• Share:
  • Send to Reddit
  • Send to StumbleUpon
  • Send to Facebook
  • Send to del.icio.us
  • Send to digg

To Eat or Not to Eat? That Is the Question

That day, that day of reckoning for those of us who struggle with our weight, has arrived.
It is New Year's Day, the day we contemplate our fate and our weight. The holiday cheer and gluttony have come and gone, and all I am left with is two totally conflicting desires: to lose weight and to continue to look for and savor every bit of delicious food on this earth. How does one reconcile these two seemingly contradictory notions? To eat, or not to eat. That, Serious Eaters, is the question.

I have at least 25 pounds to lose, more if I paid attention to the government charts, which I don't. What is my fundamental problem? The potential for deliciousness follows me everywhere I go. Every street corner holds out the possibility of something good to eat where I live. To make matters worse (or better, depending on how I look at it) people send lots of scrumptious stuff to Serious Eats headquarters. So even if I avert my eyes coming to and from work, I will still be confronted by temptation virtually every day.

So what am I going to do?

I'm going to taste, not devour.

I'm going to eat half of everything I order.

I'm going to exercise four or five times a week instead of twice.

I'm going to eat more fruits and vegetables and less pork fat.

I'm going to try and eat more slowly.

It is winter, the season of wonderful citrus fruit. I'm going to eat grapefruit, oranges, and tangerines at least three times a day.

I'm going to try and not eat after 9 p.m.

I'm going to limit myself to one pizza meal and one pasta meal a week.

I'm going to try and eat a real, substantial breakfast every day, something like yogurt and whole grain cereal or toast.

I have to use cheese as a flavor enhancer instead of as a snack.

I know I should keep a journal detailing everything I eat, but that seems like too painful an exercise. Can't I just keep a running tab in my head?

These are my ten food commandments for the coming year, my fellow serious eaters. Will they generate the desired result? You tell me.

14 Comments:

What will generate the desired result is the Shangri-La Diet and less carbs. See Seth Roberts' site.

By lowering your setpoint via SLD you will reduce your appetite but not reduce your enjoyment of the food you do eat. Eating a variety of different foods and food preparations will also help reduce your appetite.

Eating carbs is necessary to storing fat; you will need to eat less carbs. When you do eat carbs, try to eat those with a low glycemic index (G. I. ) so as not to spike your insulin level. Higher insulin levels mean more fat storage. Cf. Gary Taube's recent book.

If you can stick with these guidelines, I think you can count on great results.
The tough ones are likely to be items 1 and 3; that is, at what point does one cross the line from tasting to devouring? And efforts to eat just just half of something can be sabotaged by internal counter-arguments ('waste!' 'starving children!'). The most effective strategy I've found is to make specific, concrete plans for the other half of the item/meal in question; eating more slowly, which you also mention, also helps, since it gives a little better perspective on actual intake, so that's an important one.

Think I'm going to try these myself... I could stand to lose a bit of weight.

Happy New Year :)

Exercise! that will be a big factor. Stop work and walk for a half hour every afternoon. You'll get ideas for writing too.

I was somewhat overweight a few years ago and started simply moving/dancing to a marvelous jazz radio station. I'm sure I looked silly, but no one saw, so zero problem .

As a result I dropped about 35 pounds in just a few months. I'm guessing that walking would do the same and you have a marvelous venue for that.

These days, I "walk" the dog - or maybe it's the other way around. I still eat what I want in moderate quantities and the re-gain has been less than seven pounds.

shangri-la didn't do much for me, unfortunately. what works for me is lots of time at the gym.

i'm entertaining out of town visitors and we're heading for barney greengrass for brunch right now, so i'm starting my year out deliciously.

ed, my advice {as someone who used to be clinically obese} is to make a few small changes at a time until they become habit, and then make a few more. in my experience, expecting too much of yourself all at once is a recipe for failure.

i do recommend lots of exercise, lowering your fat intake by eating smaller amounts of fatty food, and eating lots of fruits and vegetables.

good luck!


I think you're on the right track. The food journal is impossible for me, it is way too obsessive; it takes all the joy out of food. I once told a nutritionist I was seeing that I had an apple for an afternoon snack; she looked at me very smugly and said, "How much did the apple weigh?" That was the end of her! Exercise is number one; no matter how crappy the weather (sleet/snow/pouring rain) get outside and walk or run, or go to the gym if you can handle the environment. I just find it too boring. Lucky for me I have an outdoor job. Don't give up delicious food, just eat less of it. I often have dinner's leftovers for breakfast!

Happy New Year to y'all, and thanks for this great site.

More quantitative goals will be easier to achieve, and you've got some already (working out 5x weekly).

But "eat less", "eat more fruits", etc... they are prone to a shifting target mindset.

Eat one piece of fresh fruit for breakfast and 2 servings of veggies at lunch might be a good start. Or even, "I will work out Mon-Wed-Thurs-Fri-Sun" instead of just "5x weekly" might be better....

The more specific the more likely you can hold yourself to it.

Good luck, and enjoy the new year!

Ed -- I've tried keeping track of my intake in my head, but invariably I cheat. When I write it down, I never fail in keeping to my plan. It's a pain, but it promotes self-accountability.

Best wishes for a slim-yet-fulfilling New Year!

Dominic
the zen kitchen

Hi Ed,
Are you an all or nothing person? Me, I can't have an open bag of chips without eating most or all of it so it's easier for me not to have it around or even start to nibble. If there's something yummy, I just can't stick to the "I'll just eat a bit" plan. So I usually stick to a lower calorie (but throw in some fat since your body does need it) diet on most days interdispersed with days of indulgence. I allow myself to eat all the veggies I want but a modified quantity of fruit since it's higher in calories. I also try to eat something high in fiber everyday. If your local Trader Joe's has them, try the delicious Blueberry or Apple Cranberry fiber cakes from Zen Bakery. I know it sounds yeewww but they're dense, moist and best of all, tasty. Throw in the exercise and I figure it all equalizes in the end.
Most of all, whatever works for you, it has to be a permanent change - sorry, but true. It has been for me for almost twenty years (I was a plus size person before the term was even coined!).
And remember, we're all rooting for ya!

keep moving kiddo. As for eating, remember try to stick with "real food" stay away from all the processed junk thats constantly pushed at us. Drink lots of water, and whatever you do, dont diet! the worst thing you can do is set an arbitrary limit on yourself. I spent 30 yrs fighting the battle of the bulge, when I stopped dieting and denying myself, I started loosing weight, 120 lbs so far. If you want chocolate, make it GOOD chocolate. same goes for anything else, when I denyed myself some things I just obsessed about them and then went nuts on them. Now if I want pizza I have it, but I also make sure thats not all I eat and I stick with a small amount, what you want is the taste, and all you need is 1 piece for that, especially if you know you can have it again anytime you want.

Ed I have started a topic where our community will give you some recipes to try. I advocate portion control. I also advocate you stop eating when you are not moving around so much. Eat dinner as early as you can. Chocolate especially dark is a good mouth feel snack. There is so much good chocolate around that it is a great option. I also think it gives you an opportunity to go see Jacques Torres and get an interview (jumping up and down) just a thought.
Hubby has the 25 lb bulge to deal with as well and a cholestrol issue.
Here are my recommendations.
Take white processed sugar out of your diet and replace with natural sugar. There are so many natural sugars around that you can do that right away. I use in my cooking and baking demara, muscavado, granulated pure cane, brown, turbinado. Trader Joes and Whole Foods carry lots of types. I bake with these and we do not use the old processed stuff hardly ever. I have also found a great substitute for our coffee which makes great Lattes. http://www.sugar-shots.com/index.html
We use the turbinado and sometimes I use it on fruit, in puddings, in marinades. This stuff is good.
I make Nick's supernatural brownies with natural sugar and they are very good, the recipe handles the moist sugar well.
Pick your starches well. I often make a meal with a good protein and then one small "portioned" starch. Portion control is your friend. When you go out to all the fabulous places that you do order those small plates you and I like so much. Keep us posted and the best of luck. Remember we are all here for you. You have a huge support group.

Having recently lost ten pounds with minor diet and exercise changes I do have a few suggestions.

Don't deny yourself cheese if you really love it, just restrict the times you can eat it as a snack as you are doing with carbs. I've found that eating the real thing in the form that you love does a great deal more to temper cravings than trying to water the stuff down. Likewise, if you feel a craving coming on, try to indulge it early on so that you don't end up over doing it later on as huney_bumper said above.

The only other thing I would say is that it is a good idea to try and do the journal even if you are not completely successful or even end up missing days. It is very easy for your brain to massage the data so that you "forget" how much you've eaten in a day. As a bonus, it can really help you figure out appropriate portion sizes by forcing you to recognize how much you are eating. Oops, again I'm repeating what others have said. Well, if nothing else it will hopefully reinforce those earlier comments.

So glad to see you're not paying too much attention to the charts. Tow experiences of mine along those lines...

1. For the past few years, I've been ten (or so) pounds overweight. But I'm pretty constant. And I'm extremely healthy. I look like a Woman (yes, capitalized), not a teenaged boy. (This is a good thing, since I'm a 40-something female!) The biggest benefit, though, is that I get to eat whatever I want, whenever I want. Always, always in moderation. I never feel deprived, so I seldom get cravings. I'd rather be a my current size 8 than my former size 4, because I get real joy from eating. It's no fun to obsess about all the things I *shouldn't* or *can't* eat. The only time I watch my diet is when my clothes get too snug. Then I cut back a bit. The only scale I own is a kitchen model with a 5# max capacity.

2. When hubby was working out, he was beyond obsessive. For years he'd spend several hours a day, EVERY day, at the gym. He's six feet tall and wore only a 29" pant waist. He was actually too thin (IMHO). But, according to the BMI charts he was overweight, because his muscle mass weighed so much! He weighs less now, but wears a 32" pant waist, and shows up as *normal* on the charts. Go figure.

And don't skip the cheese. It's so very, very good for you! Just eat less of it. Or substitute it for your *meat* for the day.

TIP: I've known many people who had great weight-loss success, and also learned to eat very well by using the typical diabetic diet as a guideline. It's based on good, nutritious common sense.

i so hear you, ed. and i'm right there with you.
i've put on at least 15 lbs since i started blogging
not good...
anytime i've lost serious weight, i kept track

so yes, i really do keep a log. i do it on the computer.
it helps...

i feel your pain
why can't lying make you fat?


Oh, so many food, diet, and weight loss myths to bust!

A few years ago my husband and I both had some pounds to lose (20 for me and about 35 for him). We gained most of it when we ate pasta and homemade bread more frequently. Stupidly, I was trying to keep fat intake and meat on the low side then, too. I tried the gym (though I hate gym environments), got a bit fitter, but the weight didn't budge. I didn't feel like we ate too much, nor did we eat "bad food", so I was really unwilling to starve ourselves to lose weight. I mean, how does one live that way just to lose weight and then maintain the weight loss later? Reducing iets as a short term fix are doomed to fail.

Also, exercising just to lose weight works *up* an appetite. Maybe not immediately after working out, but long term, it does. Look at what lumberjacks can eat - 5000 calories or more a day without gaining. Same for military personel in the field carrying around many pounds of equipment. And for all the calories burned in a an exercise session, it is far less than people suppose (and they often make up for it later as a "reward"). Those few hundred calories burned are about equal to a few bites of something or a slice or two of bread. I'd rather not eat the bread and save gym grunting. I'm not saying all exercise is bad, but it isn't the best way to lose weight. Not by a long shot.

Increasing body fat is due to high insulin levels, which store excess fat and glucose calories. But eating fat without a lot of sugar and starch doesn't raise insulin levels but eating carbohydrates does. So if you are going to restrict any foods, restrict sugars and starches, no matter how "whole" and "healthy" you think they are or how nutritionally incorrect it seems. Human biochemistry cannot be ignored. Fat calories cannot be stored without high insulin levels. Without insulin, the body will burn off excess fat calories as heat, rather than storing them as body fat. You can eat more non-starchy vegetables if you are not eating sugar and starch.

So it is possible to lose weight without starving oneself, without forcing oneself to spend hours at a gym instead doing something more interesting, and without eating fake food. It just makes a lot more sense to cut back on (to whatever level is necessary to lose weight) sugar and starches, which make up a disproporationate % of modern diets and provide far less in the way of nutrients and structural building materials for the body. Early humans developed without much of these foods, so think of it as getting in touch with the inner hunter-gatherer. We've maintained our weight lose without much effort or sacrifice since 2004 and can't imagine eating any other way now. It's a healthier way of eating for life. In fact, this was exactly the way to eat prescribed to me in 1998 when I was pregnant and diagonoses with gestational diabetes. Every bite had to count. I only wish I had continued with it instead of going back to empty foods like bread and pasta.

Add a comment:

Comments can take up to a minute to appear - please be patient!

Previewing your comment:

 

HTML Hints

Some HTML is OK: <a href="URL">link</a>, <strong>strong</strong>, <em>em</em>

Comment Guidelines

Post whatever you want, just keep it seriously about eats, seriously. We reserve the right to delete off-topic or inflammatory comments. Learn more at our Comment Policy page.

If you see something not so nice, please, report an inappropriate comment.