Seriously Asian: Hooked on Udon
"Finally, these were the noodles of my dreams, noodles with the kind of the flexible yet creamy strands that I had only ever tasted with homemade Italian pasta."
Note: Every week, SE intern Chichi Wang will be discussing some aspect of Asian cookery, with an emphasis on the traditional, underappreciated, or misunderstood elements thereof.

Recently, I had an epiphany on the noodle-making front. For years I'd been successfully rolling out tagliatelle or cutting papardelle by hand; every week, I'd rub my palms to the rhythm of trofie. Yet deep down, I was ashamed. I was ashamed because I'd never had success with a batch of homemade Asian noodles, the ones using only water and flour. My problem? Without the addition of eggs, the doughy strands were never quite chewy enough. Meal after meal, I would slurp down my homemade noodles floating limply in a bowl of broth with the nagging feeling that somehow, I could do better.
I wondered if it were possible to make truly fine Asian noodles at home. I wanted to find a recipe that would yield limber and slightly chewy strands, with the kind of dexterity evident upon first bite. I'd tasted such strands from relatively expensive packages of thin Korean noodles, but even those lacked the freshness that I had come to appreciate with my own Italian pasta.
Looking at episodes of No Reservations didn't boost my prospects. As I watched Anthony Bourdain visiting master noodle makers in Asia, I started to wonder if the only way I could produce a nearly perfect noodle was to take up the craft wholeheartedly, perhaps with a giant wooden dowel that would thump the dough like an overbearing masseuse.
Lacking such physical prowess, I instead tried different proportions of flour-to-water-to-salt and, after that stage, another period in which different resting times and kneading techniques were attempted. One year, I became convinced that a type of powder the Chinese call "kansui," an alkaline-related ingredient that imparts a certain aroma to the noodles in China, was my missing ingredient. I even had my eighty-six-year-old grandfather in Shanghai inquire about the matter of kansui and obtain a bag for my own use, but one taste of the powder-laden noodles left my tongue numb for well over an hour.
Just when I had set aside my dreams of making Asian noodles at home, the noodles found me. While revisiting the Dengaku technique in Japanese Cooking: A Simple Art, a recipe for udon noodles fell open onto my lap. The recipe looked similar to any other I'd seen for flour-and-water noodles, yet there in the list of ingredients, Tsuji had included egg yolks as an optional element in the dough. In that moment, I felt the force of noodle enlightenment enveloping me, and I knew that I had found my recipe.
In the past, I'd added yolk after yolk into a decadent agnolotti recipe from The French Laundry Cookbook, but I hadn't considered adding yolks to my Asian noodles. Call me parochial or just plain silly, but now, I'm kicking myself for never before plopping an egg yolk into my previous flour mounds. This time around, doing so made all the difference.

The udon noodles were slick and supple, possessing a bouncy chew that came apart in my mouth with just the right amount of resistance. Finally, these were the noodles of my dreams, noodles with the kind of the flexible yet creamy strands that I had only ever tasted with homemade Italian pasta. An egg yolk they contained, but eggy they were not. The overwhelming taste of the strands was that of the water-and-flour noodle, yet the addition of just two yolks, with their all-important fat, added a critical litheness to the chew of each stand.
Kneading the noodles was another revelation. In the book, Tsuji advises that the dough be kneaded until it is firm yet supple like the earlobe. At first I chuckled but eventually the incredible wisdom of this statement became evident as I continued to knead the dough. As I passed the ten-minute marker, I began to realize that the dough was becoming stronger yet slightly yielding. And, well, it felt uncannily like earlobe.

I served the noodles in a basic Japanese broth consisting of dashi, soy sauce, and mirin. The slippery strands, like eels swimming in a limpid pool, were so satisfying that few, if any, embellishments were needed. As I happened to have on hand a bag of fresh baby bok choy, I wilted a few pieces into the broth. Verdant and barely cooked through, the bok choy completed the sparse yet elegant canvas that so frequently defines Japanese cookery.
It was really difficult to do, but I waited for about two hours to try the noodles in a pork bone soup and found that they were just as delicious in the meaty broth as they had been in the dashi-based soup. As such, I am officially dubbing these udon noodles my homemade Asian noodles of choice.
Homemade Udon in Japanese Noodle Broth
Adapted from Japanese Cooking: A Simple Art by Shizuo Tsuji.
Ingredients
For the noodles:
1 3/4 cups cold water
2 1/2 tablespoons salt
2 egg yolks
8 1/3 cups (2.5 pounds or 1 kg) all-purpose flour
For the broth:
8 1/3 cups dashi
2 teaspoons salt
3 tablespoons dark soy sauce
3 tablespoons light soy sauce
2 tablespoons sugar
2 tablespoons mirin
Procedure
1. Dissolve the salt in the water, then add the egg yolks to the mixture. Stir to combine. Mound the flour on a board and make a well in the center. Gradually add the liquid mixture to the flour. Depending on what type of all-purpose flour you use, the amount of liquid will vary slightly. (I generally use King Arthur, and I find that it needs a little more liquid.) The dough will start to come together when approximately half of the liquid is incorporated into the flour.
2. Knead the dough vigorously, for about fifteen minutes, until it is smooth and firm yet pliant like an earlobe. Cover with a damp kitchen cloth and let rest for 8 hours during the winter or 3 hours in the summer.
3. Divide the dough into four equal sections for ease of rolling. On a flour-dusted board, roll out the dough to a 1/8 inch width. Sprinkle the sheet of dough with flour, and then gently fold into fourths lengthwise. Cut into approximately 1/4-inch strips with a sharp knife. After cutting, spread out loosely to ensure that the strands will not stick together as you are rolling and cutting the rest of the dough. This batch, in total, will make approximately 10 servings.
4. To cook the noodles: bring a large pot of water to boil. Cook for approximately 4 to 7 minutes, depending on the thickness of the noodle. Boil until the noodles are just cooked through the center; drain and rinse under cold water. Unlike Italian pasta, for which it is desirable to retain the surface starch, you want to make your udon noodles slicker.
5. Meanwhile, make your basic Japanese noodle broth. In a large pot, bring dashi to a boil and add the salt, soy sauce, sugar, and mirin. Keep at a low simmer until you are ready to use it. This broth may be made in advance, cooled to room temperature, and refrigerated in a container for up to 3 days.
6. To assemble: Place the cooked noodles in the broth, along with accoutrements, if desired. If the broth is fresh, then the noodles will be delicious on their own with very few additions needed. A poached egg, sliced green onions, or fish cake are some of my favorites.
About the author: Chichi Wang took her degree in philosophy, but decided that writing about food would be much more fun than writing about Plato. She firmly believes in all things offal, the importance of reading great books, and the necessity of three-hour meals. If she were ever to get a tattoo, it would say "Fat is flavor." Visit her blog, My Chalkboard Fridge.
Add a comment:
Previewing your comment:
HTML Hints
Some HTML is OK: <a href="URL">link</a>, <strong>strong</strong>, <em>em</em>
Comment Guidelines
Post whatever you want, just keep it seriously about eats, seriously. We reserve the right to delete off-topic or inflammatory comments. Learn more at our Comment Policy page.
If you see something not so nice, please, report an inappropriate comment.

24 Comments:
I love this series!
A couple questions:
1. I've only ever had udon that was fat and tubular. How important is that shape to its "udon-ness"?
2. I'm really interested to know where you got a hold of the "kansui". I don't read Chinese, but I do speak it, and "kansui", or lye water, always sounded to me like the Cantonese words for "soapy water:--soap, of course, is a very alkaline substance. Tell me it isn't just diluted detergent!
Michele Humes at 12:57PM on 07/17/09
Awesome. I have seen a recipe for udon that recommends wrapping the dough in a plastic bag and then a towel... and stepping on it to knead it. Even if its not super-necessary, it'd be a great kids-cooking activity!
engmcmuffin at 1:00PM on 07/17/09
Ten servings? Seeing the pictures, I'm sure that the SO and I could knock them all out ourselves, but we really shouldn't. Any recommendations for storing the unused portions?
blangblang at 1:14PM on 07/17/09
I make udon without eggs (the traditional way) and the noodles come out chewy and yummy. Yes, I do step on the dough. it's too hard to hand-knead!
I found these tutorial videos very helpful, though there may be videos with subtitles somewhere.
http://homepage2.nifty.com/nakkara/indexUdonTeuchi.html
hmw0029 at 1:37PM on 07/17/09
My first thought, when you said your udon wasn't chewy enough, was that you weren't kneading it enough. When you want chewy, you want gluten, and that means long, vigorous kneading. I'll bet you'd get the same texture if you left out the egg yolks and just kneaded the heck out of the dough.
DrGaellon at 2:54PM on 07/17/09
mmm earlobe soup!
hungrychristel at 3:36PM on 07/17/09
I adore udon! After "discovering" it at a local Japanese restaurant and raving over it, my father told me stories about making and consuming it as a child in China. To which I replied with justifiable consternation: "Wait, you've known about this stuff since you were a kid and you never made it/bought it for me??" : )
On my recent 3 week trip to China, though, I made up for the loss by eating everything exciting in sight. My latest post about my travels there describes the wonders of Shanghai street food for breakfast:
http://katacomb.blogspot.com/
As a new and young blogger, I'd love it if anyone could take a peek and perhaps leave a comment. Suggestions to improve my writing or such would be so appreciated.
But back to the topic of udon--I've found that adding vital wheat gluten helps give them more "chew." And I always rinse the dough to get rid of some of the excess starch, though of course if you rinse too much you get seitan!
Takat at 4:02PM on 07/17/09
BTW, udon is made with medium-gluten flour (churiki-ko, or udon-ko), which very similar in gluten content to all purpose flour here in the US.
The "standard" flour in Japan has less gluten. that's why you can't use all purpose flour for tempura :-)
hmw0029 at 4:09PM on 07/17/09
good tip hmw! I'll keep that in mind when i experiment.
engmcmuffin at 5:04PM on 07/17/09
When someone tells me that they can't cook, my standard reply is, "It's not the cook; it's the recipe." It's why I adore writers like Julia Child and Dorie Greenspan and now Tsuji, who use their recipes to teach what something should look like or feel like at a certain stage. Doesn't it make cooking just so much easier?
Thanks for the teaching, Chichi.
betteirene at 8:57PM on 07/17/09
Ah, I love a story with a happy ending.
marchpane at 10:01AM on 07/18/09
Hi fellow noodle slurpers,
A few things:
Michele, I’ve seen udon in the Japanese stores being sold as both the “fat and tubular kind,” as well as the “broad and flat” kind. I’m a fan of the broad type because I think it’s just a little more fun to slurp! Personal preference, though.
The bag my grandfather obtained for me was actually from the noodle shop itself, which was a well-respected shop a few blocks from his apartment. I think that in order for the kansui to be in any way palatable, you have to make a commercial-sized quantity.
The unused portions may be frozen, prior to being cooked.
DrGaellon, I’ve tried kneading udon dough in the past very vigorously, for a very long time, but the results have always been less than satisfactory. I am intrigued by hmw0029’s suggestion of doing it by foot, though! Maybe my conception of “long and vigorous” kneading doesn’t quite cut it!
Betteirene, great point. I am a huge Julia Child fan, and one thing I am always trying to work on is being more descriptive in my directions, so that readers have a common reference point from which to understand a sentence.
If any one has other Udon or Asian noodle dough recipes that they have found to be completely successful, I’d love to know about them!
The bottom line about this recipe is that for those who have found their noodles to be not quite bouncy enough, a little injection of fat in the form of yolks DOES help!
Chichi Wang at 10:49AM on 07/18/09
Filipinos have a noodle/meat/vegetable dish called pancit that is always made with dried noodles, either rice, cornstarch, wheat or mung bean threads. My mother is Filipina and I've lived there three different times and recall only dried noodles. Is that the only Asian culture without a fresh noodle?
betteirene at 1:44AM on 07/19/09
Slightly off topic, but check out the movie, appropriately titled, "Udon". It's a great dramedy about a failed stand-up comic and his love/hate relationship with his father, a master Udon maker. There are great scenes showing the making of udon and the hilarious udon pilgrimmage trend that the main character sparks.
AnnieNT at 4:00PM on 07/22/09
I'm a native Japanese. I have the book, Japanese Cooking: A Simple Art, and Shizuko Tsuji was a highly respected person. However, we NEVER put egg yolk in Udon dough, period. Sorry. This is not Udon noodle. And we have to knead Udon dough REALLY well. In Japan, when we make it, we step on it and knead it. (Of course, we cover the dough with a plastic bag. ;-)) That's why your noodle was not chewy enough. Also, this shape of the noodle is called "KISHIMEN", not udon. I needed to let you know.
thebirdie at 3:44PM on 07/23/09
Thebirdie: My information for the name and shape of the noodle as well as the content of the dough (i.e., including the egg yolks) comes from the book itself, by Tsuji. So perhaps there is a possibility that there are udon doughs that include yolks - otherwise, why would Tsuji include the yolk as an optional ingredient in the recipe that he calls "Udon"?
thanks,
Chichi
Chichi Wang at 4:01PM on 07/23/09
I also happen to own the book and Tsuji
1. does include yolk as optional
2. has you roll it out pretty flatly
Plus, as an ardent believer that my food should give me more enjoyment than I give my food, I'm not going to give the dough a full-on foot massage just so I can make noodles in my apartment.
If the end result is indeed chewy and delicious udon, then that's all that matters to me.
miloptimus at 10:47AM on 07/25/09
I know, I have the book too. But, the flour in US and Japan are different. I've lived here for 20 yrs and have plenty of experiences with the ingredients here. My guess is that they added yolks to make it easier for Americans to get the texture. You can believe that's Udon, but, if you want to be authentic, we, Japanese don't call that UDON, and the shape is not UDON either. As I said, it's Kishimen. I see so many things like that in Japanese food here. But, Japanese do the same thing too in Japan. Their pattie for the hamburger is basically a meatloaf. They put eggs, bread crumb, some vegetable, etc. I'm just to trying to tell you the authentic Japanese. I hope you understand.
thebirdie at 10:05AM on 07/27/09
Hey guys, all comments are well-noted and certainly valid. At this point we may be entering the muddy realm of semantics and what makes something "authentic," "traditional," or not.
In short, my mission was to seek a noodle that would stand up well to various types of Asian broths, and I happened to find such a noodle, called "Udon," in Tsuji's book.
I think it's important to note the traditional methods, but I'm also interested in the application of such foods to the home kitchen. Part of what makes the "traditional" approach daunting is the very fact that there's all this rigmarole involved, making it unrealistic for most home cooks.
Chichi Wang at 11:41AM on 07/27/09
I don't care if it's flat or straight. I would just like a big steaming-hot bowl of udon in a fragrant broth, preferably with some fiery red kimchi on the side.
NotAmerican at 1:00PM on 07/27/09
Thanks thebirdie. I always like knowing the background and specifics of food. It would never occur to me to step on the dough, but I think I'll try it.
Thanks Chichi Wang for the recipe.
twosavoie at 2:01PM on 07/27/09
Dare I ask, can you use the dough hook on the Kitchen Aid Mixer for the extensive kneading?
Mama Beckala at 10:28AM on 07/28/09
Mama Beckala, I've never had the gall to use my KA Mixer for kneading Asian noodle dough. The closest I've gotten is attempting pasta dough, and that did not turn out very well (the dough never came together; the bits of egg and flour just clumped up and kept spinning about in the bowl).
The most vigorous kneading I do on my mixer is for making brioche, and brioche dough is significantly more malleable than noodle dough. I'd be too afraid of wearing down the machine with a hard noodle dough, but then again, I couldn't afford to replace my mixer!
Chichi Wang at 10:42AM on 07/28/09
I love noodles too! ALL sorts of noodles and love the different textures and flavors of them. The geography and history of the people that create these different noodles have often determined the recipes. UDON of Japan is mostly accepted as kneded flour and hot salt-water only (very stiff dough, therefore kneaded by marching on plastic-bagged dough by feet), rested over-night, kneaded again, then rolled and cut. This process typically gives 1/8in thick and 1/8in wide noodles (flatter, thinner KISHIMEN noodles are from a specific area). When boiled, these Udon noodles are even enjoyed without soup, just a splash of soy sauce, a few Tbsp grated Daikon radish and a spritz of lemon (a pinch of Bonito flakes too).
This is easy and great cool or warm as a summer lunch.
Not Yukio at 5:33PM on 07/31/09