Seriously Delicious Holiday Giveaway: Two Peter Luger Steaks
Every day through January 1 we're giving away a crazy good food item on Serious Eats. Try your luck, and if you win, you'll be eating some seriously delicious food come the new year.
Today we're giving away a package of two prime, dry-aged ("longer than four weeks") porterhouse steaks, thanks to the generous folks at Peter Luger. These steaks are not small. Each weighs more than two pounds. The steaks come with two bottles of Peter Luger steak sauce and a bag of chocolate coins. —Ed Levine
To win, just answer this in the comments below: What's your favorite cut of steak?
PS: If you just can't wait for this contest to be over and want to order steaks right now from Peter Luger, you may do so at peterluger.com. You will make any serious carnivores on your list very happy.
You have until 3 p.m. ET tomorrow (December 28) to enter. One winner will be chosen at random from among the commenters. Contest winners are limited to residents of the continental U.S., and you can only win once during the duration of the Seriously Delicious Holiday Giveaway contest. The standard Serious Eats contest rules apply.
Comments are closed: 703 Comments:
porterhouse or ribeye, cooked medium rare
mrsbao at 3:05PM on 12/28/08
NY strip is always the best!
Teapothouses at 3:07PM on 12/28/08
If it's just me, a strip. For the two of us, Porterhouse or ribeye.
lemons at 3:09PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse baby...love that flavorful bone!
CambridgeFoodie at 3:11PM on 12/28/08
NY Strip.
mnsteph at 3:18PM on 12/28/08
The best steak I've ever eaten was a porterhouse. The most flavorful cut of meat I've ever had the pleasure of tasting.
Now my mouth is watering...
Ineedacatscan at 3:19PM on 12/28/08
RIbeye, for sure. Incredible depth of flavor.
maxcriden at 3:19PM on 12/28/08
NY Strip. Yum!
lillylilly at 3:20PM on 12/28/08
sirloin. it's what i grew up having.
shuffer at 3:20PM on 12/28/08
Ribeye!
lourdes at 3:22PM on 12/28/08
Ribeye
mrsbecky at 3:22PM on 12/28/08
T bone! Chew on the bone.
brando30740 at 3:22PM on 12/28/08
Filet Mignon - so rare it's practically mooing.
MMinNYC at 3:22PM on 12/28/08
porterhouse of course
ssultan23 at 3:23PM on 12/28/08
I love Porterhouse.
janetfaye at 3:24PM on 12/28/08
filet mignon- yum!
weeblet at 3:25PM on 12/28/08
Bone in Rib Eye cooked medium rare
achilles21 at 3:25PM on 12/28/08
Bone in ribeye! And I usually knaw on the bone BEFORE eating the steak!
jackiecat at 3:26PM on 12/28/08
boneless blade steak. I eat more steak at home than at a restaurant. This cut gives me the most bang for my buck.
OhPuhleezee at 3:27PM on 12/28/08
Love NY strip, Rib Eye. Only recently discovered the deliciousness of rare and medium rare steak after eating at Fogo de Chao. LOVE IT.
NicMarie at 3:30PM on 12/28/08
Flanl steak! on the grill
anny31 at 3:31PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse
jrwh72 at 3:32PM on 12/28/08
Love a ribeye any day.
gr0707 at 3:33PM on 12/28/08
fillet mignon. Also, love tri-tip on the grill.
lamora at 3:34PM on 12/28/08
T-bones - gives you a little filet and strip.
tonibelle at 3:34PM on 12/28/08
The first. It's the deepest.
shoneyjoe at 3:34PM on 12/28/08
rib eye medium rare
NanaJoie at 3:34PM on 12/28/08
I Love all steak, But I will go with Porterhouse first followed closely by New York and Rib eye.
bongeezer at 3:36PM on 12/28/08
yuuummmyy :) ribeye, medium rare
thanks!
cdm65 at 3:36PM on 12/28/08
My fave is normally whatever I have on my plate...but I do love me some ribeye!
d0d0joe at 3:36PM on 12/28/08
T-bone
crashers525 at 3:36PM on 12/28/08
Long Island's Millridge Inn's sirlointips in sauce. Bite sized mouth watering goodness!
1969norton at 3:38PM on 12/28/08
My favorite is porterhouse, medium rare, now that is yummy!!
donnanurse at 3:38PM on 12/28/08
My favorite cut is Prime Rib!
berwyn at 3:41PM on 12/28/08
A porterhouse steak! YUM!
coloradochick at 3:42PM on 12/28/08
I love a good filet mignon, that's what we are having to celebrate the new year!
carcon at 3:42PM on 12/28/08
Big old 48oz porterhouse medium rare
sigtau91 at 3:44PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse, followed closely by Ribeye
dbaxgirl51 at 3:45PM on 12/28/08
ribeye!
robotbill at 3:46PM on 12/28/08
skirt. cheap and delicious
hoff_83 at 3:48PM on 12/28/08
RIBEYE
sandy89 at 3:50PM on 12/28/08
I love T Bones. They seem to have the most flavor right off the bone.
nycphoto at 3:51PM on 12/28/08
Depends on how you are cooking but for the grill, you can't beat a porterhouse. I especially love the whole taste of filet and taste of sirlion combo of porterhouse. Mmmmm, meaty goodness.
iainswife at 3:53PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse!
calamityjake at 3:53PM on 12/28/08
I love Porterhouse.
joanne117 at 3:54PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse is my favorite!
estelle at 3:54PM on 12/28/08
ribeye :)
marchpane at 3:56PM on 12/28/08
Anything Peter Luger sells.
andysophiemom at 3:56PM on 12/28/08
Ribeye for me, please! :-)
MegB at 3:56PM on 12/28/08
medium rare porterhouse or ribeye.
dabiscuits at 3:56PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse, medium rare. Nothing better!
Nick85204 at 3:56PM on 12/28/08
filet mignon
sarahbethe at 3:57PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse: medium rare is the best!!
annemarie56 at 3:58PM on 12/28/08
porterhouse!
irisheyes131 at 3:59PM on 12/28/08
Big LARGE Porterhouse, medium rare!
kuromu at 4:00PM on 12/28/08
prime rib
thumber at 4:03PM on 12/28/08
the T-Bone
jffryclough at 4:04PM on 12/28/08
A nice Porterhouse!!!!!
ImaDevlsh1 at 4:05PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse, definitely. But I'm sure I'd love anything from Peter Luger's
diobella at 4:06PM on 12/28/08
The center cut.
MCJunkie at 4:06PM on 12/28/08
I'm having company tomorrow, I just bought my favorite steak- Filet Mignon
joanpieroni2 at 4:08PM on 12/28/08
Great contest.
Angelsminx at 4:08PM on 12/28/08
rib eye, bone in, rare
tenpointfarmer at 4:09PM on 12/28/08
ny strip
cupcakemuffin at 4:09PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse
JennH at 4:09PM on 12/28/08
My fave is prime rib, rare.
TrayMona at 4:10PM on 12/28/08
I love a good Prime Rib.
armlam@bellsouth.net
AllenMcLeod at 4:12PM on 12/28/08
Sirloin, seared, then grilled medium well
jword2001 at 4:13PM on 12/28/08
Ribeye
TNFarmer at 4:15PM on 12/28/08
Sirloin.
teancom at 4:16PM on 12/28/08
I've always loved a good rare ribeye.
Suekey at 4:16PM on 12/28/08
Filet!!! win win win win. good karma good karma good karma....
chuckjustice at 4:18PM on 12/28/08
Oh yeah--two pound, 4-week aged porterhouse is my fav; how could yu know?
BobbieAnne at 4:19PM on 12/28/08
My favorite steak is a bone - in Rib eye.
townfam at 4:22PM on 12/28/08
NY Strip, I think.
kitchenhacker at 4:22PM on 12/28/08
I've always loved a good porterhouse. Thank you for this giveaway!
dglitter at 4:22PM on 12/28/08
T-Bone is always my favorite!
crboyd at 4:23PM on 12/28/08
A well marbled ribeye cooked rare over a charcoal grill.
leah4hand at 4:23PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse
msecondo at 4:24PM on 12/28/08
I love NY strip!
juliec at 4:27PM on 12/28/08
NY strip!!
Ariel at 4:29PM on 12/28/08
ribeye
fabdumplin at 4:30PM on 12/28/08
FLANK
hickey at 4:30PM on 12/28/08
Filet mignon for me, bone-in ribeye for my husband, and we share. Win-win.
Jeana at 4:31PM on 12/28/08
Nothing compares to a great Ribeye Steak.
fangirl at 4:31PM on 12/28/08
I'll take a porterhouse. Thanks for the giveaway!
cmgnbox01 at 4:33PM on 12/28/08
hangar steak, 'cause I'm cheap.
Dee at 4:33PM on 12/28/08
1. Porterhouse 2. Ribeye 3. Prime Rib 4. Filet Mignon 5. OK... just give me meat...
vdeliz at 4:34PM on 12/28/08
Prime Rib all the way
kohndr at 4:37PM on 12/28/08
Filet mignon is my fav ... yum! Thanks for the awesome giveaway!
RobsGirl123 at 4:38PM on 12/28/08
New York strip steak is my favorite cut.
Aisling at 4:38PM on 12/28/08
jFilet Mignon - Meduium rare, please....
tdark27 at 4:39PM on 12/28/08
Strip!
architeuthis at 4:41PM on 12/28/08
Prime Rib.
ruthing73 at 4:43PM on 12/28/08
ribeye
plantainsandkimchi at 4:43PM on 12/28/08
Filet Miignon thats for me
mkfadem at 4:44PM on 12/28/08
ribeye for me
mverno at 4:44PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse is my favorite
abfantom at 4:45PM on 12/28/08
skirt, with great sauces, grilled and in tacos, taquitos, or quesadillas.MMM
alcopop at 4:47PM on 12/28/08
fielt mignon
spartana07 at 4:47PM on 12/28/08
Spencer/ribeye or any beef except burger.
Zinnia at 4:48PM on 12/28/08
I love a tender prime rib.
redfantum at 4:48PM on 12/28/08
a bone in rib -eye of course
lainie2285 at 4:48PM on 12/28/08
I love me some Porterhouse!!
sfmitch at 4:49PM on 12/28/08
filet mignon with onions
marybad at 4:50PM on 12/28/08
My most favorite cut of steak would be either a thick ribeye or a delmonico cooked medium rare.
Thank you so much for offering this wonderful giveaway.
Happy Holidays !!
jsc123 at 4:50PM on 12/28/08
Ribeye, as of today, but I'm pretty flighty with my preferred beef cuts.
HungryDaruma at 4:50PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse.
ejswanso at 4:50PM on 12/28/08
Has got to be a filet
Faither at 4:50PM on 12/28/08
Manoman, any cut with a bone to gnaw on! I think I'm part cave man!
SueZeeQ at 4:52PM on 12/28/08
I love the porterhouse steak. I can cook it any way i like. It is perfect grilled but can also be broiled, sautéd or pan-fryed. I prefer mine medium rare. It also reminds me of the old west, cowboys, family, and there no comfort food better than a porterhouse steak.
texaswaitress at 4:52PM on 12/28/08
bone-in ribeye! Medium Rare, of course.
blander at 4:53PM on 12/28/08
My favorite cut in general is the ribeye because it is the most flavorful with its great marbling. If I want something a little leaner though, I prefer a nice porterhouse. Thanks for the giveaway.
elangomatt at 4:55PM on 12/28/08
Sirloin Tip.
Nonny at 4:55PM on 12/28/08
I love porterhouse steak grilled to medium rare.
I also like a bone in rib eye steak.
Lydiad1957 at 4:56PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse.
karen r at 4:56PM on 12/28/08
filet mignon!
fshapiro at 4:56PM on 12/28/08
My favorite is filet mignon. Yum!
dmmarklin at 4:57PM on 12/28/08
filet mignon!
randio at 4:58PM on 12/28/08
I like the ribeye!
jkampf at 4:59PM on 12/28/08
Filet mignon is my kinda steak.
JEP at 5:01PM on 12/28/08
Filet, with sauteed mushrooms!
sueb84 at 5:02PM on 12/28/08
filet mignon
Cookieeater at 5:04PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse or ribeye. Love me some marbling.
feriorrenna at 5:05PM on 12/28/08
ribeye as always
Thomas6 at 5:05PM on 12/28/08
Fillet steak cooked medium rare
gracieh at 5:06PM on 12/28/08
Ribeye steak followed closely by filet mignon-depends on my mood!!
rararee at 5:07PM on 12/28/08
Filet mignon for me
pourgirl at 5:08PM on 12/28/08
ribeye
madball911 at 5:08PM on 12/28/08
ribeye
nmp164 at 5:09PM on 12/28/08
The Porterhouse for 2 @ Luger's or a great Ribeye
bessfour at 5:11PM on 12/28/08
filet mignon
egrmusic at 5:11PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse.
annerska at 5:12PM on 12/28/08
filet mignon.
savscarlett at 5:13PM on 12/28/08
A nice big Porterhouse or a couple of ribeye steaks...no better eating!
ronnifox at 5:13PM on 12/28/08
porterhouse
chromiumman at 5:14PM on 12/28/08
None that I don't like, but ribeye is high on the list.
dbcurrie at 5:15PM on 12/28/08
Mmm. New York strip!
jcwest47 at 5:15PM on 12/28/08
Rib eye, of course!
flimsy at 5:16PM on 12/28/08
Love that T-Bone
Judyv12306 at 5:17PM on 12/28/08
NY Strip, please!
dhorst at 5:18PM on 12/28/08
Favorite cut of steak- Porterhouse.. YUM!
sweeps4us@gmail.com
sweeps4us at 5:19PM on 12/28/08
Ribeye
Brettsy at 5:19PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse
kathryne4 at 5:20PM on 12/28/08
Filet Mignon
bsherrill at 5:21PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse. Dry aged. Preferably free, and from Peter Luger.
schmonsequences at 5:22PM on 12/28/08
Sirloin is my fave.
dusksunset at 5:22PM on 12/28/08
The one I win if I win this contest!
hmcnally at 5:24PM on 12/28/08
T bone!!
samf336 at 5:25PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse
diesel51 at 5:25PM on 12/28/08
Ribeye with the cap
phoney2 at 5:26PM on 12/28/08
Dr. Porter House
PerkyMac at 5:26PM on 12/28/08
Ribeye
SEFB9118 at 5:27PM on 12/28/08
The famous Mr. Ed.
Aliciaz at 5:28PM on 12/28/08
i love ny strip!
mimisbear at 5:29PM on 12/28/08
Ribeye aka Delmonico aka Spencer, medium rare please.
pgsvensk at 5:30PM on 12/28/08
fillet mignon
Thank you
fluegas5 at 5:31PM on 12/28/08
I'm dreaming of a nice ribeye.
cyberroo at 5:31PM on 12/28/08
ribeye is where it always has been, and always will be at.
zumicroom at 5:31PM on 12/28/08
Ribeye
:) Thank you for the wonderful giveaway! :)
tmim123 at 5:33PM on 12/28/08
porterhouse all up in your grill.
crapkatapult at 5:33PM on 12/28/08
ribeye, bone-in please.
Alm25 at 5:34PM on 12/28/08
Ribeye, all the way.
aadams73 at 5:34PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse steaks are wonderful, but not locally available. I am criossing my fingers and toes in hopes of winning these great steaks.
CarolHarrity at 5:35PM on 12/28/08
Ribeye, bone in, as often as possible.
jason at 5:36PM on 12/28/08
My favorite restaurant steak is definitely a ribeye, but if I'm cooking it myself, I'd go for a flank steak. Ribeye is tasty, mmm.
msfisch at 5:37PM on 12/28/08
New York Strip!
Mavisr at 5:38PM on 12/28/08
Bone-in "KC" Strip
awtane at 5:38PM on 12/28/08
I like a good sirloin.
ps9906 at 5:39PM on 12/28/08
NY Strip or Hanger...but ANY cut as long as it's med rare!
Curlz at 5:41PM on 12/28/08
I love filet mignon.
slb3334 at 5:42PM on 12/28/08
NY Strip!!! ;) For surreeee....
babygrrrl923 at 5:42PM on 12/28/08
A Ribeye is my ultimate steak that needs no sides dinner.
bobcat at 5:42PM on 12/28/08
ribeye, medium rare
wizzy at 5:43PM on 12/28/08
roundeye, nice and rare
saphyress at 5:45PM on 12/28/08
I'm a Porterhouse kinda guy! Thanks for the 'great' giveaway offering and Happy Holidays!
leandrew39 at 5:47PM on 12/28/08
T-Bone
beanish at 5:49PM on 12/28/08
My favorite cut of steak? For special occasions, Filet Mignon. Otherwise, I LOVE a great Ribeye -- medium rare with a nice glass of Merlot!!
Thanks for a great giveaway!!
Cataroo at 5:49PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse is my favorite cut.
strimble_25@comcast.net
steadier571 at 5:51PM on 12/28/08
Sirloin medium well with lots of mushrooms.
gypsy58 at 5:53PM on 12/28/08
Lately I've become a fan of the cheaper cuts, like flank and hanger steaks (a lot of them have really good, beefy flavor), but I think I could manage to find something good to do with a couple of Porterhouses. :)
msmla at 5:53PM on 12/28/08
You can't gone wrong with a thick Porterhouse.
Bunnybee at 5:54PM on 12/28/08
Ribeye...YUM
soozm32 at 5:57PM on 12/28/08
filet mignon
chaswade at 6:00PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse!
cmp45 at 6:00PM on 12/28/08
rib eye is my favorite.
barbaraeford@yahoo.com
bfordy at 6:01PM on 12/28/08
Ribeye is my favorite.
taterbug at 6:01PM on 12/28/08
Most definitely T-bone!!!!
braeuber at 6:01PM on 12/28/08
Ribeye for me please.
dmcavanagh at 6:04PM on 12/28/08
Really, I like a good skirt steak.
iahawk89 at 6:05PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse. My dog Cristina gets the bone. Thanks for the giveaway.
Blue Iris at 6:08PM on 12/28/08
ribeye for me
llinda29 at 6:08PM on 12/28/08
Bone In Ribeye is the best.
LeeCh at 6:09PM on 12/28/08
NY Strip
louiseb130 at 6:10PM on 12/28/08
Ribeye is my fave.
roblyn66 at 6:11PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse is my absolute favorite. Especially when my husband marinates and grills it over wood chips and serves it with sauteed onions and mushrooms. Delectable!
sugarstack at 6:13PM on 12/28/08
NY strip or ribeye - it depends on how its being cooked.
jettabugfox at 6:14PM on 12/28/08
OMG Porterhouse rocks and has to be cooked on the grill!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
vickilorenz at 6:16PM on 12/28/08
porterhouse or ribeye
brooke29 at 6:16PM on 12/28/08
Flatiron!
greenfield at 6:16PM on 12/28/08
ribeye.
umassfen at 6:18PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse is my all time favorite steak.......I am hungry for one now!
caverde at 6:20PM on 12/28/08
either flatiron or filet (depending on if I am paying or not)
feelgood at 6:22PM on 12/28/08
A bone-in rib-eye works just fine for me!
beano at 6:22PM on 12/28/08
Filet Mignon, so tender you can cut it with a fork
pamatmayo at 6:23PM on 12/28/08
ribeye
kalajo at 6:24PM on 12/28/08
skirt steak
carusoc at 6:25PM on 12/28/08
skirt, but if i had the $$ porterhouse all the way
homesmax at 6:26PM on 12/28/08
Bone in ribeye or hanger.
ride&cook at 6:27PM on 12/28/08
the porter!!!
kapnic at 6:27PM on 12/28/08
Kansas City Strip for me.
Reva Skie at 6:27PM on 12/28/08
Filet Mignon!
unavaca at 6:27PM on 12/28/08
ribeye
feep at 6:28PM on 12/28/08
ribeye from a fancy place, flank if it's from the supermarket!
mmclau28 at 6:29PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse, of course.
Diane from PA at 6:29PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse, for sure!
jenberger at 6:30PM on 12/28/08
Count me in with the Porterhouse lovers!
GirlintheCurl at 6:31PM on 12/28/08
Ribeye.
Louisa at 6:31PM on 12/28/08
My fav is the filet mignon!
lisagee at 6:33PM on 12/28/08
porterhouse
mhgatti at 6:36PM on 12/28/08
a simple new york..ive never tried a porterhouse though!
gibbylet at 6:37PM on 12/28/08
I love new york strip.
malleycc at 6:41PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse!
nvtribefan at 6:42PM on 12/28/08
skirt steak
tmbronk at 6:43PM on 12/28/08
filet mignon
semarr at 6:43PM on 12/28/08
NY Strip is my favorite!
lizguillet at 6:43PM on 12/28/08
Bone-in ribeye!
devaleena at 6:46PM on 12/28/08
Ribeye -- but by all means try to change my mind with a honkin' big slab of Porterhouse!
Lauri at 6:46PM on 12/28/08
ribeye
Michael Z at 6:48PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse followed closely by Ny Strip.
esperfect at 6:49PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse
gaba2 at 6:52PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse for two.
Doctorted at 6:53PM on 12/28/08
My favorite is a nice porterhouse or NY Strip. Actually, I love All steaks.
manelook at 6:53PM on 12/28/08
porterhouse
tracker at 6:55PM on 12/28/08
bone in dry aged ribeye.
simon at 6:56PM on 12/28/08
hangar
jasmall at 6:57PM on 12/28/08
ribeye
graciecat at 6:57PM on 12/28/08
sirloin strip
crawdaddy at 6:57PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse for two (served at Peter Lugers.) Seriously, has to be the best steak!
kjrivas at 7:03PM on 12/28/08
If I'm really hungry it's definitely a porterhouse, not so hungry I go with a filet mignon, but always only medium rare.
anyang at 7:03PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse, please!
MadameTart at 7:03PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse for two ala Peter Lugers.
kjrivas at 7:06PM on 12/28/08
T-Bone is best!
keeponwinning at 7:06PM on 12/28/08
porterhouse. always rare.
mandbel711 at 7:06PM on 12/28/08
I LOOOOOOVE filet!
denyse at 7:09PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse has always been my favorite cut of steak. I have not seen this cut in the markets in a long time because it is so expensive no one buys it. My next is the small rib eye.
grannyvon at 7:09PM on 12/28/08
P is for porterhouse, rare, please.
mynameispeaches at 7:09PM on 12/28/08
Ribeye, definitely
blueskyman at 7:11PM on 12/28/08
RIBEYE!
minkler at 7:12PM on 12/28/08
Cheaper than tenderloin, but just as tender and less "delicate": tri-tip
trialbyfood at 7:12PM on 12/28/08
My favorite steak is usually tender, tasty, and nicely prepared. Usually better quality meats are enjoyable to eat, but in my experience, the ribeye is the one to beat.
friendsareus at 7:13PM on 12/28/08
My favorite cut of steak is: NY Strip and funny enough I am from NY ~ lived here all my life.
Thanks for the contest and Happy New Year!
bowlpatty at 7:15PM on 12/28/08
I love porter house steaks. I love them medium rare but I know you are supposed to cook them more fully. I grew up eating them that way and I still love them.
teechbiz at 7:16PM on 12/28/08
ribeye
girlfriday at 7:16PM on 12/28/08
Ribeye...
gb944 at 7:16PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse. Thanks
captunderp at 7:18PM on 12/28/08
my favorite cut of meat would be two prime, dry-aged porterhouse steaks from Peter Luger
allancarol at 7:20PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse, well-done.
ladycat713 at 7:20PM on 12/28/08
Me too Porterhouse
junervy at 7:21PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse, please!
Kerosena at 7:23PM on 12/28/08
porter to the house
alexactly at 7:23PM on 12/28/08
ribeye please
ryansm at 7:23PM on 12/28/08
I love a NY Strip, but I wouldn't say no to a ribeye. And ya know, my birthday is next week... I'm just sayin'.
danguish at 7:26PM on 12/28/08
Ribeye, baby!
joyosity at 7:27PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse or ribeye.
Spicy at 7:28PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse!! And hanger if I am being more economical.
jinx35 at 7:28PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse, with the tray tipped up to let the juices run down to the end, Peter Luger style.
secretwoid at 7:29PM on 12/28/08
Filet mignon
alanbar at 7:30PM on 12/28/08
ribeye.
mango at 7:31PM on 12/28/08
Bacon wrapped Filet Mignon
barbmccrea at 7:33PM on 12/28/08
Love me a good ribeye. But two porterhouses from Peter Luger will do in a pinch.
eschk at 7:33PM on 12/28/08
Ribeye. All day.
reason143 at 7:35PM on 12/28/08
I go NY Strip for straight up "cow on the grill".
jakesutton at 7:36PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse. YUM!
jymbrittain at 7:37PM on 12/28/08
No question--" RIBEYE"
TxBubba at 7:38PM on 12/28/08
Have always enjoyed sirloins (and flanks, but that's almost a different beast entirely), but I'll always be happy with a porterhouse.
Yrmencyn at 7:38PM on 12/28/08
NY Strip is my fav. Thanks so much for this giveaway.
peg42 at 7:40PM on 12/28/08
Love the Filet
schlomo1 at 7:41PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse. Best of luck to everyone!
UncleVic at 7:41PM on 12/28/08
Filet is first choice, Porterhouse close second...
medictom at 7:42PM on 12/28/08
I love filet mignon, but the porterhouse steaks sound great.
arvard at 7:44PM on 12/28/08
New york strip is my favorite, but a porterhouse is also good.
bobbob6996 at 7:48PM on 12/28/08
Tbone, followed closely by Ribeye. Grilled Rare, served with Salt and pepper, a little pat of butter melting on top. Best sides would be Garlic mashed with skins still in, Grilled Corn, Garden Salad and a warm Ciabatta Bun. Serve with an Ice cold bottle of apple cider. For Dessert a steaming bowl of Rhubarb Crisp and some double churned vanilla ice cream.
thepirateking at 7:49PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse on the grill is my favorite followed closely by a t-bone.
Traumajunky at 7:50PM on 12/28/08
FLANK!
Nebagakid at 7:53PM on 12/28/08
I love ny strip!
JennVozik at 7:54PM on 12/28/08
Fillet mignon all the way
telcon at 7:55PM on 12/28/08
Ribeye.
katarina_santiago at 7:56PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse - medium rare. And a very empty stomach so that I can eat it all.
laila at 7:58PM on 12/28/08
Ribeye.............mmm
bambi4 at 7:58PM on 12/28/08
porterhouse baby!
realghostbuster at 7:58PM on 12/28/08
Ribeye, please.
MarkDPelhamNY at 7:59PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse and husband's favorite is New York strip. Thanks for the opportunity to win this fabulous gift.
elaine nan at 8:05PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse.
bobgoss at 8:05PM on 12/28/08
Ribeye - of course!
dedge at 8:07PM on 12/28/08
I love t bones. My granddad used to grill them all the time. I can taste the memories.
bennigancat at 8:09PM on 12/28/08
love the filet!
rachelleb at 8:12PM on 12/28/08
Ribeye cooked medium rare, accompanied by a nice glass of red wine.
jausten at 8:12PM on 12/28/08
...favorite cut of beef is ribeye (with a side of grilled onions & peppers).
brianpiero at 8:13PM on 12/28/08
Baseball / Cullotte. Rare, please.
xxuviolkd at 8:14PM on 12/28/08
My favorite is broiled porterhouse with a side of carmelized onions and sauteed mushrooms
peaches41 at 8:17PM on 12/28/08
fillet mignon
susan1215 at 8:18PM on 12/28/08
Ribeye
rffoodie at 8:21PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse, dry rubbed with spices, and lightly seared.
jabajabahay09 at 8:22PM on 12/28/08
Ribeye for me too!
wittybob at 8:30PM on 12/28/08
Filet is ONE of my favorites.
forkmtn at 8:30PM on 12/28/08
Ribeye
smythbr at 8:33PM on 12/28/08
porterhouse for 2 cooked medium rare.
in fact, give me 2 of them. one to eat and one to put in my pants
OH JOY
BurgerConquest at 8:37PM on 12/28/08
Prime Rib, medium rare with lots of horseradish
mcnerd at 8:37PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse, of course!
page48 at 8:38PM on 12/28/08
Bone-in rib eye
1stmakearoux at 8:39PM on 12/28/08
filet!
valser at 8:39PM on 12/28/08
Two inch thick filet medium rare please!
tshelfer at 8:40PM on 12/28/08
Rib Eye is the best!
smokeykat at 8:41PM on 12/28/08
T-Bone!
mozart23 at 8:43PM on 12/28/08
I like a T-bone medium rare (more rare than medium). I've never had Peter Luger's so I hope I win!
tugttw at 8:43PM on 12/28/08
ny strip for me
Noodlez at 8:44PM on 12/28/08
Ribeye is my true favorite!
jh70095 at 8:45PM on 12/28/08
Keep it lean - filet mignon.
ky2here at 8:46PM on 12/28/08
Pretty hard to beat the bacon-wrapped filet mignons we had for Christmas dinner.
paints at 8:47PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse makes my taste buds dance with joy.
allaboutme1 at 8:49PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse, duh.
Xtreambar at 8:50PM on 12/28/08
Filet mignon is my favorite.
fairydancer at 8:50PM on 12/28/08
deckle
cwong at 8:51PM on 12/28/08
Hanger steak is great, for the rare times when you can find it advertised on menus. Otherwise, top sirloin is hard to beat for flavor. I usually like the flavor better than ribeye.
ChrisP at 8:52PM on 12/28/08
NY strip
lezanac at 8:52PM on 12/28/08
shell steak
js1604 at 8:53PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse, strip, rib-eye...I love them all!
lisargold at 8:54PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse!
jmerville at 8:55PM on 12/28/08
Strip
bajjmayer at 8:55PM on 12/28/08
porterhouse!
brianru at 8:56PM on 12/28/08
I love porterhouse steaks, great cut of meat!
vlmolina at 8:56PM on 12/28/08
ribeye
angela67p at 8:59PM on 12/28/08
Ribeye
ericrathbun at 9:01PM on 12/28/08
NY strip
cbroth at 9:08PM on 12/28/08
Filet baby. So good.
TexasKevin at 9:11PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse, with a bone to share with our dog, Ike.
Suzzanne at 9:14PM on 12/28/08
filet mignon, medium please!
friedom at 9:16PM on 12/28/08
I love a big Filet meduim rare please
mombert5 at 9:19PM on 12/28/08
ny strip
cadmar at 9:21PM on 12/28/08
t-bone, rare!
yoni191 at 9:22PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse
gunbuster at 9:24PM on 12/28/08
ny strip or a porterhouse for more than one person sharing
jlipof at 9:28PM on 12/28/08
Boneless Ribeye
debiwelbon at 9:32PM on 12/28/08
filet!
piepie at 9:32PM on 12/28/08
ny strip
mudrunnersmom at 9:32PM on 12/28/08
prime rib
tracirick at 9:33PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse, of course. It's the best of both worlds. Yummm!
Perkins1011 at 9:33PM on 12/28/08
rib eye
toastworthy at 9:38PM on 12/28/08
New York Strip!
tara20639 at 9:40PM on 12/28/08
filet mignon
zekks at 9:40PM on 12/28/08
porterhouse
jeanilyne at 9:41PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse with lobster (surf & turf!!!), also prime rib
24taz48 at 9:44PM on 12/28/08
Filet mignon cooked medium-well with loads of sauteed mushrooms. Yum!
heathercore at 9:45PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse!!
FoodBoy at 9:46PM on 12/28/08
Filet mignon, bacon-wrapped, topped with chipotle cheddar.
EvilTimmy at 9:48PM on 12/28/08
ribeye
puppychao at 9:52PM on 12/28/08
I love porterhouses too!
puppychao at 9:52PM on 12/28/08
porterhouse for beefsteak florentine
pksmash at 9:55PM on 12/28/08
I love a NY strip
Marilouise at 9:57PM on 12/28/08
T bone-you need that bone in to make the steak moist and give it great flavor. However I'll take a prime cut of steak any way, any day.
ryanwex at 10:05PM on 12/28/08
t-bone
Eddie at 10:07PM on 12/28/08
Filet Mignon rare
susanmac at 10:09PM on 12/28/08
Charcoal Grilled Ribeye MR
Jillyctrs2 at 10:17PM on 12/28/08
Ribeye medium YUM!
Athornhill at 10:17PM on 12/28/08
Filet Mignon, medium rare!
jlsmei at 10:18PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse fer sure!
sauerkrautball at 10:22PM on 12/28/08
any Peter Luger Steak is a treat
kathyvegas at 10:25PM on 12/28/08
RIBEYE
cjopperman at 10:27PM on 12/28/08
Not sure, but I have had T- bone before and I loved it. MMM chew on the bone.
abuie at 10:32PM on 12/28/08
mmmmmmm. ribeye.
misslisa at 10:36PM on 12/28/08
ribeye is my favorite by far and the runner up would be new york strip and either cooked on a grill YUMMMM
pamelakrest at 10:41PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse!
dhl01 at 10:42PM on 12/28/08
Ribeye!
jashelep23 at 10:43PM on 12/28/08
the magical ribeye
beardaxe at 10:44PM on 12/28/08
I've really never met a steak that I didn't like, but porterhouse is probably my top choice.
chrissy75007 at 10:46PM on 12/28/08
Filet Mignon!
hamkracker at 10:51PM on 12/28/08
Filet Mignon - Medium Rare
RitaM4 at 10:53PM on 12/28/08
porterhouse 4 me
routewrecker at 10:54PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse is my favorite cut of steak.
Thanks so much for the contest.
mullin at 10:55PM on 12/28/08
Flank steak.
jkershen at 10:56PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse
atreau at 10:59PM on 12/28/08
bone-in ribeye
paulaauerbach at 10:59PM on 12/28/08
I like filet mignon.
jayfr at 10:59PM on 12/28/08
My favorite is Filet mignon.
lfhpueblo at 11:00PM on 12/28/08
Is it fair to say I like T-bone? After all it is two distinct types of steak in a single cut. It's given me more pleasure than any other cut. Ribeye comes close. Sirloin has to be treated right or I can't eat it. Medium please, not too pink.
BMTNY at 11:02PM on 12/28/08
A package of two prime, dry-aged ("longer than four weeks") porterhouse steaks, steak sauce and chocolate!
taintnoflatlander at 11:02PM on 12/28/08
Strip steak, all the way :-)
chef17 at 11:03PM on 12/28/08
Ribeye. Always. Nicely rare. Preferably with scalloped potatoes and green beans :-)
CharJTF at 11:08PM on 12/28/08
Ribeye for me - Porterhouse for husband - he's a bigger eater than me.
susitravl at 11:12PM on 12/28/08
Ribeye, bbq'd to medium perfection
dwhogan at 11:14PM on 12/28/08
Ribeye
cmcentee20 at 11:20PM on 12/28/08
Definitely the porterhouse. How can you go wrong with a filet, a strip, and a bone to savor?
JellyPA at 11:20PM on 12/28/08
rib-eye
cgreggo at 11:21PM on 12/28/08
Mmmm. . . porterhouse!
purplepassion126 at 11:24PM on 12/28/08
new york strip smothered in picado
scottdavislasvegas at 11:27PM on 12/28/08
tbone and porterhouse are my favs!
bduppa at 11:33PM on 12/28/08
A well done ribeye with some oven roasted veggies and mashed potatoes. Yummmmmy!
Summermouse at 11:34PM on 12/28/08
Ribeye!
passion4eating at 11:37PM on 12/28/08
NY Strip all the way (into my belly).
foodcoma at 11:39PM on 12/28/08
A rare porterhouse or filet mignon.
lyonsksl at 11:39PM on 12/28/08
filet mignon
rosabarto at 11:40PM on 12/28/08
I like New York Strip... served by my gf... who's wearing nothing but a smile... ;)
ghostamongyou at 11:41PM on 12/28/08
porterhouse or ribeye
QK224 at 11:46PM on 12/28/08
Filet. Mignon.
Tobster1 at 11:47PM on 12/28/08
porterhouse
jscheck at 11:49PM on 12/28/08
new york strip steak...my step=father cooked one for me every year on my birthday when i was growing up
mobileoma at 11:50PM on 12/28/08
Porterhouse! Thanks!
lisalmg25 at 11:50PM on 12/28/08
Can't afford it, but LOVE Porterhouse! Mmmm.
lisaray at 11:50PM on 12/28/08
My favorite is Ribeye. Thanks!
mistyriver at 11:51PM on 12/28/08
Ribeye!
jenilowrance at 11:57PM on 12/28/08
I'll eat them all, but my favorite has got to be a good filet mignon. Thanks!
rchung77 at 12:07AM on 12/29/08
porterhouse yes
guterbni at 12:09AM on 12/29/08
I love round steak. It's lean and there is so much you can do with it.
skytoucher at 12:10AM on 12/29/08
Porterhouse is my favorite. I really do love steak! Thanks!
iowamom at 12:14AM on 12/29/08
T-bone
dolls123 at 12:17AM on 12/29/08
Porterhouse
guthrieward at 12:20AM on 12/29/08
A thick cut rib steak.
elliepayson at 12:21AM on 12/29/08
definitely porterhouse
skim at 12:24AM on 12/29/08
Ribeye
madeas at 12:25AM on 12/29/08
New York strip
Gwenelle at 12:26AM on 12/29/08
NY strip
babycat1216 at 12:29AM on 12/29/08
Filet Mignon, medium rare
artmarcia at 12:31AM on 12/29/08
Depends on my mood, but I'll go with T-bone.
Sekhmet at 12:33AM on 12/29/08
A sizzling hot Porterhouse. Yum!
winnerbrooke at 12:35AM on 12/29/08
Porterhouse please.
JustinP at 12:38AM on 12/29/08
porterhouse, well done.
theolotto at 12:43AM on 12/29/08
A Porterhouse with a nice crust
The Feaster at 12:46AM on 12/29/08
Filet, make mine moo~
Catrona_sweeps at 12:51AM on 12/29/08
Any steak is nice but the porterhouse is the best.
billie1977 at 12:52AM on 12/29/08
ribeye ribeye!
toastykitten at 12:55AM on 12/29/08
nice thick ribeye medium rare
nellnell at 1:00AM on 12/29/08
I love me a good bloody T-bone.
Pointy at 1:06AM on 12/29/08
shell on the bone
besbes at 1:09AM on 12/29/08
yummy porterhouse!
heavenlydonny at 1:10AM on 12/29/08
Porterhouse
sarahinnewyork at 1:12AM on 12/29/08
Porterhouse, t-bone, ribeye, I love them all!
willitara at 1:23AM on 12/29/08
prime rib - rare
azrosebud at 1:28AM on 12/29/08
Rib Eye
smallchou at 1:29AM on 12/29/08
definitely filet
sharsd at 1:34AM on 12/29/08
i love a filet mignon myself
rdazer at 2:01AM on 12/29/08
gotta be a ribeye!!
sw8t at 2:03AM on 12/29/08
1 1/2" thick ribeye- seared 4 min. each side then 4 min in a 425 degree oven to medium rare...absolute ambrosia for a serious carnivore such as I! Try it...you'll love it!
hickcrazy1 at 2:11AM on 12/29/08
Bone in strip
zEli173 at 2:20AM on 12/29/08
New York Strip steak.
dksbook at 2:22AM on 12/29/08
Filet mignon is my favorite.
annulla at 2:24AM on 12/29/08
porterhouse.
icecreamsandwich at 2:28AM on 12/29/08
porterhouse
JOYVEN at 2:32AM on 12/29/08
Porterhouse is my favorite.
bhager at 2:59AM on 12/29/08
Porterhouse
sdeas at 3:02AM on 12/29/08
I love Porterhouse, my dad used to cook these when i was a kid. I also like Fillets. this is a great offer, thank you kindly
smrtim at 3:03AM on 12/29/08
RIBEYE
nenieves at 3:06AM on 12/29/08
Porterhouse steak, maybe a little bernaise on the side...
jms24 at 3:08AM on 12/29/08
Filet Mignon
Witchbaby at 3:58AM on 12/29/08
I am partial to a bone in ribeye, just short of medium
kimblyl at 4:01AM on 12/29/08
Love Ribeye.
cgeo2000 at 4:20AM on 12/29/08
got to have the skirt steak!
samanthapayntr at 4:26AM on 12/29/08
A nice big Rib-Eye
Dove420 at 4:57AM on 12/29/08
porterhouse -- the best of both worlds!
Perkins10 at 5:13AM on 12/29/08
filet
intime at 5:20AM on 12/29/08
pleeease. the best steak must be a dry-aged porterhouse!
cheers at 5:26AM on 12/29/08
My favorite steak is a porterhouse.
AsTheNight at 5:29AM on 12/29/08
Filet, ribeye, NY strip, I'll take any steak cooked properly!
bobcatsteph3 at 5:30AM on 12/29/08
New York
miriama59 at 5:31AM on 12/29/08
ny strip
dhow1611 at 5:49AM on 12/29/08
Ribeye, ribeye and ribeye.
heaventrees at 5:55AM on 12/29/08
Filet!
neojess at 5:56AM on 12/29/08
I like a ribeye steak.
rrshep at 6:11AM on 12/29/08
filet
dtaylor98 at 6:13AM on 12/29/08
Filet Mignon for me. Thanks.
clc408 at 6:27AM on 12/29/08
Ribeye
Joyce424 at 6:30AM on 12/29/08
porterhouseis my fav, you get to cuts in one steak. the tender lion and the strip. yummmmmmmmmmmmm
jimbo555 at 6:36AM on 12/29/08
filet
tholder55 at 6:58AM on 12/29/08
New York strip, please.
JonsDad at 7:03AM on 12/29/08
filet mignon
jean8 at 7:04AM on 12/29/08
Ribeye is my favorite!
susanry at 7:12AM on 12/29/08
Ribeye for sure. Fat means flavor right?
Jarod8bit at 7:13AM on 12/29/08
Delmonico, here
blday50 at 7:18AM on 12/29/08
king cut prime rib
toughturtles at 7:24AM on 12/29/08
porterhouse
miamia at 7:40AM on 12/29/08
Filet Mignon
Faither at 7:43AM on 12/29/08
I like a rare Delmonico, grilled and seasoned just right.
ketsil at 7:45AM on 12/29/08
Filet Mignon cooked Medium Rare
idahomom at 7:51AM on 12/29/08
Depends on the occasion...in no particular order...skirt, ribeye, porterhouse.
derosa at 7:52AM on 12/29/08
Porterhouse is my favorite cut, but I won't turn down a strip steak.
sito50 at 7:59AM on 12/29/08
Actually I have two: t-bone and porterhouse! YUM!
maxineu at 7:59AM on 12/29/08
I love porterhouse.
dlguss at 8:00AM on 12/29/08
Filet is my favorite
silverbele at 8:01AM on 12/29/08
Usually, NY strip steaks, but my guys would be in heaven with the porterhouse steaks.
mcferret at 8:01AM on 12/29/08
Ribeye
tlcfromtn at 8:14AM on 12/29/08
Ribeye, but I like T-bone and Sirloin, too.
amylou61 at 8:16AM on 12/29/08
Filet mignon.
finsbigfan at 8:27AM on 12/29/08
prime rib, rare
lsfish at 8:32AM on 12/29/08
I love ribeye!
lilyk at 8:34AM on 12/29/08
New York Strip - med rare..yummmmm
missdenisepa at 8:35AM on 12/29/08
Ribeye or porterhouse.
Miss Solemnis at 8:36AM on 12/29/08
Filet Mignon
Devacat at 8:45AM on 12/29/08
have not been to Peter Luger's for YEARS - anything from there would be a great treat!
gorzd at 8:45AM on 12/29/08
Prime rib is best, but almost any steak is good.
clynsg at 8:47AM on 12/29/08
Ribeye, dry-aged in my cellar (in a mini refridge devoted to the purpose) for 8 weeks, grilled over mesquite and rare.
the_next_meal at 8:49AM on 12/29/08
New York strip is lovely.
danwalk at 8:51AM on 12/29/08
I love a good sirloin, must be grilled rare. Thanks for a great giveaway!
trishden at 8:53AM on 12/29/08
Filet Mignon!
jacvil at 8:53AM on 12/29/08
Ribeye - Medium rare
yaddayaddayadda at 8:56AM on 12/29/08
Ribeye or Porterhouse, med rare.
ladyvon5845 at 8:57AM on 12/29/08
porterhouse
mixedberries at 9:01AM on 12/29/08
Skirt Steak!!!
Visually it is a beautifully marbled and striated cut that begs to be cooked quickly over high heat. Skirt steak takes on seasoning well and when cooked perfectly it has a pink juicy center and a crunchy fire kissed outside.
shiso at 9:02AM on 12/29/08
Ribeye or Porterhouse! Awesome!
jgp781 at 9:04AM on 12/29/08
hands down it has to be prime rib.
etrnlone at 9:05AM on 12/29/08
porterhouse
mmiller at 9:05AM on 12/29/08
Porterhouse of course.
herbiets at 9:06AM on 12/29/08
T Bone is my favorite cut
katmagick at 9:06AM on 12/29/08
marinated rib eye for me :)
elmomomi at 9:08AM on 12/29/08
london broil/flank steak
cbm479 at 9:10AM on 12/29/08
filet
fostertam at 9:11AM on 12/29/08
bone in filet
joeyd at 9:14AM on 12/29/08
love that porterhouse
AICORP at 9:17AM on 12/29/08
New York Strip already.
gratefulted at 9:20AM on 12/29/08
Filet Midnon because I'm always watching my weight...but when I'm celebrating, itr's always porterhouse! It's so flavorful!
Lynnharasym at 9:21AM on 12/29/08
T-bone garettsambo@aol.com
garrettsambo at 9:21AM on 12/29/08
Porterhouse!
sfullers at 9:25AM on 12/29/08
A nice thick Ribeye. Yummy! Thank you
tatertot374@sbcglobal.net
tatertot374 at 9:26AM on 12/29/08
ribeye!
krusemark at 9:26AM on 12/29/08
Porterhouse is sublime!
tozier at 9:26AM on 12/29/08
Ribeye, medium rare please.
newyorker at 9:27AM on 12/29/08
filet
swordfish at 9:27AM on 12/29/08
ribeye
AbbyF at 9:30AM on 12/29/08
a well grilled thin sliced flank
gervitsd at 9:32AM on 12/29/08
Mmmmmm...I love a good Tenderloin Medium Rare!
divaqueenie at 9:33AM on 12/29/08
NY Strip Steak would be devine!!! It makes my tastebuds water just thinking about it!
trossy at 9:38AM on 12/29/08
I love flank steak!
Tarah716 at 9:40AM on 12/29/08
I love a New York strip, cooked a proper medium with a little crispy fat on the edge. What am I doing here? I gotta fire up the grill!
Great prize, hope I win this one. I might even share it with my sweetie.
daw212(at)msn(dot)com
daw212 at 9:42AM on 12/29/08
porterhouse - of course!
daltjb at 9:43AM on 12/29/08
My favorite is a ribeye steak.
chica6969 at 9:43AM on 12/29/08
There's nothing like a juicy, grilled rib-eye steak!! It has its own unique, mouth-watering flavor! Thank you for the contest!
txgigggles@yahoo.com
txgiggles45 at 9:45AM on 12/29/08
For the best balance of flavor, tenderness, and juiciness - it's a ribeye - medium rare please.
biztekpc at 9:46AM on 12/29/08
My favorite animal is steak. Rib eye, baby!
Noswar at 9:56AM on 12/29/08
new york strip is my fav
lyndascrafty at 10:00AM on 12/29/08
Gotta have porterhouse steak here. The best possible cuts.
Bagoas at 10:02AM on 12/29/08
porterhouse
foodinmouth at 10:04AM on 12/29/08
Ribeye is my favorite
Lyris1321 at 10:05AM on 12/29/08
My fav is filet mignon!!!
martuley at 10:05AM on 12/29/08
Porterhouse, for sure. Can't afford it very often, though
caseycupcake at 10:07AM on 12/29/08
Porterhouse.
ddggr at 10:07AM on 12/29/08
Ribeye
Brewer at 10:08AM on 12/29/08
porterhouse!!
nighthawk at 10:10AM on 12/29/08
Ribeye.. a nice filet when I'm trying to be healthy
Bugsy at 10:10AM on 12/29/08
Give me a ribeye - medium rare please.
ELYSESW at 10:13AM on 12/29/08
Yummm, Im not to picky. I like lots of good cuts. Filet, NY strip, Porterhouse, T-Bone. Their all good.
Thank you for the great giveaway!
JH33194 at 10:17AM on 12/29/08
Ribeye, baby, ribeye!
drmagazine at 10:18AM on 12/29/08
Uhmmmmm meat!
pcoop1 at 10:19AM on 12/29/08
ribeye!!!
plowlady at 10:22AM on 12/29/08
Ribeye, Medium Rare
NO_Pam at 10:23AM on 12/29/08
flank steak
lakeloverhh at 10:25AM on 12/29/08
Why it's dry aged porter house of course!
dove1960 at 10:31AM on 12/29/08
Porterhouse, medium rare! Thank you!
Tina12312 at 10:35AM on 12/29/08
Anything from Peter Luger's would be absolutely divine, but if I have to choose, it would be a ribeye. Thanks for the contest!
zozanee at 10:37AM on 12/29/08
R I B E Y E
okclint at 10:38AM on 12/29/08
Filet Mignon
janmarkel at 10:38AM on 12/29/08
Flame grilled rib-eye or porterhouse!
inkystuff at 10:38AM on 12/29/08
Porterhouse, medium rare, or a T-bone
avman at 10:52AM on 12/29/08
New York Strip, pink and juicy on the inside, Charred (Pittsburgh) on the outside. MMMMMMMM
Thanks for hosting a great giveaway!
cybrlee at 10:54AM on 12/29/08
filet mignon- yum!
Twipey at 10:58AM on 12/29/08
Filet - medium rare
4829248 at 10:58AM on 12/29/08
Filet Mignon
216amyc at 11:04AM on 12/29/08
skirt steak marinated in a blue cheese marinade and grilled to medium rare.
hungrylikethewolf at 11:07AM on 12/29/08
Skirt! Hanger!
LadyMarmalade at 11:10AM on 12/29/08
Filet Mignon is my favorite, can't afford it but love it
kdkdkd at 11:12AM on 12/29/08
porterhouse of course
samandsandy at 11:12AM on 12/29/08
porterhouse
piehole at 11:20AM on 12/29/08
filet mignon
marathonnh at 11:21AM on 12/29/08
ribeye...
hookrilla at 11:26AM on 12/29/08
filet!
amywoz at 11:27AM on 12/29/08
I love ribeye!
leeleemac at 11:29AM on 12/29/08
filet mignon
mistablitz at 11:37AM on 12/29/08
yey porterhouse!
mcc32 at 11:39AM on 12/29/08
Ribeye!
EmilyN at 11:48AM on 12/29/08
porterhouse..but I'll never turn down any good steak
elaine nan at 11:51AM on 12/29/08
Ribeye
Bingo at 11:52AM on 12/29/08
NY Strip
gregb at 11:53AM on 12/29/08
Ribeye--Charred on the outside and still pink in the middle. Smothered with garlic butter and sauted mushrooms. Yum
jmerk06 at 11:55AM on 12/29/08
The flat iron steak at Higgins in Portland, Oregon, is the most tender steak I've ever eaten and so flavorful.
galeogirl at 11:55AM on 12/29/08
Love a small sirloin~medium rare!
lynderae at 11:59AM on 12/29/08
Ribeye!
gurizzy at 11:59AM on 12/29/08
Ribeye
foodhuntress at 12:03PM on 12/29/08
My favorite cut of steak is Prime dry-aged PORTERHOUSE
preskiteer at 12:03PM on 12/29/08
I love the ribeye best.
Nesie at 12:11PM on 12/29/08
Bone-in ribeye, medium rare!
pcrackenhead at 12:19PM on 12/29/08
I always order filet mignon
emkaye at 12:20PM on 12/29/08
Probably the petit filet mignon.
cowleyh at 12:22PM on 12/29/08
I like a top sirloin wrapped in bacon
dianerph at 12:26PM on 12/29/08
Rib eye of course
gambler72 at 12:29PM on 12/29/08
Wow... this is a tough choice, but the tenderloin side of Porterhouse (medium rare) gets my vote.
ledbetse at 12:29PM on 12/29/08
Porterhouse or marinated flank steak both pink but not bloody.
kevlney at 12:32PM on 12/29/08
Has anyone actually won one of these things?
Ribeye
Pupster at 12:32PM on 12/29/08
I've always loved Filet Mignon
penemio at 12:35PM on 12/29/08
While filet mignon is my favorite for going out to eat, my favorite to cook is probably skirt steak.
bansidhe at 12:37PM on 12/29/08
Porterhouse or something else nice and fatty
heikkinen at 12:38PM on 12/29/08
strip!
jknepfle at 12:42PM on 12/29/08
Porterhouse
sjwoodin at 12:42PM on 12/29/08
Chicago Chop!!
Belsbernd at 12:42PM on 12/29/08
Porterhouse!
threedogkitchen at 12:50PM on 12/29/08
Porterhouse on the grille
peatheski at 12:50PM on 12/29/08
Ribeye, yumm!
kbama at 12:51PM on 12/29/08
We like porterhouse steak. Thanks for having the contest and Happy New Year to all!
brmetcalf at 1:03PM on 12/29/08
I love a good filet!
nesta67 at 1:05PM on 12/29/08
every
maportofu at 1:16PM on 12/29/08
Nothing beats a filet mignon!
TOMFARL at 1:16PM on 12/29/08
flank steak cooked on the grill...smothered in onions
chuchubi at 1:16PM on 12/29/08
I go through different phases and have learned different ways to prepare all the cuts of meat. But, I have always loved Filet Mignon.
Bakersdozen at 1:16PM on 12/29/08
ribeye FTW!
SteveB at 1:16PM on 12/29/08
ooh, the center cut of tenderloin please ;D
munny at 1:17PM on 12/29/08
T-bone
winkyj at 1:19PM on 12/29/08
porterhouse
lavenhouse at 1:24PM on 12/29/08
Ribeye
kcook84 at 1:27PM on 12/29/08
skirt steak
eastcoastvb at 1:32PM on 12/29/08
a nice Filet Mignon
Firestorm51 at 1:35PM on 12/29/08
T-bone
gschaefer at 1:36PM on 12/29/08
Sirloin
derekt1 at 1:44PM on 12/29/08
T-Bone
mrstrooper at 1:59PM on 12/29/08
in my house, it's a porterhouse!
nightmoon at 1:59PM on 12/29/08
Medium-rare ribeye!
JungMan at 2:05PM on 12/29/08
a T-Bone for me!
pinkyga1 at 2:06PM on 12/29/08
I like new york strips
dakotamoon at 2:07PM on 12/29/08
A big, thick, well marbled rib eye, grilled medium-rare over a real wood fire !
hk5685 at 2:11PM on 12/29/08
ribeye!
foodiegirl at 2:19PM on 12/29/08
Ribeye!!!
nichole at 2:23PM on 12/29/08
My favorite is filet mignon! Thank you!
mommyto2 at 2:25PM on 12/29/08
filet mignon!
rainbowbrite7576 at 2:31PM on 12/29/08
new york strip
harstark at 2:32PM on 12/29/08
Ribeye for me, Porterhouse for the old man!!!
sherri19 at 2:38PM on 12/29/08
Porterhouse--they're the best!!!
jayhawker at 2:39PM on 12/29/08
My FAVORITE CUT OF MEAT IS THE RIBEYE, A BIG OLE' JUICY FAT LADEN 16 OZ WONDER!!!
tatertex at 2:43PM on 12/29/08
I love a good ribeye.
andreect at 2:46PM on 12/29/08
Ribeye, yumm. Thanx for the contest.
kmbennet at 2:53PM on 12/29/08
filet mignon
Sunnyvale at 2:54PM on 12/29/08
Sirloin Steak!
bhjustice at 2:58PM on 12/29/08
ribeye baby ribeye hot off the grill
johnney47 at 2:58PM on 12/29/08
ribeye
billwinsbig at 3:05PM on 12/29/08
Rib Eye is the best, most suculent steak!!
sandyza at 3:11PM on 12/29/08
Prefer a ribeye cooked charred on the outside and pink and warm on the inside.
rcstout12 at 3:12PM on 12/29/08
I love sirloin, cooked medium well with a bit of garlic rub! This is a fantastic giveaway; can't even imagine if I was lucky enough to win!
lilacflowers180 AT yahoo DOT com
LadyJemima at 3:16PM on 12/29/08
Porterhouse
schnitzel at 3:18PM on 12/29/08
Ribeye
bagstac at 3:19PM on 12/29/08
ribeye
prolda at 3:22PM on 12/29/08
Porterhouse -- cooked in a cast iron skillet, medium rare!
Quidnunc at 3:25PM on 12/29/08
porterhouse is the yummiest
llcool2u2 at 3:26PM on 12/29/08
ribeye,cooked over charcoal, rare
2martinis at 3:51PM on 12/29/08
Porterhouse or ribeye...medium rare
storm5 at 3:51PM on 12/29/08
Ribeye...no Filet Mignon...no KC Strip...no Ribeye... OK, I can't decide on a favorite...I love a good juicy steak anyway!
nlarma at 3:52PM on 12/29/08
porterhouse
redron at 3:53PM on 12/29/08
Filet mignon ... wrapped in bacon please!
droller02 at 4:17PM on 12/29/08
Porterhouse medium rare, browned in a skillet then placed in the oven for a perfectly cooked steak!
Berkeley2306 at 4:26PM on 12/29/08
I love a great Porterhouse.
cdziuba at 4:44PM on 12/29/08
my favorite is ribeye mmmmm good
blueeyeleo at 4:49PM on 12/29/08
I like T-Bone
bosslady2898 at 5:02PM on 12/29/08
Filet Mignon
garnet63@msn.com
myfflyn at 5:08PM on 12/29/08
NY Strip
CAROLTENNIS at 5:09PM on 12/29/08
Bone-in ribeye
slvance at 5:10PM on 12/29/08
Porterhouse. As rare as possible.
Saoder at 5:10PM on 12/29/08
Poterhouse
dlfone at 5:12PM on 12/29/08
I really love Flat iron steak!
HSlater351 at 5:22PM on 12/29/08
Filet mignon
julis55 at 5:34PM on 12/29/08
My favorite is Filet Mignon and my husband's is bone- Rib-Eye (Or Saratoga) - SO a great big, top-quality Porterhouse is our idea of perfection!
Salleefur at 5:37PM on 12/29/08
t-bone on the grill
cthewig at 5:42PM on 12/29/08
Filet Mignon for me and RibEye for my husband!
terrigogo at 5:42PM on 12/29/08
porterhouse
deckit at 5:52PM on 12/29/08
My Hubby makes the best ribeye, so that's my favorite!
Twincere at 5:59PM on 12/29/08
T-Bone is my favorite cut.
dawn0124 at 6:27PM on 12/29/08
my favorite cut of steak is the T-Bone!
madamerkf at 6:28PM on 12/29/08
porterhouse
klp1965 at 6:45PM on 12/29/08
Definitely Ribeye steak. But I'd take a real good cut of T-Bone if no Ribeye were to be had. After all...beef it what I crave.
Noggy at 6:51PM on 12/29/08
love the porterhouse.
jdbaron at 7:00PM on 12/29/08
An inch thick ribeye steak seasoned with a little salt and pepper cooked medium rare over a hot wood grill, yummy.
waltkoons at 7:07PM on 12/29/08
Today I'm in the mood for a charbroiled pepper-crusted sirloin. Make mine medium-rare, please. Thanks for the offer!
geekbearinggifts at 7:30PM on 12/29/08
porterhouse - med rare
greenda at 7:33PM on 12/29/08
hey, a good win
1mmentor at 7:43PM on 12/29/08
I love the porthouse steak!
OULori at 7:58PM on 12/29/08
Ribeye!
fatbuddy at 8:02PM on 12/29/08
I always forget which one I like better--sirloin or NY strip. But yummy!
blueviolet at 8:22PM on 12/29/08
ihavent had a steak in so long i would love this!
gimmesweeps2 at 8:32PM on 12/29/08
Bone-in ribeye for sure
decadent at 8:47PM on 12/29/08
I would love a NY Strip. I also love skirt steak
dn6511 at 8:51PM on 12/29/08
mmmmmmmmmmmmmm porterhouse - med rare
lr_bjorklund at 9:13PM on 12/29/08
t bone
annmuth at 9:34PM on 12/29/08
Peter Luger rocks! Porterhouse is my fav
dpripps at 10:03PM on 12/29/08
Bone in Rib Eye...RARE
my favorite...
smvalvo at 10:03PM on 12/29/08
I love a good Tbone. MMmmmm
qwill at 10:34PM on 12/29/08
Sirloin
ZESTYWONDERLAND at 10:48PM on 12/29/08
porterhouse
vibrantfun at 10:53PM on 12/29/08
We love ribeye steak. A strip steak is second choice. But for a special day a standing rib roast is tops!
lkjust at 11:17PM on 12/29/08
My favorite is Kobe Porterhouse.
azdave58 at 11:36PM on 12/29/08
I love a Porterhouse steak, medium rare, with cognac peppercorn sauce. My husband and I order this and split it, just enough for two!
swhitaker99 at 11:54PM on 12/29/08
While I love a nice rib eye thick with dry rub and baked or thin on the grill with seasoning, the mighty Porterhouse is the undisputed champion.
beefitswhatsfordinner at 12:00AM on 12/30/08
a T bone steak sounds good right now!
joyciesdotcom at 12:28AM on 12/30/08
porterhouse!
opjoec2 at 12:28AM on 12/30/08
porterhouse
bettyannie at 6:29AM on 12/30/08
Believe it or not... the best cut I ever grilled was a flat iron steak. Tender like Fillet Mignon, with the beefy taste of a Strip steak. My new favorite.
scotdc at 7:10AM on 12/30/08
Bone-in ribeye
heartinky at 8:37AM on 12/30/08
gotta be ribeye
graciemom at 12:45PM on 12/30/08
filet! but u gotta love the skirt steaks too!
sirrah718 at 12:56PM on 12/30/08
I don't really have a favorite. I just love steak. If I had to pick one it would probably be a filet.
schweetmel at 10:29PM on 12/30/08
Thank you for participating, and congratulations to our winner: chromiumman
Winner has been notified by email and also appears on our Contest Winners page.
Adam Kuban at 4:55PM on 01/05/09