A Hamburger Today

We Made a Thanksgiving Cherpumple, It Was Crazy


Remember earlier this year when we showed you our Thanksgiving Cherpumple? It was a little early to be thinking about Thanksgiving back then so we won't be offended if you paid no attention to it. Now might be a better time to show you this triple-layer-pie-embedded-in-a-cake monstrosity.

The Inspiration

A cake made of pies

What's a Cherpumple, you ask? It's something like the turduckens of desserts. First there was an original Cherpumple (yes there was a forefather Cherpumple who spawned derivative Cherpumples); it was comprised of three layers of pie—cherry, pumpkin, apple, hence the portmonteau name "cher-pump-le." Each of these pie layers was baked into a cake, and they were all stacked on top of each other. How do you... what the.. where is... Yes, all valid questions. See above for a visual.

But we took this concept to the next level. Why? Because we're crazy like that. And because the ladies of Food52 challenged us to a Cherpumple-Off, so we couldn't say no.


Sixteen hours of construction later, this is what Kenji came up with. Meet Sir Plumple, our Thanksgiving-inspired Cherpumple.

The Layers of Sir Plumple


Note: all of the pies within were double-crusted.

The Careful Stacking of Sir Plumple

Thanksgiving cherpumple

Stacking success

Mashed Potato Piping

Final piping

The Audience Ooohs and Aaaahs

Cherpumple audience

So You Want to Make a Thanksgiving Cherpumple?

We don't really recommend trying this at home. But in case you really-really-really want to, here are some recipes for possible pie and cake layers, depending on if you want to go sweet or savory.

Possible Pie Layers

Possible "Cake" Layers

Printed from http://www.seriouseats.com/2012/11/thanksgiving-cherpumple-crazy-pies-cakes.html

© Serious Eats