The Most-Stained Cookbooks

When the New York Times asked a selection of cookbook users, from chefs to store owners to bloggers, to name their favorite sources of inspiration, a few key cookbooks were cited multiple times. One can only imagine the blotched, dog-eared, well-used pages of the books deemed The Most-Stained Cookbooks—the ones selected by at least four different food professionals as an essential reference.
The list includes classics such as Irma S. Rombauer's The Joy of Cooking, and Mastering the Art of French Cooking by Julia Child, Louisette Bertholle, and Simone Beck, in addition to more modern resources like Harold McGee's On Food and Cooking.
How about you, serious eaters? What are your most loved cookbooks? And just how batter- or soup-stained are their pages?
Add a comment:
Previewing your comment:
HTML Hints
Some HTML is OK: <a href="URL">link</a>, <strong>strong</strong>, <em>em</em>
Comment Guidelines
Post whatever you want, just keep it seriously about eats, seriously. We reserve the right to delete off-topic or inflammatory comments. Learn more at our Comment Policy page.
If you see something not so nice, please, report an inappropriate comment.


50 Comments:
When I was just starting to spread my wings in the kitchen "The Joy of Cooking" took a beating, but in the last 3 years, it's been Anthony Bourdain's "Les Halles Cookbook" and that thing is an absolute mess. Dog-eared, stained (mostly with wine and duck fat), and tons of notes.
The cleanest in my collection? The French Laundry, of course. That book's not allowed in my workspace. Coffee table only. :-)
philn at 6:49PM on 08/07/08
My 25 year old mass market paperback edition of Marcella Hazan's _Classic Italian Cooking." I've been using it since I was 12!
antrobin at 6:57PM on 08/07/08
No question: The Farmhouse Cookbook by Susan Hermann Loomis. Great simple country cooking from the freshest ingredients.
The pumpkin whoopie pies page is particularly messy.
Second-messiest: The New York Cookbook. Messiest page? Horn & Hardart's mac & cheese...mmm...
missbhavens at 7:12PM on 08/07/08
I think my recipe box has the most stained recipes...and some of the oldest! All the family recipes are in there. After that, it's the original "Betty Crocker" cookbook.
myrnie_twin at 7:14PM on 08/07/08
i've gotta say, my marlene sorosky Cooking for Entertaining is pretty darn stained! oh, and my lori longbotham Luscious Chocolate Desserts. oh, and my family cookbook, not available in stores anywhere! :)
happygomarni at 7:17PM on 08/07/08
Moosewood
Molly Katzen's Vegetable Heaven
PeanutButter at 7:18PM on 08/07/08
Moosewood
Molly Katzen's Vegetable Heaven
PeanutButter at 7:25PM on 08/07/08
My most stained, dog-eared is certainly The Joy of Cooking. It also has about 50 other recipes stuffed inside to the point the binding is falling apart.
The newest cookbook in the collection that is taking on the same appearance is "Staff Meals" by David Waltuck. It's a great cookbook.
winebill at 7:29PM on 08/07/08
The Barefoot Contessa Cookbook. It falls open to the page for Perfect Roast Chicken.
melveeta316 at 7:35PM on 08/07/08
I got "Food That Really Schmecks" by Edna Staebler when I was 13. It's lost its spine and is really REALLY soiled, especially on dessert and cake recipes.
I loved this book as a kid, the writing is so evocative and delightful. The recipes are so simple and good. I still love this book and I pick it up every now and then. It brings back so many happy memories.
Pointy at 7:43PM on 08/07/08
The first cookbook I ever touched is Joy of Cooking. My copy belonged to my grandmother. It is so very old!
izatryt at 8:39PM on 08/07/08
My first cookbook - a 1976 edition of The Settlement Cookbook.
Nezrite at 8:48PM on 08/07/08
@pointy, i have two books by edna staebler! cakes and pies with schmecks appeal and desserts with schmecks appeal. i got them when i was in canada, and i love them!
i don't cook from books anymore. but the ones in the past i have used the most are silver palate and edward espe brown's the tassajara recipe book.
cybercita at 9:20PM on 08/07/08
all my childhood favorites are from the Silver Palate!
tzm13 at 10:10PM on 08/07/08
I started out with "The Joy of Cooking," back when it included recipes for muskrat, but in recent years our default source has been Mark Bittman's "How to Cook Everything." Madhur Jaffrey's "A Taste of India" is well-used here, but we have several other South Asian books. Least-used are probably Donna Hay's books--very pretty but a lot of work.
jscheck at 10:54PM on 08/07/08
Fanny Farmer is my most beat-up cookbook, and I just replaced my Joy of Cooking that was about 30 years old with the brand new version.
Mocha466 at 12:09AM on 08/08/08
My copy of How to Cook Everything is a bit of a mess, but I love it all the same.
BrooklynBrownie at 12:25AM on 08/08/08
The Joy of Cooking always gets checked in OCD moments when I'm boiling eggs. Stop and Smell The Rosemary, a Houston Junior League Cookbook, gets used a bunch, and I still use The Frugal Gourmet Cooks Three Ancient Cuisines. I recently discovered Judith Huxley's Dinner For Eight, which simply a delight to read.
hungryinhouston at 12:41AM on 08/08/08
I have a copy of the Joy of Cooking that was falling apart as I was growing up. I can remember my mother stuffing the chunks of the index back into the book endless times. Over the years, more and more of it fell out, and somewhere along the line the cover disappeared too. It's a mess. It's on my bookshelf. I replaced it with a gently used version of the same edition (1950ish) and then I went hunting and got the whole darned series.
Yes, I am a cookbook addict.
dbcurrie at 1:10AM on 08/08/08
what? no one mentions the new york times cookbook itself? I bought mine in college at a second-hand store in town and it's a great reference. I also use good housekeeping cookbook when stumped. sike.
avisualperson at 1:31AM on 08/08/08
Stain-wise, I'm going to side with @myrnie_twin and swear by my own 3x5 card box full of favorites. In all other previous threads, I have promoted and defended the "Joy of Cooking", 70s edition, but after our last discussion on topic I ordered Mark Bittman's "How to Cook Everything" and am loving its simplicity and versatility. It may capture my heart...
czken at 1:43AM on 08/08/08
Have to agree with a previous reviewer my "Settlement Cookbook" is all gummed up from prior years of use. Betty Crocker with the large rings has raw cookie dough still imprinted upon the sugar cookie recipe. Also, "Betty Crockers Cookbook for Boys & Girls" from 1957 has fudge on the "fudge" page.
AndiofLMF at 9:02AM on 08/08/08
James Beard's Theory and Practice of Good Cooking. It's been out of print for years but can be found on Amazon.
Check out www.cookingwithdee.net for other cookbook inspirations. There are two lists, all referenced to Amazon because many are out of print.
Stain-wise it's Volume 1 of Mastering the Art of French Cooking.
tdl1501 at 10:12AM on 08/08/08
Deborah Madison's "Vegetarian Cooking for Everyone".
Also, while "On Food and Cooking" is an essential reference, it's not a cookbook. There are a few recipes in it, but almost all of them are centuries old. You can't exactly pick up liquamen and garum at the A&P.
Buckethead at 10:34AM on 08/08/08
@ Buckethead - I just got Madison's book and I am sooo looking forward to putting it thru its paces! What is your favorite recipe so far?
I don't have a card box, but rather a notebook with photo sheets. The pages the recipes are printed on are stained, because they don't get stuck in the book until they have been thoroughly tested. If it's stuck, it's a keeper, haha!
erinlovestoeat at 10:46AM on 08/08/08
My most stained has to be a handwritten collection I put together when my son was an infant...Buckeyes, Texas Sheet Cake, No Bake Cookies... He's almost 24 now.
Many family contributions, and others that I found along the way, with notes on the pages "Not too good", "Perfect", "Too Much Cocoa"...
thewrighttaste at 10:50AM on 08/08/08
Neelam Batra's "The Indian Vegetarian." Other cookbooks, I read for a general idea, but this one, I read for detail. Hence, a lot of time open on the countertop, more vulernable to sloshing. When I first started cooking for myself out of cookbooks regularly, way back in grad school, it was 50% of my cookbook collection, so it fell victim to my haphazard neophyte technique.
Also- printouts from the Cook's Illustrated website get pretty well-worn (and saved!).
sloppydelicious at 1:13PM on 08/08/08
All of my Silver Palate books are sticky, gooey and once in a while I'll find a sweet & low stuck in as a bookmark! Also, The Victory Garden and Moosewood books are ancient, abused and still wonderful!
AnnArtiste at 1:55PM on 08/08/08
When I first started cooking (and way before I knew what a mise-en-place was) the SILVER PALATE books were my culinary bibles--consequently, these are my messiest cookbooks. However, with years of cooking behind me, I must admit that my My Mario Batali MOLTO ITALIANO cookbook is looking rather splattered.
Foodwoolf at 3:35PM on 08/08/08
When I first started cooking (and way before I knew what a mise-en-place was) the SILVER PALATE books were my culinary bibles--consequently, these are my messiest cookbooks. However, with years of cooking behind me, I must admit that my My Mario Batali MOLTO ITALIANO cookbook is looking rather splattered.
Foodwoolf at 3:40PM on 08/08/08
My cookbook collection started with The New Basics. It's well worn. By now I've memorized several recipes from it such as the carrot cake, basic pizza dough, penne with broccoli and parmesan.
lisal at 5:57PM on 08/08/08
The Joy of Cooking is my old standby. My parents have a Chef Cardini cookbook- I don't know the title- that is seriously falling apart. About 10 years ago my mom found another copy, but then they bought a vacation house in the mountains, and the original copy has moved up there.
cmtigger at 1:37AM on 08/09/08
Moosewood Cookbook
Enchanted Broccoli Forest
both by the venerable Mollie Katzen
and my first cookbook - Kids Cook!: Fabulous Food for the Whole Family
by Sarah & Zachary Williamson, a seemingly genuine brother and sister pair who introduced me to the idea of putting apples into a grilled cheese sandwich, making my first breakfast burrito, and other great dishes when i decided to start cooking for the family once a week at the age of 10!
barredowl at 6:24PM on 08/09/08
The Silver Palate cookbook in my house is falling apart. I use it for exact recipies as well as inspiration in creating my own.
Nursemegg at 9:07AM on 08/11/08
I was given a copy of "the New McCall;s Cookbook" by Mary Eckley, food editor of McCall's.....way back in 1974. It was an engagement gift from my soon to be sister in law. The international food section got my attention since I was from central Pennsylvania and my mom's idea of spices were salt and pepper! Both covers are separated from the binding and held in place with a rubber band. This book got me through many dinners early in my marriage (34 years now) and I still go to it for the pumpkin pie at Thanksgiving....best I ever had.
I have since collected nearly 500 cookbooks and they are all out on the bookselves. I read them like novels. Love my cookbooks!
vacationmomma at 9:14AM on 08/11/08
My most cherished cookbooks are "The Complete Italian Vegetarian Cookbook" by Jack Bishop and "How to Cook Everything Vegetarian" by Mark Bittman. Both books, filled with healthy, simple, fail-safe recipes, helped transform my household into a bunch of passionate eaters and cooks. (The days of eating dinner "whenever" or in front of the tele are thankfully behind us.)
The pages of each book are well stained with the likes of balsamic vinegar residue and blueberry splatter, and even carry the smell of minced garlic. And then there are the work notes we've added to the text: This dish pairs well with this Beaujolais, served this one on this date to rave reviews...
mrsbaldwin at 9:39AM on 08/11/08
My 1st cookbook was "Joy" which I still use as a reference. Then I learned about Julia and The French Chef Cookbook is my most spattered. I have many, many cookbooks but another standout is my Pennsylvanis Dutch Cookbook, having grown up in Reading, PA.
Last Hanukkah I made a gift for my 3 adult children of all their fave recipes and they were copied stains et al.
lmstanley at 10:45AM on 08/11/08
My 3x5 recipe cards (that I started in junior high...and I'm in my 50's now) look like hell - dogeared, stained and fading. But they're family favorites, some passed down from my greatgrandmother.
Also, my Betty Crocker cookbook that I received as a wedding present back in 1979 is pitiful.
I've done some damage to my Giada DeLaurentis cookbooks as well as all of my Cooking Light compilation cookbooks.
Chef Jo at 11:38AM on 08/11/08
The two books I go to most often: Madeleine Kamman's 1978 paperback The Making of a Cook, and Anne Seranne's 1950 The Complete Book of Home Baking. Both books give me great results, every time. Madeleine Kamman spells out the processes for cooking all types of dishes, and when I follow her instructions the food turns out just as I hoped it would. In Anne Seranne's book, I have found recipe gems for some basic dessert foods such as layer cake and pie crust that are about the best I've found anywhere. Both books are stained and worn because they are so reliable.
minonda at 12:33PM on 08/11/08
For me, Mastering the Art of French Cooking Volume 1 has nearly come apart at the seems, and Rick Stein's English Fish Cookery and Simon Hopkinson's Roast Chicken and Other Stories, Gammon and Spinach and The Prawn Cocktail Years are positively soggy by now. Marcella Hazan also suffers at my hands...... And the Moro books, partricularly Volume 2, with their practical North African dishes. I am, of course, writing from the UK so some of these will not be relevant in the US so much. I have also recently started cooking from the super "Simple Indian" by Atul Kohchar - a chef who has a 2 Michelin starred restaurant in London where the dishes are extraordinary, with a lightness of touch and use of spices that is divine. That's getting stickier by the day.
Foodlexi at 12:38PM on 08/11/08
"With a Jug of Wine" is certainly one of the most well-used books in my collection. There was so much spillage that my dog pulled it down from a low shelf and tried to eat it. Most of the spine and title pages are gone (and it was pretty bedraggled when puppy got to it) but I hold it together with rubber bands and masking tape. I believe my edition is from the early '50s.
smckinney at 1:26PM on 08/11/08
I have to say Betty Crocker. It has been the "ole" stand by for many years
(I hate to say how many years). It's basic, but that's what I like about it, nothing fancy just old fashioned comfort food. I have altered many recipes to suit todays lifestyle, lower in fats etc. and use it more as a reference. I have collected cook books for 40+ years. Joy of Cooking being one but I have always loved local cookbooks, garden clubs, Junior League and several restaurant cookbooks. I love cajun cooking and "Don's seafood and steak house" is one of the best and I must say it finally bit the dust and I had to break down and buy a new one. Betty's binding is loose and a bit floopy ( but then, so am I ) but I don't need to replace her yet !
1gourmet at 3:08PM on 08/11/08
I must say, It's an old book that both of my parents used; and when my Dad passed away (nine years after my mom) I took the book. It's "Amy Vanderbilt's Complete Cookbook".) The book was published in 1961, but still has some of the best recipes that would rival today's books. The Quiche Lorraine is still the best in the city. If it's still in the stores, I would urge cooks to go and purchase it. My parent's book is in really bad shape, it's in pieces and held together with tape, but it's still a terrific and fulfilling cookbook emotionally because of my parents using it for so many years, as well as physically!
sassy at 4:46PM on 08/11/08
Lately, I've been bespattering "Vegetarian Cooking for Everyone", Deborah Madison, too but I also like to read the late Laurie Colwin's "Home Cooking" and "More Home Cooking". Her enthusiasm and quirkiness are infectious and there are many easy, practical and delicious recipes in both volumes. Katherine Hepburn's "Brownies" are exceptional! I use Joy of Cooking's "Know Your Ingredients" chapter for weights, substitutions, etc. These pages are fused together. The first cookbook I used is "Three Meals A Day", Jessie Read, Musson Publishing, Toronto:1946. I love its post-war economies, its basic recipes, my grandmother's entries on the blank pages and entries I made as an eleven year old learning to cook. I have TOO many favourite cookbooks - I collect cookbooks but I also use them.
Raki5 at 5:35PM on 08/11/08
Oh - I've got three that really look like they've been through the mill - The Settlement Cookbook was the first cookbook my folks gave me when I got my first apartment 25, 30 years ago? Marcella Hazan's Classic Italian Cooking - the pasta pages are all stuck together, the veal picata is close to unreadable. Lastly, Marlene Sorosky's Holiday Cookbook - that sweet potato praline thing for Thanksgiving - mmmm
Szerlip1EA at 10:57PM on 08/11/08
Two cookbooks from Margaret Fox, the Cafe Beaujolais Cb and Morning Food are certainly among the worst-looking. I have bought multiple copies of each as gifts, and when I am sure they won't be returned for store credit, I copy my own notes on each recipe into them. The first two Silver Palates are also valuable, but I found nothing but disaster in the recipes I tried from New Basics so sent that one a-packing. I have three and a half tall bookcases full, plus more stacked nearby, and there are probably too many that I only use one recipe from. But some books are too much fun to re-read to send off to the Book Fair.
lemons at 10:07AM on 08/12/08
Definitely the Joy of Cooking...too bad about that binding that's falling apart!
kate01 at 10:53AM on 08/12/08
I would have to go with either the first Barefoot Contessa Cookbook (her bbq sauce and her scones are always hits around here), Bold American Food by Bobby Flay (his sauces) and The Silver Palate Cookbook (their recipe for Spaghetti with Oil & Garlic has been used more than anything else in there). I just adore the flavor of the chicken broth in that recipe! So creative.
RisaG at 12:35PM on 08/13/08
For me it's How To Cook Everything, The Essential Seafood Cookbook, and The Student's Vegetarian Cookbook.
RI Swampyankee at 10:59PM on 08/13/08
All the Hazan cookbooks (I have Marcella's Cucina, both Classic and the first one, her Italian Kitchen; Bugiali's comprehensive tome, Giuliano Hazan's wonderful pasta cookbook, James Beard's American Cooking, Olney's Simple French Cooking.
Jolivore at 6:21PM on 08/15/08