Mixed Review: Crate & Barrel's Butternut Squash & Apple Soup

20111016-174817-butternut-squash-and-apple-soup-1.jpg

[Photo: Lucy Baker]

A hearty, creamy bowl of soup makes a great cold weather meal. This mix--made entirely of freeze-dried and powdered ingredients--promised to be a "rich fall harvest blend of squash, apple and pumpkin with a touch of brown sugar." Could it pack any real vegetable flavor without any fresh vegetables?

Over the years I've been writing this column, I've reviewed many Crate & Barrel mixes, and enjoyed most of them. Perhaps the biggest exception was their Pumpkin Chowder mix, which I reviewed in 2009 and found underwhelming: "The instructions said to season the soup to taste, but this was ridiculous. I must have dumped a whole tablespoon of salt and several teaspoons of pepper before it was palatable." Two years later, I was curious--would this new soup mix be any better?

The package of mix ($7.95) consisted of layers of powdered butternut squash, pumpkin, sweet potato, and dehydrated apple. Additional ingredients included brown sugar, parboiled rice, toasted onion, and curry. To prepare the soup, I brought four cups of chicken stock and one cup of water to a simmer. I added the mix and simmered everything for 25 minutes. When the apple chunks were tender, I pureed the soup with an immersion blender and stirred in one cup of milk. I appreciated how quickly this soup came together (in under 40 minutes from start to finish). It's definitely the sort of thing I would prepare on a chilly, dark weekday evening.

Unfortunately my praise ends there. Like the pumpkin chowder two years ago, I found this soup to be exceedingly bland. It had a processed, dull vegetable taste, like cheap canned soup, and the curry was muted and completely lacking in heat. Again, I found myself aggressively seasoning the soup with salt and pepper in order to give it flavor. In a blind taste test, I'm not sure if I would be able to identify any of the key ingredients. In the end, I would not recommend this mix. You're far better off taking the time to make soup from scratch. Try this easy recipe for Roasted Butternut Squash Soup.

Lucy Baker is a food writer and the author of The Boozy Baker: 75 Recipes for Spirited Sweets. She is currently at work on a second book about homemade food gifts. She lives in Brooklyn with her husband and dachshund.

Serious Eats Newsletters

Keep up with our latest recipes, tips, techniques and where to eat!

Comments

Comments can take up to a minute to appear - please be patient!

Previewing your comment: