Serious Eats Gift Guide: For the Baker
I don’t have solid research data to back me up on this, but I’ve always thought that when the holidays roll around even people who haven’t seen the inside of their ovens all year pull down the flour bin and bake. It’s part of what makes the holidays so jollyand so surprising.
If you’re looking to surprise a baker on your list, here are a few gift suggestions. This isn’t a complete build-your-baking-batterie-de-cuisine list; it’s not just for beginners; and it’s not in any special order. Mostly it’s a sampling of some things I really like and think you and yours might like, too.
Because Raphael has already posted a great list of basics, I’m not going to repeat the wonderful KitchenAid stand mixer, the Cuisinart food processor, which is so good for making pie and tart doughs, or the nifty Silpat silicone baking mats, which I never want to live withoutall of my baking sheets are stored with Silpats on them, so I’m always ready for the next batch of cookies. But any of these would be terrific to give or to get.
So, here’s my list of stuff to make the holidays sweeter. (Prices do not include shipping unless otherwise noted.)
A Powerful Handheld Mixer
Even if you have a stand mixer, it’s nice to have a handheld mixer for the extra jobs: How many times have you needed to whip egg whites and been stymied because your stand mixer was busy? If you’re not up to a stand mixer, this mixer can handle just about any recipe you want to tackle with the exception of something that beats forever, like brioche. KitchenAid 7-Speed Ultra Power Plus Hand Mixer, $70
A Fanciful Nonstick Bundt Pan
Invented in the 1950s by NordicWare, still the leading brand, Bundt pans take a simple sturdy cake and make it look like it was bought from the best bakeryit’s all in the pan’s curves. Originally, just a tube pan with a few swirls and flourishes, today you can get a Bundt shaped like a medieval castle or a football stadium. I’m kind of partial to the chrysanthemum pan, mostly because I love the way a cake from this pan looks when it’s dusted with powdered sugar. Cast Aluminum Chrysanthemum Bundt, $30
A Digital Kitchen Scale
Even though most American recipes are written for volume measures (i.e., cups and spoons), it’s always good to have a scale around when you’re measuring chocolate, nuts or fruit, or when you’re faced with a metric recipe you’re dying to try. Choose a scale with a read-out in both grams and pounds and look for one that allows you to go to zero while you’ve got stuff on it and then to continue adding and weighing ingredients. This scale has an automatic shut-off, which, for absent-minded people like moi, is a mini blessing. Salter 11-Pound Stainless-Steel Digital Kitchen Scale, $45
A Good French Rolling Pin, The Kind Without Handles
Use this for rolling delicate tart and pie dough. (Because there are no handles, you control the pressure on the dough and the direction of the pressureit’s like driving a well-tuned sports car.) Vic Firth Rolling Pin, $12.95
A Rolling Pin for Bread and Other Doughs That Need to Be Pushed Around
A rolling pin for bread and other doughs that need to be pushed around. When you’ve got heavy doughs, particularly yeast doughs that push back at you, you need a rolling pin with a little heft, handles and some ball-bearings that give you mechanical advantage. The fact that the new pins are silicone and come in bright colors makes them fun, but no less serious as tools. $40, from Cooking.com
A Piecrust Bag
It looks like a slipcover for a pillow, but it helps you roll dough out to the perfect thickness and diameter. You put your disk of dough in this zippered plastic bag (I flour the bag) and roll, roll, roll. Even if you’ve never rolled out pie dough before, you can look like an ace with this gadget. A friend gave me one a couple of years agoI’d never seen them beforeand I’ve been using it (and giving it as gifts) ever since. $6, from King Arthur Flour
Tart Pans with Removable Bottoms and Fluted Sides
These classic European panswell, almost classic, these are nonstickare what you need to make beautiful tarts and quiches. They’re expensive, but you’re only going to buy them once in your life. Twice, actually, because it’s good to have both a 9-1/2 inch and an 11-inch pan. 9 1/2-inch pan, $16; 11-inch pan, $28
An Offset SpatulaOr Three
I love having a wardrobe of offset, or angled, spatulas for frosting cakes, getting a perfect glaze on tortes or just loosening just-baked cookies from a baking sheet. Start with a longish spatula (this one’s almost 10 inches long), then work your way downyou’ll find uses for all the sizes. Ateco Medium-Size Offset Spatula, $10
Pure Vanilla Extract
It must be pure (imitation vanilla will ruin whatever you’re making) and the fragrance must make you dizzy. I continue to be a fan of Nielsen-Massey vanilla extract, but I’ve recently fallen hard for this mix of Tahitian and Bourbon vanilla extracts with vanilla-bean pulp. It’s a fabulous blend. $19 each
Chocolate, Chocolate, and More Chocolate
Chocolate, chocolate, and more chocolate. Security comes in many forms. For me, it’s knowing that I’ve got a generous supply of my favorite chocolate at hand. While you can buy Valrhona chocolates in just about any quantity, I think that giving (or getting) pounds and pounds of it makes the special chocolate even more special. My go-to variety is Manjari, a bittersweet chocolate with a winey spiciness and I always buy it in "feve" form. Feves, like lozenges, melt faster and more evenly, can be chopped quickly and make a great snack. $66 for a 3-kilogram bag
Add a comment:
Previewing your comment:
HTML Hints
Some HTML is OK: <a href="URL">link</a>, <strong>strong</strong>, <em>em</em>
Comment Guidelines
Post whatever you want, just keep it seriously about eats, seriously. We reserve the right to delete off-topic or inflammatory comments. Learn more at our Comment Policy page.
If you see something not so nice, please, report an inappropriate comment.





17 Comments:
I'm as surprised as anybody by this, but Cooks Illustrated recently did a vanilla test, and found that artificial vanilla was rated highest in a blind test. Since seeing that, I've been using the fake stuff in all my cooking, and honestly haven't noticed any negative effects.
eliah at 2:11PM on 12/07/07
Great list, Dorie. I have several offset spatulas and use them all.
Can't wait to try that vanilla!! I think I need the piecrust bag too.
Cathy at 2:32PM on 12/07/07
i just saw bottles of that Sonoma Syrup vanilla crush, and the plain extract for $10 at a Marshall's and TJ Maxx, just a heads up for us frugals.
protest at 2:56PM on 12/07/07
This list is great, Dorie! Nothing's super expensive and it's all practical and essential. Thanks!
Adam Kuban at 3:20PM on 12/07/07
Eliah, I remember that mind-boggling taste test, but here's what I think: It's possible that artificial vanilla might not ruin some things, but really great vanilla can make anything taste much, much better.
Cathy, I think you'll really love the vanilla and you'll have fun with the piecrust bag. I always feel like I'm cheating when I use the bag -- but I use it anyway.
Protest, Good "heads up" - thank you. I've seen the vanilla crush at TJ Maxx too and I always buy a few jars when it's there. And you're right -- it's less expensive. (I think I paid $12.99 the last time I bought it.) I'm just not sure that it's always available.
Thanks Adam.
dorie at 3:48PM on 12/07/07
I would be very happy if I found any one of these items under my Christmas tree or stuffed in my Christmas stocking!
JEP at 5:15PM on 12/07/07
I have a question about those Silpat mats - what are the advantages to using those vs. parchment paper aside from the the fact that they're reusable?
PattyCho at 6:18PM on 12/07/07
JEP, I'm with you!
Patty Cho, re-usability is a major advantage of Silpats and so is their remarkable non-stickability. Their surface is so slick that even caramel just lifts right off them. Ditto tuiles, those fragile tile-shaped French cookies. And there's the convenience factor -- they're exactly the right size for a baking pan. And then there's the easy clean-up -- since nothing sticks to them, they're a cinch to clean and have ready to use again. Oh, and they don't wear out.
dorie at 7:03PM on 12/07/07
I think all of us fake vanilla users need to come out of the closet. There's no shame.
Vanillin and proud,
mamster
mamster at 11:37PM on 12/07/07
I ran off to TJ Maxx and grabbed 2 bottles. If Dorie says it is good I have to try it.
I agree to disagree about the imitation vanilla. The McCormick brand (which everyone can find anyplace) the fake one is 2.49 and the real one is 2.99 (.50 of a difference) now come on folks if only diamonds had this small a cost difference from fake diamonds.
I use real vanilla and I use it in a lot of things in different variations. Extract in double/triple/paste/powder and vanilla beans. There is no substitute for real vanilla and I agree with Dorie, fake vanilla will not hold up.
http://www.cooksillustrated.com/images/document/tasting/ND03_vanillaextracts.pdf
The fake vanilla was put in creme anglais at the very end was was not "cooked" and in butter cake.
I think CI needed to add one more taste to the experiment. A baked custard and maybe something that the vanilla lends a larger presense. Creme anglais and butter cake are kind of bland in terms of vanilla. One puts the creme anglais on something to add a dimension of flavor. Also the butter cake is a vehicle for frosting and maybe a filling to frame it.
As for the list of gift suggestions they are all fabulous gift for the home baker on your christmas list.
I love to hear from Dorie.
JerzeeTomato at 5:02AM on 12/08/07
Alright, (re: JerzeeTomato) I agree that perhaps the methodology was not the best. But I don't think you're interpreting the results correctly, Dorie. *If* the testing is sound, and finds that fake is best, that doesn't mean just that there are some things fake won't ruin; it means that fake is best, period, and you won't get an improvement switching to real. But yeah, it would have been nice to see some other vanilla testing vehicles.
eliah at 9:55AM on 12/08/07
About real vs artificial vanilla, I think the only thing I can say is "it's a matter of taste." If you like the flavor of artificial vanilla, use it; if you don't, then don't. Tastes are subjective and so are taste tests.
dorie at 4:48PM on 12/09/07
Thanks for the ideas - I know I would love to have a kitchen scale in my kitchen!
Oh - I just had to comment on the imitation & real vanilla string of comments..... I did a little digging into vanilla & came across this information that seems to be quite comprehensive - it goes through & explains about all the different types of vanilla & it even goes through how imitation vanilla came about - it's seems to be a by-product of the paper industry or a coal-tar derivative. I always try to use fresh, whole ingredients in cooking or baking so using the real stuff is just what I'm used too...here's the info on vanilla:
http://www.vanilla.com/html/facts-extracts.html
lizrana at 9:22PM on 12/11/07
Great list, and I love that offset spatulas are included -- truly, the unsung secret weapons of any pastry kitchen!
And chocolate, yes, can never go wrong... :)
NinaMW at 11:45PM on 12/14/07
Lizrana -- thank you for the vanilla link - very interesting.
NinaMW -- you're right about offset spatulas, they are the secret weapons of a pastry kitchen. So handy for so many things. Just last night I grabbed one to slide along the bottom of a tart to make sure it hadn't stuck to the tart pan.
dorie at 10:44AM on 12/16/07
This is a great list! I just bought an Ateco offset spatula yesterday and I'm so excited to use it. Those pie crust bags look amazing; would those also work for rolling out cut-out cookie dough?
sfpaulina at 1:28AM on 12/19/07
Just moments ago,UPS delivered the kitchen scale I ordered from Sears over the weekend. Looks like I have an excuse to do some baking tonight.
dmcavanagh at 3:50PM on 12/11/08