close Monday at 6 p.m. ET. The usual Serious Eats contest rules apply.
125 Comments:
a few years ago my friend and i were making thumprint cookies and instead of putting in 1 stick of butter, we put in one cup of butter. needless to say, they didn't work out so well
missmicker at 9:34AM on 10/06/07
The first time I used sea salt I didn't realize how much saltier it was. That dinner was inedible.
chasgoose at 9:53AM on 10/06/07
I was making Russian teacakes - the world's simplest, easiest recipe, and one that I have been making since my earliest childhood.
I forgot that my oven at college tended to overheat - the cookies melted. Completely melted. Then they baked.
I ended up with a baking sheet filled with lumpy cookie-goo, burnt black around the edges.
KarynMC at 10:01AM on 10/06/07
In an attempt to gain family support for our new catering (ad)venture, the husband and I invited them to a dinner at home to present our ideas. All went well until the Diavolo roast chicken...it needed just a little more time in the oven, but the drippings were burning so I poured in cold water...to the pyrex dish. Explosion and glass shards everywhere...we took them out to dinner. Not my best sales presentation....ahem.
Cary at 10:03AM on 10/06/07
I put a tablespoon of baking powder into Red Velvet Cupcakes instead of a teaspoon. They rose alright : )
StudentStomach at 10:07AM on 10/06/07
I don't know if this counts, but it really was the worst. It was my first experience "cooking" with our brand-new Amana microwave in the eighties (I think I was 8, and the microwave was the size of a refrigerator). I put my chicken nuggets in to warm them up, and set the timer for something like 6 minutes... That smell was unforgettable, and the results were a great argument against the "parts is parts" mentality!
flootsmith at 10:18AM on 10/06/07
I was making a simple sauce from my mom's recipe. (The recipe is as follows: 1/3 cup sugar, 1/3 cup soy sauce, 1 tsp corn starch, 1 clove of garlic and a good pinch of ginger. Boil for one minute and let cool.) I was grating the ginger from one of the dried roots, and I went to town. Scrape scrape scrape scrape scrape scrape scrape scrape...scrape scrape scrape. It just didn't look like enough, you know?
The sauce, that night, was so gingery that one drop nearly burned my tongue to a cinder. And I'd poured it all over the chicken.
ErisianSaint at 11:01AM on 10/06/07
Easy. Years ago, back when I was just starting out in my cooking career, on my day off I went to Chinatown, where I bought a big bag of live blue crabs, somehow under the impression that they were soft-shells. I was also somehow under the impression that the proper way to cook these not-soft shell crabs was to deep fry them in a vat of boiling oil without any kind of prep whatsoever.
Dropping the live, writhing crabs into the oil produced a torrential boil over, which ignited into a tower of flame that scorched the ceiling. We managed somehow to put out the fire, but that was the end of the meal, and the last time I attempted soft shells, at least until I saw the real thing made in my restaurant kitchen, by someone with a clue.
dikaryon at 11:14AM on 10/06/07
A one of my girlfriends birthdays I was in charge of baking the cakes. At some point where I should have grabbed the container with sugar, I accidentally picked the one with finegrained salt. I was in a hurry so I didn't even notice it before it was waaaay to late and the cake was ready to be served. Luckily I had a lot of cookies and candy to replace the inedible cakes.
kimusan at 11:16AM on 10/06/07
Late one night, I was really hungry and I decided to fry some chicken. I found some frozen chicken wings, and then I went to go look for oil. After digging through the cabinet, I found sesame oil and thought, oh this would be really interesting. I heated up the oil, threw in the frozen chicken wings, and the whole thing went up in flames. Up to the ceiling. Everyone panicked, and my sister tried throwing water on it, which just made the flames stronger. I finally found a metal bowl and threw it over the pan, putting out the fire. There are scorch marks on my ceiling now, but my mother has never noticed.
Na at 11:19AM on 10/06/07
Oh, gee. I have this thing where I can't stand cold butter. I hate putting it on my toast, because it never spreads and you get little clumps of butter disrupting the harmony of your perfectly-toasted toast. I hate cold butter because it never seems to warm up to room temperature in time to fit the window of opportunity briefly opened on a Sunday afternoon for baking. And this is an old hatred. I've hated cold butter since I was, like, ten. Definitely ten, because at the age of ten I was so fed up that I put an entire pound of foil-wrapped butter in the microwave, intending to soften it so that I could enjoy my toast in piece. The microwave caught on fire, of course.
I guess that counts as cooking, right?
Christina at 11:24AM on 10/06/07
Age 5, breakfast in bed for my parent's wedding anniversary.
Toast: black and burning at the edges
Scrambeled eggs: a hard blob of yellow and white
orange juice: spilled all over the toast and eggs.
Nevertheless, we went to the diner for breakfast that morning.
thehungryrose at 11:40AM on 10/06/07
I was in middle school. I was into baking when I got home from school, even had my own cookbook for kids. There was a recipe for an all-purpose baking mix, which you could then use to make cookies, cakes, pancakes, etc.
I wanted to whip up a cake, so I started with the base. Halfway through, I called my mom at work and told her to bring home a bag of flour, as I didn't have enough to finish my mix.
"But," she said, "I just bought an entire bag. Look in the pantry."
I had looked in the pantry...and used that entire bag. I had neglected to read how many servings the mix would produce. Instead of one cake, we had enough mix to make about 50. Which wouldn't have been a problem if I hadn't used too much baking soda. Every one of those cakes tasted like crap...
jlhartford at 12:30PM on 10/06/07
Substituting peppermint for spearmint when making a goat cheese dip. It tasted so strongly of toothpaste I couldn't eat it.
bingsy at 12:35PM on 10/06/07
The first cake I ever made when I was probably 10 or 11...
It was a "spice cake" from the Betty Crocker cookbook. Well, despite the fact that we didn't have all the spices it called for and I heavily substituted, I also underbaked it. But that didn't stop me! I was going to frost a 2-layer cake and I just filled up the low spot in the middle with extra frosting. When we cut into it, the inside was raw spice cake batter and frosting. BLECH!
(I still don't like to bake--I much prefer to cook!)
bfmomma at 12:52PM on 10/06/07
My worst culinary disaster has to be in the last 2 years, for tha is when I started really cooking. I was playing around with recipes from the food network and decided on roasted chicken.
I forgo to urn the oven on and left a chicken in a non-heated oven for 1 1/2 hrs.
sln123 at 12:58PM on 10/06/07
I failed in my attempt to make a cake version of pignoli cookies for my boyfriend.
In baking, the outer perimeter of pignoli nuts I'd sprinkled on top disappeared into the batter, leaving a craggy, burnt center that made the cake look like a bumpy demonic eyeball.
I tried to cover the whole thing with a confectioner's sugar glaze + confectioner's sugar dusting, which a) exacerbated the eyeball problem, b) melted off the cake plate into crusty puddles on my kitchen floor and table, and c) somehow turned sickly yellow-green in pronounced lumpy clusters after about twenty minutes of contact with the cake, making it look like it was infested with mold.
As I am not independently wealthy, I have since stopped trying to be creative with almond paste and pignoli nuts.
SusannaEats at 1:02PM on 10/06/07
When we were kids, we took turns making dinner on the weekends. I was a(n inexperienced) food freak already, and thought I would make a simple pesto to show off my culinary skills. Having not so many cooking turns under my belt, I took "3 garlic cloves" to mean 3 heads of garlic...
Out of compassion?, charity?, sheer lunacy?, everyone ate it and never said a word that night.
nsf1976 at 1:06PM on 10/06/07
My husband and I had this brilliant idea to try to make beer can chicken for the first time for a crowd of about 20. The chicken browned beautifully, but when it came time to take it out and serve it, we discovered that it's awfully hard to take a hot aluminum can out of a hot chicken's nether regions. So hard, in fact, that after some fruitless machinations to try to remove it, my husband resorted to brute force, sending the chicken rolling across our lawn in front of our 20 dinner guests. Five second rule?
ebarrett at 1:11PM on 10/06/07
When I was twelve, my best friend and I were making chocolate chip cookies without any adults at home - just her older brother. We didn't notice that the oven was set to broil, and we put the cookies on the top shelf. By the time we noticed something was wrong, the cookies were each little balls of fire.
twonickels at 1:12PM on 10/06/07
we decided to make gnocchi. but with potato flour. it was 10p. by the time we got some semblance of dough together i had been told to keep my opinions too myself, everyone was cranky, everyone was hungry. we dropped the gnocchi into the boiling water through a generic ziploc bag with the corner cut off. we dropped our gnocchis into the water, but when it came time to drain them, they combined into what looked like cornstarch and water in the strainer. we were really very hungry by that point and went out to find pre-made gnocchis, which also involved a lot of deliberation and strong opinions. we're still looking for a gnocchi recipe.
snacks at 1:35PM on 10/06/07
All of my culinary disasters include: Stove lighting on fire: Very burnt food. I am partially blind and not a very good or well trained cook, so I tend to burn things or set things ablaze. Maybe it would help to follow instructions? LOL ;)
Anastasia at 1:50PM on 10/06/07
fell asleep while braising a pan full of lovely trimmed baby artichokes. I was tired, should have set a timer or something. The result was sad for the pan, the smell in house, the artichokes, dinner, and all involved. I learned to like smoke alarms.
intheyearofthepig at 1:53PM on 10/06/07
One of my aunts is famous for her chocolate cream pies. Every Christmas, she's expected to provide several for the family gathering, wherever it may be held.
One year when my mother was expecting a particularly large group to assemble at her house, my aunt decided to bring the prepared pie ingredents and assemble them on-site, to avoid the hazards of transporting five -- yes, five -- pies with fragile cream topping. In Mom's kitchen she lined up five baked pie shells and began work on the cream toppings. Enlisting me to help, she pointed to a gargantuan ceramic bowl of chocolate pie filling and said "You can start distributing that among the pie shells -- and make sure they're filled equally!"
As I hefted the bowl off the counter (it required both arms to lift it) and headed toward the row of pie shells on the table, I knew instantly that I had failed to notice the moisture condensation that had formed on the outside of the bowl. And before I could even scream for help the bowl was slipping down, down, down toward the tile floor.
Later, we could only speculate on the physics of just what happened. My cousin Ned, an engineer, had an explanation: the round bottom rim of the bowl must have hit the floor perfectly flat, every millimeter landing at exactly the same millisecond, to create the pressure that caused the entire bowlful of semi-liquid chocolate to explode straight up out of the bowl with enough velocity to fly in a mass SPLAT against the ceiling.
But that was later. At the time, we could only stand there, mouths agape, looking up and down, up and down -- from the bowl on the floor, unbroken and as clean as if it had been licked by a hungry dog, to the ceiling, where six quarts of thick chocolate cream pie filling was dripping back to down to earth a cupful at a time, like an upside-down bubbling tar pit.
cookbot at 2:12PM on 10/06/07
I was in elementary school and leading the life of your average latch-key kid. Bored and hungry one afternoon, I had the brilliant idea of making chocolate bread in our little toaster oven. Having no idea what constituted a bread recipe, I assembled what I thought were the appropriate ingredients: flour, baking soda as a substitute for yeast, sugar, salt, water, oil, and of course, lots of chocolate syrup to give it the right flavor. I mixed it up, let it sit for a couple minutes because I KNEW that bread dough had to rise, mixed it up some more, and poured it (yes- the batter was so thin that I poured it) onto a small sheet of foil. I set the toaster oven to "Bake" and let it cook. When it looked solid enough, I took it out. It hadn't risen, but I saw little bubbles in the flat soft cookie/cake-like result. I tried to peel it off, but only succeeded in picking some crumbs off the foil. It pretty much tasted like bland cake...sort of. Needless to say, my family never saw that culinary masterpiece.
I have to say though, I was an inventive kid who came up with some genius recipes, though others might think of them as culinary disasters. My favorites: Hershey's chocolate syrup over shaved ice and melted American cheese in a bowl, which could be eaten by scooping it out with your finger. That bowl was always a tough one to clean before my parents came home to discover my kitchen experiments...
kjeweler at 2:20PM on 10/06/07
My dad has been on a low-fat diet since I was a kid, so I've grown up around some pretty inventive low-fat cooking techniques. By the time I was in college, I thought I had mastered the art of such "substitution cooking," which is why I was so confident that when we realized we had no eggs for a birthday cake, we could just add some extra oil instead. The cake turned into more of a thick chocolate pudding than anything else - not completely inedible - but that was probably because it was from a BOX MIX. I screwed up Betty Crocker, aka "Cooking For Dummies."
lamenteuse at 2:27PM on 10/06/07
Is this supposed to be the worst thing that happened when preparing a meal, or just the worst meal?
If it is the latter, then it would have to be a loaf of bread I once made. I had been baking my own bread on and off for a few months, so I don't know how it happened. I took the loaf out of the oven, and it seemed to be completely baked. The outside was a nice golden brown, and tapping produced a hollow sound. When I cut into the loaf however, the inside was nowhere near done. Into the garbage bin it went.
For the former, I have to say it was the time I severed a tendon in my right index finger using my mandolin. The only upside was that the blades where so sharp, that there was only a slight discomfort from the injury itself. It was the injection of the painkillers in the ER that hurt worst.
Nicholas H at 2:49PM on 10/06/07
When I was in high school, I needed to make lunch for my much younger sister and cousins. I decided to make my own spaghetti sauce despite a very shaky handle on what went into spaghetti sauce. I poured a can of tomato sauce in a pan and added some oregano. It was really bland, so I added some salt and pepper. Still really bland. Added more oregano, didn't help. Finally I dumped in a tablespoon of cayenne pepper. Not bland anymore! My one little cousin actually started to cry in pain after the first bite. The worst part was my teenage pride would allow me nothing less than to eat my whole serving and proclaim the whole time "It's not that hot", as my taste buds burned out.
changlingsea at 2:54PM on 10/06/07
Indian Peanut Butter Soup. From a cookbook, I swear. Followed the directions exactly, and made probably the worst dish I've ever made. I should have known better (peanut butter soup??) but I was 15. Thankfully, the other two courses were fine, but man, that put me off complicated meal planning for quite a while.
Peasantwench at 3:25PM on 10/06/07
I nearly set the kitchen on fire at work one day. I had some leftovers of a chicken panini that I didn't want to eat cold, so I thought there was no harm in quickly popping it in the microwave - even though it was partially wrapped in foil. Well, after a few seconds I turned around and saw that the entire interior of the microwave was going up in flames. Luckily (?) I noticed it in time to stop the timer and put it out.
And this doesn't exactly qualify as a "culinary disaster", but I also managed to spill a jumbo size box of cornflakes on the kitchen floor shortly thereafter.
Shohini at 3:25PM on 10/06/07
I didn't do this directly but it has had lasting effects on my culinary abitions to this day! For our one month anniversary of being married my new husband decided to make a romantic dinner. He chose crab cakes, scallops, mashed potatoes and bacon wrapped fish on the grill. He carefully opened our brand new box of calaphon cookware (directly from the BOX!!) and got started on the meal. When I opened the door to come in the house he ran screaming towards me to stay out as smoke poured out at me. He had cooked everything on hight heat and RUINED my new pans...I scrubbed and scrubbed but those poor pans are still VERY well seasoned! We ended up with a very yummy candlelight dinner of instant mashed potatoes. And someday he promised to buy me new pans!
tammylizzie at 3:27PM on 10/06/07
Well, my very worst disaster was when I was going to bake a chocolate cake from Nigella Lawson's Feast. The book was brand new, and this was the first thing I tried from it. Well, I love Nigella, and I definitely trust her, so even though I thought it was a bit strange to line the cake tin with plastic wrap.. I did it. I really SHOULD have known better, because even though she assured me that no, it would not melt, it sure did. It ruined the tin, and needless to say, the cake. To make matters worse, Nigella specified to poke holes in the finished cake (in order to pour over a chocolate syrup) with a potato tester, or lacking that, uncooked spaghetti. I didn't have a potato tester at the time, and used spaghetti. In my warm cake. Well, guess what? Spaghetti breaks! Real! Easily! So, my unedible plastic cake was also studded with tiny pieces of broken spaghetti. Delicious, huh?
Anyway. I hear that the instructions have been changed in later editions and on the show as well - happy to hear it! And I will *never* make the same mistake again!
annesfood at 3:27PM on 10/06/07
I have quite a few but...I was making a cake for my son's first birthday and I was making a large sheet cake and then going to decorate the top in free hand with a scene from Thomas the Train Engine. My kitchen is very small and I was rushing and as I was going to set the LARGE sheet cake pan into the oven, I tripped and cake batter went everywhere inside the oven - the entire surface of the oven, the drawer underneath the oven and the floor under that. This was my first "event" in my new home and I had to clean the oven, drawer, floor and go buy new ingredients to do it all again. For a year I swear I still faintly smelled cake batter when using the stove!
Thank goodness no one but my husband saw this and the insane crying that came afterwards.
Oh yeah, I recently went to go make brownies and I had no canola or vegetable oil, only extra virgin olive oil. I knew it was a mistake to try it, but gave it a shot anyway...my advice? Don't do it.
radley24 at 3:41PM on 10/06/07
I had a lovely homemade beef pot pie with a biscuit crust in the oven in a stoneware baking pan my Father & Mother-in-law bought us at Cosco. I should've known something was up. All of a sudden we heard this tremendously loud crack & a violent sizzling. The pan had broke because I had the oven up a little too high to bake the biscuit crust properly. The pie filling was all over the oven & we had a huge mess to clean up. Never again! Now I use my trusty Pyrex baking dishes!
gwenpentland at 4:00PM on 10/06/07
i started baking a pancake with cornstarch instead of flour (they're both nondescript white powders)
hedgehog at 4:15PM on 10/06/07
I keep my salt and sugar in green topped parmesan cheese jars, clearly labeled mind you, but I grabbed the wrong one while making spaghetti and ended up with a half cup of salt instead of sugar in my sauce. I realized it shortly after when I taste tasted, and ended up throwing out the batch.
mmiller at 4:51PM on 10/06/07
the first time I tried to cook from a cookbook I followed all the instructions except that the "non-stick pan" used escaped my attention. Needless to say, my food sticked stubbornly to the skillet and both dinner and the pan were spoilt.
Mandy at 5:27PM on 10/06/07
Sadly, mine was making a frozen lasagnia. Idiot proof, right? Wrong. I knew how long to bake it, so just glanced at the directions, saw the picture of the tray going in PLASTIC ON, and threw it in the oven. By the time the smell died down enough to think about eating (something else), it would have honestly been faster and more convenient to have gone to the store, bought everything to make a real lasagnia, and made one.
beanish at 6:06PM on 10/06/07
i halved a recipe for mexican chocolate mousse that i was making for valentines day but forgot to cut the salt in half. very salty mousse.
tortor at 6:07PM on 10/06/07
It would have to be the year we decided to have "non-traditional" Thanksgiving dinner and picked goose as the poultry, rather than turkey. The night before the big dinner, we set about one of the first preparatory steps -- dunking the bird into a pot of boiling water -- this is supposed to make the goose skin more snug around the body. Well, the pot overflowed, extinguishing the gas stove flame, and water poured into the interior of the stovetop. The sparking devices for all the burners were sparking away! My husband spent the rest of the night taking the stove apart, in hopes of having it repaired for Thanksgiving. After all that, the nicely roasted goose got a lukewarm reception from the family! :)
pondlady at 6:49PM on 10/06/07
I got a Williams Sonoma cookbook for Christmas one year and in an effort to avoid studying for midterms I was flipping through it to find something to make for dinner. Cucumber soups sounded like a good idea, so I headed out to the grocery store, picked up the ingredients, and proceeded to start cooking. Imagine my roommate's surprise to walk in on me putting 4 sliced cucumbers in the blender with salt, pepper, and chicken stock. Blend, pour, taste, and spit. It was absolutely gross - I'd messed up the proportions somehow. Ugh!
pacgirl44 at 8:13PM on 10/06/07
Just yesterday I tried a recipe for pumpkin biscotti. I should have known it would be a dud when I saw that the recipe calls for NO fat at all -no butter, no oil, nothing. I tried it anyway and ended up with the most tasteless, dry chunks of yuck I've ever had.
One time my husband put some water on the stove and then WENT TO WALMART ("I've got plenty of time! This is taking forever to boil!") when I was at work. I don't know HOW our house didn't burn down. When he got home the pan was completely dry and red hot.
jerseygirl at 8:21PM on 10/06/07
I will never hear the end of the "spicy" pumpkin pie I baked many years ago. By mistake, I grabbed the Cumin instead of Cloves. It was not a good substitution! Now, I get reminded every year when pumpkin pie baking time rolls around. Needless to say, I am a bit of a perfectionist about my baking, so my family has fun teasing me about it!
amylou61 at 8:28PM on 10/06/07
I was 13 or 14 and home alone when I decided to make taffy from the Better Homes and Gardens cookbook. I put the corn syrup in a sauce pan, turned the heat on high, and walked away. I cleaned my bedroom for like the next half hour and completely forgot about the pot on the stove. When I finally went back into the kitchen, the entire room was filled with black smoke and the corn syrup was black and burnt to the pan. Middle of winter (in Wisconsin) with the windows open trying to air out the house before my parents came home. Bad bad bad night.
laurensm0m at 8:41PM on 10/06/07
One Thanksgiving, I baked the turkey (with wrapped turkey innards included) and only discovered this when we went to carve the turkey.
izzy's mama at 8:57PM on 10/06/07
The first non-dessert food that I cooked was bok choy. A microwave cookbook said that you should cook it in there. It seemed convenient enough, putting in bok choy with salt and pepper. Mine came up all brown, shriveled and dry. It took me a couple years before I convinced myself that I really can cook.
thesu at 9:01PM on 10/06/07
I was demonstrating how to make do-ahead dishes on a local TV show. The idea was I was supposed to be an expert, right?
I decided to make eggs benedict. I prepared the sauce ahead of time and put it in a thermos, to keep it warm, I explained on the air. "Then, when it's time to serve the dish, just poach the eggs, put the pre-toasted muffin on the plate, top it with the pre-cooked slice of Canadian bacon, and then," -- and I unscrewed the thermos -- "just pour on the sauce!" I tipped the thermos and the entire contents, sauce which had solidified into a solid with a Jello-like consistency, fell out of the thermos and perched there, on top of the stack of muffin, ham and egg, looking like a creamy yellow tin can. Which was now some kind of huge, buttery mass. I was stunned and fascinated by the fact the "sauce" just sat there, not falling over, just looking like a yellow smokestack on a plate. The audience and the host got a big laugh out of it. I was mortified but I had to laugh. Too bad it was live TV -- I couldn't even ask them to stop tape so I could try again!
wordsandmusic at 9:08PM on 10/06/07
The boyfriend and I had just moved into our first apartment together. I was about to begin culinary school and was eager to prove my food cred to him, as well as breaking in the kitchen in the new apartment. I decided on eggplant parmesan, one of his favorites. I bought lovely wine and ingredients, found the perfect recipe, and told him dinner would be ready at 7ish. Oh I was such a novice! The eggplant soaked up all the oil, and not knowing any better, I kept adding more and more to keep it from scorching. I cooked the hell out of it, basically turning it into oily mush. My from scratch tomato sauce had promise until I added the minced garlic. The recipe read "8 cloves", but being utterly ignorant, I thought a clove was the same as a head. 8 heads of garlic is alot. Things weren't progressing as I'd hoped and when dinner wasn't ready at 8pm, the poor boyfriend wandered into the kitchen to offer his help and I testily told him to "get out!" He said the garlic was burning his throat and opened all the windows. I started drinking wine to calm my frayed nerves. Now it was time to put the oily eggplant pucks and tomato sauce into the oven, at least according to my interpretation of the recipe. I just assumed the eggplant was supposed to suck up the woupy sauce, so I baked it until, oh, 10:45pm or so. Poor dutiful boyfriend. When I took it out of the oven, I could see what a disaster I'd cooked up, so I drunkenly sobbed while he ate 2 huge portions of the mess. He said he loved it and promised to eat the leftovers the next day. I miss that boyfriend. The eggplant was happily gone from the fridge the next day and I didn't dare ask if he actually ate it. The apartment smelled of garlic for an entire week. He never teased me about it and when my birthday rolled around he bought me "The Joy of Cooking" and a Kitchenaid mixer. Best birthday ever! Jimmy, if you're reading this, I want you to know I can now make an excellent eggplant parmigiana. Sorry I broke your heart.
nellopea at 10:04PM on 10/06/07
Oh, definitely thinking that parchment paper and wax paper were interchangeable. Turns out...they're not.
EmmaC at 10:21PM on 10/06/07
I was trying to impress a new boyfriend at the time and tried to doctor a bottled marinara pasta sauce by whizzing it in the food processor with a block of tofu (vegan) (I somehow thought it would turn into ricotta) and thawed frozen spinach. In desperation I just kept adding salt and then some old wine my roommate had out-- essentially, it was inedible goo and I definitely learned my lesson.
philoserine at 10:23PM on 10/06/07
In my impatience, I tried to make peanut butter banana muffins with too-green bananas and what came out tasted like how stewed oysters smell. Very weird, very bad.
pezbabypez at 11:08PM on 10/06/07
I was giving a cocktail party for my co-workers and I was making about 20 different things. I have a very old oven where I have to light the stove every time I use it. The broiler and oven pretty much attached. I had been broiling negamaki and decided to heat up my goat cheese leak tartlets and completely forgot that since the broiler was on the oven was at about 500 degrees...so needless to say I ended up buring the tartlets. I was so up set I blamed my boyfriend on the mistakes since he was helping...poor guy.
malenky at 11:21PM on 10/06/07
Several years back, and as a new married couple, we hosted our very dear bachelor friend for dinner as often as possible. This was not only because he was a close friend, but mostly due to the fact that he only ate frozen dinners when at home. I figured I could do better for him.
I planned to make a vegetarian enchilada dinner with homemade pinto beans, so I started prep the day before by soaking them overnight and slow cooking them all the next day.
Somewhere during the slow cooking process, something went horribly, horribly wrong. After all the soaking and slow cooking, they were just about as rock-hard as when they were in their dried state. Read: teeth could have been broken.
The worst part? I did not discover this until we were all taking our first bites of the meal I had painstakenly assembled and plated.
At least our friend still returns for dinner, all these years later.
I just don't serve beans.
iamchanelle at 11:32PM on 10/06/07
I made a potentially delicious homemade macaroni and cheese which horrifically blew up in my oven. Now every time I use a glass dish in the oven I say a little prayer that it wont explode.
Erin at 12:03AM on 10/07/07
I'm tied for two;
One time, baking cookies, I preheated the oven and forgot the cardinal 'look inside first' rule. Half an hour into mixing, exploding coffee mugs.
Second, I was baking an apple brown betty (It turned out pretty tasty from the bit I had.) I took it out of the oven and went to the bathroom. Just in that time, mum came in, and grabbed the hot pot, sending it crashing to the floor. Can it get worse? She cut an artery in her arm picking up the glass and spent the day at the hospital while me and my brother headed to the neighbours'.
michichan at 12:04AM on 10/07/07
I was making some cream cheese frosting, working on auto-pilot from a friend's recipe. It was only after adding the 4th cup of sugar (to 1/2 a packet of cream cheese and some ridiculous amount of butter) that I figured out that the recipe HAD to be off. Needless to say, the frosting was inedible. I later found out that the recipe had been transcribed from an old, totally stained piece of paper that rendered the quantities illegible. Ever since then, I try to pay more attention when following a recipe to make sure it actually makes sense!
Sandicita at 1:06AM on 10/07/07
While working at a coffee shop where I did a lot of the baking, I accidentally baked a cake with powdered sugar instead of flour. Both were stored in the same kind of unlabeled container, but I still don't know how I could have mixed them up. I haven't worked there in ages and I still get teased for the cake that would never bake.
salena at 1:33AM on 10/07/07
Besides burnt foods and overdone meats...
The saddest food "disaster" was a baking incident. I'm a scientist, so I'm normally detail-oriented and follow protocols wells. My boyfriend was craving pumpkin pie, so we bought all the ingredients and proceeded to make the pie together. Since I had more baking experience, I was charged with most of the pie-making responsibilities. The pie looked great when it came out of the oven. Unfortunately, when we bit into it we immediately realized that something was wrong. I had forgotten to add the sugar! Oh, the disappointment that ensued... I classified this as one of my worst food "disasters" because superficially the pie looked perfect!
jpark107 at 2:30AM on 10/07/07
Back in the day when I had more ambition than knowledge, I decide to make a chocolate layer cake for my family for Mother's Day. The recipe called for bittersweet chocolate - not understanding the difference, I used unsweetened chocolate. Since there was no other sugar n the recipe, the cake turned out absolutely inedible! Entenman's saved the day....
JeffsInTheKitchen at 4:48AM on 10/07/07
I'm a fairly new cook. Not too experienced. A friend taught me how to make a tomato quiche that includes nutmeg. One night, while my sister-in-law was in town, I decided to make the quiche since it's quick and easy and oh-so-good. As I was trying to reach for the nutmeg to sprinkle in the mixture, I accidentally reached for the cinnamon and sprinkled that in the mixture instead. I tried to scrap out as much as I could, but in the end we had a sweet tomato quiche for dinner.
ehirschklau at 9:06AM on 10/07/07
i like it spicy: one day discovered dried African piri piri peppers and used them to make an arrabiata. It was my first experience with them and I didn't realize how potent they were-- I used a generous amount. 15 min post meal was a painful pyrotechnic experience.
mazzio at 9:53AM on 10/07/07
At a weekend cabin in northern Michigan, our uncle neglected to tell us that the old restaurant stove he had installed was hooked up with propane and not natural gas. My older brother, a short order cook at the time was going to make breakfast, he lit a match and tried to get the stove going. He and my younger brother and I were peering into the hole and waiting, and waiting and waiting. The stove didn't light. Another match, then another one and when it finally lit, kaboom! I lost a good part of my hair, my eyebrows and eyelashes; my older brother was left with only half of his mustache and baby brother (11 years old at the time) was screaming at me to stop hitting him on the head (he didn't realize he was on fire). I guess propane doesn't rise as quickly as natural gas.
ceres at 10:56AM on 10/07/07
It must have been a elementary school bake sale, my sister and i baked plain old sugar cookies. I only sold one cookie, and everyone else gave me a dirty look. I finally tried one and found out that i made salt cookies =(.
mikechan at 11:32AM on 10/07/07
Years ago for Christmas, my partner gave me a gift of doing the cookng for dinner that day. He decided that AppleJack, basically a strong apple flavored liquor,would add some flavor. When the chicken wasn't done when expected, he turned the oven up to 500!
Not too long after that I was jolted off the couch by a huge explosion that blew open the oven door and shot liquid everywhere. He had poured the entire bottle in the pan and the high heat had finally caused the alcohol to flame up.
Once I realized what had happened, I couldn't stop laughing. To be nice I forced down a couple of bites of chicken, but it was awful.
We had Chinese take out later that night!!!
BostonFoodMan at 11:48AM on 10/07/07
a few years ago my friend and i were baking thumbprint cookies and, instead of adding 1 stick of butter, we added one cup of butter! needless to say, our cookies didn't turn out so well (they were mush on the pan) but they still tasted good!
missmicker at 12:23PM on 10/07/07
Yes, I did it too. I was so proud of my first rustic plum crostata coming out of the oven. I cut myself a generous piece topping it with a nice blob of fresh mascarpone... only to discover at the first bite that I had used salt instead of sugar for the crust....
ngaloppo at 12:32PM on 10/07/07
so this wasn't really an accident as much as a game, but it was nasty none the less. my boyfriend and i were being indecisive one night about what to do for dinner, so we decided to make a game out of it. the rules were that we each left the apartment separately, we each had $8 to spend, and whatever we brought back was dinner. the point was to go to a bunch of different places, and see what we could come up with. i went to mcdonalds and bought a happy meal (for the mario toy they had at the time), and then a super market and bought broccoli and a piece of steak. he bought 3 package of ramen, a hot dog, naan, tacos and some other stuff. the tacos and the steak being enough for a decent meal, he started goofing around with the other stuff. so he made ramen. added the cut up hot dog and the fries from the happy meal. then, deciding it wasn't enough, he added the meat from the hamburger to it too. we had a good meal, but tasting that ramen was grooooosssss....
anado at 12:37PM on 10/07/07
Almost a year ago one of my little cousin, 5 years old Yann came for lunch after beach time at my place. So I cooked pasta and ham and for dessert I decided to make a chocolate brownie. I did not have regular sugar so I put powered sugar, oh God such a BIG mistake! My brownie was burned on the top, hard as a rock all around and not cooked (still liquid) at the center. My little cousin is still not believing I can cook good cakes.
Babeth at 2:11PM on 10/07/07
I had worked in restaurants while growing up, but never really learned how to cook. My first attempt to cook a dinner (to impress a red haired nursing student at Bowling Green) was, if not a disaster, a disappointment. I didn't really read a soup recipe, and knew nothing about stocks, so the soup had about a half inch of fat floating on top. I also knew nothing about degreasing. I called it Yoda's swamp soup and served it anyway.
While it would be fair to say that I didn't follow the recipe properly, what I really discovered is that I had no idea what it means to cook. I had no understanding of the fundamental knowledge of what cooking is.
I am much better today!
Scotty at 2:46PM on 10/07/07
Keep in mind that this was after cooking for 15 years! I was trying out a new meatloaf recipe (which, BTW, once I mastered is my family's favorite!). I decided that for the number of people I was serving I needed to double the recipe. Not only did I double the ingredients, but I also DOUBLED the time. Needless to say, the meatloaf was more a 'meatbrick'! LOL
nsharoff at 2:53PM on 10/07/07
Mine would have to be when, in taking a flourless chocolate cake out of the over, the bottom of my springform pan fell out. It was very sad, and our neighbor still remembers my mom and I hosing off the oven racks in our driveway.
joanie at 3:43PM on 10/07/07
I'm sure this doesn't really compare to some of the ones out there, but I tried this recipe online for broiled tilapia, smothered with butter, mayo, parmesan, and some different herbs and spices. The recipe called for the fish to be just a few inches under the broiler, so here I have it in the oven, and I hear it sizzling and I'm all excited. So I go to open the oven and realize that my fish is on fire! I finally mustered up the courage to grab the fish and run it under water. Surprisingly, the fish under the charred surface was still good!
Vincci at 4:32PM on 10/07/07
I was trying to create my own chili spice rub for a piece of flank steak. One bite and my husband - who has a high tolerance for spicy - had tears in his eyes. He got up and ran the steak under the faucet to wipe off the rub.
FKC at 4:38PM on 10/07/07
while experimenting with unfamilar spiced from the local ethnic grocery store I did a rub for the steak I was preparing. after grilling the steak to mouth - watering perfection, I serving it to my guest and anxiously awaited their praises before they could speak a word,I could tell by their facial expressions my (experiment) had gone terribly awry the unexpecited flavor they got was MINT and a lot of it.
girlina at 6:14PM on 10/07/07
When I was six I learned to make scrambled eggs in the microwave which is disasterous at best, as they generally turn out grey and rubbery, especially if you enjoy watching them rise in the microwave and then deflate when you take them out, as I did. One weekend I was making breakfast in bed and I knew my dad liked a brown sauce (which I found out later was worcestorshire sauce) on his eggs, so I found what looked appropriate and poured it all over his grey eggs. He ate every bite and then turned to my mother and asked her, in the future, to please show me the difference between worcestershire and soy sauce.
minx16 at 7:40PM on 10/07/07
I came home after a night out and decided to make a cheese omelette. What I didn't realize until I actually tasted it was that I had accidentally poured way way waaaayy too much salt in the egg mixture. To remedy this, using all of my skewed logic, I decided to make two more plain omelettes to put on top of the super salty one. Obviously, this didn't actually help at all.
platecleaner at 7:51PM on 10/07/07
I was baking a rather simple recipe for ginger cookies over thanksgiving. First of all, I didn't have all the necessary equipment (i.e. bowls) and ended up mixing everything in uneven batches in cups then lumping it all together. I used wax paper to line the baking pan, put the cookies on it and stuck the entire thing in the oven. I left them in there for the 12 or so minutes the instructions had told me, but within 5-6 minutes, there was smoke rising from oven and a minute later, billowing out in giant clouds. I slammed the kitchen door shut, yanked open the oven door and set off the fire alarm. Some cookies looked like they had melted, others were burnt black and the wax paper was on fire. I grabbed the sheet with a towel, burned my thumb and middle finger, and dumped the entire thing in a sink of water. I was just relieved I didn't set the dorm on fire.
half_caff at 7:52PM on 10/07/07
Well, I was finally given the chance to cook Thanksgiving dinner for our entire family.
Me, being the nervous twit I am, was chatting on the tele while mixing together the pumpkin pies that were to be scrumptious!...and forgot the sugar!!
My mother's face told me instantly that I had just had my last family dinner!! *sigh*......oh, well.......the tele call was important!!
mrskfmartin at 8:03PM on 10/07/07
Worst culinary disaster…
Back in 1985 when I got my first microwave, I decided to make peanut brittle from one of the recipes that came with the oven. When it came time to stir, I used my new plastic spoon that came with the microwave oven. When I went to take it out, I was a sugary mess, I knew it would be a hassle to clean and I would have to stir it several times more until it was finished. Then it dawned on me- this was a microwave and not a “real” oven, the spoon was plastic .s and not metal so why not leave it in the bowl? Great idea right? Unfortunately NOT… the boiling sugar melted the spoon and it had incorporated into the brittle mixture. What a mess.
kkbear at 8:05PM on 10/07/07
We'd been married for about two weeks. We decided to try to make two small fillets of fish in our newly gifted Pyrex glass baking dish. A few minutes after I put it in the oven, I heard a strange BAM, like a gun went off. The dish had shattered -- spiderwebbed cracks lined the glass and sprinkled chunks onto the bottom of the oven.
Best part? We didn't have any money to replace the fish, so we gingerly picked the big chunks of glass out and tried to salvage what we could. Neither of us died, but probably not the best risk to take!
SLOLindsay at 8:17PM on 10/07/07
I'm a newlywed and its Thanksgiving. We live over 2000 miles from home, so my in-laws are coming and my mother-in-law is going to cook. She faxes me the grocery list on it is "frozen onion, chopped." Thanksgiving morning arrives and she asks where's the onion. I open the freezer and remove one yellow onion completely frozen and wait for her to chop it.
memphish at 9:10PM on 10/07/07
i've made the same double layer chocolate cake for years, and one late night with a bunch of friends, i decided to make it again on a whim. after the cakes were put into the oven to bake, we were playing cards, but we started to smell chocolatey smoke. huh. i got up and went to check in, and the cake batter had brimmed over the top and had spilled over the two grates and onto the bottom of the oven. i had to spend the next half hour cleaning off bits of burnt chocolate drips while my friends kept playing cards. to this day, i still have no idea what went wrong.
uninorth at 10:13PM on 10/07/07
I'm blonde, so perhaps that has something to do with my smoothie mishap. I was on a diet, again, and decided that I was going to mix blackberry yogurt with some actual blackberries, a cup of milk, and some ice to make a low-cal smoothie. Now, although I'm in my late 20s, I do not have blender experience. I seriously don't even know how to turn on the oven. I'm a serial microwaver. I took the blender down from the shelf, removed the lid, and dumped all my contents inside. Next, I carefully plugged in the blender and snapped on the lid. After turning it on, I didn't know what to do next, so I yelled to my mother, who was in the next room. She yelled back for me to hit the puree button, so I did. Everything was spinning nicely and filling my kitchen with the aromatic smell of blackberries. Hooray! I was a chef! I couldn't believe it - my first smoothie. Perhaps now I can tackle other kitchen appliances like the can opener or the food processor. After the drink was completely blended, I was ready to pour the drink into my waiting glass ... but how was I going to get the smoothie out? I yelled to my mother for instructions. "Just take off the jar," she said. That sounded easy, so I started unscrewing the glass jar from the blade/stopper. "Just lift and pour," I said to myself. I started lifting the glass jar away from the blade when PLOP ... the ENTIRE smoothie came pouring out, all over the blender, and all over my kitchen. I was left standing there, holding an empty glass jar with the lid still attached ('cause I didn't want to make a mess). Panicking, I yelled for my mother to stay where she was (in the living room). I didn't want to hear her reaction when she saw the disgusting mess I'd made. I did, however, ask her why my smoothie had fallen out of the glass. It was then I learned that the glass jar NEVER gets separated from the blade/stopper unless you're cleaning it. Ohhhhhhhhhhhh ... so that's what stops the liquid from coming out!! I wish I would have known that earlier. I wouldn't have made a mess, wasted food, or had to resort to eating Cocoa Puffs. Oh, and I as I write this, my mother sits beside me complaing about how I used a whole roll of paper towels cleaning up the kitchen. What a mess!
NewEnglandBites at 10:27PM on 10/07/07
When I was twelve, I made my step-sister the most disgusting meal. I microwaved dog food from a can, then I placed it in a flour tortilla with sauteed onions and American cheese. It wasn't a total disaster, because I knew what I was doing. I was devious and cruel, but she ate every bit of it without knowing what it was. How gross!
plopfizz at 11:27PM on 10/07/07
When I was in 12th grade my girlfriend at the time and I made cookies with equal which is NOT good for baking. Ended up with really artificial tasting cookies.
philfna at 11:56PM on 10/07/07
Someone gave my family a boneless whole turkey for Thanksgiving several years ago (somehow the bones had been extracted). We cooked it and it deflated like a balloon.
Myszka at 12:34AM on 10/08/07
My girlfriend loves shrimp. I don't really care for the little things- always sort of considered them the cockroaches of the ocean. However I attempted not once but twice in a week to cook them, both with miserable results. The first time I made a marinated sauteed shrimp which I drastically overcooked. They were approximately the texture of kitchen sponges with the flavor of bad Chinese takeout. The second night I decided to make her very favorite- fried beer battered shrimp. In response to my first well-done batch of shrimp I had the heat WAY too low- the batter came out gluey, chewy, and anything but appetizing! To add insult to injury, I didn't have the ingredients to make cocktail sauce and had to improvise a tomatoey, mayonaissey mess to replace it. My girlfriend, being the darling that she is, ate them bravely, but even she couldn't refrain from suggesting that next time I want to cook for her I just stick to chicken!
SavvyKnowsBest at 12:46AM on 10/08/07
Several years ago I was trying to impress my new boyfriend (now husband) by recreating my mother's incredible baked ziti. We were visiting my parents and therefore cooking in their kitchen. I baked the ziti, grated mozzarella, and mixed the innards up. Usually, I top my ziti (before baking) with some Parmesan cheese. Not being my kitchen, I looked in the usual place for Parmesan - the fridge and the freezer. Here's where things went awry. My mother is famous for her blueberry betty and sometimes she makes extra topping (1 part flour to 1 part butter to 1 part sugar) and puts it in a ziploc in the freezer, she also does this with extra Parmesan cheese. The bag was not labeled, and thinking it was Parmesan cheese, I poured a generous amount of this deliciousness atop the ziti, baked it for 45 minutes and removed it from the oven. Dying of hunger, we dug into the ziti - only to be thoroughly repulsed by the most unlikely tastes to be combined - sweetly-topped ziti with cheese and pasta sauce. Thinking that maybe we could solve things, we tried to scrape off the top layer. As the flour-butter-sugar combination permeated the ziti, we were disgusted, unable to take another bite, had to discard a huge dish of baked ziti, and ruined my attempt at delighting my boyfriend with my kitchen prowess.
lneedleman at 12:54AM on 10/08/07
Has been fun to read all these culinary disasters :) I am fortunate to already own Adam's hilarious & helpful book (have read it twice already)! Good luck everyone!!
JEP at 5:39AM on 10/08/07
Eggplant. I salted those suckers with probably 1/4 of salt and didn't do a good job of getting it all off. It would have been such a great dish, if salt wasn't the only thing you could taste!
Littlebluesiren at 6:33AM on 10/08/07
Thirty-odd years ago and my parents were selling the house and moving cross country. They had read that the smell of baking was conducive to making a sale, and so I was tasked with a daily routine of cookie prep (I was heavily into baking for a seven-year-old). On a particular day, I was told to double quantities, as there was a church fete coming up. Keenly, I doubled sugar, eggs, butter, and flavourings. But forgot to double the flour. Four shelves off cookie mix melted, dripped off the trays and filed the whole house with smoke. No sale that day. But lesson learnt.
godstar at 7:35AM on 10/08/07
Being a good and true Good Eats fan, several years ago I tried making AB's yellow cake recipe, with a chocolate whipped cream frosting. The cake turned out fabulous - moist and delicious. The frosting was made with whipped cream mixed with AB's hot chocolate mix (cocoa, powdered sugar, powdered milk, etc., with a pinch of cayenne to give it some kick). Not needing a full recipe of the mix to make the frosting, I scaled the measurements. Evidently I miscalculated a bit on the cayenne, though. Said one friend, "The cake is wonderful, but frosting should not have a slow burn!"
DuncanHusky at 8:43AM on 10/08/07
Years ago I had some chicken salad at a girls luncheon that I loved - it had canned crushed pineapple in it. I decided to make it myself at home the next day. I usually can tell what's in a dish by tasting it. I figured I could make it even better by using chopped "fresh" pineapple. Long story short, after I made it, I tasted it (perfect!) then I put it in the refrigerator to serve it for dinner that night. Well, when dinner came around my chicken salad had turned into mush. I found out afterwards fresh pineapple breaks down the chicken meat. I always believe in using fresh ingredients whenever possible, but this is one time only "canned" will do.
Susiebee at 9:07AM on 10/08/07
One Christmas I decided to try a new cookie for the family. I don't remember exactly what kind, but they were some type of meringue cookie. The recipe called for cream of tartar. I thought to myself, wow, that's odd, why would a cookie recipe call for tartar sauce. Even when people serve it with fish I don't like it. I shrugged my shoulders and said well... what else could it be? So I mixed the ingredients together and did a taste test. Right about then my husband was coming home. He saw the look on my face and asked what was going on. I explained what I did and he laughed and laughed. He too, had never heard of cream of tartar but knew that wasn't right. So I called my mom and explained and she couldn't stop laughing. I think she might have been crying. Lesson learned. Go with my instincts when I think something sounds "funny" in a recipe.
Every Christmas the family gets a good laugh out of that one.
swulff at 9:23AM on 10/08/07
The goal was to make some delicious iced tea. I started, as you do, by brewing a large pot of tea, inhaling the fragrant aromas as it steeped. Then, rather than letting it cool some, I instead decided to pour it into the plastic jug I was going to be using. It bulged a little, but I didn't think much of it at the time. I put it into the fridge to cool down, and a few minutes later I saw something dripping from the fridge. I open the door to find that the hot tea has melted through the plastic jug, and drenched the entire contents of my fridge. Of course, I didn't even have a glass of ice tea to cool me down after I finished cleaning up that mess.
langenu at 9:51AM on 10/08/07
Just after college I lived with three friends of mine. One night I decided to do a shrimp boil in our kitchen. Liking my food fairly spicy, I dumped a lot of cayenne pepper into the boiling water. Well the cayenne mixed with the steam from the pot and the result was about the same as spraying our house with pepper spray. Me and my roomates were coughing and our eyes were waterting for about 30 minutes. My throat was burning for about an hour after it happened.
EatWisconsin at 10:13AM on 10/08/07
I once prepared a turkey using lots of different spices from the pantry. I remembered a trick about adding some soup mix, but forgot how just a little of that stuff goes a long way. I used it as a base for a rub all over (and under) the turkey skin. While it was the most prefectly cooked turkey I've ever prepared, it was WAYYYYY too salty. I was hosting about 10 people at the meal and huge embarrassment followed. My other big cooking disaster came from the same weekend when a pot of chicken soup that I thought had been simmering on a large hot plate for several hours actually turned out to be warming instead. By warming I mean incubating some of the most vile-looking yuckiness as a skin over the whole thing. Uch!
I feel better about those things by thinking of the tiem my friend invited 22 people over for lunch and tried to serve a split pea soup with hot dogs in it that had cooked in a crock pot for a few hours before someone tripped over the plug without replacing it. This was in NYC in the middle of the summer, so when everyone got to the apartment after meeting up elsewhere hours earlier it smelled like something had died in there and we drew lots for who had to open the pot, tie up the bag, and take it to the garbage. The smell lingered for longer than I'd like to remember.
Stufsocker at 11:01AM on 10/08/07
I would have to say this is a tie....
either the time I tried to bake chocolate chip cookies when I was in high school to impress my boyfriend... I couldn't figure out why the top of the cookie burnt, but the bottom was raw... I left the oven on pre-heat instead of bake. I also once forgot to take the cardboard off the bottom of a frozen pizza and it caught on fire! I'm happy to say that I've improved my cooking skills since then.
keli1203 at 11:14AM on 10/08/07
I was trying to impress my extended (southern) family with my skills, and some of them requested biscuits. I'd never made them before, but I didn't think it would be a problem. After all, my butternut squash gnocchi and tarte tatin (homemade! puff pastry!) and strawberry napoleons had all been big hits. Biscuits are simple, they only have 4 or 5 ingredients, it couldn't possibly be a problem. It turns out that good buttermilk biscuits are the Riemann hypothesis of the culinary world. Though I made several attempts, the best biscuit I could come up with still had the flavor and texture of a moldy sponge. I still don't know how that happened. I had to serve frozen biscuits to family members who could bake good ones with a blind fold on. Disgrace!
BeccaLove at 11:24AM on 10/08/07
Oh, there are so many to choose from.
How about the time I made an oreo cheesecake for my boyfriend's birthday that turned out more like a rubber brick? Or the time that I made a red velvet cake that shrunk AND fell in the pan, also forming a tough, brick-like substance. Or maybe it would be the lemon muffins that ended up as lemon discs. Or setting ramen noodles on fire. Or..............
I'm contemplating taking cooking classes.
karenelizabeth at 11:31AM on 10/08/07
As a young bride, my first try at making guacamole in a blender was a green disaster -- forgot to put the lid on the blender, if you can believe that. I also made a rice, that when rolled into a ball and tossed on the floor, bounced. It was laughable to me, but my astonished and hungry husband did not share the humor. Later, after we had divorced, my mother delighted in telling my ex that I had won a blue ribbon at the county fair for my apple pie. The expression on his face was priceless!
hatlady at 11:32AM on 10/08/07
I was trying out a vegan recipe (I'm not vegan, but was interested to try some things) for Lunchbox Fondue (http://shmooedfood.blogspot.com/2005/11/lunch-box-fondue.html) from the Vegan Lunchbox blog. The recipe calls for 1/4 tsp dry mustard which I read as 1/4 CUP dry mustard. As I measured it out I thought, "Wow...this one recipe has almost used up my entire bottle of dry mustard!" First taste: felt like a mushroom cloud of HOT swept through my entire head obliterating anything in its path. My husband of almost 2 years, who has never said anything bad about my cooking (bless him), took a bite and could not hold back: "Oh MY GOSH! That's horrible! OH! What IS this!!" I contemplated making the batch bigger to balance out the mistake (I HATE throwing food out) but decided against it when I figured out I'd used 48 times the correct amount of the mustard.
Kimberly at 11:41AM on 10/08/07
It's gotta be the time a friend and I were making a home cooked dinner for two men in order to impress them. We helped ourselves to a little to much wine while cooking and a few things (integral to the meal like the vegetable/green beans dish) never made it out of the fridge.
Pierogi at 12:08PM on 10/08/07
It's hard to determine the worst (or, in retrospect, funniest). There was the time that the cayenne was substitured for the sweet paprika for the Paprikosh. Oof! Then there was the poptart in the toaster oven incident in Somerville MA, in which my sweetie had put the strawberry unfrosted toaster pastries in to toast while a friend called from out of town, the pastries started to burn and flame (!) and she called for me to help -- and my friend Gary refused to get out the damn phone "but-but-I have more to say!". *oy* So I unplugged the toaster oven and ran the whole thing out onto the front porch and shoveled show into it!
Stushi at 12:12PM on 10/08/07
the worst was probably the time i attempted a savory shrimp flan seasoned with fish sauce. The flavor was off, and the flan was an overcooked mess.
arbeck at 12:16PM on 10/08/07
Starting the kitchen on fire by putting an oven mitt on a hot burner during Homecoming Weekend at college on "taco night" in our apartment. Subsequently knocking out power for the 3 apartments that made up our house, and highly irritating our many houseguests trying to get ready to go out for the night.
bobcatsteph3 at 12:41PM on 10/08/07
The very first thanksgiving dinner I ever did myself. 10 lb frozen turkey, in the oven for the prescribed ammount of time, correct temp. 100% by the book. Except I forgot to thaw it first... I was so proud until a tried to slice into a perfectly browned, frozen solid bird.
grs100 at 12:47PM on 10/08/07
Yet another taco disaster! I came home from my high school job of cooking at a senior center to find all the fixin's for soft tacos left out for me by my parents, who were out attending the local PTA meeting. I fired up the wok with hot oil but spilled salsa all over my work top. I left the kitchen to put my clothes in the washer...a couple of minutes later my dog came running to find me, barking like Lassie. I ran back to the kitchen to find all the wood cabinets up in flames from the grease fire. I ran to the wash room, grabbed as many towels as I could find, threw them on top of the wok and frantically beat the living daylights out of the cabinet fire. I successfully got the fire out, but turned around to see four feet of thick, black, greasy smoke filling up the entire first floor of the house. I opened up all the windows and doors, got the house fans out and blew the smoke out of the house. I called up the fire dept and had them check out the house for any potential problems. Needless to say, I did not have an appetite for soft tacos anymore. Ever.
A Big Fan of TAG at 1:12PM on 10/08/07
How many people does it take to cook hamburgers on a grill?
Five.
And one to order Pizza.
Too much lighter fluid, wet charcoals. Someone had the bright idea to put them under the broiler in the oven. Grease fire, and then an oven filled with flour.
The pizza was only o.k.
danielle719 at 1:56PM on 10/08/07
I consider myself to be a very proficient pastry chef. So imagine my embarrassment when I went to make a meringue buttercream for a friend's birthday cake but kept coming up with egg white and butter soup. My apt was scorching hot and I couldn't cool it down (AC was busted) and my egg whites wouldn't whip up properly. Keep in mind that I'm already 20 minutes late to her birthday party and she lives a half hour away. I made another batch but the same thing happened. I had no choice but to scrap the buttercream and just slap some melted white chocolate all over the cake. It looked horrible, like something a 5 year old would make. Luckily for me, I was able to slice and serve the cake without anyone seeing the entire thing. So I wasn't publicly embarrassed, but I was embarrassed nonetheless.
charm city cupcake at 2:00PM on 10/08/07
I cooked dinner for my dad and I a couple months before I got married. I was inspired to make home made bisquits. I pulled them out of the oven and they looked great, they just didn't raise at all. Undeterred, I put them in a basket and set them on the table when it was time to eat. I told my dad proudly that I made dinner all myself. He looked at the basket of bisquits and said "it looks like you made cookies for dessert"! We laughed when I told him that they were supposed to be light, fluffy bisquits!
I make awesome bisquits now and my dad and I still giggle!
maryoneski at 2:11PM on 10/08/07
Let's see, SO many to chose from! How about the time I cooked a spaghetti squash in the microwave WHOLE! I knew that I had to let the steam escape and punctured the squash several times with a knife. But evidently this was not enough. I had walked out of the kitchen and I heard what sounded like a small explosion. The spaghetti squash had burst and blew open the door to the microwave, covering every surface of my small kitchen to include the ceiling with "spaghetti". It is amazing how much surface area on squash can cover! I cleaned up spaghetti squash for WEEKS! Now I know to CUT the squash in have before microwaving.
Sindy at 3:00PM on 10/08/07
That would be mashed potatoes. My little brother phoned halfway through the whipping process. After I came back to the pan, I thought I'd better add more milk as they seemed kind of thicker than usual. Wow, and kind of sticky. More milk. Erm, more glueish. Well, make lemonade, right? I scraped the potato mixture into a baking dish, dotted with a little butter, sprinkled paprika for a "this was intentional" look of Jacketless Twice Baked Potatoes. Um, after baking for 30 minutes, not so much. Instead, that would be wallpaper paste. Maybe spackle. Really REALLY hard to clean up, and certainly not edible. Nobody distracts me during mashed potato preparation anymore.
lailshie at 3:41PM on 10/08/07
my mom had an easy peesy recipe for making some ribs with soy sauce, vinegar, rice wine, and sugar. it was something like three parts vinegar and two parts sugar.
when it was cooked and i eagerly dug in to discover that i forgot the sugar and it was as if i just braised something in rice vinegar.
that first bite caused me to make a face like what you saw on those "bitter-beer-face" commercials. good times.
foodinmouth at 4:16PM on 10/08/07
My oven had accumulated lots of little bits of food in the bottom over the months. I didn't realize how much had accumulated until I had 15 people over for a pizza party dinner and the fire alarm went off relentlessly. There was no way to turn it off because I live in a loft with 13 foot cielings. Everyone's ears were pierced and we had no dinner because there was no othher way to bake the pizzas!
chezmadeleine at 4:19PM on 10/08/07
It was two weeks before we were closing on our house - in a market where we were lucky to even have someone to make an offer - I decide to make a bag of popcorn in the microwave. I was glad I smelled the smoke before the flames started licking at the cabinets. It took a fire extinguisher to get out all the flames. Popcorn makes really good fuel - and smells really, really bad for a couple of weeks. I will never, ever, ever cook in a kitchen without a little red canister - I think it saved my house! Luckily, we sold the house and we're much more careful about popping popcorn.
Dancingaroundthehouse at 4:55PM on 10/08/07
My worst cooking disaster was technically a baking disaster. I was making key lime cheesecake bars, which sound delicious but which were HORRIBLE. Of course part of this was probably my fault because I forgot to shake up the key lime juice before adding it to the batter. The other parts that made it horrible include a pretzel crust and pistachio topping. I took a bite when they were ready and didn't like it but thought maybe my husband would still like it as he's less of a picky eater. When he got home he dug right in and then looked shocked. He couldn't decide whether to spit it out and risk offending me or to swallow it and deal with the pain. In the end, I told him it was OK if he didn't like them because I didn't either. We threw out the rest of the pan and vowed never to try that recipe again.
MrsCa at 4:58PM on 10/08/07
My absolute worst cooking disaster was back almost 30 years ago when I was a new bride just beginning to cook. Up until then, Mom had done all the day-to-day cooking, and there's just so many hotdogs you can eat. I had received a crock pot as a wedding gift, along with it's little recipe booklet. Hmmm. Cauliflour soup. Sounded pretty good, and within my skills range. Put everything in in the morning, and turned the pot on. Came home after work, expecting great things. Oh no. The aroma wafting under the door was not at all pleasant. The entire apartment reeked of rotten onions. I still use the crock pot, but that little recipe book went right into the garbage, along with all that soup.
sjwoodin at 5:09PM on 10/08/07
a food disaster haiku:
home alone- first time!
.....gray macaroni and cheese!!!?!
hello garbage bin!
bisbee at 5:39PM on 10/08/07
This weekend, we made a Black Forest Cake for an Octoberfest party. Unfortunately, the humidity got the best of the cake and the layers started to slide around. Not one of our best cakes...
rudolfrassen at 7:20AM on 10/09/07