Mark Bittman's Savory Oatmeal with Scallions and Soy Sauce

Last week on NPR, Mark Bittman recommended savory oatmeal like it ain't no thang. "At lunch, you might have that same bowl of oatmeal, with perhaps um, oh I don't know, scallions and soy sauce on top, which would be very Asian, but still pretty good... Oh, my God, it's great."
Holy cats, savory oatmeal?! He can't just casually combine those two words and not expect an onslaught of gasps and hyperventilating. Of course, the Twittersphere was all atweet about it and suggested we try it. As senior oatmeal bureau chief, I was assigned the case.

Conclusion: Not gross. At all. In fact, it became more of a gooey sticky rice mass with crispy scallions folded inside. Not quite congee, the savory Asian rice porridge, but thinking about it in that possibly more familiar context could stop your head from hurting. For a soupier version, just add more water. Really, you'll forget it was ever oatmeal. The recipe, after the jump.
Mark Bittman's Oatmeal with Scallions and Soy Sauce
- serves one -
Ingredients
1 cup rolled oats (steel cut is my personal recommendation)
2 cups water
2 teaspoons soy sauce
1 tablespoon scallions for stirring, 1 teaspoon for garnish
A couple shakes of sea salt
1. Combine water, salt, and oats in a medium saucepan and turn the heat to high. When the water boils, turn to low and cook, stirring frequently, until the water is just about absorbed (about 5 minutes).
2. Turn off heat, stirring in 1 tablespoon of scallions and soy sauce while the pot cools down. Sprinkle that last teaspoon of scallions on top for extra crunch.
Note: You can also do this in the microwave. Some will call this sacrilegious, and sure, maybe the texture is compromised a tad, but if you're in an office or getting anxious thinking about a pot, it's fine. Just cook the oats, water and scallions for 2 1/2 to 3 minutes, and add soy sauce and extra scallion garnish after.
Add a comment:
Previewing your comment:
HTML Hints
Some HTML is OK: <a href="URL">link</a>, <strong>strong</strong>, <em>em</em>
Comment Guidelines
Post whatever you want, just keep it seriously about eats, seriously. We reserve the right to delete off-topic or inflammatory comments. Learn more at our Comment Policy page.
If you see something not so nice, please, report an inappropriate comment.

82 Comments:
It's just like how my college roommate would get grits from the dining hall for breakfast, and put soy sauce and a fried egg on top. It was a weird marriage of the South and Asia.
Speaking of congee, I think I will make some!
uninorth at 9:17AM on 01/28/09
so funny that you posted this - because i heard the same NPR program and had the same reaction!! cheap eats indeed.
emoelely at 9:23AM on 01/28/09
No no no. That is just not anything I would eat.
JerzeeTomato at 9:23AM on 01/28/09
On his blog he added olive oil and tapenade which I must say sort of grossed me out. Scallions and soy sauce sounds much tastier. Also, I think you should get business cards that say "Senior Oatmeal Bureau Chief."
ejayinator at 9:35AM on 01/28/09
You can totally cook oatmeal so it tastes very very similar to plain congee. And then you can add whatever you add to congee and it's a savory dish.
Have I eaten oatmeal with pork floss before? Yup.
foodinmouth at 9:40AM on 01/28/09
i am so going to try this.
carriebwc at 9:40AM on 01/28/09
I actually don't like oatmeal and have been trying to get myself to eat it for years-- this sounds GREAT, especially with the fried egg. I'd even add a little sesame oil/chili oil. The microwave option makes it perfect for the office!
Jenn Sit at 9:42AM on 01/28/09
I heard the same interview, and agreed with pretty much everything the awesome Mr. Bittman said...until this recipe...
Check please.
(I should note, though, that I think the Scots use oats in many more savory applications than we do...)
HeartofGlass at 9:50AM on 01/28/09
lol I've been doing that for a long time with cream o' wheat. I'll have to try it with oatmeal, although I have made oatmeal savory, just not with soy and scallions. heck it tastes alot better than it does with sweet stuff.
huneybumper at 9:56AM on 01/28/09
Try savory oats cooked as a pilaf rather than a porridge. I've been making different variations of this recipe from the "Quaker Oats Wholegrain Cookbook" for years, as a dinner side dish.
overw8 at 10:04AM on 01/28/09
Oats are just like any other grain (braley, quinoa, rice, etc.). I made some oat "risotto" last spring with shrimp, asparagus and pecorino...tasty!
bitchincamero at 10:10AM on 01/28/09
To see this first thing in the morning is the acid test. And I vote yes, to my personal amazement. Why not? Oatmeal is as neutral as any other grain-type product. It's all in our heads.
lemons at 10:12AM on 01/28/09
I agree with the all in our heads statement. I'm going to try it.
arugulafiles at 10:21AM on 01/28/09
You are very brave to be the one to try this recipe! That said, it looks...pretty good! I think I may have to give it a shot.
omglawdork at 10:23AM on 01/28/09
I often eat oatmeal cooked in milk and seasoned with kosher salt. It is simple, but satisfying. The nuttiness of the steel cut oats (McCann's really is tastier than other brands in my experience) is accentuated this way. Overall, I probably prefer it slightly sweet, but it is very good either way.
ECA at 10:31AM on 01/28/09
I so want to try this as well...the image looks divine.
hungrychristel at 10:43AM on 01/28/09
This recipe made me wonder why I only associated oatmeal with sweet things; it tastes awesome savory! It doesn't really taste like oatmeal, for better or worse (better for me, because I'm not a big oatmeal fan). I prefer the sticky rice-like consistency over a congee consistency.
Robyn Lee at 10:46AM on 01/28/09
Horrific! What have you done to my precious oatmeal?????
Lvn4life at 10:49AM on 01/28/09
I've read that any grain can be cooked and eaten like congee. Some day I might try this, but I'm not a big oats fan. Someday when I'm feeling adventurous, I'm going to try this oatmeal soup
IndyGal at 10:57AM on 01/28/09
I like mixing in kimchee, especially when it's gotten riper than I like it. It dulls some of the super acidic flavors. I've also added bacon before. Yum.
synaesthesia.dc at 11:03AM on 01/28/09
Why?
Why? Why? Why?
Deb07 at 11:11AM on 01/28/09
I've been doing the savoury oatmeal for a while:
http://flickr.com/photos/zorbs/416435147/
I add "yu soong" and Maggi sauce to mine. And a scoop of unflavoured protein powder.
Zorbs at 11:12AM on 01/28/09
Mind you, not why would SE cover this? It was pretty funny and I second the business card idea!
The bigger WHY?
Deb07 at 11:12AM on 01/28/09
My ex-boyfriend used to make this for me for breakfast, plus he would add a teaspoon of tahini. YUM!
LadyMarmalade at 11:15AM on 01/28/09
It's about time! My mom used to make savory oatmeal with tender pork tenderloin strips. It was always a good way to start a cold Minnesota morning. For a long time, I thought it was normal to eat savory oatmeal (with pork). I don't know if I would like the oatmeal with soy sauce and green onions alone. Growing up, I had a difficult time eating sweet oatmeal. Maple brown sugar... Blah!
kkernportland at 11:23AM on 01/28/09
It's crazy how big a shock to my system this idea is! I love oatmeal, and I love congee ... but this is like fantasy land. Like unicorns and griffins. I ate pig stomach and tofu skin soup on Monday, but this is more foreign. It's clearly time for a reset.
OneWallKitchen at 11:36AM on 01/28/09
wow, why did not I think of this? It seems like a great idea!!!
orchidgirl at 11:55AM on 01/28/09
Sounds like comfort food. I'd never think to make oatmeal savory but why not think beyond the usual?
CanadianFoodieGirl at 12:09PM on 01/28/09
I like to cook steal cut oats risotto-style, it is delicious and healthful. I assume you could do this with any liquid but i am particularly fond of the savory variations.
evemarcellus at 12:16PM on 01/28/09
And my husband thought I was weird. I love congee, but more often make oatmeat for my husband. I spice mine similarly to Bittman, but I add fish sauce instead of soy sauce and a bit of calamansi juice (like kamquat, lemony,lime), salt and pepper. Cheers!
catbird at 12:26PM on 01/28/09
Well darn, the link didn't work. Here's the link to the oatmeal soup:
http://strongwomen.com/recipes/recipe031_oatmealsoup.htm
IndyGal at 12:28PM on 01/28/09
I was just wondering about this very thing, since I'm not a big fan of sweet breakfast foods--blasphemy, i know. I suppose since grits and congee and kasha all work in a savory realm, this isn't that much of a stretch. I'm most curious about the texture. might have to try it!
The Mouse at 12:31PM on 01/28/09
Good stuff, but a common breakfast at our house.
This a.m. I had 10 Grain Cereal with a little sesame oil and Hoisin Sauce. I won't tell you what else I had on it. :-)
Anonimo at 12:37PM on 01/28/09
My wife, who is Greek, likes oatmeal made with milk and feta cheese. Once you get past that, this isn't so far out.
mwainer at 12:38PM on 01/28/09
Not really that bizarre when you think about it. I mentioned rice gruel in the SE post regarding gruel recently. Unadorned oatmeal/grain isn't particularly "sweet" or "savory." I hate brown rice, so I'll have to try this for myself to see if I would eat it again. I'd just ditch the scallions, add mustard cabbage and bamboo shoots, and dashi instead of shoyu.
Cassaendra at 12:55PM on 01/28/09
I'll pass.
mhurst826 at 1:03PM on 01/28/09
I would add a poached egg.
Michele Humes at 1:14PM on 01/28/09
I have yet to try soy sauce, but when I don't want a traditional breakfasty oatmeal, I add dashi to the water when I cook the oatmeal to give it more of a savory flavor. After it's cooked, I'll add a bit of miso paste, some greens and a poached egg. I feel like you can get away with whatever savory mix-ins anyway -- I've put in chicken, Chinese sausage, etc. I think the breakfast association makes people balk at it at first, but as someone said earlier, it's really no different from gruel.
Emily Koh at 1:32PM on 01/28/09
Gonna try this recipe - except I'm gonna cook it up and add more water and mix it it with preserved eggs and salt instead od soy sauce. Yes - Im congee on this
ll2014 at 2:15PM on 01/28/09
I have to admit this made my gag reflex burst into hyperdrive at first read. After considering all the comments, I am truly amazed at the amount of people who have eaten their oatmeal prepared in a savory way. As adventurous an eater as I am, it has never been something I've even remotely considered. I am not sure that I am ready for this. It just seems wrong to me.
juliebugsmama at 2:30PM on 01/28/09
I am laughing that this is so shocking to people. I used to always salt my oatmeal, since I prefer salty to sweet, and one day, as a child I complained to my mother that we were out of salt and she being a resourceful person immediately said "add soy sauce, it is basically just salt" and it was delicious. And I've eaten it and cream of wheat and any number of other things that way since!
dagoose at 3:15PM on 01/28/09
Savory oatmeal is great. Mixed with bacon fat, seasoned salt, onions and a fried egg, it is bliss.
JungMan at 3:18PM on 01/28/09
for those of you on the fence, simply try plain oatmeal with some salt. it's amazing
alexeatsworld at 3:26PM on 01/28/09
I could see adding an egg being ok, but don't try to convince me that you could add chicken or steak... Oatmeal is really meant to be sweet or slightly savory but don't kill the idea
NewEnglandFoodie at 3:41PM on 01/28/09
It looks just slightly more appetizing than some of the stuff Andrew Zimmern eats.
dmcavanagh at 3:45PM on 01/28/09
soooooooooooooo... is it good? no one has really answered that question...
spartana07 at 5:19PM on 01/28/09
Interesting. A couple of months ago, I had the same "brilliant" idea to make savory oatmeal when I was starving and unwilling to spend money. I used bacon salt.
The result was repulsive. So this is making me shudder right now. D:
Pammeh at 5:32PM on 01/28/09
nm just made it. i didnt care for the raw scallions as garnish.
pretty good but not as good as oatmeal with dried fruit and honey.
spartana07 at 5:43PM on 01/28/09
jacques pepin actually has a recipe for oatmeal soup with bacon and leeks in his autobiography, "The Apprentice." it's delicious.
it depends what you like, i love savory food for breakfast... its the thought of chocolate (pancakes, muffins) in my day-starter that makes me gag.
mycherrypie at 9:39PM on 01/28/09
I've made this a couple times, though I usually add a little sesame oil too. It's great! You can sub shredded nori for the scallions, if you want.
My dad, a Mediterranean through and through, likes olive oil, cracked pepper, and shaved parmesan. Sometimes rosemary. YUM.
piccola at 10:08PM on 01/28/09
... I really don't understand the revulsion here. I've been making savory oatmeal (peppers and onions are my go-tos) for years. It's a grain like any other grain, folks. Think of it as oat grits if it weirds you out (get it, oat grits / oat groats.. *sigh*).
Yrmencyn at 1:52AM on 01/29/09
Just made this. Seasoned the water with fat slices of ginger and whole garlic cloves. Used steel cut oats.
When it was done, fished out the ginger / garlic and added scallions and cubed tofu. Splashed on some really salty soy and must say that I was really happy. Not as tasty as khao tom, but better than most congee.
jdmcdonald at 12:27PM on 01/29/09
omg. my mom used to make this for me when i was growing up. but people always thought i was weird whenever i would mention 'soy sauce' and 'oatmeal' in the same sentence.
thank you mark bittman.
GLEE827 at 12:28PM on 01/29/09
This sounds very much like something I've made on occasion - I like a little protein with my oatmeal, so I sometimes include a scoop of TVP if I don't have any breakfast meat, and I prefer the steel cut oatmeal. Bob's Red Mill is here in Portland, so steel cut is available in most of our stores. My mother is Canadian (yup, my mother is an alien!), and they put Worcestershire sauce on their mac & cheese - it was a short leap to putting it on my oatmeal. Not all that different than using soy sauce and sesame oil. I've eaten this for both breakfast and lunch - the scallions are a great addition! Just one more proof, Bittman really has things figured out - he's innovating in the same direction as a lot of us. Just got his new book, Food Matters, it is really fascinating. This recipe is very much in keeping with his grains, beans, veges, and fruits emphasis in the book. We're looking forward to trying some of his recipes - they seem to be quite open-ended, allowing for substitutions of this or that - many recipes would be made differently by each cook.
renewbee at 2:40AM on 01/30/09
I hit upon savory oatmeal during my bento days (back when I had a job), when I was struggling with making onigiri; I invented "oat-nigiri" and ate them for breakfast. It involves making oatmeal thick enough to hold a spoon upright, and then squeezing it in those cute little molds. I did eat it savory sometimes, with a nice chiffonade of greens to go with those green onions. It's even better if you start by fermenting steel-cut oats overnight with a little yoghurt first; makes 'em tart.
I just discovered Bittman's How to Cook Everything, and I've been cooking out of it every night for a couple of weeks. I just bought my own copy. I'm figuring out what to serve with his Radish Salsa tomorrow. Carnitas, rice and leftover veg., I think.
gentlyferal at 4:07AM on 01/30/09
But what about all the TopChef savory oatmeal hoopla? Granted, most of them used oats as a coating for fried stuff, but oats are a traditional ingredient in sausage (especially certain blood sausages), and are just another grain. Maybe it's not appealing with soy sauce, but on a juicy pork cutlet or in a sage and mushroom grain pilaf, oats are great.
butterface at 11:21PM on 01/30/09
Here in Hong Kong congee is a local favorite - so much so that you really must be careful when you buy oatmeal at the supermarket... you see, Quaker Oats offers two special savory flavors of instant oatmeal packs here - Chicken & Mushroom and... Anchovy!! No kidding.
HK Expat at 5:27AM on 01/31/09
@renewbee -- does mac and cheese NEED more salt? :-)
susanova at 10:06AM on 02/02/09
Try the "Oatmeal and Tomato Soup" recipe at allrecipes.com. It's a a family favorite (Mom, Dad, and four teens). Not so pretty to look at, but very savory and delicious. Warming, filling, and comforting, not to mention cheap, easy and healthy.
thimblepie at 10:58AM on 02/02/09
Aren't those chopped leeks in the photos? And would you recommend eating them raw like that?
el_mitch at 1:56PM on 02/02/09
My wife is Japanese and never eats her oatmeal , farina , grits , rice [ of course ] or any other cooked cereal sweetened it's always savory no matter what time of day or night she has even got me in the program but having lived in S.E. Asia in rural communities my tastes are different now from how I was raised here in the U.S.
Just a small amount of various veggies mixed in can create a satisfying meal that is filling and healthy .
I bet a fluffy oatmeal would put a tasty spin on Nasi Campor in place of the rice , I'm gonna give it a go . I've never tried to fry oatmeal like the fried rice in Nasi Goreng wonder if it would hold up to the heat without mushing out ?
shipwreck at 2:42PM on 02/02/09
My mom owns a Chinese restaurant and puts egg drop soup in her oatmeal every morning when she gets to work.
achenglovesfood at 10:02AM on 02/03/09
Anyone who thinks Oalmeal is "neutral has had too many bowls of old, packaged oatmeal. Try Anson Mills; it'll open your eyes.
Jolivore at 2:00PM on 02/03/09
Wha? But...but... I (sputtersputter)...I don't understand. I'm staring at this picture and my brain is...lost.
I find the idea of savory oatmeal (I can't even believe I just typed that) so...weird.
But SO GOOD!
missbhavens at 5:35PM on 02/03/09
I don't know why people freak out about savory oatmeal... or savory breakfast, period. I hate sweet breakfasts, and have taken to making my steel-cut oats with salt and pepper. Delicious!
moondanz7 at 10:21AM on 02/04/09
HA! I love it! I was always the "wierd kid" because I liked my Cream of Wheat and Maypo (do they still make this?) with butter, salt and pepper instead of the traditional sugar and milk!
DancingShoes at 11:38AM on 02/04/09
I am down with the flu and yesterday wanted something warm but the idea of sweet put my stomach into twitters. I remembered this and tried it, with the addition of a few small cubes of a very savory pork and beef summer sausage for a little extra porky savory goodness and some frozen leeks.
It was delicious. I would eat it again, maybe with a few drops of sesame oil and a few sprigs of cilantro. Yum.
BananaMonkey at 1:31PM on 02/04/09
It all seems so...wrong. Oatmeal? My favorite breakfast food? SAVORY? I was surprised to see so many other foodies eat their oatmeal savory-style as well. I guess I'm more of a breakfast traditionalist in that way.
Well I can't say I'm not intrigued (especially with all of the positive comments), even though the thought of it makes me grimace just a tiny bit. I'll make it tomorrow for lunch. And put an egg on top.
avocadoboba at 11:58AM on 02/05/09
i've been doing this for years, courtesy of my Chinese dad. But, I would suggest making the oatmeal with chicken stock, not water, and garnishing with sesame oil, not soy. I'll usually eat it with classic chinese shihfan garnishes: shredded pork, spicy bamboo shoots, gluten with peanuts, etc. a nice whole-grain adaptation of a traditional chinese breakfast!
halvsie at 1:58PM on 02/05/09
I had it for breakfast a weekend or two ago and really enjoyed it. Bittman's always been a proponent of veggies for breakfast, utilizing different grains, etc. Not too far off from a traditional Japanese breakfast or congee.
rockchick at 3:06PM on 02/05/09
I like to use Cream of Wheat to make a savory South Indian breakfast dish called Upma. Heat oil and pop mustard seeds. Add onions, chopped chilis, ginger, raw peanuts, salt. Add water and bring to a boil, then add the cream of wheat, slowly stirring until desired consistency (You can follow the measures of water to cereal listed on the box.) Add a dollop of butter and a squeeze of lime and stir in. Can eat with Indian pickles like mango pickle or my new favorite--garlic pickle.
YUM.
inothernews at 12:51PM on 02/06/09
I've been using steel cut oats in soups for quite some time. I have a good spicy tomato, turkey & oat soup as well as a cabbage, oat & apple soup.
manatree at 8:17PM on 02/07/09
I wanted to ask Bittman and all of you who are doing this whether you prefer oatmeal to rice and, if so, why? Or do you eat savory oatmeal sometimes and other times rice congee? We returned from our first trip to Southeast Asia absolutely hooked on congee for breakfast, and regularly eat make the rice porridge with some combination of scallions, bits of meat, dried fish, dried shrimp, red pepper flakes, chili oil, and whatever else occurs to us. Are we missing something by eating rice rather than oats? Why mess with success? Are people like Bittman doing it for the taste, superior health benefits to rice, or what?
Lorenzo at 5:44PM on 02/09/09
@Lorenzo--I don't think anyone is knocking congee...but for me, who doesn't have a rice cooker, or much time/patience in the morning...I can knock this out with quick cook (not instant) oats in five minutes.
I have no idea how long a good rice porridge takes to set up...but I'm guessing it's a bit longer.
BananaMonkey at 5:31PM on 02/10/09
I made a version of this recipe using some leftover chinese "brown sauce" which had scallions in it, and was somewhat like soy sauce thickened by cornstarch but not too salty, I added a bit of butter and some garlic powder and it was delicious!!!
Definitely going to make this a lot more often, hopefully with the scallions though, and seriously considering making a pork roast just to add that wonderful meat to it.
iamon02 at 11:57AM on 03/09/09
I tried it and liked it a lot. My husband is very, very into sweet stuff, but I like savory stuff, including for breakfast. I don't understand the appeal of waking up to something very sweet
crden at 4:29PM on 04/05/09
I prepared oatmeal as directed (maybe a bit more salt) and served with tomato and avocado. A dash of hot sauce makde it super yum. Savory oatmeal has made me a happy girl.
isis28dayslater at 9:27AM on 04/09/09
My brother makes something similar to this (except he adds fish sauce) and swears it tastes arroz caldo, a Filipino soup.
pinkalicious at 4:20PM on 04/27/09
Oh my goodness. All I can say is...I can't believe I never thought of making oatmeal savory! I mean, I like it with fruit and such, but...I also know that it's good with even just a little butter. My brain never got past the "put more than butter on it" line. I can't wait to try some of the ideas you all have thrown out there. And I'm going to search for more savory recipes with oatmeal!!!
Sheene at 8:56AM on 05/12/09
I couldn't believe when I found this article....I've been doing this for years and just posted a savory oatmeal recipe: http://tinyurl.com/mybypg.
rovinglemon at 8:23AM on 06/01/09
I just tried this for the first time but I made it with chicken broth, minced onions, black beans and topped with sour cream....mmmm mmmm good
lildrehawk at 6:20PM on 07/09/09
I just found this Blog. Great ideas. I would skip the meats, bacon, regular sour cream, etc. since I am trying to lower my cholesterol. Thanks.
pattycake62 at 2:37PM on 09/22/09