Eat for Eight Bucks: French Onion Pastina

There's a sort of magic in caramelizing an onion; it doesn't seem possible that all that sugar is hiding inside the sulfurous bulb. And it's that surprising sweetness that makes French onion soup one of the most comforting foods I know.
While I'm always soothed by French onion soup, I'm rarely left full, and I've long plotted to somehow bulk it up. But filling up on baguette seems unimaginative, and simply throwing some cooked noodles into the pot, as you might do with a chicken soup, doesn't feel like a coherent dish. So I've devised what you might call a mock risotto, in which acini di pepe (a pastina, or little pasta, named for its peppercorn shape) is cooked directly in the soup, absorbing all of its sweet, oniony flavor. As with risotto, any unabsorbed liquid is thickened by the starch to form an almost creamy sauce. But, unlike risotto, there's no stirring or incremental ladling of stock.
It wouldn't be French onion soup without the cheese, so I stir some grated Parmesan into the finished pastina and top it with a Parmesan crisp. The crisp is a fussy, and optional, extra, but little flourishes like this one always make me feel better about cooking on the cheap. The dish, after all, cost just $6.85 to make.
The Shopping List
Note: Items bought in large quantities, like the pasta and Parmesan, have been pro-rated for cost. Ingredients a cook can reasonably be expected to have on hand are considered "Pantry Items" and are not factored into recipe cost.
2 large onions - $0.86
1 quart beef stock - $3.29
1/2 pound acini di pepe - $0.85 (total cost of item - $1.69)
3 ounces domestic Parmesan - $1.85 (total cost of item - $3.09)
Pantry Items
Dried thyme; flour; olive oil; salt and pepper
Total Cost
$6.85
French Onion Pastina with Parmesan Crisps
- serves 2 -
With every effort you make to chop the onions finely and evenly, they'll caramelize exponentially faster. Be patient, too, once they're in the pan; full caramelization is what gives both color and flavor to this dish, and pale onions make for a bland end product.
Ingredients
2 tablespoons olive oil
1 pound onions (about 2 large), very finely sliced
1 tsp flour
3 1/2 cups beef stock
1/4 teaspoon dried thyme
1/2 pound acini di pepe, or other very small pasta (orzo, stelle, seme di melone)
1/4 cup shredded Parmesan
Salt and freshly ground black pepper
Parmesan crisps (recipe follows)
Procedure
1. Cook onions in oil in a large, deep saucepan, stirring occasionally, until onions are very soft and a deep brown color, 25-30 minutes. As the onions cook down, they may start to stick to the bottom of the pan; whenever this happens, deglaze with a small quantity of cold water, scraping with wooden spoon to dissolve brown bits.
2. Remove about 1/4 of onions from pan, reserving for garnish. Season with salt and pepper and cover to keep warm.
3. Sprinkle flour over the onions in the pot, stirring to incorporate. Add beef stock and dried thyme and bring to a boil. Lower to a simmer, adjust seasoning, and add pasta. Cover pan and simmer, depending on type of pasta, for 6-9 minutes, or until pasta is al dente and most of the liquid is absorbed. Stir once or twice during cooking to prevent sticking.
4. Remove pasta from heat and stir in shredded Parmesan. Adjust seasoning if necessary. To serve, top with reserved onions and Parmesan crisp.
Parmesan Crisps

1. Heat a nonstick pan over medium-low heat. Sprinkle a small handful (about 1 1/2 tablespoons) of grated Parmesan into the pan to form a circle about 3 inches in diameter. Cook until cheese is somewhat melted and beginning to take on color, 1-2 minutes. Using a spatula, gently loosen the cheese and flip, cooking for an additional 30 seconds.
2. Place on paper towels to cool, or, for a curved shape, immediately drape over a rolling pin or other cylindrical surface.
Add a comment:
Previewing your comment:
HTML Hints
Some HTML is OK: <a href="URL">link</a>, <strong>strong</strong>, <em>em</em>
Comment Guidelines
Post whatever you want, just keep it seriously about eats, seriously. We reserve the right to delete off-topic or inflammatory comments. Learn more at our Comment Policy page.
If you see something not so nice, please, report an inappropriate comment.

18 Comments:
Wow -- This sounds delicious. I think I'll try it for dinner tonight. I've been experimenting with lots of french recipes lately, and this looks like a good one. Thanks!
seabee at 3:11PM on 02/05/09
I am going to have to try a vegan version of this with israeli couscous (one of those things that I've had forever because I'm not a huge fan).
KarynMC at 3:13PM on 02/05/09
Yeah, this one's definitely a keeper. I make french onion soup quite a bit for my family (I use tarragon instead of thyme...try it, you'll love it...) but the addition of the pasta is a great idea to make it more filling. And my DH adores those parm crisps. Great idea!
juliebugsmama at 3:41PM on 02/05/09
@karynmc: i love israeli couscous! i use dried wild mushrooms & mushroom stock to make a really good vegan faux risotto. fauxsotto? risfauxto?
dmarina at 4:15PM on 02/05/09
Recipe looks good. =) I should say, though, that the fillingness of french onion soup is all in how you make it. I make a really rich stock to go with it, and I found I have to put it in smaller bowls because it's so rich that people can't eat a large one. Delicious, but very very filling.
leilah at 4:25PM on 02/05/09
That's so cool. I'm going to start making Parmesan crisps all the time now. Just because I can.
Blake Royer at 3:54AM on 02/06/09
Michelle Humes is my hero.
meg3j at 8:20AM on 02/06/09
I'm wondering what, exactly, is the difference between acini di pepe and israeli couscous...
beano at 11:18PM on 02/06/09
@beano - Not much, size-wise. But Israeli couscous is toasted by the manufacturer, and has a nuttier taste.
Michele Humes at 7:33AM on 02/07/09
This took forever to make but it was delicious.
artychoke at 4:55PM on 02/08/09
I was drooling as I read this. This sounds dead easy and my DH loves a flavorful, filling soup during the cold days. This should fill the bill! I don't mind spending extra time if the result is as good as this sounds.
skyeyes at 11:21AM on 02/11/09
@artychoke Would you mind telling me which part of it took forever, so I can adjust the recipe where cooking times might be inaccurate? I'm glad you enjoyed it.
Michele Humes at 11:22AM on 02/11/09
I made this last night! Fantastic! Caramelizing the onions does take a long time, but it's fun (really!), just be patient as is says in the recipe. I originally bought actual "pastina" at the store, but decided it was too small to use, so I went with Orzo. I'll try Israeli Couscous next time (and there will be a next time). Paired this with a salad for a complete meal. From shopping bag to table took me about an hour.
mhmurray at 3:16PM on 02/12/09
I made this last night, it was delicious. I had about half a cup of extra beef stock, so I used that instead of water for the first two deglazings, then used a quarter cup of sherry for the final deglazing.
The key step was using a mandoline to slice the onions, I think it sped up the cooking time.
howlandwolfe at 2:05PM on 02/24/09
this is going to be dinner tomorrow night - thank you!!
Gizmosma at 2:39PM on 03/12/09
Good tip on using the mandoline, howlandwolfe.
I substituted shortened strands of whole-grain spaghetti in place of acini di pepe (or other small pasta like orzo), added a bit of water to deglaze and started pouring in beef broth without measuring. I used one onion, whereas the recipe calls for two large for two servings. And I probably threw in too much pasta. Anyway, this is a savory way to use spaghetti away from the tomato-based sauces. The beef stock gives it some heft and Parmesan, well, that just makes many foods better. Slurp the spaghetti, coated in the beef stock, which has a little flour and dried thyme mixed in. If you can find a good-quality beef stock, all the better. It might not be the most visually-stunning, or exciting-sounding dish, but it tastes good and it's a recipe that could feed a group.
bster18 at 5:57PM on 05/24/09
Hey everyone,
I didn't make the Parmesan crisps.
bster18 at 6:06PM on 05/24/09
I make parmesan crisp "bowls". Yummy and impressive looking. Simply increase the diameter of cheese spread in the pan. It should be less dense as well- when finished they almost look like lace. Invert melted cheese over a small bowl and voila! (I use rounded metal bowls and put them in the 'fridge to expedite the process.) It makes a lovely (individual) salad bowl -- will use next time I do (French onion) soup and salad.
mspsi at 9:38PM on 08/17/09