Homemade Food Gifts for a Deliciously DIY Holiday Season

20161208-diy-gifts.jpg

[Photographs: Vicky Wasik, unless otherwise noted]

When it comes to holiday gifts, there's not much money can't buy...provided you have it in the first place. But if you're on a tight budget this season, a trip to the grocery store and a few hours in the kitchen can yield an impressive pile of presents for cheap. Homemade edible gifts aren't just easy on the wallet, though—they're heartwarming labors of love (or, at least, that's what your friends and family will think). If you have the right recipes in hand, they'll also be far more unique and delicious than their store-bought counterparts. And if you're the least bit crafty, a spool of ribbon and a session of hand-decorating labels can transform even the most ho-hum of condiments, like mayo or barbecue sauce, into charming packages.

Read on for our favorite easy-to-make, easy-to-gift crowd-pleasers, from rich chocolate truffles to creamy caramel to briny, punchy olive tapenade. For a more substantial presentation, just whip up a handful of these recipes in big batches, portion them out into Ball jars and cellophane bags, toss them in a tissue-paper-lined wicker basket, and let the gifting commence.

Sweet Gifts

Crisp Homemade Granola

Homemade granola is an ideal food gift—easy on the eyes, designed to be made in giant batches, and shelf-stable for up to six weeks. But all too often, granola recipes create jagged, overly sweetened oats that taste like a sad and stale crumbled cookie. For a lighter, crisper blend, we soak the grain base—a flavorful mixture of oats and flax, nutty-sweet wheat germ, and faintly floral and crunchy chia seeds—in buttermilk and melted butter. Toasting it low and slow builds caramel notes, while pumpkin seeds, almonds, pecans, dried apricots, dried cherries, and dried blueberries add complexity and textural interest to the mixture.

Get the recipe for Crisp Homemade Granola »

Oven-Dried Grapes (a.k.a. Raisins)

Okay, admittedly, "homemade raisins" may not sound like the most exciting of presents, but these plump, juicy specimens just might surprise you. Drying grapes in a very low oven preserves their fresh flavor and gives them a more tender texture—they'll be dry enough to store for several weeks, but far less hard and shriveled than their store-bought counterparts. Plus, this method allows you to mix and match grape varieties, for a more exciting range of color and flavor.

Get the recipe for Oven-Dried Grapes »

Cookie Butter

This stuff is bananas: a spread with the texture of peanut butter, but the flavor of a nutty-sweet speculoos cookie. For those of you who are addicted to Biscoff (or our DIY version of the Belgian classic), this one's a no-brainer. For that matter, it should be a no-brainer no matter who you are. Pack it up in jars, and keep it handy to spread on white bread, French toast, fresh fruit, or—gasp—MORE COOKIE.

Get the recipe for DIY Cookie Butter »

Toasted Sugar

20160329-roasted-sugar-vicky-wasik--1-3.jpg

It doesn't get much more budget-friendly than a recipe that calls for literally nothing beyond granulated sugar and a stint in the oven. Load up a baking dish with a few pounds of sugar, and let it toast at a low 300°F (150°C) for anywhere from two to five hours, stirring occasionally. The result is a richly caramel-flavored sugar with a subdued, more subtle sweetness. Your recipient can use it as a one-to-one substitute for plain sugar—it's key to our Perfect Swiss Meringue, but it'll play just as well in coffee or in their favorite batch of cookies.

Get the recipe for Toasted Sugar »

Fresh Lemon Syrup

Stop chucking your lemon rinds and start saving them up for a big batch of this brightly tart-sweet syrup. We toss the used rinds with about half their weight in sugar for a deeply flavorful, colorful extract—no juice, added flavorings, or dyes required. The resulting syrup bottles beautifully and lasts in the fridge for up to three months. It can be used as a mixer in any cocktail where a hint of citrus would be welcome, or added to an addictive batch of whipped cream. Don't have any leftover rinds? The same principle, applied to freshly cut whole lemons, will yield an electrifying batch of lemonade (and it works wonders with limes as well).

Get the recipe for Fresh Lemon Syrup »

Easy Caramel Sauce

20160822-caramel-vicky-wasik-6-thumb-1500xauto-434048.jpg

It takes just 20 minutes and a remarkably short ingredient list to pull together a batch of this silky homemade caramel. A quick simmer of water, sugar, and salt will get you most of the way there, but a cup of cream, a dash of vanilla extract, and an empty vanilla pod give it a smooth texture and complex flavor. Stop when it reaches a pale, honey-colored hue for a simpler, more straightforward sweetness, or keep simmering until it's a toastier amber shade to coax out a pleasantly bitter edge. You'll want to jar the caramel promptly, as it will thicken and stiffen as it cools. Though your recipient should use it within a month, chances are it'll go a lot faster than that.

Get the recipe for Easy Caramel Sauce »

Cajeta Casera (Homemade Goat's Milk "Caramel")

For something a little more nuanced and, well, gooier than your standard caramel, we turn to this twist on dulce de leche. In place of boiled cow's milk, cajeta casera embraces the tangy-rich, faintly funky flavor of goat's milk. One benefit is that the unique cooking properties of goat's milk allow for a relatively quick stint on the stovetop. The result is a deeply concentrated, intensely flavored topping perfectly suited to drizzling over ice cream, spreading over cakes, adding to cookies, and binge-eating straight from the jar.

Get the recipe for Cajeta Casera »

Chocolate Truffles

20161208-chocolate-truffles-vicky-wasik.jpg

If you don't mind getting your hands a little dirty slathered in chocolate, chocolate truffles are a surprisingly low-effort undertaking, with serious visual (and gustatory) appeal. The process is simple: Whip piping-hot heavy cream into a bowl of finely chopped dark chocolate, then whisk in some butter and, if you like, a splash of your favorite booze. When the mixture has firmed up in the fridge, just roll it into bite-size balls and coat them in powdered cocoa, ground nuts, or tempered chocolate. Our recipe makes a sizable batch, enough for at least a few small gift sets.

Get the recipe for Chocolate Truffles »

Cookies

Cookies are the OG of DIY gifts, and we have more than enough options for all your needs. From chewy chocolate-dipped coconut macaroons to the best chocolate chip cookies that science (and an insane level of obsessive passion) can produce, you'll find dozens of recipes on our holiday cookie page to get you started.

See all of our holiday cookie recipes »

Homemade Milk Duds

20160929-milk-duds-vicky-wasik-1-4.jpg

This recipe gets a tad messy, but the chewy, chocolaty, caramel-laden results are well worth it. Each caramel is hand-dipped in chocolate, for delicately thin shells with far greater complexity than those of the yellow-boxed originals.

Get the recipe for Homemade Milk Duds »

Savory Gifts

Chaat-Spiced Chex Mix

There's something for everyone in a classic batch of Chex Mix. But tossing it with some chaat masala is a great way to transform the crowd-pleasing snack into an extra-special gift. The South Asian spice blend is traditionally used to season chaat, a popular street food (and an excellent, if somewhat more involved and less shelf-stable, DIY gift unto itself). You may have to hunt around a bit to find all the ingredients, but the salty, tart, spicy combo is worth the effort—you could even dole out batches of the spice blend alone.

Get the recipe for Chaat-Spiced Chex Mix »

Marinated Goat Cheese

If you're especially short on time, or lack much confidence in the kitchen, this is the project for you. Buy fresh goat cheese, slice it into portion sizes (or roll it into balls), and marinate it in jars with olive oil, garlic, lemon zest, bay leaves, and thyme. In a matter of hours, that unassuming store-bought log will be infused with herbal, citrusy flavor—a major upgrade, with virtually no effort required. The cheese should be consumed within a week's time, so encourage your recipient to dig in sooner rather than later.

Get the recipe for Marinated Goat Cheese »

Homemade Pickles

Like marinated goat cheese, pickles are a low-effort, high-reward undertaking. But it's worth noting that one of the biggest factors here is time—you'll want to give yourself at least three weeks to let these babies ferment. Our Milwaukee-style cucumber pickles simmer with vinegar, sugar, and spices before they're packed up with garlic, onion, and dill to brine for several weeks. For a more sour pickle, try out some lacto-fermented dill pickles instead. A saltwater brine creates the ideal environment for lactobacillus bacteria. You can make half-sours in just three weeks' time, or commit to a longer fermentation period (about six weeks) if you'd prefer full-sours.

If your giftee isn't a fan of cukes, or if you're looking for a new project, homemade sauerkraut is a remarkably fun undertaking, and perfect for the sausage- or hot dog–lover in your life.

Read more about the science of pickling »

Rillettes

With their fancy French name and their fancy French flavor, rillettes will make your recipient feel fancy—and think you're fancy, too. In fact, the only thing that isn't fancy about rillettes is that they're incredibly easy to make (not that anyone else needs to know that). The spreadable hors d'oeuvre is made from shredded meat or seafood, and we have recipes for both pork- and salmon-based renditions. Both entail gently cooking the protein until tender, then mixing it with fat and aromatics until it's silky-smooth and insanely rich. It can be stored and gifted in small Ball jars, and makes a perfect addition to a cheese and meat platter, accompanied by cornichons and toast or crackers.

Get the recipes for Salmon Rillettes and Pork Rillettes »

Homemade Carr's-Style Crackers

20170227-homemade-carrs-whole-wheat-crackers-vicky-wasik-16.jpg

These whole wheat crackers are incredibly versatile—thin enough to go with dainty hors d'oeuvres, but hearty enough to snack on by themselves, and equally well suited to both sweet and savory accompaniments. They'd make a wonderful gift on their own—perhaps packaged in some cellophane—but they're also a great way to round out any of the homemade spreads and dips on this list, like rillettes, olive tapenade, or even cookie butter.

Get the recipe for Homemade Carr's-Style Crackers »

Spiced and Candied Nuts

20160225-candied-pistachios-vicky-wasik-9-thumb-1500xauto-430624.jpg

Seasoning nuts is a time-honored way of dressing up profoundly simple ingredients with fairly minimal effort. If you've made our lemon syrup and have some to spare, try using it in a batch of crispy citrus-candied pistachios. For something a bit less labor-intensive, though, we have a few easy combos to spice up the holiday season. Ground ginger and cayenne pepper add a savory kick to our Mexican Spiced Chocolate Pecans, bound in a light, crispy egg white coating. That same treatment gives our Smoky Candied Almonds their delicate shell, spiced with smoked paprika, cayenne, and punchy Old Bay. If you'd rather avoid the sweetness of candied nuts, our savory, briny, and herbal Olive-Rosemary Spiced Cashews should hit the spot.

Read more on our homemade spiced nut recipes »

Olive Tapenade

20151016-tapenade-vicky-wasik-15-thumb-1500xauto-427236.jpg

Tapenade, as most of us know it, is an olive-heavy purée, typically spiked with garlic, anchovies, and fresh herbs. But traditional tapenade, created by a chef in Marseille back in 1880, takes its name from the Provençal word for capers, tapeno, and it's flavored accordingly. With equal parts olives, capers, and fish (in our case, anchovies and tuna), it's briny and intense, and it gets further flavor from fresh herbs, Dijon mustard, and a splash of cognac. It's not for everyone—which is why we have a recipe for the more commonplace variety as well—but it's the kind of gift that's guaranteed to please and surprise more adventurous palates.

Get the recipe for Traditional Provençal Tapenade »

Better-Than-Store-Bought Mayo

20160815-mayonnaise-video-primary-3-thumb-1500xauto-433749.jpg

[Photograph: J. Kenji López-Alt]

Sure, most people already have a jar of mayo sitting in their fridge, but true mayonnaise connoisseurs will appreciate the substantial flavor improvements you can get from homemade. The traditional method, which calls for hand-whisking a slow drizzle of oil into a mixture of egg and mustard, takes some serious elbow grease and has a tendency to go awry. But if you have a hand blender, the process couldn't be easier—simply combine your ingredients in a jar and blend. Two minutes later, you'll have a rich, creamy, complex bowl of mayo. If that doesn't sound quite exciting enough to gift, stir in some sriracha or garlic for added punch.

Get the recipe for Foolproof Homemade Mayonnaise »

Homemade Garam Masala

20150402-garam-masala-thumb-1500xauto-430932.jpg

[Photograph: J. Kenji López-Alt]

The key to a truly nuanced, full-flavored spice blend is toasting fresh whole spices before grinding them—a step that most likely won't have gone into your average store-bought blend. With an aromatic mix of green cardamom pods, coriander seed, cumin, black peppercorns, cloves, fennel, cinnamon, anise, and nutmeg, garam masala is a bold, bright mix that can be used for a wide variety of curries, braises, and other Indian preparations...or just a soothing round of aromatherapy.

Get the recipe for Homemade Garam Masala »

Great Barbecue Sauce

[Photograph: Daniel Gritzer]

Some traditional varieties of barbecue sauce can be pretty time-consuming to prepare. But these three variations take just minutes to complete. All start with a base of ketchup and Worcestershire sauce, but they quickly diverge from there. Our Coffee-Ginger Barbecue Sauce is smoky and rich thanks to a touch of paprika, a little dark chocolate, and a drizzle of molasses; it's great for pairing with pork shoulder or brisket. For something more acidic and hot, give our Buffalo Barbecue Sauce a shot—with Frank's RedHot and butter, it's the perfect vinegary topping for wings, smoked chicken, or pulled pork. Funk-lovers will revel in this Korean Kimchi Barbecue Sauce, packed with the intense, tangy heat of kimchi and gochujang (Korean chili paste). We love it on grilled chicken, pork, and shellfish.

Read more on our homemade barbecue sauces »

DIY Cheez-Its

20160822-homemade-cheez-itz-vicky-wasik-15-thumb-1500xauto-434241.jpg

Fans of Cheez-Its will get a kick out of these homemade crackers, which deliver the same buttery, cheesy, utterly addictive crunch of the snacktime classic, but elevated with higher-quality ingredients and some TLC. To replicate the Cheez-It look, you can slice them with a fluted pastry wheel and use a skewer to add the signature center dimple. Alternatively, just grab a cookie cutter and go to town, stamping them out in any shape you'd like.

Get the recipe for DIY Cheez-Its »

Superior Sauces

Whether it's an Easy Italian-American Red Sauce or The Best Slow-Cooked Bolognese, a homemade pasta sauce is virtually guaranteed to taste better than whatever you'll find in a supermarket jar. No matter which recipe you choose, though, take the time to properly can it, or be sure to tell the recipient to use the sauce within a week or so. We doubt they'll have much trouble following through.

See all of our pasta sauce recipes »