Seriously Delicious Holiday Giveaway: Two Peter Luger Steaks
We actually have a few more gift packages to give away, so our Seriously Delicious Holiday Giveaway will run through January 6. Try your luck, and if you win, you'll be eating some crazy good food this new year.
Today we're giving away a package of two prime, dry-aged ("longer than four weeks") porterhouse steaks, thanks to the generous folks at Peter Luger. These steaks are not small. Each weighs more than two pounds. The steaks come with two bottles of Peter Luger steak sauce and a bag of chocolate coins. —Ed Levine
To win, just answer this in the comments below: What's your favorite cut of steak?
PS: If you just can't wait for this contest to be over and want to order steaks right now from Peter Luger, you may do so at peterluger.com. You will make any serious carnivores on your list very happy.
You have until 3 p.m. ET tomorrow (January 4) to enter. One winner will be chosen at random from among the commenters. Contest winners are limited to residents of the continental U.S., and you can only win once during the duration of the Seriously Delicious Holiday Giveaway contest. The standard Serious Eats contest rules apply.
Comments are closed: 1101 Comments:
Filet Mignon!
semarr at 3:10PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye
lavenhouse at 3:10PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse.
roxlet at 3:11PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse
gb944 at 3:11PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye
caramel at 3:14PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse.
dprice at 3:15PM on 01/03/09
skirt steak
tmbronk at 3:17PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye
velouria57 at 3:17PM on 01/03/09
new york strip
ruby182 at 3:18PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye for my husband, filet for me, then we share! Best of both worlds....
Jeana at 3:19PM on 01/03/09
new york strip steak
cupcakemuffin at 3:20PM on 01/03/09
porterhouse is soooo good
ssultan23 at 3:22PM on 01/03/09
Filet
sarahinnewyork at 3:23PM on 01/03/09
T-bone
foodiebuddha at 3:23PM on 01/03/09
Usually filet but today I feel like a porterhouse...
piepie at 3:24PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse.
hoya68 at 3:26PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye
Cary at 3:26PM on 01/03/09
ribeye..but a Peter Luger porterhouse could change that
kathyvegas at 3:28PM on 01/03/09
Right now, it's flank steak, lightly seared, sliced really thin and put on an amazing salad.
Sarajahii at 3:28PM on 01/03/09
I LOVE A FILET, MY HUSBAND, LEON, LOVES A PORTERHOUSE>>> BUT ANY GREAT STEAK FROM PETER LUGER WOULD BE PERFECT!
WHAT A GREAT CONTEST, YUMMMMMMMMMMM...
HAPPY NEW YEAR!
theflyingacc at 3:30PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse.
hold the mayo at 3:32PM on 01/03/09
New York strip! Thanks!
lillylilly at 3:32PM on 01/03/09
Filet mignon
finsbigfan at 3:33PM on 01/03/09
filet mignon- thanks!
illeatyou at 3:34PM on 01/03/09
Black&blue ribeye.
bessfour at 3:35PM on 01/03/09
Flatiron
greenfield at 3:35PM on 01/03/09
skirt steak for cooking at home, but when I'm out I love a perfectly seared rare filet.
tricia_m at 3:36PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse!!
Markbb at 3:39PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse.... Black and Blue...Please
vl327 at 3:42PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse
Kerosena at 3:44PM on 01/03/09
porterhouse.
cyberroo at 3:44PM on 01/03/09
Seriously, from Peter Luger? Whatever they want to serve me! Rare, please.
izatryt at 3:44PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye..mmmmmmm....meaty goodness
taoistpunk at 3:45PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse! Cooked in a cast iron skillet!
Quidnunc at 3:46PM on 01/03/09
filet mignon
unavaca at 3:46PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse from Luger! Pleeeasssseeee!!!
wadevice at 3:46PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse.
Philybe at 3:46PM on 01/03/09
ribeye
plantainsandkimchi at 3:47PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse :D
h3psibah at 3:47PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye and skirt steak
SEFB9118 at 3:48PM on 01/03/09
A porterhouse would be awesome!
cmballa at 3:48PM on 01/03/09
porterhouse
brooke29 at 3:48PM on 01/03/09
Since I am troubled with T.B. (Two Bellies!) I love all types of prime beef, espically the one's from Peter Luger, along with their world famous steak sauce.
BeachBumBob
Irvine, Calif
BeachBumBob at 3:48PM on 01/03/09
ribeye !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
pattyrose27 at 3:49PM on 01/03/09
Rib. Eye.
99paa at 3:50PM on 01/03/09
rib eye
danlevy at 3:51PM on 01/03/09
filet mignon
film_score at 3:51PM on 01/03/09
Bone-in Ribeye
pickled at 3:52PM on 01/03/09
porterhouse.
calamityjake at 3:52PM on 01/03/09
hanger
jasmall at 3:52PM on 01/03/09
Filet mignon!
miette at 3:56PM on 01/03/09
New York Strip!
jonfoxx at 3:56PM on 01/03/09
NY Strip!
dhorst at 3:58PM on 01/03/09
Filet. If you can get a foie gras + butter chapeaux on top of that, it's pretty much the best thing in the world. Nod to Dylan Prime.
zackola at 3:59PM on 01/03/09
RIBEYE!!
debiwelbon at 4:00PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse and/or marinated flank steak cooked rare.
kevlney at 4:00PM on 01/03/09
New York Strip
mnsteph at 4:00PM on 01/03/09
filet!
amywoz at 4:00PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse *drools*
freakdujour at 4:02PM on 01/03/09
New York Strip- Medium Rare
collegefoodie at 4:03PM on 01/03/09
Filet
*goodluckgoodluckgoodluckgoodluck*
chuckjustice at 4:03PM on 01/03/09
Filet mignon is my favorite
peaches41 at 4:03PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye
Bingo at 4:04PM on 01/03/09
Skirt.
Dan Dickinson at 4:04PM on 01/03/09
skirt steak. its amazingly delicious and cheap
hoff_83 at 4:05PM on 01/03/09
Sirloin for me.
ps9906 at 4:05PM on 01/03/09
porterhouse, thanks for the contest!
yrguide at 4:06PM on 01/03/09
A good rare Prime Rib will do me just fine.
armlam@bellsouth.net
AllenMcLeod at 4:07PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse if I can afford it. If not, a strip.
DanielJ at 4:07PM on 01/03/09
RIBEYE!!!!!!!!!!!!!
tgrabler at 4:07PM on 01/03/09
filet for hubby and prime rib for me
cherierj at 4:08PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse rocks my world.
cdziuba at 4:08PM on 01/03/09
T-bone
ariannajoy at 4:08PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye
sscoffee at 4:08PM on 01/03/09
Probably a ribeye for me.
geralynj at 4:08PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye for me!
tlcfromtn at 4:10PM on 01/03/09
Bone-in ribeye
kmitch218 at 4:12PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye is so fabulous
shellsok at 4:12PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye please, medium rare!
hungryinhouston at 4:12PM on 01/03/09
the whole cow
friedom at 4:13PM on 01/03/09
hanger
Joseph Bayot at 4:14PM on 01/03/09
Today, it's porterhouse because I was just remembering a time when my parents bought half a cow and a freezer. I didn't know how lucky I was, but I used to come home from work in the middle of the night and pull a steak out of the freezer. The porterhouse was huge, tender, and very tasty. While it was cooking, I would mix fresh salsa and sour cream into an ugly but very tasty sauce. Thanks for the offer!
geekbearinggifts at 4:14PM on 01/03/09
NY Strip
Sigismondo at 4:14PM on 01/03/09
kool keith, porterhousin' things
crapkatapult at 4:14PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye or hanger. Mmmmm, steak.
bettyjoan at 4:15PM on 01/03/09
Filet mignon - medium
poomy at 4:15PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye...... seared over charcoal for crunchy on the outside, and medium-rare on the inside
Tootsie at 4:15PM on 01/03/09
The aforementioned porterhouse
earlzy at 4:16PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse with flank as my second choice.
yankeesgal at 4:16PM on 01/03/09
New York Strip Steak, yumm!!
mariana at 4:16PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse....yum!
jrock at 4:17PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye.
shoneyjoe at 4:17PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye puh-leeze.
HungryDaruma at 4:18PM on 01/03/09
Fillet.
andysophiemom at 4:18PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye! Ribeye forever!
zumicroom at 4:18PM on 01/03/09
Nothing better than a ribeye
dwhogan at 4:19PM on 01/03/09
I love Prime Rib!
berwyn at 4:19PM on 01/03/09
new york strip!
Mavisr at 4:19PM on 01/03/09
Filet Mignon
pamatmayo at 4:20PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse.
dhl01 at 4:20PM on 01/03/09
grilled filet - Yum
page48 at 4:22PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse
wunami at 4:22PM on 01/03/09
My fave is Filet mignon
hulachicky at 4:22PM on 01/03/09
SIRLOIN
scottdavislasvegas at 4:23PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse.
annerska at 4:23PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye!
Jane917 at 4:24PM on 01/03/09
DH loves a good Porterhouse or T-Bone, me - ribeye all the way!
susitravl at 4:25PM on 01/03/09
I love hangar steak.
clgregor at 4:26PM on 01/03/09
Onglet - fun to say, delicious to eat!
dansch at 4:28PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse :)
Thank you for the yummy giveaway!!
fluegas5 at 4:28PM on 01/03/09
ribeye
feep at 4:30PM on 01/03/09
porterhouse! :D
teenagefoodie at 4:30PM on 01/03/09
ribeye
Thomas6 at 4:31PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye or strip.
bobcat at 4:33PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse for two...for me alone.
zelig1 at 4:33PM on 01/03/09
Top Sirloin..yum!
witchy64 at 4:34PM on 01/03/09
T-Bone
beanish at 4:34PM on 01/03/09
dry aged rib eye
brainpam at 4:36PM on 01/03/09
Medium rare.
If I have to choose, I'll say ribeye.
dbcurrie at 4:36PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse!
jennybento at 4:36PM on 01/03/09
ribeye
ramy kin at 4:36PM on 01/03/09
rib eye
toastworthy at 4:37PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse. Fillet on one side, NY Strip on the other.
Cloaked_Bert at 4:38PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye!
hmneilson at 4:40PM on 01/03/09
NY Strip
louiseb130 at 4:40PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye, nothing else comes close.
Lakeside at 4:40PM on 01/03/09
porterhouse
rebikah at 4:40PM on 01/03/09
I love all cuts of steak. I am a meat and potato gal. But I will say, my favorite is one not too many like. It's the 7 bone Chuck steak. It's fatty and greasy and really bad for you, but I love it, it always comes out so tender. I don't eat them often, but I thoroughly enjoy it when I do.
eyzofblu63 at 4:40PM on 01/03/09
Picking one seems highly unfair. As long as its medium rare I'm happy. Playing by the rules, I'll pick a tender piece of prime rib next to a filet mignon.
Lopro89 at 4:41PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye
puppychao at 4:43PM on 01/03/09
New York Strip. Mmmm
fuzzmanmatt at 4:43PM on 01/03/09
I'm a big fan of flap steak. Quick and tasty!
ifeelcrazy at 4:43PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye followed close by new York strip
Dgrgich at 4:44PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye's my fave.
slmiresse at 4:45PM on 01/03/09
Bone in NY strip
meanc at 4:45PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye!
texas_sweetie at 4:46PM on 01/03/09
aged porterhouse, yum....
bionicgrrl at 4:46PM on 01/03/09
ny strip
wirki999 at 4:47PM on 01/03/09
porterhouse
guterbni at 4:48PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye!
doehog at 4:48PM on 01/03/09
Kansas City Strip.
WOSSquee at 4:48PM on 01/03/09
I want quality over quantity: a dry aged Onglet! (hanger steak)
Sommelier at 4:48PM on 01/03/09
Potterhouse
washinbrig at 4:49PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse or New York Strip.
keeron at 4:49PM on 01/03/09
filet mignon
Noodler at 4:49PM on 01/03/09
ribeye when i can afford it
mverno at 4:49PM on 01/03/09
love porterhouse
makebelieve at 4:50PM on 01/03/09
porterhouse steak
jimbo36500 at 4:51PM on 01/03/09
ribeye
samsnana at 4:51PM on 01/03/09
New York strip.
Aisling at 4:52PM on 01/03/09
ribeye
dandylion at 4:52PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse. Rib eye. NY strip. On the rare side. Naked but for a grind of pepper. Now. Yum.
BobbieAnne at 4:54PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye if someone else is paying, Flank if it's me who is footing the bill.
mmclau28 at 4:55PM on 01/03/09
Rare t-bone, yum!
SueZeeQ at 4:57PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse.
sarash at 4:59PM on 01/03/09
Bone-in Ribeye...nothing else compares.
MikeL at 5:00PM on 01/03/09
I love Prime Rib
ooodaisymaeooo at 5:00PM on 01/03/09
ribeye
alice01 at 5:00PM on 01/03/09
ribeye, very,very rare
fstbkcuda at 5:01PM on 01/03/09
Give me a Porterhouse any day!!!
tutugirl at 5:01PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye
kylee5 at 5:01PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye
huntsvillewine at 5:02PM on 01/03/09
A 2" Ribeye, medium rare!
dixiesue at 5:03PM on 01/03/09
I'm a wicked carnivore, so am a little less fussy than some folks I know. I'd probably have to say Ribeye or Porterhouse are my faves basted with garlic butter. However, my two dogs are spoiled rotten, so I usually buy Porterhouse just so they can have the bones.
BruinsMom at 5:03PM on 01/03/09
Bone in ribeye... but come on were talking Peter Luger steaks here, any steak from there makes my mouth water.
achilles21 at 5:03PM on 01/03/09
My favorite cut of steak is a nice fat sirloin.
footballmom9412 at 5:04PM on 01/03/09
porterhouse!
chromiumman at 5:05PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse can't be beat!!
kohndr at 5:05PM on 01/03/09
Filet mignon
emvark at 5:06PM on 01/03/09
Nothing beats the taste of a ribeye to me...mmmmmmmmmmm
rita4120_ at 5:08PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye
IndyGal at 5:08PM on 01/03/09
Favorite = Porterhouse
FoodBoy at 5:08PM on 01/03/09
I'll have to go with filet mignon or prime rib
joni514 at 5:08PM on 01/03/09
ribeye
nmp164 at 5:09PM on 01/03/09
filet mignon
sarahbethe at 5:10PM on 01/03/09
My favorite steak is: NY Strip ~ Thanks!
bowlpatty at 5:10PM on 01/03/09
Filet Mignon
javal at 5:11PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse.
LindaY at 5:12PM on 01/03/09
New York Strip! medium well, marinated....
McKennaNY at 5:12PM on 01/03/09
New York Strip
thesixthguy at 5:14PM on 01/03/09
Filet for me
forkmtn at 5:15PM on 01/03/09
porterhouse
icecreamsandwich at 5:15PM on 01/03/09
NY STRIP!!!
rlic80 at 5:15PM on 01/03/09
skirt steak for me
alainakunin at 5:15PM on 01/03/09
Bone in ribeye or hanger.
ride&cook at 5:15PM on 01/03/09
porterhouse of course
fleww3 at 5:16PM on 01/03/09
Skirt steak. Mmmmm.
iahawk89 at 5:16PM on 01/03/09
Filet mignon!
Deep9x at 5:16PM on 01/03/09
t-bone
Eddie at 5:17PM on 01/03/09
Prime rib is my favorite cut.
TrayMona at 5:17PM on 01/03/09
If I'm cooking at home, I really like flank steak - I like to butterfly it, layer on some stuff, and roll it to roast. It keeps me amused to come up with new combinations. If I'm out, a good rare porterhouse, please.
Nicole214 at 5:18PM on 01/03/09
Filet Minion
eSusan at 5:19PM on 01/03/09
Hanger steak is my new favorite!! (Although I'll never pass up a filet mignon or good strip!)
epidemickittykat at 5:20PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye on the bone, 2" thick.
Oakland Aaron at 5:20PM on 01/03/09
Love my Rib-eyes.
phasbargen at 5:20PM on 01/03/09
I would usually say Ribeye, but the filet mignon we had for Christmas dinner would be hard to beat.
paints at 5:21PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse
vdeliz at 5:21PM on 01/03/09
Yay, flatiron!
BangieB at 5:22PM on 01/03/09
Filet Mignon
tdark27 at 5:24PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse
jeanilyne at 5:24PM on 01/03/09
Filet Mignon, but really, it's all good!
Jebbica at 5:24PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye (though I usually get skirt).
SanukTom at 5:24PM on 01/03/09
ribeye
mango at 5:24PM on 01/03/09
Well, I used to think it was a closer-to-rare med. rare NY strip, but I'd be willing to give a prime, dry-aged ("longer than four weeks") porterhouse a shot. And as I said last time, Monday *is* my birthday.
danguish at 5:24PM on 01/03/09
T-Bone!
crboyd at 5:24PM on 01/03/09
Mmmm. Porterhouse it is.
dcflyer at 5:27PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse!
jenx18 at 5:28PM on 01/03/09
prime rib
crackerfan at 5:28PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye!
chronarion at 5:29PM on 01/03/09
Give me a sirloin.
dusksunset at 5:29PM on 01/03/09
bone-in ribeye for me
CrashBangBoom at 5:29PM on 01/03/09
My favorite is ribeye. Thanks for the giveaway!
kport207 at gmail dot com
KPort207 at 5:30PM on 01/03/09
Filet mignon is my favorite! :)
Every time I come to serious eats I get soooo hungry. ;) Good thing I'm not on a diet. :)
:) Thank you for the wonderful giveaway! :)
tmim123 at 5:30PM on 01/03/09
center cut sirloin
carriesmom at 5:31PM on 01/03/09
I think,...Ribeye also....steak is always fun,...I can't recall having ever hated one...
steve123 at 5:32PM on 01/03/09
I like a bone in Rib-Eye - sort of like a prime rib steak!!
houdini at 5:32PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse--we share!
alliedash at 5:34PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse!
Great giveaway. Peter Luger is the best.
Buffs4837 at 5:34PM on 01/03/09
Boneless ribeye is my favorite and cut at least 1 inch thick.
seriouskgr at 5:34PM on 01/03/09
New York Strip
happygirl5432 at 5:35PM on 01/03/09
ribeye
madball911 at 5:35PM on 01/03/09
i like filet mignon! Hubby likes ribeye
bellows22 at 5:38PM on 01/03/09
porterhouse. thanks.
ephraim at 5:39PM on 01/03/09
ribeye
Dee at 5:39PM on 01/03/09
Filet
sua550 at 5:40PM on 01/03/09
Flank steak, if I'm cooking. Filet if a professional is!
sandler at 5:41PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye.
TheOtherLaura at 5:41PM on 01/03/09
ribeye!
robotbill at 5:41PM on 01/03/09
Prime Rib - thick with a bit of fat on it
hawaiijack at 5:42PM on 01/03/09
Filet.
HelloChris at 5:42PM on 01/03/09
Bone in ribeye!
jackiecat at 5:42PM on 01/03/09
filet mignon
MajaMeza79 at 5:43PM on 01/03/09
Filet Mignon
maggie0352 at 5:43PM on 01/03/09
I like a medium rare T-bone and then gnaw on the bone.
slehan at 5:44PM on 01/03/09
I usually buy a ribeye, but I have nothing against the porterhouse :)
jkampf at 5:44PM on 01/03/09
It matters not what kind of chocolate,
They all taste so good to me
So give me what ever you want to
And I will say "thanks" to thee.
slehan at 5:45PM on 01/03/09
NY Strip
sgrodnick at 5:45PM on 01/03/09
NY Strip
kitchenhacker at 5:47PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye
angela67p at 5:47PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye
aadams73 at 5:47PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye, the best!
flimsy at 5:50PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse, naturally.
cjstephens at 5:52PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse.
ejswanson at 5:52PM on 01/03/09
filet mignon!
someemptyfriend at 5:53PM on 01/03/09
good old T-bone
jffryclough at 5:54PM on 01/03/09
filet.
racklebelize at 5:54PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse
kathryne4 at 5:55PM on 01/03/09
ribeye! the tastiest armpit around!
timferlito at 5:55PM on 01/03/09
New York strip - no question!
Bunnee at 5:55PM on 01/03/09
New York steak
rkoenig at 5:58PM on 01/03/09
T-bone baby, yu-um!
teresajoc at 5:59PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye!
ajkdvm at 6:00PM on 01/03/09
New York Strip
kanopemainer at 6:02PM on 01/03/09
If the meat comes from Peter Luger then any cut would be great. What a wonderful way to start the new year. My own personal favorite is New York steak.
David
Dfree45185 at 6:03PM on 01/03/09
RIBEYE!!!!!!
nenieves at 6:04PM on 01/03/09
ribeye
lundysl at 6:07PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse!!
mom2anutball at 6:08PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye, please.
MarkDPelhamNY at 6:08PM on 01/03/09
New York Strip...closely followed by ribeye.
meliass at 6:08PM on 01/03/09
ribeye
nokrapt at 6:09PM on 01/03/09
My favorite is filet mignon.
sc2466 at 6:09PM on 01/03/09
Skirt or Flank...so tender and flavorful when done right!
But a Peter Lugar Porterhouse sounds fantastic!
sussnk at 6:09PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye is the bomb!!
timgeri at 6:10PM on 01/03/09
I adore a perfectly cooked sirloin at home, but when I'm out it's Ribeye for me!
Delinia at 6:10PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse has always been my favorite.
Traumajunky at 6:11PM on 01/03/09
rib-eye!
dettling05 at 6:11PM on 01/03/09
filet mignon!!
randio at 6:12PM on 01/03/09
porterhouse
9string at 6:12PM on 01/03/09
I love a filet, but my husband is hands down a porterhouse aficionado. When I mentioned this contest, he said, "I'd kill for this. Those steaks are legendary."
fauxrealtho at 6:13PM on 01/03/09
ribeye!
okclint at 6:13PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse
truenotes at 6:13PM on 01/03/09
Ditto on the filet with salad upthread (especially with Keller's mustard vinaigrette).
fauxrealtho at 6:14PM on 01/03/09
NY Strip. I want to eat a steak that tastes, smells and feels like steak. It's got to give my teeth a run for their money and satisfy the carnivorous craving that has me eating steak in the first place.
therealchiffonade at 6:14PM on 01/03/09
Grind it into a hamburger
jdettling at 6:14PM on 01/03/09
flat iron or ribeye cap...
deluxo at 6:18PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse
diesel51 at 6:19PM on 01/03/09
Mmmm. . .ribeye.
purplepassion126 at 6:20PM on 01/03/09
Filet or Flat Iron. Yum :)
rmalino2 at 6:21PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse of course, just don't overcook it, medium rare at most!
anyang at 6:21PM on 01/03/09
Anything ground into burger meat.
jvanhoy at 6:23PM on 01/03/09
Strip steak.
cochon at 6:23PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye
foodhuntress at 6:24PM on 01/03/09
New York steak everytime!
supalola at 6:24PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse
thepapaya at 6:25PM on 01/03/09
New York Strip!
JonsDad at 6:26PM on 01/03/09
New York Strip!
mmindlin at 6:27PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse, please, rare and perfectly salted. With butter.
pbyaeger at 6:27PM on 01/03/09
Oooooooooh! I guess my favorite is a medium rare New York strip, but I could make do with a big juicy porterhouse. Your website makes me drool!
flos49 at 6:28PM on 01/03/09
porterhouse
cadmar at 6:29PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse
mmiller at 6:30PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse, baby.
jaqqo at 6:31PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse.
joanne117 at 6:32PM on 01/03/09
Hanger steak. Skirt steak. Ribeye. All good.
mother91 at 6:32PM on 01/03/09
ribeye, yo
SteveB at 6:33PM on 01/03/09
Bacon-wrapped filet mignon, but if I'm looking for steak-y satisfaction, a 20oz+ porterhouse can't be beat.
EvilTimmy at 6:33PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse, please please rare!!
jinx35 at 6:33PM on 01/03/09
Filet Mignon, RARE
kfgoldshow at 6:35PM on 01/03/09
mmm...ribeye.
foresttracy at 6:36PM on 01/03/09
bone-in filet!
rovingfork at 6:38PM on 01/03/09
A rib steak (bone in, natch).
pixframe at 6:38PM on 01/03/09
Filet mignon, medium rare thank you! Although I'll take a porterhouse too :)
alanbar at 6:38PM on 01/03/09
A big T bone
mombert5 at 6:38PM on 01/03/09
T-bone
ratgirl1204 at 6:40PM on 01/03/09
New York strip.
flos49 at 6:42PM on 01/03/09
Beautiful rare ribeye.
spikefish at 6:43PM on 01/03/09
FILET ,MEDIUM RARE
lainie2285 at 6:43PM on 01/03/09
ribeye
sandy89 at 6:43PM on 01/03/09
Rib Eye - had one last night-melted in my mouth!
zina1017 at 6:44PM on 01/03/09
Filet Mignon
emial75 at 6:44PM on 01/03/09
ribeye
thumber at 6:44PM on 01/03/09
Thanks so much for this yummy giveaway. I love T-Bone and Porterhouse the best. Thanks.
peg42 at 6:45PM on 01/03/09
ribeye with bellpeppers,and mushrooms
shawn63 at 6:46PM on 01/03/09
rib eye
gsergio at 6:46PM on 01/03/09
New York Strip
DuncanHusky at 6:48PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse or Rib Eye, depending on the weather. Ahh, this contest is making me hungry.
premiumsqueezed at 6:50PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye suits me to a t-bone! OK, Ok, couldn't resist.
maningrida at 6:51PM on 01/03/09
delmonico, strip or prime rib all done med rare for sure!
tracirick at 6:51PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse please. Thanks.
pmintpat at 6:52PM on 01/03/09
outside cut - prime rib!
ddewald at 6:53PM on 01/03/09
Filet mignon
drew13000 at 6:54PM on 01/03/09
porterhouse
mhgatti at 6:55PM on 01/03/09
porter
kapnic at 6:56PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye - the best of fat and lean deliciousness mixed...mmmmmm
bookwormchef at 6:56PM on 01/03/09
It's still ribeye for me.
heaventrees at 6:57PM on 01/03/09
to tell the truth... I love them all.....depends on my mood. Can't beat a tbone.
brando30740 at 6:57PM on 01/03/09
NY Strip
calliope at 6:58PM on 01/03/09
filet mignon!
mazpink at 7:03PM on 01/03/09
Hanger steak
FMFats at 7:05PM on 01/03/09
I'm a total carnivore and steak is my meat of preference. I just love a really good prime rib med rare or a nice thick porterhouse also med rare. Just a bit more than rare and warm in the middle!!! MMMMMM
ImaDevlsh1 at 7:05PM on 01/03/09
bone in NY strip --- meduim rare
tender crumb at 7:05PM on 01/03/09
Filet, definitely.
brandi at 7:06PM on 01/03/09
NY Strip or Sirloin. My husband loves porterhouse. :)
ldunn at 7:06PM on 01/03/09
I love a good filet mignon
carcon at 7:07PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse.
masha339 at 7:07PM on 01/03/09
filet mignon
susan1215 at 7:11PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse, medium rare please!
jrwh72 at 7:12PM on 01/03/09
Bone in Rib Eye !!!!!!
winebill at 7:12PM on 01/03/09
Filet Mignon
zekks at 7:12PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye- rare and salty!
Nesie at 7:12PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye all the way.
n5rat at 7:13PM on 01/03/09
filet mignon for everyday, but PORTERHOUSE for celebrations!
Lynnharasym at 7:13PM on 01/03/09
N.Y. Strip Steak done rare!
casib69 at 7:14PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse, medium, medium. Dash of salt and baby 'bellas on the side.
sillygentilly at 7:14PM on 01/03/09
porterhouse
tracker at 7:14PM on 01/03/09
Filet Mignon.
TexasKevin at 7:17PM on 01/03/09
my favorite cut is a strip steak well done, I dont like any pink showing in my meat.. gotta be well done always
Thanks for the fantastic giveaway, and Happy New Year everyone!!!!
deb126 at 7:18PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye, but if money is tight and I can find it, chuck eye.
coffeesnob at 7:19PM on 01/03/09
Filet. wrapped in bacon.
steept at 7:19PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye
angelacisco at 7:20PM on 01/03/09
always always always the new york strip for my taste!
cosmic charlie at 7:21PM on 01/03/09
Filet Mignon of course!
stargazers at 7:22PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse
mrsbao at 7:23PM on 01/03/09
My favorite since I was 2 (so says my momma) has been the Filet Mignon.
dmmarklin at 7:24PM on 01/03/09
NY Strip
Marilouise at 7:24PM on 01/03/09
A nice thick T-Bone black on the outside and rare on the inside.
OH BABY OH...
Abart at 7:25PM on 01/03/09
rib eye
bfordy at 7:26PM on 01/03/09
Its the Ribeye from Fountain Prairie Farms cooked over a hot charcoal fire.
bostont at 7:31PM on 01/03/09
Skirt steak
delilahhhhh at 7:31PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse!
screename at 7:31PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye
MsHalo6 at 7:32PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse!
likaluca at 7:33PM on 01/03/09
I would normally say a ribeye when I am grilling, but...nah. Lets stick with ribeye.
Munklunk at 7:33PM on 01/03/09
ny strip steak
patang at 7:35PM on 01/03/09
Filet mignon
AmaHugs2 at 7:35PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse
cmp45 at 7:36PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye!!!!! (the only cut for me)
fangirl at 7:36PM on 01/03/09
Hands down, filet mignon, I order it when we go out just because it is always so good!
Thread at 7:37PM on 01/03/09
Oh gosh...do I have to pick just one?!?! Fine..Ribeye with a side of Filet Mignon.
hammondcheese at 7:39PM on 01/03/09
a 2 inch New York Strip
paryjeja at 7:41PM on 01/03/09
filter mignon, nothing better
gomercobs at 7:41PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye for sure!
tontek at 7:42PM on 01/03/09
Filet Mignon
dhsailboat at 7:42PM on 01/03/09
ny strip...charcoal grill
dhow1611 at 7:43PM on 01/03/09
ribeye!
missbean at 7:43PM on 01/03/09
skirt steak
dennisandluba at 7:46PM on 01/03/09
Filet Mignon
janmarkel at 7:47PM on 01/03/09
I love a good Porterhouse.
capwell at 7:48PM on 01/03/09
I think my favorite steak is a good, well-cooked sirloin. Tasty!
tuxedo51 at 7:49PM on 01/03/09
filet mignon
morgy at 7:49PM on 01/03/09
ribeye
radhikanayak at 7:49PM on 01/03/09
top sirloin wrapped in bacon
dianerph at 7:50PM on 01/03/09
ribeye!
fatbuddy at 7:50PM on 01/03/09
filet mignon is my favorite
rdazer at 7:50PM on 01/03/09
cow eyeballs. i've never had steak so maybe give me some to try?
sailordave at 7:52PM on 01/03/09
a thick Porterhouse!
phauxtoe at 7:53PM on 01/03/09
NY strip
jessleigh at 7:54PM on 01/03/09
A grilled NY Strip has my vote hands down!
conlar at 7:55PM on 01/03/09
Filet mignon
withfries2 at 7:55PM on 01/03/09
new york strip
cbroth at 7:57PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse.
kmg365 at 7:57PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse!
Xtreambar at 7:57PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse. Delicious.
hankantor at 7:58PM on 01/03/09
I like a Kansas City strip.
Reva Skie at 7:58PM on 01/03/09
Fillet Mignon
telcon at 7:59PM on 01/03/09
bone-in ribeye
paulaauerbach at 7:59PM on 01/03/09
it's still sirloin
shuffer at 8:01PM on 01/03/09
strip!
bajjmayer at 8:02PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse
dallan at 8:03PM on 01/03/09
porterhouse
burgerblurb at 8:03PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye - just like the one we got from the local butcher and grilled in Wisconsin winter for New Year's Eve!
Nezrite at 8:03PM on 01/03/09
its gotta be: filet mignon
Verhunny at 8:04PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse.
bhager at 8:05PM on 01/03/09
Sirloin
qwill at 8:06PM on 01/03/09
make mine ribeye
emkaye at 8:08PM on 01/03/09
Definately ribeye
carogonza at 8:09PM on 01/03/09
NY Strip, au poive once in a while.
beefneck at 8:10PM on 01/03/09
a nice slice of medium rare prime rib... mmmmmm
donut at 8:11PM on 01/03/09
I love ribeyes!
yellowlabs at 8:11PM on 01/03/09
Sirloin
bhjustice at 8:13PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse on the grille
peatheski at 8:15PM on 01/03/09
ribeye (bone in) or t-bone
skkip at 8:18PM on 01/03/09
Bone in ribeye, medium rare.
Rookiecook at 8:19PM on 01/03/09
Skirt steak, if I'm responsible for cooking it
Max Fischer at 8:21PM on 01/03/09
NY Strip!
malleycc at 8:21PM on 01/03/09
filet mignon
chaswade at 8:22PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye...Ohhhh yeaaahhhh....
ajdaddy at 8:23PM on 01/03/09
the best...filet mignon!
Fancy at 8:23PM on 01/03/09
Rib eye
catlulu at 8:23PM on 01/03/09
I love filet mignon, but the porterhouse steaks sound great.
arvard at 8:24PM on 01/03/09
filet mignon
bibliothecaire at 8:26PM on 01/03/09
porterhouse.
karen r at 8:30PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse, because I can never quite make up my mind which cuts the best. This way I get both! Tenderloin and T-bone
cornbella at 8:30PM on 01/03/09
rib eye. and i can't remember if i already entered this contest or not--im not trying to double dip.
maered at 8:34PM on 01/03/09
Flat iron steak marinated with Daddy Hinkle's.
jsnxrs3 at 8:38PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse...husband's favorite NYstrip. Thanks for the great contest.
elaine nan at 8:41PM on 01/03/09
ribeye
vhh12 at 8:42PM on 01/03/09
Filet Mignon please!
floridayaya at 8:43PM on 01/03/09
NY Strip
JudyZ at 8:43PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse
sappidus at 8:43PM on 01/03/09
I love Filet Mignon, Porterhouse or T-Bone cooked very rare! Yum!
Bunnybee at 8:45PM on 01/03/09
porterhouse for sureeeeee
skalobster11 at 8:45PM on 01/03/09
yum filet mignon. then again i love t-bone, porterhouse, steak, steak steak
teechbiz at 8:46PM on 01/03/09
I waffle between filet mignon and flank steak. Depends on what I'm cooking.
hautenegro at 8:47PM on 01/03/09
I actually just like flank steak, because I'm really cheap (broke) and I don't know much about steak anyway.
alicialynn at 8:47PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye (filet mignon runs a close second).
taterbug at 8:49PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse, well-done.
ladycat713 at 8:50PM on 01/03/09
ribeye
emgordo02 at 8:51PM on 01/03/09
NY Strip. Mmm.
leslie82 at 8:52PM on 01/03/09
Steak sandwich - a cut of medium rare prime rib, filet mignon, and porterhouse laced with glazed button mushrooms, onions, a splash of salt and delicious A-1 to top it off.
mjkopy at 8:53PM on 01/03/09
Porter House, Medium rare.
bongeezer at 8:53PM on 01/03/09
Bone-in New York Strip
pinoyeats at 8:54PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye!!
mammjamm18 at 8:55PM on 01/03/09
Rib eye is my favorite
Shakabaca at 8:56PM on 01/03/09
A well marbled ribeye.
pdxcardinal at 8:56PM on 01/03/09
New York Strip!
tara20639 at 8:56PM on 01/03/09
ribeye
grape juice at 8:58PM on 01/03/09
pretty much any
islandexile at 8:58PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse!
lychee at 8:58PM on 01/03/09
skirt steak - so easy, so good!
Curryinnohurry at 8:58PM on 01/03/09
I love filet mignon.
artmarcia at 8:59PM on 01/03/09
NY STRIP!! Love it, and now I am drooling.
SayWhat at 9:01PM on 01/03/09
Love porterhouse, Yum
strimble_25@comcast.net
steadier571 at 9:02PM on 01/03/09
ribeye... medium
smythbr at 9:03PM on 01/03/09
Big thick T-bone all the way
singermagic1 at 9:03PM on 01/03/09
New York Strip, baby!
mince at 9:07PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse or a thick thick t-bone.... hmmmmmm
wiicked at 9:08PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse, followed by bone-in ribeye. Thanks!
LBirk at 9:10PM on 01/03/09
In a restaurant, I would order a Fillet Mignon..but my favorite is any good steak on the BBQ...and not a gas bbq., btw.
jcamp2020 at 9:14PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye!
Juliezzz at 9:14PM on 01/03/09
Filet Mignon
jlsmei at 9:20PM on 01/03/09
Prime Rib has a taste all its own.
ballfan at 9:22PM on 01/03/09
rib eye! the best one our family has ever tasted. (cuchatta casino in louisiana)
alienangel at 9:25PM on 01/03/09
I am a porterhouse kinda girl!
alycep06 at 9:26PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse!
daveg227 at 9:27PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse
lvfordguy at 9:27PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse, with Peter Luger sauce.
I win!
secretwoid at 9:28PM on 01/03/09
ribeye!
NicMarie at 9:28PM on 01/03/09
Package of two prime, dry-aged porterhouse steaks from Peter Luger. That's my favorite
allancarol at 9:30PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye.
tawnjun at 9:31PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye for myself and New York Strip for hubby. With prime rib for both.
TES283 at 9:32PM on 01/03/09
ribeye
chrisv400 at 9:33PM on 01/03/09
ny strip
llinda29 at 9:34PM on 01/03/09
delmonico
blday50 at 9:35PM on 01/03/09
ribeye!
tessymay at 9:35PM on 01/03/09
Definitely Porterhouse! Delicious!
disbelief11 at 9:35PM on 01/03/09
New York Strip, medium rare please.
tony2x at 9:35PM on 01/03/09
wipe its butt
carve it up
put it on my plate!
hudpro at 9:36PM on 01/03/09
Though there is no beef cuts I would ever turn down, I find I buy more tri-tips, flank steaks, and skirt steaks or flap meat for the grill.
lamora at 9:37PM on 01/03/09
Tbone!
SharonZ at 9:38PM on 01/03/09
prime rib, please!
stevideter at 9:38PM on 01/03/09
New York Strip steak- black and blue.
deefine at 9:38PM on 01/03/09
bone-in ribeye, followed closely by the bone-in filet.
merk1013 at 9:41PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye...
mikepaul at 9:45PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye
metri8 at 9:46PM on 01/03/09
Why YES! DELISH!!
petesfriend at 9:49PM on 01/03/09
New York strip.
danwalk at 9:50PM on 01/03/09
Strip steak.
deenarae0 at 9:50PM on 01/03/09
Delmonico
stinkyfink at 9:51PM on 01/03/09
1. Fillet Mignon
2. Porterhouse
3. Prime Rib - yeah I know it is not considered a "steak"
all rare, cooked just until the inside is warm.
blmayberry at 9:52PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse. Accept no substitute.
jymbrittain at 9:53PM on 01/03/09
bone in new york strip.
CambridgeFoodie at 9:53PM on 01/03/09
filet mignon
spartana07 at 9:57PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse & rare prime rib!
PDXbiker at 9:57PM on 01/03/09
Filety Mignon!! Yum ;)
yoginimolly at 10:00PM on 01/03/09
Filet Mignon for me. Thanks for the yummy giveaway.
SeahorseLady at 10:04PM on 01/03/09
I love all cuts, but nothing beats a simply done medium rare porterhouse.
brittj8585 at 10:04PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse
Stephen Rushmore at 10:05PM on 01/03/09
My favorite cut of Steak was Filet Mignon, now it's Porterhouse. Thanks for the opportunity to enter the giveaway.
lfhpueblo at 10:05PM on 01/03/09
For now, NY Strip. I've never actually had a porterhouse but would love to try one.
lbellomy at 10:05PM on 01/03/09
Prime Rib End cut
mcnerd at 10:06PM on 01/03/09
filet mignon
ptreskovich at 10:07PM on 01/03/09
I love filet mignon.
dlguss at 10:07PM on 01/03/09
filet mignon is the one
loveis at 10:08PM on 01/03/09
Tbone....I'd like to try a porterhouse though.
barrbet at 10:08PM on 01/03/09
filet migon just can't afford it very often
phogle at 10:10PM on 01/03/09
filet mignon!
weebb33 at 10:13PM on 01/03/09
filet mignon...mmmm
firni at 10:16PM on 01/03/09
NY Strip
jlipof at 10:16PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse!
marilynnj52 at 10:18PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye.
umassfen at 10:21PM on 01/03/09
rib eye will do but the steak with the bone is even better!
creatrice at 10:22PM on 01/03/09
ribeye
simon at 10:22PM on 01/03/09
ribeye, medium rare
wizzy at 10:23PM on 01/03/09
filet
sstrudeau at 10:24PM on 01/03/09
Filet mignon. For a roast, I just love prime rib. But there aren't many cuts of beef I can't cook up royally and really enjoy! (Pot roast!)
Wanda at 10:25PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse, of course!
dgl440 at 10:25PM on 01/03/09
Oh so many, but I'm particularly fond of Prime Rib. But really, I love them all!
wrathofall at 10:26PM on 01/03/09
porterhouse
lily1129 at 10:26PM on 01/03/09
Sirloin, Porterhouse or rib-eye, I love them all!
lisargold at 10:27PM on 01/03/09
At home, skirt steak...but if we're out at a nice restaurant and want something a little more indulgent...porterhouse, ribeye, filet, ny strip - not much we'd turn down!
JessieLynn at 10:28PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse, medium rare finished with a squirt of lemon juice & olive oil.
chascates at 10:28PM on 01/03/09
NY strip
krunkymunky at 10:29PM on 01/03/09
porterhouse you bet
scooter7018 at 10:29PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse!!!
Gastro888 at 10:30PM on 01/03/09
T-bone
dolls123 at 10:30PM on 01/03/09
i love ny strip, it is so good!
JennVozik at 10:30PM on 01/03/09
Portehouse, ribeye, filet mignon-love all equally!
Roseann at 10:30PM on 01/03/09
KC Strip!
kristelh87 at 10:31PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse grilled on a Geo, Foreman grill.
memetu at 10:32PM on 01/03/09
NY strip makes me a happy girl!
pearl at 10:48PM on 01/03/09
ribeye
kvelchoff at 10:52PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye - yum!!!
fslavin at 10:53PM on 01/03/09
RIBEYE
cjopperman at 10:56PM on 01/03/09
flatiron or filet
feelgood at 10:57PM on 01/03/09
I love steak. My favorite would have to be the Porterhouse steak. Thanks!
iowamom at 10:58PM on 01/03/09
A well marbled bone in Rib Steak.
ppekpb at 11:00PM on 01/03/09
New York strip for me.
Gwenelle at 11:00PM on 01/03/09
Rare only, whether Porterhouse or Filet Mignon.
lyonsksl at 11:01PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse
nvtribefan at 11:06PM on 01/03/09
Born and raised in So. Cal. I don't know about Peter Luger Steaks. Sounds really special though. Rib eye and Filet are my Favs, But hubby likes Porterhouse. (so big!!)
stacemace at 11:06PM on 01/03/09
porterhouse medium rare with peter luger steak sauce, of course.
sandoramandora at 11:09PM on 01/03/09
The flat iron steak at Higgins in Portland, Oregon.
galeogirl at 11:10PM on 01/03/09
Filet Mignon
briguy2001 at 11:13PM on 01/03/09
Rib eye, without a doubt. Although I wouldn't say "No!" to any number of other steaks.
tmdonahue at 11:14PM on 01/03/09
ribeye
cgreggo at 11:14PM on 01/03/09
skirt, cheap and delicious!
samanthapayntr at 11:16PM on 01/03/09
primerib, thanks for the contest
fullmontecarlo at 11:16PM on 01/03/09
Ribeye.
gr0707 at 11:17PM on 01/03/09
prime rib, rare, a little horseradish
redfantum at 11:17PM on 01/03/09
Definitely a nice tender Filet Mignon!
marleenandlouie at 11:18PM on 01/03/09
My favorite cut of steak is a ribeye.
rrshep at 11:26PM on 01/03/09
I like Porterhouse.
janetfaye at 11:27PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse....Pittsburgh style! Blackened on the outside and still moo-ing on the inside.
JellyPA at 11:29PM on 01/03/09
Filet mignon
googy at 11:29PM on 01/03/09
Has to be the filet Mignon!
Amanda123 at 11:31PM on 01/03/09
T-bone
crashers525 at 11:33PM on 01/03/09
filet mignon
missm at 11:36PM on 01/03/09
Our most favorite cut of steak is either a thick cut Ribeye or a Delmonico.
Steak is also our favorite meal with a baked potato and salad.
I guess because we don't get to have it very often lol.
Thank you so much for all of the wonderful giveaways.
jsc123 at 11:36PM on 01/03/09
Love, Love , love tenderloin!
Rookiesmom at 11:37PM on 01/03/09
Filet Mignon, I love steak thanks for the giveaway.
fmd518 at 11:38PM on 01/03/09
porterhouse, yum
miamia at 11:40PM on 01/03/09
ribeye
nicknormile at 11:43PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse, which is just right for sharing.
Suzzanne at 11:45PM on 01/03/09
I really love any cut from the sirloin section, but I would seriously eat just about any cut from the cow.
Notamama at 11:46PM on 01/03/09
filet mignon. bonus if it's wrapped in bacon. nom nom nom
speare at 11:47PM on 01/03/09
can't beat a dry aged porterhouse
opjoec2 at 11:48PM on 01/03/09
About a 3/4 to 1 inch bone-in ribeye grilled over a hot fire.
It just get any better than that (especially if it comes from Peter Luger) !
Grifola frondosa at 11:48PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse, no question. I like a filet with bearnaise sauce, but I've never warmed to ribeyes. And NY Strips are just porterhouses without the fun part.
smithcraft at 11:51PM on 01/03/09
Definitely Filet Mignon! Haven't eaten it in years, way too dear these days. Happy New Year to you all!
beadbird at 11:54PM on 01/03/09
I gotta go with filet mignon.
darcybel at 11:54PM on 01/03/09
Porterhouse!!!! (Of course!)
Nick85204 at 11:56PM on 01/03/09
New York Strip. :)
ghostamongyou at 11:57PM on 01/03/09
Tbome!
tereza at 12:00AM on 01/04/09
t-bone
teancom at 12:00AM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse
BenNYC at 12:02AM on 01/04/09
Ribeye!
withgrace at 12:07AM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse, most def!
Teton2008 at 12:08AM on 01/04/09
Filet mignon :) *Thanks* for the giveaway!
MoonMaiden at 12:09AM on 01/04/09
My favorite is definitely the ribeye...In fact I might have one tomorrow for dinner!
kimepoo at 12:17AM on 01/04/09
New York strip
phathui5 at 12:19AM on 01/04/09
A QUALITY Porterhouse made up as a med rare black diamond!! HMMMM
Thanks so much for the giveaway.
twinkle at 12:19AM on 01/04/09
Ribeye is best-especially with marinated mushrooms!
gabrielj1 at 12:20AM on 01/04/09
I Love Ribeyes. Very rare. Just walk the cow through a warm room.
Sandy335 at 12:24AM on 01/04/09
I
lritz at 12:26AM on 01/04/09
Bone in ribeye grilled over a very hot fire!!!
blander at 12:28AM on 01/04/09
ribeye or skirtsteak
Peter Luger's is terrific!!
gorzd at 12:28AM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse.
miso at 12:30AM on 01/04/09
It varies with me, but right now I would love a ribeye.
Bakersdozen at 12:30AM on 01/04/09
Ribeye
madeas at 12:31AM on 01/04/09
filet:)
jchic45102 at 12:33AM on 01/04/09
Easy... ribeye
proncis at 12:39AM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse is our favorite steak.
mullin at 12:48AM on 01/04/09
I love a good filet!
nesta67 at 12:49AM on 01/04/09
oh I love a good ribeye!
ajd495 at 12:51AM on 01/04/09
r-i-b e-y-e!
gtrine at 12:58AM on 01/04/09
I LOOOOVE filet!
denyse at 12:59AM on 01/04/09
a big a.. porterhouse. medium.
qcjoe at 1:00AM on 01/04/09
shell
js1604 at 1:01AM on 01/04/09
ribeye
lleebooga at 1:04AM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse and bone-in ribeye
Pluff Mudder at 1:16AM on 01/04/09
My favorite cut of steak is a bone in Rib-eye, cooked rare.
Scoggdog at 1:16AM on 01/04/09
filet
coyote at 1:20AM on 01/04/09
Without question.... RIBEYE
TxBubba at 1:20AM on 01/04/09
My favorite hands down is "Hanger Steak". This was a difficult decision for me to decide whether I should enter this contest and comment because even though I want to win I also want to keep "Hanger Steak" a well kept secret for those of use who enjoy buying this relativly inexpensive but delicous cut of beef.
timothysliao at 1:21AM on 01/04/09
I love myself a juicy sirloin steak.
agsweeps at 1:22AM on 01/04/09
A ribeye steak would taste good right one. Thanks for having the contest!
brmetcalf at 1:28AM on 01/04/09
Filet paired with a large Lobster Tail for me ;)
tiglesia at 1:28AM on 01/04/09
I like T-Bone on the grill, but the wife prefers filet mignon seared in a cast-iron skillet and finished in the oven, so the filet is what I usually cook.
Remander at 1:31AM on 01/04/09
ribeye if forced to chose just one...
Domerskee at 1:31AM on 01/04/09
Bone-in Rib Eye FTW!
daryn at 1:32AM on 01/04/09
Filet Mignon
lisalmg25 at 1:37AM on 01/04/09
My favorite is filet mignon with mashed potatoes- yummy!!
autumnbride7 at 1:44AM on 01/04/09
I like a great big hairy ribeye with lots of moo left in it.
drmagazine at 1:47AM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse ever since a chef told me it's the best -- she was right. Before that, strip steak.
sito50 at 1:51AM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse. Thanks for the giveaway!
cmgnbox01 at 1:54AM on 01/04/09
Mmmm Strip Steak.....
chef17 at 1:54AM on 01/04/09
Ribeye!
pcrackenhead at 1:57AM on 01/04/09
A ribeye steak is my all time favorite!
laralin2266 at 2:00AM on 01/04/09
I'm a porterhouse kind of girl. ;)
jeni0816 at 2:03AM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse! Big and tasty!
kuromu at 2:06AM on 01/04/09
T-bone on the grill
littlebevi at 2:08AM on 01/04/09
My fave is a T-bone ...Yum!
cation at 2:21AM on 01/04/09
Mine is ribeye
puffpuff108 at 2:29AM on 01/04/09
prime rib
DudeLovesFood at 2:31AM on 01/04/09
RIBEYE!
Michael Z at 2:32AM on 01/04/09
Ribeye
jasminbaron at 2:39AM on 01/04/09
I love the rib eye.
amgconz at 2:43AM on 01/04/09
Ribeye or Porterhouse
Erinay77 at 2:44AM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse of course.
JustinP at 2:49AM on 01/04/09
Filet Mignon
Elkaye at 2:51AM on 01/04/09
It's pretty much a tie between porterhouse and center-cut ribeye.
AHR at 2:53AM on 01/04/09
New York!
ptash01 at 2:53AM on 01/04/09
When I have money? Ribeye, no question. But, I like a good flank steak when I'm nearing the end of my student loan money for the term!
honeybee413 at 2:55AM on 01/04/09
brisket
doozercries at 2:57AM on 01/04/09
spinalis dorsii
hanamaru at 3:01AM on 01/04/09
strip
Noodlez at 3:18AM on 01/04/09
filet!
frostrockr at 3:24AM on 01/04/09
A nice, thick, dry-aged Prime, bone-in ribeye. At least 24 ounces and two inches thick.
dan_hyphen_e at 3:28AM on 01/04/09
Ribeye
carol3023 at 3:42AM on 01/04/09
It's a tie between Porterhouse and Filet Mignon. Filet Mignon.
lunaocho at 3:45AM on 01/04/09
I love a bone in ribeye....one of the best cuts of steak ever
MMMmmm! It's great to be a carnivore!
kimblyl at 4:14AM on 01/04/09
A Ribeye of course!!
iguanablue at 4:15AM on 01/04/09
I 'll go with the Ribeye, grilled over an open flame, with grilled onions & peppers and potato's on the side.
brianpiero at 4:15AM on 01/04/09
porterhouse
pkreater at 4:29AM on 01/04/09
NY Strip. With butter.
dksbook at 4:37AM on 01/04/09
Rib Chop
akwok at 4:52AM on 01/04/09
T-Bone, yessss-s-s-!
rangrace at 5:24AM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse
sassy1 at 5:27AM on 01/04/09
Prime Rib as rare as it comes.
twinstar at 5:28AM on 01/04/09
t-bone
ben222 at 5:38AM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse
sdeas at 5:51AM on 01/04/09
filet mignon
intime at 5:55AM on 01/04/09
Ribeye is my favorite
rdoor at 6:06AM on 01/04/09
Prime rib, medium rare with au jus , sour cream & horseraddish sauce.
randycur0962 at 6:06AM on 01/04/09
Prime Rib...YUM!!!
mama43 at 6:14AM on 01/04/09
omgosh brisket..mmm.... ribeye. yum.
ababystarr at 6:16AM on 01/04/09
Ribeye
kskex5 at 6:25AM on 01/04/09
filet
silverbele at 6:26AM on 01/04/09
hanger steak
thepictsie at 6:45AM on 01/04/09
Filet Mignon
boover57 at 6:50AM on 01/04/09
I ♥ ribeye!
merrylee147 at 6:57AM on 01/04/09
porterhouse. please sir, i'd like some steaks
schmonsequences at 6:57AM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse too
katybug at 7:00AM on 01/04/09
I love a good sirloin!
blueviolet at 7:04AM on 01/04/09
Love me a good New York Strip
Griffvan at 7:05AM on 01/04/09
Filet Mignon
Devacat at 7:06AM on 01/04/09
My fave is Ribeye. Thanks!
mistyriver at 7:08AM on 01/04/09
Just like a poster said above, I'll take a flank at home and a porterhouse when I'm out. Glad I'm not the only weirdo.
jthirteentimes at 7:13AM on 01/04/09
Filet Mignon!
Faither at 7:13AM on 01/04/09
I like Filet Mignon.
clc408 at 7:15AM on 01/04/09
filet mignon, medium rare
jean8 at 7:16AM on 01/04/09
I love Filet Mignon. Thanks for the giveaway.
fairydancer at 7:18AM on 01/04/09
Filet - what up?!?
PhredYammers at 7:18AM on 01/04/09
Filet Mignon
idahomom at 7:24AM on 01/04/09
Ribeye all the way!
carolasar at 7:25AM on 01/04/09
T-bone
gschaefer at 7:29AM on 01/04/09
pOrTeR hOuSe FoR mE!
dsja761 at 7:31AM on 01/04/09
Sirloin
jword2001 at 7:34AM on 01/04/09
Filet Mignon
tchoughtby at 7:34AM on 01/04/09
Our favorite is Porterhouse; I get the filet section, Rod gets the Tbone section.
AsTheNight at 7:35AM on 01/04/09
prime rib
lsfish at 7:40AM on 01/04/09
sirloin
ladcraig at 7:41AM on 01/04/09
Ribeye
jilltonja at 7:43AM on 01/04/09
Filet Mignon!
ldrnc2000 at 7:46AM on 01/04/09
My favorite cut is a ribeye. Thanks for the contest.
suzieque810 at 7:47AM on 01/04/09
Bone in ribeye.
susanry at 7:51AM on 01/04/09
I have to say that I enjoy a filet mignon - but my guys inhale almost anything beef. This would be an awesome win :-)
mcferret at 7:52AM on 01/04/09
Only way to eat a steak is to order a tenderloin steak.
Teeeveee at 7:56AM on 01/04/09
NY strip
overw8 at 8:00AM on 01/04/09
ribeye
patramey at 8:04AM on 01/04/09
filet mignon
janew at 8:09AM on 01/04/09
ribeye
bettycd at 8:13AM on 01/04/09
a ribeye (am i supposed to say porterhouse? ; )
but i am a new fan of the flatiron steak as well!
mrshendu at 8:13AM on 01/04/09
porterhouse for two.
NikkiC at 8:14AM on 01/04/09
Beef Tenderloin and Filet Mignon
musicjess at 8:19AM on 01/04/09
New York Strip! Yum!
jerseygirl137 at 8:20AM on 01/04/09
filet mignon
oliverography at 8:21AM on 01/04/09
Filet Mignon has to be my favorite....
redsisme at 8:25AM on 01/04/09
Best of both worlds with a Porterhouse!
alaska4jamie at 8:26AM on 01/04/09
T-Bone
pamcallahan at 8:26AM on 01/04/09
definately prime rib
etrnlone at 8:26AM on 01/04/09
Filet mignon
Twipey at 8:28AM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse---to share with wife and friends...with a beautifully charred exterior and a medium rare interior, and rosy red juices flowing tenderly from pieces just begging to be eaten; lightly flavored with sea salt and a trace of freshly ground pepper, nothing more. Succulent aromas of carefully aged and properly handled prime meat..........Yummmmmm
mmatsunaga at 8:28AM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse--medium rare.
bobgoss at 8:28AM on 01/04/09
Strip steak
architeuthis at 8:29AM on 01/04/09
bone in ribeye
tulawdog76 at 8:29AM on 01/04/09
ribeye
bmcdonal6674 at 8:30AM on 01/04/09
T Bone
Quarryrat at 8:32AM on 01/04/09
Ribeye for sure! Yummy!
jonesies at 8:38AM on 01/04/09
I've always loved a good affordable club steak.
tfacey at 8:38AM on 01/04/09
Prime aged ribeye.
jmsmnz at 8:39AM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse is my favorite, but I am not known to turn down steak regardless of cut. If it's beef, I'm going to eat it.
DamnAvocado at 8:40AM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse.
ghinson at 8:41AM on 01/04/09
Fillet mignon!
MzDaisy135 at 8:42AM on 01/04/09
A filet mignon is my favoite!
muprofeng at 8:43AM on 01/04/09
Ribeye!
jako11 at 8:45AM on 01/04/09
prime rib is my alltime favorite cut---but steak, hmmmm...how do you narrow it down...I'd have to say rib eye!
plowlady at 8:47AM on 01/04/09
I'm another Filet Mignon girl
theamira at 8:47AM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse
JohnR34231 at 8:49AM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse, you get a little filet and a strip steak too!
gpops44 at 8:49AM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse!
alberttiii at 8:49AM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse.
Thanx for the contest.
kmbennet at 8:51AM on 01/04/09
NY Strip
jd7979 at 8:52AM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse! thanks so much for the contest!
karmakreme at 8:54AM on 01/04/09
I love a good flank steak!
Tarah716 at 8:56AM on 01/04/09
filet
fostertam at 8:58AM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse for a splurge, but Ribeye is what generally order the most!
Flank stakes and london broils are for cooking at home on a budget.
NancyA at 9:06AM on 01/04/09
Ribeye
Missjane at 9:12AM on 01/04/09
Filet mignon is my favorite! I splurge as I deserve it after many years of hard work!
pms3237 at 9:27AM on 01/04/09
Filet is my fave, but we're a family of carnivores, so any cut of beef is good for us
mkboldin at 9:28AM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse is my favorite
abfantom at 9:28AM on 01/04/09
I like T-Bone steak.
asketcher2 at 9:29AM on 01/04/09
t-bone
chino3pr at 9:31AM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse please
rolledspleen at 9:34AM on 01/04/09
filet mignon
ds605 at 9:35AM on 01/04/09
I do love a good Porterhouse. Thanks!
dglitter at 9:36AM on 01/04/09
drfinately, a porterhouse!
vlmolina at 9:37AM on 01/04/09
T-bone!
maxineu at 9:38AM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse
garrettsambo at 9:40AM on 01/04/09
I love filet mignon and Ribeye!
ksbeav at 9:44AM on 01/04/09
Ribeye is my favorite!
misaacmom at 9:46AM on 01/04/09
Rib Steak
andee506 at 9:47AM on 01/04/09
ribeye!
tendency at 9:49AM on 01/04/09
Ny Strip
shnickyy at 9:49AM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse, please!
MadameTart at 9:52AM on 01/04/09
Ribeye!
Cookee at 9:56AM on 01/04/09
Prime rib
clynsg at 9:57AM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse or Ribeye, love them both equally
Klontra at 9:58AM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse, rare to mid-rare. Duh.
cuisson at 9:58AM on 01/04/09
prime rib
helcho at 10:00AM on 01/04/09
Filet Mignon, of course!
timberlea at 10:01AM on 01/04/09
There's nothing like a lip-smackin' ribeye steak!! Thank you for the contest!
txgigggles@yahoo.com
txgiggles45 at 10:02AM on 01/04/09
DRY AGED Porterhouse!
dove1960 at 10:04AM on 01/04/09
I prefer filet mignon but any BEEF is great when cooked right. Especially if it is a good cut to begin with.
geneveve2 {at} gmail {dot} com
geneveve2 at 10:07AM on 01/04/09
Ribeye
karree at 10:09AM on 01/04/09
I love ribeye steaks, but I would love to try the Luger porterhouse steaks. They sound awesome.
Cindy at 10:11AM on 01/04/09
porterhouse!
brianru at 10:11AM on 01/04/09
porterhouse
danimal898 at 10:13AM on 01/04/09
a nicely grilled very thin sliced flank
gervitsd at 10:14AM on 01/04/09
My favorite is ribeye
Joyce424 at 10:15AM on 01/04/09
T-BONE
ROBYN853 at 10:15AM on 01/04/09
you people are mostly crazy, not that I would turn down these steaks. My pick is brisket.
canonizer at 10:17AM on 01/04/09
tenderloin
nancy1 at 10:17AM on 01/04/09
For special occasions, porterhouse, for everyday, flank steak.
edeliz at 10:22AM on 01/04/09
Ribeye
bramy010105 at 10:24AM on 01/04/09
Rare Ribeye! Pass the garlic salt!
hondaray6 at 10:24AM on 01/04/09
T-Bone
sonyasparks at 10:25AM on 01/04/09
sirloin strip
derekt1 at 10:28AM on 01/04/09
Kansas City Strip!
oldsalt at 10:28AM on 01/04/09
filet mignon with seared foie gras....what else is there?
castor_de_luxe at 10:28AM on 01/04/09
I love flat iron steaks.
HSlater351 at 10:29AM on 01/04/09
New York Strip
toughturtles at 10:30AM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse, with a rib-eye a close second
avman at 10:30AM on 01/04/09
New York Strip Thanks for the great giveaway!
silanti at 10:31AM on 01/04/09
flank steak on the grill, smothered in mushrooms
chuchubi at 10:38AM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse pleases the three of us: strip for Big Guy, filet for me, and the bone for our chihuahua. Rare, ... very rare, please.
caseydecuervito at 10:38AM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse by far!
pcoop1 at 10:39AM on 01/04/09
ribeye!
masscb at 10:39AM on 01/04/09
Filet Mignon! Yum!
divaqueenie at 10:40AM on 01/04/09
Ribeye!
reginalewis7 at 10:41AM on 01/04/09
Ribeye please
kalajo at 10:42AM on 01/04/09
filet mignon and don't forget the onion rings.
tweetie at 10:44AM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse.
murphykatt at 10:48AM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse has always been my favorite. A side of sauteed mushrooms and I'm in heaven.
dddiva at 10:50AM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse from Peter Luger's is the perfect steak and my favorite
harstark at 10:51AM on 01/04/09
Ribeye with a pat of sun-dried tomato compound butter
chanterelle at 10:52AM on 01/04/09
HEB carries bacon wrapped filets in two and four packs (I think the HEB brand is much better than the HCF brand). I marinade for abount a half hour in some balsamic vinagar with fresh ground pepper and sea salt (go easy on the salt), and add some Adam's roasted garlic bits. I throw these on the gas grill, a crime here in Texas, for about ten minutes a side using indirect heat, and then with low direct heat for about four minutes a side--just until the edges of the bacon start to burn. They melt in your mouth!
chicohog at 10:52AM on 01/04/09
Filet mignon!
fshapiro at 10:53AM on 01/04/09
Ribeye
amylou61 at 10:53AM on 01/04/09
Filet Mignon mmmmmmmmmmm!
zolysr at 11:00AM on 01/04/09
I think Ribeye is the most tender cut of meat. Love it pan seared. Yummy! Think I'll go cook one up now.......
sweepster49 at 11:02AM on 01/04/09
Ribeye, definitely.
silvermike at 11:02AM on 01/04/09
I'm a Porterhouse kinda guy! Thanks for the 'great' giveaway offering and Happy Holidays!
leandrew39 at 11:04AM on 01/04/09
Ribeye
bagstac at 11:05AM on 01/04/09
No question. Filet mignon.
jlg513 at 11:09AM on 01/04/09
ribeye
janenyc at 11:11AM on 01/04/09
ribeye!
janenyc at 11:12AM on 01/04/09
ribeye no doubt
gambler72 at 11:15AM on 01/04/09
porterhouse
Cozmo at 11:16AM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse!
caseycupcake at 11:16AM on 01/04/09
porterhouse
candl417 at 11:18AM on 01/04/09
Ribeye
johnsole2222 at 11:20AM on 01/04/09
porterhouse
piehole at 11:23AM on 01/04/09
filet
leeann777 at 11:24AM on 01/04/09
RIBEYE
whitbord at 11:25AM on 01/04/09
Filet mignon, pan seared on each side, and finished off to a medium well. I know some folks think this ruins it, but when it's done correctly, it's still juicy!
maryte at 11:27AM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse
rsadowsky at 11:28AM on 01/04/09
ribeye
czeledon at 11:28AM on 01/04/09
As I said before, porterhouse is the GREATEST!!!
jayhawker at 11:30AM on 01/04/09
New York Strip
lcinga at 11:32AM on 01/04/09
New York Strip for the 5th time.
gratefulted at 11:35AM on 01/04/09
My favorite cut is prime rib, black and blue.
LIDARKSIDE at 11:36AM on 01/04/09
porterhouse
kcook84 at 11:36AM on 01/04/09
New York Strip well done.
jspackman at 11:37AM on 01/04/09
Ribeye!
southeasterneater at 11:37AM on 01/04/09
porterhouse
jetlag89 at 11:40AM on 01/04/09
porterhouse; I like the tenderloin
lovegr8food at 11:41AM on 01/04/09
ribeye
jlharp770 at 11:42AM on 01/04/09
Filet mignon!
DevoBK at 11:42AM on 01/04/09
Ribey!
tripateam at 11:43AM on 01/04/09
Filet mignon is my favorite, followed by t-bone in second... yum
c81280 at 11:43AM on 01/04/09
favorite cut is definitely filet mignon
scottsgal at 11:44AM on 01/04/09
ribeye
ricereport at 11:46AM on 01/04/09
Prime Rib!!!
wenzdaygirl at 11:47AM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse, no comparison.
mreid01 at 11:47AM on 01/04/09
filet mignon
raymondlovesfootball at 11:48AM on 01/04/09
porterhouse :)
klp1965 at 11:48AM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse
candigrlme at 11:48AM on 01/04/09
filet
yumtal at 11:49AM on 01/04/09
ribeye
dearrie at 11:49AM on 01/04/09
simple sirloin medium if eating out, otherwise a ribeye
MadameD at 11:51AM on 01/04/09
T-Bone
mulkeyusa at 11:52AM on 01/04/09
The kind that my seriously kick-ass fiance cooks for me. :)
maryofdoom at 11:52AM on 01/04/09
ribeye
tawnda at 11:53AM on 01/04/09
Ribeye
b1exrts at 11:54AM on 01/04/09
Bone-in ribeye!
Lord Malvern at 11:54AM on 01/04/09
Gotta have that nice rare porterhouse steak
Bagoas at 11:54AM on 01/04/09
Filet or Ribeye
Bdm413 at 11:59AM on 01/04/09
Ribeye
dakhath at 12:00PM on 01/04/09
ribeye ~ well please
cathirushing at 12:01PM on 01/04/09
I think I'll just dream of porterhouse a little...
Dogstar at 12:03PM on 01/04/09
ribeye
applin22 at 12:04PM on 01/04/09
Ribeye, rare. Well-seasoned, char-grilled. Yum yum.
anadequatenovel at 12:04PM on 01/04/09
Ribeye
Riotgrrrlll at 12:04PM on 01/04/09
Ribeye or a thick strip, grilled medium rare and thinly sliced. Oh, I have just had my first flat iron steak. Not a ribeye, but very tasty. Oh, any beef at all will do.
tmdonahue at 12:05PM on 01/04/09
Ribeye
burgerluver at 12:06PM on 01/04/09
Ribeye...fresh off the grill, served with Garlic mashed potatoes, Bushs baked beans and homemade buttermilk biscuits. Somebody ring the dinner bell!
Noggy at 12:08PM on 01/04/09
Ribeye
joyluck at 12:09PM on 01/04/09
I love the ribeye the best.
blueskyman at 12:10PM on 01/04/09
RIBEYE!!!!!!
Bria at 12:10PM on 01/04/09
porterhouse
redron at 12:19PM on 01/04/09
I like ribeye.
samf336 at 12:20PM on 01/04/09
New York Strip pour moi!
michaele at 12:21PM on 01/04/09
NY Strip
bgrimes at 12:22PM on 01/04/09
Filet Mignon...the best!
raypatb at 12:23PM on 01/04/09
porterhouse
Marilyn at 12:24PM on 01/04/09
Filet Mignon
fancyfeet48 at 12:25PM on 01/04/09
NY Strip
drala625 at 12:26PM on 01/04/09
My favorite is filet mignon. Thank you!
mommyto2 at 12:29PM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse. Peter Luger is the best!
nantaylor at 12:32PM on 01/04/09
A big old porterhouse for me and a rib-eye for my wife
ceredo at 12:33PM on 01/04/09
my bf likes filet mignon, but I love Porterhouse steak. I like it with garlic salt and pepper. It reminds me of summer. I love to bbq it. Then have some iced tea, tomato bread, and a slad with french dressing. In the winter, I can put it on the broiler and pretend it is summer.
TERILEE at 12:33PM on 01/04/09
NY strip, definitely!
juliec at 12:39PM on 01/04/09
I like them all but I like Filet mignon best :)
kdkdkd at 12:41PM on 01/04/09
Love t-bone
slcrose at 12:42PM on 01/04/09
The Ribeye is King!!!!!!
matttx76 at 12:43PM on 01/04/09
bone-in ribeye :)
noshing at 12:44PM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse...must be Porterhouse. Does Peter Luger serve any other?
Brogan at 12:45PM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse. Biggest & best!
jeffmahrens at 12:46PM on 01/04/09
ribeye
CAROLTENNIS at 12:47PM on 01/04/09
Filet Mignon is our family favorite!
Redlady at 12:50PM on 01/04/09
The one and only... filet mignon!
jefflysiak at 12:52PM on 01/04/09
Ribeye is my favorite.
mizztara71 at 12:52PM on 01/04/09
Favorite cut is third from the middle going towards the bone on a porterhouse.
drbenelli at 12:53PM on 01/04/09
Filet mignon!!
DePro1 at 12:54PM on 01/04/09
Ribeye is my favorite
buckyandtux at 12:56PM on 01/04/09
Today, I'm craving well marinated hangar steak... fajita-style.
mlcottingham at 12:57PM on 01/04/09
Prime rib with au jues (did I spell that wrong? Most likely!)
Tricia316 at 12:57PM on 01/04/09
I like porterhouse steaks.
lucky65nj at 12:58PM on 01/04/09
Ribeye no contest!
sabum at 12:59PM on 01/04/09
If I'm buying and cooking, it's top sirloin: far less costly, lower in fat, and the most "beefy taste." It's a good deal less tender, so marinating and/or cooking style requires adjustment.
gcomstock at 1:00PM on 01/04/09
I love prime rib but I also like Porterhouse.
Lydiad1957 at 1:00PM on 01/04/09
ribeye!!
angelak at 1:03PM on 01/04/09
My favorite is bone in rib eye!!!!!
emf77 at 1:03PM on 01/04/09
ribeye
Mike Sula at 1:07PM on 01/04/09
t=bone
imicindy at 1:07PM on 01/04/09
It would have to be Filet.
April1p at 1:07PM on 01/04/09
ribeye.
ynot4me at 1:09PM on 01/04/09
I have to say the T-Bone, But I like the Ribeye and the NY strip very much to.
jaydogs at 1:12PM on 01/04/09
Tenderloin Baby!~ I love you.
Zenwins at 1:15PM on 01/04/09
Prime Rib
agordon10 at 1:15PM on 01/04/09
Nothing beats a great prime rib
morty63 at 1:17PM on 01/04/09
Filet
lindsayag7 at 1:19PM on 01/04/09
ribeye
lilyk at 1:20PM on 01/04/09
Ribeye
orangecloud at 1:22PM on 01/04/09
I love porterhouse!
ninasmom at 1:24PM on 01/04/09
Prime Rib....
Das615 at 1:31PM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse, of course
tuniabug at 1:32PM on 01/04/09
Prime rib.
gerigrrl at 1:33PM on 01/04/09
I'm going to say Tri-tip, just to be different.
DubiousKaj at 1:35PM on 01/04/09
Rib eye
phoney2 at 1:36PM on 01/04/09
PORTER HOUSE
galena at 1:38PM on 01/04/09
Ribeye.
cchops at 1:39PM on 01/04/09
porterhouse
nystagmus at 1:40PM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse
dpripps at 1:41PM on 01/04/09
grilled tri-tip steak.
pintolinda at 1:41PM on 01/04/09
If I say Porterhouse do I win? Seriously anything from Peter Luger's is great!
Porterhouse
thegoch at 1:42PM on 01/04/09
Filet Mignon
savedtoserve at 1:42PM on 01/04/09
Filet Mignon!!!! Then again, I don't think I have ever met a cut of beef I didn't like!!!
jensweeps at 1:43PM on 01/04/09
ny strip
emtstacey76 at 1:43PM on 01/04/09
Ribeye!
mgantolak at 1:46PM on 01/04/09
ribeye
Carly705 at 1:46PM on 01/04/09
NY strip for me!
docrck at 1:46PM on 01/04/09
Can't beat a porterhouse - a twofer!
tozier at 1:46PM on 01/04/09
Rib eye and filet mignon are beautiful!
Wandering Lion at 1:47PM on 01/04/09
Ribeye!
I'm still not the best griller but ribeye is mighty forgiving and also tastes great when dry fried in kosher salt for the hubby.
ohiogal at 1:49PM on 01/04/09
For grilling, easily porterhouse so you get a little sirloin and a little tenderloin. Ribeyes, properly trimmed, are nice but sirloin has so much more flavor.
iainswife at 1:49PM on 01/04/09
My favourite cut of steak is the first cut made with my knife into any USDA Prime piece of meat that has been properly prepared and gets it to my mouth the quickest.
pixelchef at 1:50PM on 01/04/09
New York Strip!
dakotamoon at 1:50PM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse is my favorite
Jaleigh78 at 1:52PM on 01/04/09
filet mignon. bloody rare.
aidank at 1:55PM on 01/04/09
ribeye...
SanMan at 1:56PM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse, or a skirt steak deliciously marinated in curry powder, white wine, garlic and soy sauce.
Bumblebutton at 2:01PM on 01/04/09
New York Strip. Still Mooing...
kbwise1 at 2:01PM on 01/04/09
ribeye, and more recently I have discovered hanger steak which I also really like.
Rick Kazmer at 2:01PM on 01/04/09
bone-in ribeye
thebeef at 2:03PM on 01/04/09
Prime Rib or Ribeye
whammyammy at 2:06PM on 01/04/09
porterhouse, nice and tender
melodys at 2:06PM on 01/04/09
Ribeye
sfgourmet at 2:07PM on 01/04/09
Filet Mignon
maryelisabeth at 2:08PM on 01/04/09
New York Strip Steak
kenkozak at 2:10PM on 01/04/09
Prime rib, when I can afford it.
carolyn554 at 2:11PM on 01/04/09
mmm Porterhouse. i like NY Strip too.
amberlicious at 2:11PM on 01/04/09
New York Strip. Medium Rare, Charred on the out.
cybrlee at 2:15PM on 01/04/09
ribeye!
gurizzy at 2:16PM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse
Hd00g at 2:16PM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse
one2win at 2:18PM on 01/04/09
I like Top Sirloin, Thanks for the great contest.
inismom at 2:19PM on 01/04/09
Bone-in ribeye!!!!
vholdman at 2:27PM on 01/04/09
I like SKIRT STEAK so verstiable
sue14625 at 2:27PM on 01/04/09
rib eye, all the way!
heylucy at 2:28PM on 01/04/09
a nice juicy, red filet
tanners12 at 2:31PM on 01/04/09
ribeye!
graciecat at 2:31PM on 01/04/09
filet mignon
bingsy at 2:34PM on 01/04/09
filet for sure!
andeeram at 2:34PM on 01/04/09
I love a bacon-wrapped filet mignon with garlic butter sauce. MMmmmmm!!
tawneej at 2:35PM on 01/04/09
I love a nice, medium rare ribeye steak!
sbbuckley at 2:35PM on 01/04/09
I love the New York Strip.The porterhouse is great too.
upholster at 2:36PM on 01/04/09
The ribeye is my favorite.
jfellows at 2:38PM on 01/04/09
Prime rib for me, Porterhouse for hubby and son!
ruthing73 at 2:39PM on 01/04/09
New York Strip!
txhottie_86 at yahoo dot com
sl1038 at 2:40PM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse and rib eye steaks for me.
willitara at 2:40PM on 01/04/09
My favorite cut in general is definitely ribeye because it has the most flavor, but if I want a leaner cut of meat, I love a porterhouse too.
elangomatt at 2:42PM on 01/04/09
skirt steak
elcid42 at 2:45PM on 01/04/09
Ribeye Baby!
ELYSESW at 2:47PM on 01/04/09
Ribeye
MrsSue at 2:50PM on 01/04/09
First cut, prime chuck steak - believe it or not. My bubbe used to prepare chuck steak for my Uncle, who worked all night "on the railroad," in New Jersey. He'd come home from work in the morning, and she'd serve his utterly cooked (for hours) steak with onions and "brown potatoes", while we had to eat our oatmeal. It's always been a treat to have chuck steak the ay she cooked it.
maxboswell at 2:51PM on 01/04/09
The steak I'm chewing on!
lomaxx23 at 2:56PM on 01/04/09
Rib Eye or Hanger, depends on the mood.
Patrixio at 2:57PM on 01/04/09
flank!
Hess5534 at 2:57PM on 01/04/09
porterhouse
splitraindrop at 2:57PM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse, with just a touch of good salt.
Calichef at 2:59PM on 01/04/09
Ribeye
cmcentee20 at 3:09PM on 01/04/09
filet mignon
jplooster at 3:11PM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse!
atreau at 3:11PM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse, medium rare! Thank you!
Tina12312 at 3:31PM on 01/04/09
I like a NY strip steak well done
nannetterya at 3:39PM on 01/04/09
All the above!
tmc151 at 3:40PM on 01/04/09
ribeye. we grill them for all the men in the family (and womenfolk), especially on Father's Day.
momtimestwo at 3:43PM on 01/04/09
gonna have to go with the filet
misteroz at 3:43PM on 01/04/09
Love to have some filet mignon!
gloriase at 3:50PM on 01/04/09
PORTERHOUSE! 2 cuts that allows you to have you steak and eat it too!
BurgerConquest at 3:51PM on 01/04/09
I love Filet Mignon and Rib-Eye, but I also love a barbaque'd T'Bone.
Mikelynn at 3:56PM on 01/04/09
New York strip!
esperfect at 3:58PM on 01/04/09
RIB eye or aged sirloin
ellenf48 at 3:58PM on 01/04/09
A nice thick ribeye grilled to medium rare with loads of mushrooms on top
pamelakrest at 4:07PM on 01/04/09
Filet Mignon:-)
Teena29 at 4:08PM on 01/04/09
Sirloin Steak for me, well done! Thanks so much for such a wonderful giveaway, my husband and I would love this!
furygirl3132[at]comcast[dot]net
furygirl3132 at 4:08PM on 01/04/09
Ribeye for me, Porterhouse for hubby.
dawnnut1 at 4:09PM on 01/04/09
Love the porterhouse!!!
Thanks for the amazing give away!
ksweeper21 at 4:19PM on 01/04/09
Ooo...how to choose just one! I guess a NY Strip would be my first choice - today anyway! Thanks!
covetcat at 4:22PM on 01/04/09
I would say porterhouse is my favorite, and my hubby loves prime rib, the rarer the better
cindy47 at 4:25PM on 01/04/09
filet mignon
stigay at 4:29PM on 01/04/09
a delicious crusty on the outside, melting on the inside porterhouse from PL!!
lisetted at 4:30PM on 01/04/09
filet mignon rare
susanmac at 4:30PM on 01/04/09
Gimmie that med-rare, bone-in rib-eye!
DeaconVolker at 4:32PM on 01/04/09
Depending on my mood: sometimes ribeye, sometimes filet, sometimes poerterhouse. Steak is GREAT!
cindyj921 at 4:32PM on 01/04/09
Love me some porterhouse.
alexasoto at 4:41PM on 01/04/09
T-bone, to chew on the bone in the end.
christine1225 at 4:49PM on 01/04/09
NY Strip
klsm54 at 4:51PM on 01/04/09
porterhouse
gunbuster at 4:52PM on 01/04/09
Filet Mignon!
KathyOH at 4:54PM on 01/04/09
I love a lot of steak cuts, but I would have to say ribeye probibly is my favorite.
brack78 at 4:56PM on 01/04/09
Flank steak rolled with applewood bacon, portabello mushroom, and fresh ground peppercorn
sunpep53 at 4:56PM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse.....
But any good steak I cut to eat is a good cut!! ;-)
knifeforkspoon at 4:56PM on 01/04/09
filet mignon
dementeddoll at 4:59PM on 01/04/09
Ribeye
TNFarmer at 5:00PM on 01/04/09
porterhouse!
swordfish at 5:00PM on 01/04/09
Ribeye!!!!
missmeigs at 5:03PM on 01/04/09
T-Bone, T-Bone, Da-da,da,da, da,da, da,da,da,da,da....But a 2-pound Porterhouse has gotta be somethin mmmm mmmm good too.
RosaRosa at 5:11PM on 01/04/09
Filet mignon served raw in thin slices or rare.
Cassaendra at 5:12PM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse
sutler7 at 5:14PM on 01/04/09
crzycrs@hotmail.com porterhouse steaks are my favorite
itchyfoot at 5:20PM on 01/04/09
Either a ribeye or prime rib, medium rare
moneal at 5:20PM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse
julis55 at 5:23PM on 01/04/09
the new york strip
cmarie at 5:23PM on 01/04/09
the cowboy cut, of course!!!!
A “cowboy cut” is a cut of steak with the bone in (for use by cowboys as a handle). The term “cowboy cut” appeared in the late 1960s and 1970s; Wrangler introduced its “cowboy cut” jeans before this steak cut had its name.
go dallas cowboys!!!
njtom
njtom at 5:27PM on 01/04/09
My favorite is the simple Sirloin - you can't beat it for flavor and for tenderness when it is grilled!
kaylee8 at 5:44PM on 01/04/09
NY strip is my favorite
silverfox at 5:55PM on 01/04/09
Ribeye!!!
Bugsy at 5:59PM on 01/04/09
all parts with a bit of fat makes me very happy...my kids profess to be vegetarians, so it's a holiday when I can eat a nice piece of med-rare meat!!!!
cherylmom at 6:03PM on 01/04/09
I am really partial to a "bone-thick"Ribeye burnt over natural charcoal
sanman18 at 6:05PM on 01/04/09
I love a porterhouse!
jdbaron at 6:11PM on 01/04/09
My favorite would be filet mignon.
hawkshoe at 6:12PM on 01/04/09
Gotta have me a ribeye!
THELASTRESORT at 6:30PM on 01/04/09
tenderloin!
midge at 6:31PM on 01/04/09
ribeye , porter house , prime rib , new york
frozenman20 at 6:33PM on 01/04/09
Filet mignon is hot!
BOJENSEN at 6:44PM on 01/04/09
rib eye on the bone
shozgirl at 6:44PM on 01/04/09
Filet!
droller02 at 6:47PM on 01/04/09
I guess I'd have to admit it's Ribeye! But oh any good steak will do!!!
Granny Debra at 6:48PM on 01/04/09
Rib-Eye for me.
circargus at 6:52PM on 01/04/09
I like a nice tender ribeye
Suekey at 6:54PM on 01/04/09
Bone-in Ribeye
slvance at 6:58PM on 01/04/09
ribeye..
lindalou1 at 6:59PM on 01/04/09
The one in front of me! But given a choice probably Filet Mignon
nancymorrell at 6:59PM on 01/04/09
This Canadian digs Porterhouse!
bareneed at 7:00PM on 01/04/09
I like almost any steak but if I get to choose it will be a New York, rare to medium rare. Yummmm.....
whirlarado at 7:16PM on 01/04/09
My favorite is the filet.
kbamos at 7:35PM on 01/04/09
Depending on my mood, I could go for a Filet megnon or a NY strip.
knycks at 7:40PM on 01/04/09
1 inche thick T-Bone, Baby!
dvhnvr4040 at 7:52PM on 01/04/09
Ribeye Please
brighton at 7:55PM on 01/04/09
Ribeye and porterhouse
RossS at 8:01PM on 01/04/09
Definitely the Luger Porterhouse.
GGGGG at 8:10PM on 01/04/09
filet mignon
Lindab401 at 8:11PM on 01/04/09
My favorite cut is choice sirloin...excellent at Texas Roadhouse or Outback!
prismperfect at 8:28PM on 01/04/09
Ribeye
Bandbabe at 8:35PM on 01/04/09
My husband's favorite is the New York Strip. Thanks for the chance.
ecfreitas579 at 8:39PM on 01/04/09
My favorite is the outside Skirt Steak
dn6511 at 8:50PM on 01/04/09
I love Porterhouse. Thanks!
tlpounds at 8:54PM on 01/04/09
I love the filet mignon when i can afford it.
pwhite98270 at 8:56PM on 01/04/09
Tri-Tip!!!
Carla
cpullum(at)yahoo(dot)com
cpullum at 8:59PM on 01/04/09
I love a thick T-bone!!!!
braeuber at 9:12PM on 01/04/09
Filet!!
markmaz21 at 9:12PM on 01/04/09
Yummm, Im not to picky, I like almost all good cuts of steak. T-Bone, Porterhouse, Filet Mignon, NY Strip, Rib Eye. Bring on the steak!
Thank you for the great giveaway!
JH33194 at 9:15PM on 01/04/09
I like new york strip
kerri69 at 9:16PM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse, yum!
justcuzz at 9:20PM on 01/04/09
Ribeye. Wife goes for Filet Migon when in the mood for meat.
Osk325 at 9:29PM on 01/04/09
Ribeye
hstamper at 9:40PM on 01/04/09
Filet Mignon
allelect at 9:46PM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse
minbari at 9:57PM on 01/04/09
Ribeye!
ross33 at 10:09PM on 01/04/09
Filet or NY strip
kathemc at 10:14PM on 01/04/09
Has to be ribeyes.
EDRing at 10:14PM on 01/04/09
Ribeye..definitely ribeye
jdmimi at 10:39PM on 01/04/09
Up here in the great white frozen north, we just peel 'em, knock the horns off, put 'em on a spit, roast his carcass for a time and take a chunk from his loins!!
james735 at 10:46PM on 01/04/09
Ribeye...always.
timjertson at 10:52PM on 01/04/09
Although it's not in the budget, I love a good porterhouse.
lisaray at 10:52PM on 01/04/09
Porterhouse hands down. The best of both worlds.
axis blunts at 10:55PM on 01/04/09
favorite is filet
ginagfunk2005 at 10:56PM on 01/04/09
filet mignon definately!
greeny1232 at 11:00PM on 01/04/09
Ribeye
jashelep23 at 11:03PM on 01/04/09
ribeye
1mmentor at 11:08PM on 01/04/09
Ribeye, marbled.
ktmtfl at 11:13PM on 01/04/09
I usually make a T-bone. My DH loves the NY strip and I eat the filet. So it's the perfect family steak for us!
rocksea at 11:15PM on 01/04/09
Ribeye is my choice cut of steak. It is the most flavorable cut because of the fat and I love it. Bring it on!
LuckyTJG at 11:23PM on 01/04/09
I've always preferred ribeye or filet mignon. They are both fattier, but the are tender and moist.
angieprater at 11:26PM on 01/04/09
porterhouse is one of my favorites,mesquite smoked when I can manage it
rubytom at 11:33PM on 01/04/09
Primerib- definitely. Thank you.
bohemiangypsy at 11:56PM on 01/04/09
Ribeye but filet with a really good bearnaise is tough to pass up.
janecooks at 12:06AM on 01/05/09
I just had a ribeye tonight. And Friday too, come to think of it. I swear I can stop whenever I want...
stu_spivac at 12:08AM on 01/05/09
bone-in ribeye, medium rare. ... cheers!
merlot at 12:13AM on 01/05/09
My favorite cute is a porterhouse
chestnuyouth at 12:38AM on 01/05/09
New York Strip
ZESTYWONDERLAND at 12:50AM on 01/05/09
Gotta be Ribeye!
FullOn at 1:11AM on 01/05/09
A nice Big T-bone.
Tonyga1 at 2:00AM on 01/05/09
New York still holds the fondest place in my heart
gibbylet at 2:06AM on 01/05/09
CHICKEN FRIED STEAK WITH LOTS OF GRAVY
nenieves at 3:42AM on 01/05/09
filet at a restaurant, flank to make.
bookcat at 4:23AM on 01/05/09
Filet! with a cesar salad and grilled vegetables, who could ask for anything more!!!!!
agrigirl at 6:45AM on 01/05/09
Ribeye
Nemis at 9:12AM on 01/05/09
Porterhouse.
Gregg at 9:16AM on 01/05/09
bone-in ribeye.
please.
intheyearofthepig at 9:18AM on 01/05/09
NY Strip
JudyH at 9:39AM on 01/05/09
Porterhouse.
zoverman at 9:42AM on 01/05/09
rib-eye on the bone
struver at 9:49AM on 01/05/09
Filet Mignon
mmakis at 10:01AM on 01/05/09
Ribeye!
EmilyN at 10:21AM on 01/05/09
Flap meat aka Bavette!
zindh at 10:38AM on 01/05/09
Prime Rib. Cut at the bone and Broiled!
dashiel at 10:39AM on 01/05/09
porterhouse.....!
nighthawk at 10:51AM on 01/05/09
Aged NY Strip
mlbykb at 11:09AM on 01/05/09
bone in rib eye
alexeatsworld at 11:11AM on 01/05/09
Filet mignon
Rosamund at 11:24AM on 01/05/09
petite oscar
csbrown at 11:29AM on 01/05/09
Ribeye
Pupster at 11:47AM on 01/05/09
Hanger or NY Strip
klovely78 at 11:52AM on 01/05/09
porterhouse
elaine nan at 11:53AM on 01/05/09
Tri-Tip!
SmokedMeat at 11:55AM on 01/05/09
Ribeye
wchuang at 11:57AM on 01/05/09
Thank you for participating, and congratulations to our winner: Kerosena
Winner has been notified by email and also appears on our Contest Winners page.
Adam Kuban at 10:33AM on 01/07/09