Dinner Tonight: Proper French Omelet

This post isn't meant to be a take-down of good old American diner omelets: fluffy, stuffed full of fixings, oozing cheese. I happen to love omelets like that. But I also love an omelet that's done in the classical French way, a more artful affair that's thin, spare, and just barely cooked past runny. Laced with a bit of cheese, perhaps some chopped herbs, or nothing at all—what's important is that the omelet is not a vehicle for what's inside. It's about the eggs themselves.
And it's a sublime transformation from raw eggs to omelet, done in less than two minutes (unlike scrambled eggs, which are best cooked for an age over impossibly low heat), so the perfect quick pantry dinner. I found the recipe I was looking for in an old post on eGullet, a website which never fails to satisfy (and usually stoke) my curiosities. Besides offering good suggestions for salt and pepper, it also suggests a teaspoon of cold water per egg, which steams during cooking, adding some extra fluffiness to the eggs.
In the end, a good omelet is about good technique, which is really a matter of practice. But this post got me started.
About the author: Blake Royer founded The Paupered Chef with Nick Kindelsperger, where he writes about food and occasional travels. He is currently living for the year in Tartu, Estonia.
Proper French Omelet
- serves 1 -
Adapted from eGullet.
Ingredients
2 tablespoons butter
2 eggs
1/4 teaspoon salt
4 grinds of fresh pepper (preferably white, but only for aesthetic reasons)
2 teaspoons cold water
1/4 cup grated cheese (optional)
2 tablespoons chopped fresh herbs (optional)
Procedure
1. In a mixing bowl or measuring jar, combine the egg, seasoning, and water. Whisk vigorously to combine so that the mixture is relatively homogeneous.
2. Heat a small skillet, preferably nonstick, over medium-high heat until drops of water dance on the surface. Add the butter. When the foam subsides, add the egg mixture all at once.
3. Immediately, begin to shake the pan to distribute the eggs all over the pan and up the sides. Technique varies—some suggest pulling up the sides of the omelet and tilting the pan to let uncooked egg slide under, or using a spatula to gently break holes in the eggs to let uncooked egg run there. What's important is to never quit shaking the pan to prevent any browning, and to cook until the eggs are still wet on top. Distribute cheese or herbs across the whole omelet, if using.
4. Using a spatula, fold one side of the omelet 1/3 of the way towards the opposite side. Tip the omelet out of the pan, rolling it onto a plate so both sides fold under. Serve immediately.
View other entries from Dinner Tonight.
Add a comment:
Previewing your comment:
HTML Hints
Some HTML is OK: <a href="URL">link</a>, <strong>strong</strong>, <em>em</em>
Comment Guidelines
Post whatever you want, just keep it seriously about eats, seriously. We reserve the right to delete off-topic or inflammatory comments. Learn more at our Comment Policy page.
If you see something not so nice, please, report an inappropriate comment.

15 Comments:
I could never understand why people add water to their eggs. I generally add 2% milk or higher percentage milkfat, or even sour cream. But the water makes no sense to me. I had watered-down eggs in the Navy and to me they were tasteless. Can anyone explain why this is done, besides "That's how the French do it"?
LunaPierCook at 5:40PM on 06/02/09
The omelet in that picture isn't a good example of a classic french omelet: Overcooked on the outside, not folded right. Don't add water either... that's no good. Neither is milk for that matter. For a classic omelet, you need eggs, salt, pepper if you like (white if you don't want black specks), and butter. That's it. Nothing more, nothing less. The technique though is tricky... takes some practice and it helps to see someone do it right first.
Olho de Gato at 5:49PM on 06/02/09
I learned a lot about making omelets from Gordon Brown and Good Eats. Season 7 Episode 3:
http://www.tv.com/Good+Eats/The+Egg+Files+VI%3A+French+Flop+(a.k.a.+Zen+and+the+Art+of+Omelet+Maintenance)/episode/309544/summary.html
weedenbc at 6:24PM on 06/02/09
Gordon? Is that Alton's brother? :-)
ajdaddy at 6:33PM on 06/02/09
Yea, but Gordon talks funny and drives on the wrong side of the road ... @Olho de Gato, I do like mine with no liquid added as well, just neglected to mention it. This pic also seems rather out-of-focus. Of course now every time I use the word "focus", in my mind it sounds as it does in the one scene in Hellboy II ...
LunaPierCook at 8:02PM on 06/02/09
Howard Helmers techniques works
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RNB_KW9rHTA
winebill at 9:09PM on 06/02/09
I remember an episode of the Frugal Gourmet from when I was just a kid: probably my first cooking show memory.
Jeff Smith says, "If you don't want watery omelettes, add water to them."
I never understood the principal behind that, nor have I ever done a scientific test to ascertain is verity. But now, I will.
Perhaps the extra water helps evaporates faster than the bound moisture in the egg, helping it soufflé slightly more, leading to a lighter - and therefore dryer tasting - texture?
J. Kenji Lopez-Alt at 9:56PM on 06/02/09
@GoodEaterKenji - please be kind, I'm such a fan of yours. You totally rock! I can actually answer why Jeff Smith advised adding water! His Frugal Gourmet cookbook was one of my first, I still have it. On page 91, he's giving hints for a good omelet. His 4th hint is to "never use milk in the egg mixture. Use only water. Milk makes your eggs watery since it will not blend with the eggs. Water blends and helps keep the water high." Whether or not this is truly fact or mere perception, I can't say. But I have followed his rule ever since then. Anyhow, that's why he said it.
RossS at 11:16PM on 06/02/09
Okay, I'm not clear on the concept. I've had omelets I've loved and omelets I've hated - the latter had distinctly runny, uncooked egg inside; I repeat, uncooked and runny and nasty and horrible. Tell me why this would ever be considered a good thing. The ones I've loved had egg that was just barely cooked through, but definitely cooked (not slippery and sticky and icky, not suitable for making paint but not for eating). Yet I have paid quite a bit for the awful ones, and practically nothing for the good ones. I may be the only person I know who has sent an omelet back to the kitchen to be replaced with a cooked dish, in spite of the server's eye-rolling and patient explanation that it's supposed to be coldish and sticky and drippy inside. Am I just a philistine?
Likeswords at 11:59PM on 06/02/09
Slight typo on my previous post. Should read "Water blends and keeps the omelet high." Sigh...
RossS at 12:04AM on 06/03/09
I've been thinking again (yeah I know, that's dangerous) ... 2 tablespoons butter seems a whole heck of a lot for two eggs in a small skillet. Not sure if we're frying or deep-frying the omelet ... yeah, I think I'll stick to what I know. My son and I have done omelet buffets for up to 50 people and I think we do it up rather nicely, and without the pretentiousness.
LunaPierCook at 6:22AM on 06/03/09
Everyone likes all egg dishes their own way. I like firm and fluffy omelets, smothered with cheese and fillings. I like creamy, barely-cooked scrambled eggs on toast, I like hard-cooked scrambled eggs with fried potatoes, I like fried eggs, fried till lacy and crisp, on a sandwich made with buttered white toast and a slice of cheese. It's just such a personal thing.
And consider the egg. It can do so much. It can help your baking, it makes a fine salad, it can be hard-boiled, soft-boiled, poached, even deep-fried (everyone should have a Scotch Egg at least once...a hard boiled egg wrapped in ground sausage and bread crumbs, then fried). Is there a single type of food that doesn't benefit from the egg? What a culinary miracle it really is. Thanks, chickens. Keep up the good work.
NotAmerican at 7:47AM on 06/03/09
de Gato...AMEN! Maybe a little truffle butter if you're particularly flush
Deb07 at 11:41AM on 06/03/09
I love omelets and eggs in all their variations and forms.
Thanks for the recipe and reminder that a simple omelet can be a perfect dish-- all about the egg.
CJ McD at 12:50PM on 06/03/09
Just tried the recipe, and I am happy to report that this is the best omelette I have EVER eaten. Thanks for a good, simple, honest recipe. Delicious! Though, yes, I went a little lower on the butter than suggested.
hillymae at 7:10AM on 11/04/09