• Share:
  • Send to Reddit
  • Send to StumbleUpon
  • Send to Facebook
  • Send to del.icio.us
  • Send to digg

Do You Wash Melons Before You Eat Them?

20080814-melon.jpg

Photograph from Kanko* on Flickr

Although David Lebovitz will fearlessly eat steak tartare and raw milk cheeses, he confesses that he has been washing melons in soap and water for a few years in light of past large-scale melon recalls. Do you also wash melons before you eat them?

35 Comments:

LOL when you phrase it like that, it makes me feel a bit silly. Yes, I do wash all of my vegetables and fruits with soap and water; kiwis, mangoes, melons, etc. even though I always cut up melons off the rind, as well as other non-appetizing skin, and put the fruits in containers for consumption.

yup...I do. No soap, though.

Yeah, I don't get it -- why would washing a melon ever be necessary? The rind is completely non-edible (or have I been living my entire life under a misconception?).

Agree. I don't wash a pineapple before I peel it either.

If I had just picked the melon in a muddy field I may wash it but I see no reason to soap & water the exterior if I'm just going to peel it and throw the rind away, not eat it.

of course... because if you do not wash them, when you put the knife through to cut it, anything nasty that might be laying on the surface will go with the knife and contaminate the inside...

Just water and a paper towel for me.

People were getting sick from germs on the surface of melons when they cut the fruit so I clean my melons AND am very careful when I peel the fruit.

in culinary school, we learned that melons are top of the list for carrying foodbourne illness. the fields in mexico where many melons are grown are do not have proper toilet facilities for the farm workers, so there can be alot of bad bacteria on the melons.
like MadelynR said, bacteria on the surface are transferred to the flesh of the melon by cutting. the bacteria multiply rapidly without proper refrigeration.
i NEVER buy cut melon from the store & i wash whole melons & store them in the fridge once cut.

Absolutely. As MadelynRodriguez and ocarol expressed, cutting through the unwashed rind will contaminate the melon. I also wash bananas before peeling them. And no, I don't have OCD. I just would rather not ingest E coli or any of its cousins. From what I understand, soap doesn't do a better job than plain water, but a rinse of water and white vinegar is best of all. I keep white vinegar in a spray bottle next to my kitchen sink. I spritz fruit and vegetables thoroughly with vinegar, then rinse well.

OMG, there are no proper toilet facilities in melon fields.... Thanks for the tip. I don't think I would eat another melon anytime soon. They cost over USD100 in Tokyo, where I live, anyway. Gimme an apple any day!

I agree with always thoroughly washing the outside of melons before cutting & I, too, will never buy pre-cut melons at the market.

I wash melons before eating them.

Always wash with water only

OMG does any one not wash all their fruits and vegetables before eating them?

Yes I do; better safe than sorry.

:-( I don't. Now I really feel like the odd man out too. It does make me feel better to know they have bathrooms where most of my melons come from but I've bought plenty from the store over the years too. I'll count myself lucky or stupid that I haven't gotten sick but still probably won't wash my melons in the future.

I've never gotten sick, but I do always wash them, for the reasons set out above. If I'm going to get food poisoning, I'll be damned if I get it from fruit when there are so many 'riskier' foods out there.

I've never washed a melon, banana, or a pineapple, or any other fruit where I don't eat the rind/skin. Hell, I don't think I've ever even washed the skin of an orange, and I used to let those bang around in the bottom of a hot, dirty backpack all day.

I wash everything now...even lemons and limes.

Ok ..I'll admit it..the first time I read the headline all I could think of was.." You're supposed to was Melons??"

LOL but I'm healthy like an ox

Yes. I wash all produce before eating, even organic "washed" greens.

This is a no-brainer to me.

Maybe, I'm just some sort of filthy animal...but soap? Soap is for dishes, not for food. If one is worried about ingesting chemicals or pesticides, would you rather consume the ingredients of most soaps? A quick rinse, sure.... if I'm not really really hungry (which is rare, hehe).
:)

I wash all my produce--I know how many grubby hands probably touched it before mine came along to buy it up. ;)

Bananas? Washing bananas before peeling them?

I understand how germs can be transferred from a knife slicing thru a melon, but you peel bananas by hand... and nothing is slicing thru to the inside.

Definitely, cantaloupes are notorious for being one of the dirtiest fruits out there and they are very difficult to clean because of their rough outer rind.

Yup. Warm, soapy water every time.

unless they are obviously dirty (as in, i can see some dirt on 'em), I don't wash melons (or bananas, or kiwis, or oranges, or anything where i'm not going to eat the outside). why wash the rind, i'm not going to eat it.

foodborne illnesses, gunk on the rind getting onto my knife and then onto the melon, blah blah blah.

immune system. exposing it to itty bitty little melonny bits only makes it stronger. let it be known though, that i was also one of those kids who ate worms, dirt, orange rinds, acorns off the ground, and crabapples off the tree.

Do you wash water before you drink it?

Yes, I wash them, the knife is going through the outer rind that have been sitting in a bin at the market, where it's potentially been handled (not to mention the trip to market, passing through who knows what?). Takes a minute, insures my health.

I don't know why soap, unless it's antibacterial, would help. But I do rinse everything well with water - less to get rid of foodborne illness risk (which, as spinach taught us, rinsing won't take care of), than to wash off pesticide residue (for non-organic food) or other people's hands residue. The five seconds it takes to wash a melon, an avocado, or a lemon seems worthwhile - all three of these are generally cut through the rind before preparing, so obviously any dirt/residue is being drawn on the knife through the edible part. I have never washed a banana, though.

Of course I wash melons before I eat them. The knife goes through the skin and carries whatever was on the skin onto the flesh.

i never wash anything. im just kind of gross like that. i think im slightly hydrophobic.

@FastFoodCritic: I wash bananas before peeling because whatever is on the banana skin would be transferred from my hands to the fruit. Next time you slice one into your cereal, consider how the banana travels from Ecuador, Costa Rica, Colombia, Honduras, the Philippines, Panama, or Guatemala (see http://www.banana.com/farming.html) to your market, and what dreck the fruit has collected on its way. Blech!

I have heard that soap can leave a residue. I always use this veggie wash spray - it does the trick (you should see the color of the water after I wash strawberries with this stuff!). http://www.veggie-wash.com/ I put my produce in a bowl, spray on a bit of the wash, run some water in the bowl and agitate for a minute or so, then rinse several times until the water is clear.

Another reason not to use pre-cut melons: when you put the leftover pieces (if any) in a container for later use, the rind from one slice will invariably touch the slice next to it.
It may sound weird to those of you who insist on NOT washing, but it absolutely isn't weird. Check out any of the YouTube videos re lemons and bacteria and you will immediately be washing every piece of fruit or vegetable in your fridge.
I agree, soap is probably not necessary, but that veggie wash or the water/vinegar combo will work well.

Add a comment:

Comments can take up to a minute to appear - please be patient!

Previewing your comment:

 

HTML Hints

Some HTML is OK: <a href="URL">link</a>, <strong>strong</strong>, <em>em</em>

Comment Guidelines

Post whatever you want, just keep it seriously about eats, seriously. We reserve the right to delete off-topic or inflammatory comments. Learn more at our Comment Policy page.

If you see something not so nice, please, report an inappropriate comment.