Gallery: 28 Cookie Recipes from the Serious Eats Cookie Swap

Double-Chocolate Cranberry Oatmeal Cookies
Double-Chocolate Cranberry Oatmeal Cookies
"The recipe is adapted from this Epicurious one for Triple-Chocolate Cranberry Oatmeal Cookies. My version is Double-Chocolate Cranberry Oatmeal Cookies (I left out the white chocolate chips and skipped the chocolate drizzle on top). I also doubled the salt. I chose this recipe because I love cranberries and oats, and everyone else loves chocolate." Alaina Browne, SE general manager

Get the recipe here »

Alexis Stewart's Brown-Sugar Chocolate Chip Cookies
Alexis Stewart's Brown-Sugar Chocolate Chip Cookies
I was dreading the cookie swap. A room full of foodos with the mandate to produce homemade baked goods? Yeah, like that's not a recipe for a serious pissing match. My secret weapon? Alexis Stewart's Brown-Sugar Chocolate Chip Cookies. Yeah, Martha's daughter Alexis.

If you follow Alexis's blog, you know she's serious about baking, and has been for a while. She developed these cookies when she was 12 — I think I read somewhere that they were an attempt to win her mother's approval. No small feat that. Did it work? Well, I've also read in various places that these are Martha's favorite cookies. And if they're good enough for Marty, I figured they'd be good enough for the folks here at HQ.

I'm not one to toot my own horn, but I pretty much had to scramble to salvage a couple of my own cookies. What's the appeal? Um, how 'bout a POUND OF BUTTER and THREE CUPS OF SUGAR? Approval never tasted so rich ... and chewy ... and crisp. Adam Kuban, SE editor

Get the recipe here »

Mice Cookies
Mice Cookies
"I didn't get the licorice tails (too lazy) and substituted vanilla extract for almond because I prefer vanilla. I made them because they were TOO CUTE not to make!!! :D"Christine Tsai, SE web developer and fabulous Cookie Swap photographer

Get the recipe here »

Gingerbread Dumplings
Gingerbread Dumplings
Since Cookie Swap eve fell on the same night as our prime rib tasting, my baking time was limited. I didn't get home until after 11 p.m. and, gulp, I did it. I used a mix. The horror! But..nobody seemed to notice because they were Dumpling-shaped. [Note: I did make the cookie cutter shape from scratch.]

Nobody even really asked about the recipe though, except our intern Carly who picked up on the nutty, spelt-like texture. I used Hodgson Mill's whole wheat gingerbread mix. They came out, fittingly enough, a dog biscuit texture. They weren't anything to write home about but, bottom line again, Dumpling-shaped!

The color was off—he's more of a sandy shade, not this dark molasses-brown—but they accurately portrayed his occasional lazy eye (with off-centered chocolate chips), and floppy ears (some featuring his famous one-ear-up-one-ear-down phase of yore). Erin Zimmer, SE editor

Toffee Bars
Toffee Bars
"Another recipe borrowed from my mom. When she was growing up in Minnesota, her neighbor used to bake these every year for Christmas." Rachel Heise Bolten, SE intern

Get the recipe here »

Chocolate Crinkles
Chocolate Crinkles
"When I was home for Thanksgiving, I copied down a bunch of my mom's cookie recipes. These are one of my sister's favorites." Rachel Heise Bolten, SE intern

Get the recipe here »

Swedish Christmas Cookies
Swedish Christmas Cookies
"Another recipe borrowed from my mom, this one dating back to her childhood. I'm not sure what makes these cookies 'Swedish.'" Rachel Heise Bolten, SE intern

Get the recipe here »

Cranberry Shortbread
Cranberry Shortbread
"My version of Martha's Cranberry Shortbread - my sister in law, Meredith, made these and they are now my favorite holiday cookies aside from my mom's sugar cookies. I added the white chocolate because I figured after failing 3 holidays in a row to properly melt this finicky chocolate that I was not going to let it defeat me and I finally got it right!" Erin Adamo, SE ad sales director

Get the recipe here »

Coconut Macaroons with Salted Caramel
Coconut Macaroons with Salted Caramel
"The cookie part of this recipe is very closely adapted from Joanne Chang's new Flour cookbook (the subtitle, "Spectacular Recipes from Boston's Flour Bakery and Cafe," is totally legit—the recipes are incredible and the bakery is too, as any Bostonian will attest!). At the bakery, Chang's version is mammoth—eating two is a challenge—so I prefer to make mine smaller. The Salted Caramel (based on a recipe from Food & Wine) was meant to replicate a particularly memorable flavor combo I'd tried recently, and is otherwise my own addition to what's an already fabulous recipe." Nikki Goldstein, SE Gadgets columnist

Get the recipe here »

Clinton Street Baking Company's Spiced Brookies
Clinton Street Baking Company's Spiced Brookies
"I am always looking for the perfect meeting of a brownie and a cookie, and this is it. Also, adding the spices made it taste like Abuelita brand Mexican hot chocolate." Carly Gilfoil, SE intern

Get the recipe here »

Jam Thumbprints
Jam Thumbprints
Baked by SE intern Hannah Smith-Drelich, SE intern. These are adapted from Martha Stewart Magazine Holiday Cookies 2010.

Get the recipe here »

Chocolate Eggnog Cookies
Chocolate Eggnog Cookies
"Mrs. Fields meets Stephin Merritt." Liz Clayton, SENY Coffee Chronicles columnist

Get the recipe here »

Egg Nog Fudge with White Chocolate and Walnuts
Egg Nog Fudge with White Chocolate and Walnuts
"This creamy, buttery fudge is flavored with vanilla and nutmeg and spiked up with bourbon and dark rum. Toasted walnuts add a bit of crunch. It tastes exactly like real eggnog, but in a condensed, bite-sized version." Lucy Baker, SE Edible DIY columnist

Get the recipe here »

Biscochitos
Biscochitos
"Biscochitos are a traditional New Mexican holiday cookie; a subtly porky confection made from lard, with anise seeds and brandy or rum. In December, biscochitos comprise maybe thirty percent of the diet of the average New Mexican." Chichi Wang, SE Nasty Bits columnist

Get the recipe here »

Spicy Gingerbread Cut-Outs
Spicy Gingerbread Cut-Outs
"Here's my recipe! It's now mine, as it's been adapted quite a bit. I picked it because nothing tastes more like the holidays than gingerbread to me, and I love decorating cookies. It's like a coloring book you can eat!" Laurel Randolph, SE ad sales

Get the recipe here »

Russian Tea Cakes
Russian Tea Cakes
These were baked by Natalie Podrazik, SE tech support and good pal.

Get the recipe here »

Traditional Jewish Mandelbrot (Mandel Bread)
Traditional Jewish Mandelbrot (Mandel Bread)
"Family recipes aren't as set in stone as we all like to think. Like for example, this mandel bread. I called my mom for the recipe, which I'd attributed to my Grandma Ruth, only to find out that my mom had started making Nick Malgieri's recipe years ago. So, here is our new family recipe for mandel bread. Thanks to Mom, Grandma, and Nick." Ben Fishner, SENY Apps Only columnist

Get the recipe here »

Spilt Whiskey Tollhouse Cookies
Spilt Whiskey Tollhouse Cookies
"This is the classic Tollhouse recipe, except some whiskey fell into the batter. Oops. Sometimes it also falls into my mouth." James Boo, SE barbecue columnist

Get the recipe here »

Ginger Spiced Molasses Sugar Cookies
Ginger Spiced Molasses Sugar Cookies
Baked by former SE intern Katie Quinn, who got the recipe from Food52.

Get the recipe here »

Mini Chocolate Peanut Butter Whoopie Pies
Mini Chocolate Peanut Butter Whoopie Pies
"I was going to make the Turtle Cookies from this same 2010 issue of a Cook's Illustrated, but the whoopies were much less work and seemed more festive. The peanut butter filling was inspired by my local Foodtown market, which for some appalling reason doesn't have marshmallow Fluff—the base for the filling in the original recipe." Liz Gutman, SE chocolate columnist

Get the recipe here »

Ginger Sandwich Cookies
Ginger Sandwich Cookies
"I loved the idea of sandwiching puckery lemon cream between classic gingersnap cookies. The recipe is from Food and Wine. I think using freshly grated ginger makes all the difference." Tressa Eaton, former SE intern

Get the recipe here »

Double Chocolate Icebox Cookies with Aji and Chipotle
Double Chocolate Icebox Cookies with Aji and Chipotle
"These are intense little cookies. They've got two forms of chocolate, two layers of chile, and a fair amount of salt." Max Falkowitz, SE Spice Hunting columnist

Get the recipe here »

Adapted Momofuku Compost Cookies
Adapted Momofuku Compost Cookies
"The original recipe is found here. I picked this because I like the original Momofuku cookie, and this recipe gets you the same cookie, but in a smaller doses."—Blondie of Blondie and Brownie

Get the recipe here »

Milk Chocolate Cookies with Ginger and Toffee
Milk Chocolate Cookies with Ginger and Toffee
Thick and Chewy Chocolate Chip Cookies
Thick and Chewy Chocolate Chip Cookies
"I like my cookies like I like my burgers: straight up." Matt Jacobs, FoSE

Get the recipe here »

Cinnamon Raisin Rugelach
Cinnamon Raisin Rugelach
"Back in 1996 I went to a rugelach making class at the Eldridge Street Synagogue led by Herb Schon, proprietor of Grandma's Recipe Rugelach. He told the story of how he started his business: when he was recuperating from a broken limb, some friends brought him some rugelach. He thought "my grandma used to make this - I wonder if I can find the recipe." He tracked down the recipe and made a batch, which he consumed in one sitting. He made another batch for his friends, who told him he should go into business baking rugelach, which is exactly what he did. The recipe reflects that his grandmother, who did all the family cooking, was relegated by her American-born daughters at Thanksgiving to making just a little something sweet. In addition to the traditional cinnamon, raisins and nuts, there is also whole-berry cranberry sauce, which was around at Thanksgiving and which cuts some of the sweetness. I use pecans rather than the traditional walnuts because my family in Texas used to grow pecans, and I think they make pretty much anything better." Christopher Stephens, Slice intern

Get the recipe here »

Spicy Pandan Cashew White Chocolate Cookies
Spicy Pandan Cashew White Chocolate Cookies
Baked by Krista Garcia, SENY Fast Food International columnist. They're adapted from PhamFatale.com

Get the recipe here »

Butterscotch Pistachio 'Cookies'
Butterscotch Pistachio 'Cookies'
"I basically used Irma, The joy of Cooking (1970s edition). I loosely used her butterscotch brownie recipe. My grandma on my dad's side, Grandma Surber, as we called her because my mom's was Grammy. My Grandma Surber raised eight children, so whipping up anything usually took her all of like five minutes. And the nice thing about Butterscotch Brownies or 'Blondies' is that she always had those ingredients in house, so no trip to the store was required. Whenever we were good, she'd pull them out of thin air. A nice glass of truck delivered milk and Grandma's Butterscotch Brownies. So, when I was thinking of cookies I thought I should do a tribute to her. Because I miss her. Especially around the holidays. I think that'll always be the case. She was my inspiration for heading into the kitchen and I'm always trying to fill her boots. I added some raw pistachios because I wanted to add another layer of caramel goodness and a bit of texture. I had them lying around, so in they went." —Wayne Surber (and Tracie Lee), FoSE

Get the recipe here »