Seriously Delicious Holiday Giveaway: Two Peter Luger Steaks
Today we're giving away a package of two prime, dry-aged ("longer than four weeks") porterhouse steaks, thanks to the generous folks at Peter Luger. These steaks are not small. Each weighs more than two pounds. The steaks come with two bottles of Peter Luger steak sauce and a bag of chocolate coins.
To win, just answer this in the comments below: What's your favorite cut of steak?
You have until noon ET tomorrow (Thursday, December 27) to enter. One winner will be chosen at random from among the commenters. The standard Serious Eats contest rules apply.
PS: If you just can't wait for this contest to be over and want to order steaks right now from Peter Luger, you may do so here. You will make any serious carnivores on your list very happy.
Comments are closed: 847 Comments:
cowboy rib eye
hicoffice at 12:17PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse.
floretbroc at 12:18PM on 12/26/07
t bone
gidget at 12:19PM on 12/26/07
porterhouse
brooke29 at 12:20PM on 12/26/07
Filet mignon
Cheran at 12:20PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse!!!
whippingwater at 12:21PM on 12/26/07
porterhouse
eatnutmeg at 12:21PM on 12/26/07
filet or porterhouse or tbone or sirloin or ribeye. :-)
jbfrommi at 12:22PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse
ranya112 at 12:23PM on 12/26/07
filet mignon!!! What a great Boxing Day treat!
Teri at 12:24PM on 12/26/07
Filet mignon.
rffoodie at 12:26PM on 12/26/07
Carpaccio!!
ianmoore at 12:26PM on 12/26/07
ribeye
bhforc at 12:27PM on 12/26/07
Poterhouse.
LindaY at 12:28PM on 12/26/07
Filet mignon
scentednights2002 at 12:28PM on 12/26/07
bone in ribeye
goodbyeohio at 12:30PM on 12/26/07
Def the Porterhouse!!! mmm...
mmmichele at 12:31PM on 12/26/07
filet mignon!
parkercat at 12:32PM on 12/26/07
Gotta be porterhouse.
kmg365 at 12:32PM on 12/26/07
ribeye
marelsa at 12:33PM on 12/26/07
Bone -in- Ribeye
smythbr at 12:33PM on 12/26/07
Bone in Rib Eye, Black&Blue!
bessfour at 12:33PM on 12/26/07
Filet Mignon is the best!
iamcdron at 12:34PM on 12/26/07
filet mignon
celticbikerbabe at 12:35PM on 12/26/07
filet mignon, natch.
weeblet at 12:36PM on 12/26/07
New York Strip
BeauRivage at 12:37PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse of course!!!!!
courtneyp at 12:39PM on 12/26/07
I LOVE A THICK JUICY SIRLOIN.
lawman228 at 12:40PM on 12/26/07
Filet!
PattyCho at 12:40PM on 12/26/07
Luger's Porterhouse rocks! That's my favorite cut. I also love a rare strip steak from time to time.
Rosetta at 12:42PM on 12/26/07
T-bone--definitely--grilled or barbequed to medium rare--YUMMY!
kathyb53 at 12:43PM on 12/26/07
filet
balanese2001 at 12:43PM on 12/26/07
filet
carcon at 12:44PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse. Definitely.
Cheesewit at 12:46PM on 12/26/07
Filet mignon...... rare, smothered in sauteed mushrooms. (That's probably more info than you needed to know, but I'm seriously hungry right now!)
mincognita at 12:48PM on 12/26/07
ribeye.
mango at 12:48PM on 12/26/07
A big, thick ribeye, medium rare and nice 'n salty!
Nesie at 12:49PM on 12/26/07
My Fave - Porterhouse steaks !
jsicolts at 12:50PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse...Yummy!!
Thank you!
tmim123 at 12:51PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse, please!
jbernet at 12:51PM on 12/26/07
I love porterhouse steak I hope I win
animanni1 at 12:51PM on 12/26/07
ribeye
raspberryberet at 12:53PM on 12/26/07
Gotta be Porterhouse!
jenberger at 12:53PM on 12/26/07
filet
susan1215 at 12:54PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse on the grill of course.
daveg227 at 12:54PM on 12/26/07
new york strip
shay77 at 12:54PM on 12/26/07
Prime rib is my fav, with lots of horseradish sauce, but I like all kinds of steak. Yummy Yum Yum!!!
kycejo at 12:55PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse
Orono1 at 12:56PM on 12/26/07
T-bone
Suesur at 12:56PM on 12/26/07
Ribeye
mbtmom at 12:57PM on 12/26/07
still love the porterhouse
threedogkitchen at 12:57PM on 12/26/07
porterhouse, all the way.
aburke6666 at 12:58PM on 12/26/07
porterhouse
paryjeja at 12:58PM on 12/26/07
bone-in ribeye
TheJTrain at 12:59PM on 12/26/07
ribeye
kathyvegas at 1:00PM on 12/26/07
ribeye
ride&cook at 1:01PM on 12/26/07
dry-aged ribeye
foodiegirl71 at 1:01PM on 12/26/07
ribeye
feep at 1:02PM on 12/26/07
I love a filet!
bargaingirl at 1:02PM on 12/26/07
Filet mignon
Teddy at 1:03PM on 12/26/07
Filet Mignon
marlmuck at 1:03PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse
CVilleBilly at 1:03PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse hands down
jphillips776 at 1:04PM on 12/26/07
Filet all the way.
tanners12 at 1:04PM on 12/26/07
filet mignon
mhgatti at 1:05PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse
gscherr at 1:07PM on 12/26/07
Sirloin. Yum steak and chocolate. They each deserve to have their own tier on the food group pyramid.
angelfish at 1:09PM on 12/26/07
New York Strip, rare
dadekian at 1:10PM on 12/26/07
T-bone
crashers525 at 1:13PM on 12/26/07
I'll take a hanger.
calamityjake at 1:13PM on 12/26/07
I Love Sirloin Steak
Mur6950 at 1:13PM on 12/26/07
I love a great New York strip.
ceriously at 1:16PM on 12/26/07
definitely the ribeye
dewayne at 1:16PM on 12/26/07
ribeye
catmint12 at 1:17PM on 12/26/07
porterhouse are my fave
jblue at 1:17PM on 12/26/07
filet mignon
myfflyn at 1:17PM on 12/26/07
FILET MIGNON OF COURSE
pcbdolphins at 1:21PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse rules! You people who say filet mignon -- yeah, it's tender, but you're missing out on a whole lot of flavor!
Gwenelle at 1:21PM on 12/26/07
filet mignon
izackcarson at 1:21PM on 12/26/07
filet
jtennantwise at 1:22PM on 12/26/07
Um...porterhouse?!
EmmaC at 1:22PM on 12/26/07
porterhouse
cmarro19 at 1:22PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse
curmudgeon at 1:22PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse, all the way! Especially if it's smothered in sauteed onions & mushrooms
dbaxgirl51 at 1:22PM on 12/26/07
porterhouse. A good hunk of steak is MY favorite food!
kris_1492 at 1:22PM on 12/26/07
Hard to pick a favorite, I like them all! -- Filet mignon
HSlater351 at 1:22PM on 12/26/07
Grilled bone in ribeye!!!
mdashkin at 1:23PM on 12/26/07
Filet Mignon :)
LusciousJ3 at 1:25PM on 12/26/07
Ribeye
gotrootdude at 1:25PM on 12/26/07
Gotta be the NY Strip, but I also like filet mignon.
SonjaK at 1:26PM on 12/26/07
T Bone!! YUM!!
bfox74 at 1:26PM on 12/26/07
Midwest Prime Rib. So soft and lovely.
Sarajahii at 1:27PM on 12/26/07
Ribeye, if you please
omnivore at 1:27PM on 12/26/07
Filet
GoldenEel at 1:27PM on 12/26/07
Hanger steak
tartetatin at 1:28PM on 12/26/07
strip
mverno at 1:28PM on 12/26/07
Bone-in ribeye, for sure...and MAN, am I craving one right now!
bettyjoan at 1:29PM on 12/26/07
wow! ribeye for me please...
cook eat FRET at 1:30PM on 12/26/07
ribeye
angi261 at 1:30PM on 12/26/07
a new york strip steak. in pepper corns. no sauce needed
bigbob1958 at 1:30PM on 12/26/07
ribeye!
sadiellen at 1:31PM on 12/26/07
Ribeye for taste but sirloin for mouth feel.
Nabozny at 1:31PM on 12/26/07
porterhouse
kevlney at 1:31PM on 12/26/07
rub some cut garlic over a thick porterhouse steak and throw it on the barbeque!
Dianalah at 1:32PM on 12/26/07
New York au poive (I can't spell). Hope I win!
thaddius at 1:32PM on 12/26/07
Has to be T bone steak.
chrochlin at 1:32PM on 12/26/07
My fav is Ribeye!
janetfaye at 1:34PM on 12/26/07
Filet mignon
zekks at 1:34PM on 12/26/07
skirt steak
carusoc at 1:35PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse for sure!
therealpotato at 1:35PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse
tradertiki at 1:35PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse
kktwins at 1:35PM on 12/26/07
porterhouse
mepolo at 1:37PM on 12/26/07
rib(@)
wapiti7777 at 1:37PM on 12/26/07
nothing but ribeye....best in the world
zman1858 at 1:37PM on 12/26/07
T-Bone for me :-)
fluegas5 at 1:38PM on 12/26/07
RIBEYE,OH YEAH!!!
jeleigh99 at 1:38PM on 12/26/07
Can't get any better than rib eye for me. Mmmmm
jlc123 at 1:38PM on 12/26/07
FILET MIGNON!!
saxoman at 1:38PM on 12/26/07
ribeye
Tomas at 1:39PM on 12/26/07
Filet
Twipey at 1:39PM on 12/26/07
ribeye
mdv1410 at 1:39PM on 12/26/07
Bone-in Ribeye, medium rare, crusty on the outside, covered in sauteed mushrooms and, of course, a fine cabernet.
Grifola frondosa at 1:39PM on 12/26/07
It's a tie between Filet Mignon and New York Strip. I also love a really well-prepared Flank Steak... tender yet slightly chewy, and oh so flavorful...
LoCo at 1:40PM on 12/26/07
A seriously rare prime rib.
TrayMona at 1:40PM on 12/26/07
porterhouse
joanne117 at 1:41PM on 12/26/07
rib-eyeeeee
curse at 1:42PM on 12/26/07
Ribeye is the BEST................
shawn at 1:42PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse!
JeffsInTheKitchen at 1:44PM on 12/26/07
New York Strip
hoping4amiracle at 1:44PM on 12/26/07
definetly RibEye .... yes.
toyota at 1:45PM on 12/26/07
chuckeye!
anaheim at 1:46PM on 12/26/07
Filet
robotbill at 1:49PM on 12/26/07
I love them all - porterhouse, t-bone, rib eye - just point me to a steak and I'm happy.
willitara at 1:50PM on 12/26/07
filet mignon does it for me!
JMCilento at 1:50PM on 12/26/07
The Porterhouse--it is the King and Queen of Steaks!!!
bespo81 at 1:50PM on 12/26/07
Ribeye
paintime at 1:53PM on 12/26/07
My favorite cut of steak is one that is cooked medium rare with a nice bernaise sauce.
greenfield at 1:53PM on 12/26/07
T-Bone
cgeo2000 at 1:54PM on 12/26/07
Fillet mignon
x86cpu at 1:54PM on 12/26/07
Hanger steak. Medium rare. Red wine reduction.
cdegel at 1:55PM on 12/26/07
Rib Eye
pemabuk at 1:56PM on 12/26/07
i love ribeye!
berwyn at 1:57PM on 12/26/07
filet and ribeye. Oh, ok, porterhouse.
msecondo at 1:57PM on 12/26/07
filet mignon
kingsinister at 1:57PM on 12/26/07
well, i'm a vegetarian - but my wife and kids love steak and i'm in charge of grilling them. kids have not yet had a porterhouse, i'd be thrilled to grill them some!
stevea at 1:57PM on 12/26/07
PORTERHOUSE!!!!!!!!!!!!!
cdziuba at 1:58PM on 12/26/07
T-bone!!
rubyneko at 1:58PM on 12/26/07
filet mignon
umassfen at 1:59PM on 12/26/07
It's a tie between porterhouse & filet.
kwenzel at 2:01PM on 12/26/07
T-Bone
shel704 at 2:02PM on 12/26/07
as I said before, porterhousefilethangerstripskirtribeyecubechickenfriedflank.
rps at 2:02PM on 12/26/07
New York Strip.
jenkins at 2:03PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse!
robnolen at 2:03PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse
SelimaCat at 2:03PM on 12/26/07
Ribeye Charred on outside, Rare on inside.
attgig at 2:03PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse
elysek at 2:04PM on 12/26/07
New York Strip. Filet. I love red meat.
lo82070 at 2:04PM on 12/26/07
Filet mignon
lightkeeper54 at 2:05PM on 12/26/07
porterhouse
mamamouse at 2:07PM on 12/26/07
ribeye
brandonphx at 2:09PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse all the way baby!
jnjn123 at 2:09PM on 12/26/07
medium rare, filet mignon. I like the pinwheels that have the filet spiralled with spinach and cheese
mellaw1124 at 2:10PM on 12/26/07
Sirloin for flavor, hands down
Jrlobo at 2:10PM on 12/26/07
Anything with lots of fat.....I know, I know
eyzofblu63 at 2:11PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse, for me.
dcoates at 2:12PM on 12/26/07
ribeye
pdxirishman at 2:14PM on 12/26/07
T-bone medium rare
drming5k at 2:16PM on 12/26/07
Filet mignon
redron at 2:16PM on 12/26/07
London Broil........Medium rare
vetstadium at 2:17PM on 12/26/07
New York strip medium rare. :) What a delicious giveaway!
mom24girls at 2:18PM on 12/26/07
Ribeye, flatiron a close second
judyob at 2:20PM on 12/26/07
tenderloin
bev1132 at 2:20PM on 12/26/07
Depends on the wine (or the beer) and the sides, But NOTHING beats a medium rare porterhouse, baked potato and baked beans! Git 'er done!!!
talkingtex at 2:20PM on 12/26/07
Delicious, delectable filet mignon.
schorel at 2:23PM on 12/26/07
Porthouse steak
furman1144 at 2:24PM on 12/26/07
Grilled Steak is Great!
Stephen1969 at 2:24PM on 12/26/07
yum...t-bone
mozart23 at 2:26PM on 12/26/07
Ribeye. This is a cool prize for my hubby whose hobby is cooking.
harmonden at 2:26PM on 12/26/07
filet mignon
cev426 at 2:28PM on 12/26/07
Prime Rib - we had the best prime rib for Christmas with a red wine peppercorn reduction. We used an Australian Merlot, mmmmm!
janthecarnivore at 2:29PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse please!
alicat68 at 2:29PM on 12/26/07
ribeye, rare.
fsmchang at 2:29PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse
plhill2000 at 2:30PM on 12/26/07
ribeye
disgustingfoodie at 2:32PM on 12/26/07
New York Strip Steak - RARE
MrTechno at 2:32PM on 12/26/07
Filet Mignon...for sure!
icebox36 at 2:32PM on 12/26/07
Prime rib would be my favorite choice, but T-bones, porterhouse and ribeyes rank right up there at our house too. We just love Beef !
goodthunder at 2:33PM on 12/26/07
Ribeye, definitely.
digitalfish at 2:34PM on 12/26/07
ribeye
llinda29 at 2:35PM on 12/26/07
Rare ribeye!
michba at 2:35PM on 12/26/07
ribeye
vixita at 2:36PM on 12/26/07
porterhouse :)
skalobster11 at 2:36PM on 12/26/07
NY Strip
betty at 2:36PM on 12/26/07
Cowboy cut Ribeye!
tripateam at 2:37PM on 12/26/07
yum! new york strip!
friedom at 2:37PM on 12/26/07
ribeye
n5rat at 2:38PM on 12/26/07
ribeye
brunjaune at 2:40PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse and NY Strip
rugbyspartan at 2:41PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse
jessejames819 at 2:42PM on 12/26/07
Filet Mignon
Das615 at 2:42PM on 12/26/07
Ribeye
utahups at 2:46PM on 12/26/07
ny strip
jellosheriff at 2:48PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse
jkershen at 2:48PM on 12/26/07
Ribeye, please!
gduran at 2:48PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse
Suekey at 2:50PM on 12/26/07
Filet Mignon!
wufferhund at 2:50PM on 12/26/07
It really depends on my mood--usually a ribeye, but I have a hard time saying no to an offer of a hanger steak.
beano at 2:53PM on 12/26/07
porterhouse
gpadav at 2:53PM on 12/26/07
Would love to try this for the New Year!
Teeeveee at 2:54PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse!
schnitzel at 2:54PM on 12/26/07
filet mignion,sirloin,ribeye, then porterhouse
ddyddy at 2:57PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse
someguy at 2:58PM on 12/26/07
delmonico
royny23 at 2:59PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse always.
jpq123 at 3:00PM on 12/26/07
In our house, we love any steak.... period. Given the choice, I always choose a porterhouse. Usually we eat them at about an inch thick so they cook up real nice on the grill, we prefer them med. rare.
Our brother-in-law buys them from a popular meat freezer plan and pays a fortune for them, and they are nothing to write home about....I prefer to go to the store and pick them out myself, choosing ones with lots of marbling for that tender, juicy taste.
Ok, now you've got me really hungry for steak.....
ababe28 at 3:02PM on 12/26/07
My summer as a butcher taught me that a porterhouse has the highest quality-to-cost ratio, but when I'm craving beef, I want flank steak, marinated for hours in garlic and mustard.
jasonbaldwin at 3:03PM on 12/26/07
I love a great T-bone grilled with fresh garlic.
drala625 at 3:04PM on 12/26/07
Filet Mignon
lovercas at 3:04PM on 12/26/07
rib eye
billygoat at 3:07PM on 12/26/07
Rib-eye
sjwoodin at 3:07PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse
witchy64 at 3:08PM on 12/26/07
Prime rib, but if it comes off a cow, we'll pretty much eat it.
redfantum at 3:08PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse.
ELYSESW at 3:08PM on 12/26/07
Delmonico is the way to go.
doglover at 3:09PM on 12/26/07
Rib eye, bone in.
Medium rare.
Rookiecook at 3:10PM on 12/26/07
Ribeye, medium-rare
SunnysideUp at 3:10PM on 12/26/07
T-bone
DwayneW at 3:10PM on 12/26/07
NY Strip
ScotSpiwak at 3:10PM on 12/26/07
Filet Mignon or marinated flat iron.
bobcatsteph3 at 3:11PM on 12/26/07
skirt steak, rare
jamesl8n at 3:12PM on 12/26/07
filet mignon, the french are right about something!
RCF60527 at 3:12PM on 12/26/07
My fav has got to be a Rib Eye
mbrevard at 3:12PM on 12/26/07
On the strange side, I LOVE stuffed flank steak with a butter/mushroom sauce. YUMMY!
sweepster49 at 3:12PM on 12/26/07
ribeye
NomNomNom at 3:15PM on 12/26/07
Filet all the way !
bleweye at 3:17PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse!!!
Sylla Rynry at 3:19PM on 12/26/07
Prime rib
edknees at 3:21PM on 12/26/07
NY Strip... mmm
virgored at 3:22PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse, charred rare please.
cookbot at 3:22PM on 12/26/07
filet mignon!
woodenspoon at 3:22PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse
maddgiggler at 3:23PM on 12/26/07
porterhouse
rosidentevil at 3:23PM on 12/26/07
filet mignon
MajaMeza79 at 3:26PM on 12/26/07
delmonico
stlydr at 3:27PM on 12/26/07
porterhouse
JudyH at 3:28PM on 12/26/07
Filet Mignon is my favorite.
Xaubf at 3:28PM on 12/26/07
porterhouse
gala2 at 3:29PM on 12/26/07
porterhouse.
tish123 at 3:29PM on 12/26/07
filet mignon
fshapiro at 3:29PM on 12/26/07
filet mignon
Emelie at 3:31PM on 12/26/07
rib eye
apmd428 at 3:31PM on 12/26/07
A beautifully seasoned and seared sirloin...yummy!!!
cojay10 at 3:32PM on 12/26/07
Rib Eye
motwell at 3:32PM on 12/26/07
Rib eye
sillelin at 3:34PM on 12/26/07
Rib eye has the most flavor.
Tom Steele at 3:35PM on 12/26/07
With my dentures I look for the most tender cut, so Filet Mignon is for me.
sdadolf at 3:38PM on 12/26/07
Cowboy cut
cmckenna at 3:40PM on 12/26/07
PrimeRib
cindyb at 3:41PM on 12/26/07
filet mignon-medium
googy at 3:42PM on 12/26/07
T-bone, rare, from Colorado grass and corn fed beef.
rodeogranny at 3:43PM on 12/26/07
new york strip
gladstone7272 at 3:44PM on 12/26/07
NY Strip Steak. Yummm.
Aisling at 3:45PM on 12/26/07
If I can find it, Porterhouse for sure.
CarolHarrity at 3:48PM on 12/26/07
black and blue ribeye...yum!
jacklynanne at 3:49PM on 12/26/07
Filet mignon
nsord44 at 3:51PM on 12/26/07
FILET MIGNON
Happyhusky at 3:52PM on 12/26/07
T-Bone
Thank you
znzn123 at 3:54PM on 12/26/07
filet mignon
slb3334 at 3:55PM on 12/26/07
I love T-Bone steaks - learned it from my dad, and I carry on the tradition!
RoseBC at 3:57PM on 12/26/07
FILET MIGNON!
deesbree at 3:58PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse, cut thick, charred and bloody.
EJtheDJ at 3:58PM on 12/26/07
Filet Mignon
janetnels at 3:59PM on 12/26/07
T Bone!!!
ydsddd at 4:02PM on 12/26/07
Ribeye- always
russrpm at 4:05PM on 12/26/07
I AM A T-BONE MAN
GOING41 at 4:06PM on 12/26/07
Ribeye.
bettycracker at 4:06PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse, oh yeah
Rexthedog at 4:07PM on 12/26/07
ribeye.......smothered in kosher salt and garlic powder......crisp on the outside .......delicate and rare on the inside......
parker at 4:07PM on 12/26/07
Filet Mignon
kamewh at 4:09PM on 12/26/07
filet mignon
dan031082 at 4:11PM on 12/26/07
porterhouse, all the way!
sweetscove at 4:11PM on 12/26/07
Prime rib from standing rib roast coated with horseradish and garlic.
SEFB9118 at 4:11PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse is always my first choice, followed closely by NY Strip then Ribeye... pretty much can't go wrong with any cut if it is cooked right, though. Great prize, thanks. :)
dovie at 4:13PM on 12/26/07
I love Rib Eye with a marinade of crushed onion, garlic and salt and pepper!
irish51 at 4:16PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse - medium rare
leeleemac at 4:16PM on 12/26/07
What a great prize. I am a lover of thick cut sirloin.
cornbella at 4:17PM on 12/26/07
A juicy thick medium rare prime rib, oh, my mouth is watering up just thinking about it!
ajavagal at 4:17PM on 12/26/07
hanger
zach272 at 4:17PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse
Mike Sula at 4:18PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse please! thanks.
mcc32 at 4:20PM on 12/26/07
MMMMMMMMMMMMMM
STEAK !!!!
I LOVE IT ALL
TODAYS FAVORITE
IS
PORTHOUSE
MED/RARE
WITH HERB BUTTER
routewrecker at 4:21PM on 12/26/07
PRIME RIB!!!
cre8tveminde at 4:22PM on 12/26/07
Definitely porterhouse
sadkins at 4:22PM on 12/26/07
Man, have you got my mouth watering about a thick, juicy porterhouse steak, my favorite by all means!!!
omaha98 at 4:23PM on 12/26/07
Filet Mignon! Final answer!
leandrew37 at 4:23PM on 12/26/07
T Bone
murph675 at 4:25PM on 12/26/07
Ribeye on the bone; onglet off
hrobb at 4:27PM on 12/26/07
although i enjoy a steak, my fav is prime rib
etrnlone at 4:28PM on 12/26/07
Give me an arm roast
tcover at 4:29PM on 12/26/07
Ribeye bone-in, lip on.
rickster at 4:29PM on 12/26/07
I love a medium rare filet mignon!
ChiefFamilyOfficer at 4:30PM on 12/26/07
Mmmm. Filet mignon.
agardener at 4:32PM on 12/26/07
I'll take a tenderloin, medium rare, please
kwils at 4:32PM on 12/26/07
filet mignon all the way
banquetbabe at 4:32PM on 12/26/07
ribeye
lavenhouse at 4:33PM on 12/26/07
bone-in filet
thotfulspot at 4:34PM on 12/26/07
Same answer, NY Strip with a little Bleu Cheese and a good red wine.
peonynut at 4:34PM on 12/26/07
I'll take a Tenderloin, medium rare, please
kwils at 4:34PM on 12/26/07
strip, please
jd7979 at 4:36PM on 12/26/07
filet mignon for me
mverno at 4:38PM on 12/26/07
ny strip
uscbecca at 4:40PM on 12/26/07
Bone in rib eye rare!
tknodcmn at 4:44PM on 12/26/07
ny strip!
Littlebluesiren at 4:46PM on 12/26/07
Delmonico!!!!!!!!
WiiWinner at 4:48PM on 12/26/07
cowboy cut ribeye
sallbritton at 4:51PM on 12/26/07
Rib eye beats all for us!
rhjames at 4:51PM on 12/26/07
Filet Mignon
sewingmema at 4:52PM on 12/26/07
A Black Diamond T bone steak is the best of heaven. Hmm the memeories make my mouth water.
redtwinkle at 4:54PM on 12/26/07
gimme a dry-aged ribeye, somewhere between rare and medium rare!
guy2k at 4:54PM on 12/26/07
The Porterhouse is the perfect steak for us - Since I love the filet and my husband adores the rest. And Peter Lugar's steak are THE BEST! (And I haven't had the heavenly experience of dining on one since I moved from New York 20 years ago.)
Salleefur at 4:56PM on 12/26/07
Ribeye
ch121 at 4:59PM on 12/26/07
In a conventional steakhouse, filet all the way!
If purchasing from your favorite butcher, the "gizmo" cut is the best steak I ever had!
Snooky at 5:02PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse!
myeager at 5:03PM on 12/26/07
Prime Rib. I have never tried a Porterhouse before.
Tricia316 at 5:04PM on 12/26/07
It's gotta be boneless prime rib
ruthlessu at 5:06PM on 12/26/07
porterhouse.
NinaC at 5:08PM on 12/26/07
ribeye if i'm being really decadent (so flavorful, so much fat), and hangar if i am feeling more ascetic.
mickeymets at 5:10PM on 12/26/07
a bone-in ribeye!
runningwithtweezers at 5:11PM on 12/26/07
sirloin...medium well.
elaine nan at 5:13PM on 12/26/07
a ribeye rare cooked on a charcoal grill
pdwoodall at 5:14PM on 12/26/07
Ribeye
Pupster at 5:17PM on 12/26/07
t-bone on a grill
diesel51 at 5:19PM on 12/26/07
porterhouse for my husband, and a filet mignon for me!
pootieposh at 5:19PM on 12/26/07
Medium rare delmonico, and I grill the best !
ketsil at 5:20PM on 12/26/07
sounds really delicious my hubby loves steak
tcandy214 at 5:21PM on 12/26/07
Prime Rib and Ribeye!
whammyammy at 5:25PM on 12/26/07
sirloin, tenderloin, or really just any really good steak, medium rare.
PrairieThistle at 5:25PM on 12/26/07
Prime Rib for sure.
AllenMcLeod at 5:27PM on 12/26/07
Prime Rib Always!
susanmac at 5:27PM on 12/26/07
I love Porterhouse. Thanks for the really yummy giveaway!
peg42 at 5:29PM on 12/26/07
My favorite is Prime rib. Lots of flavor and very tender.
leech1234 at 5:30PM on 12/26/07
Rib Eye...always..
dentonzee at 5:31PM on 12/26/07
Ribeye.
madball911 at 5:31PM on 12/26/07
T-Bone cooked on the BBQ!
OR541 at 5:33PM on 12/26/07
Ribeye!
writerkathy1 at 5:34PM on 12/26/07
Delmonico!
Mizbee at 5:35PM on 12/26/07
porterhouse
surfwithus at 5:35PM on 12/26/07
prime rib for moi
PoignantTuna at 5:37PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse
deedleweedle at 5:38PM on 12/26/07
Filet mignon
tiffginn21 at 5:39PM on 12/26/07
porterhouse no doubt about it.
carnivore1212 at 5:40PM on 12/26/07
Lightly seasoned NY strip - Medium Rare!!
metally at 5:41PM on 12/26/07
porterhouse
babycat1216 at 5:41PM on 12/26/07
PORTERHOUSE IS THE FINEST CUT OF ALL THE MEATS-HANDS DOWN!!
GDNEUMANN at 5:43PM on 12/26/07
porterhouse
squiggy241 at 5:43PM on 12/26/07
Well, I have recently been introduced to the flat iron ? cut, but I really like a strip steak!
mrshendu at 5:45PM on 12/26/07
ny strip medium rare
jlipof at 5:46PM on 12/26/07
I love a filet or prime rib with a horseradish sauce!
randio at 5:47PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse
BorderMommy at 5:48PM on 12/26/07
NY strip.
Eilen at 5:51PM on 12/26/07
Ribeye
susitravl at 5:51PM on 12/26/07
New York Strip or sirloin flap.
dksbook at 5:52PM on 12/26/07
petite fillet
anninva at 5:54PM on 12/26/07
rib eye
pritesh at 5:55PM on 12/26/07
filet mignon
sylmar at 5:55PM on 12/26/07
As before:
1. Hanger steak
2. Skirt steak
3. Ribeye!
HunterAnglerGardenerCook at 5:55PM on 12/26/07
My favorite steak is a perfectly seasoned 10 to 12 oz. Ribeye! It MUST be grilled to just medium rare and accompanied by a steaming hot baked potato swimming in butter with a large helping of cold sour cream on the side.Perfection!!
terrie48 at 5:56PM on 12/26/07
Thick Juicy Filet Mignon w/Peter Luger Steak Sauce
soozyq263 at 5:56PM on 12/26/07
filet mignon
cdlwin at 6:00PM on 12/26/07
Beef Tenderloin
saturdaynightfever at 6:04PM on 12/26/07
Le petit filet....
zazzie at 6:05PM on 12/26/07
filet mignon, medium rare
anyang at 6:10PM on 12/26/07
filet mignon, cooked medium rare
hitchwins at 6:11PM on 12/26/07
T-Bone
AICORP at 6:12PM on 12/26/07
Filet Mignon rare and wrapped in bacon.
lindasu at 6:12PM on 12/26/07
mmmm...filet mignon
angela67p at 6:13PM on 12/26/07
A nice Porterhouse.
michelleleeh1 at 6:13PM on 12/26/07
porterhouse, medium rare!
kangatron at 6:14PM on 12/26/07
boneless New York strip steak is good!
reome at 6:14PM on 12/26/07
i really don't care as long as it's steak hahahahah!
samanthapayntr at 6:14PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse!
achnss at 6:15PM on 12/26/07
Im cheap, Mine is Denver Steaks, as a cuttout part of the steak, Im saying the middle of the cow.
MCJunkie at 6:16PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse.
sonyasparks at 6:16PM on 12/26/07
In descending order......filet mignon, porterhouse, bone-in ribeye, T-bone and any steak that happens to my plate!
martinscot at 6:17PM on 12/26/07
filet mignon
shamrockin at 6:18PM on 12/26/07
Prime Rib , Injured........
taintnoflatlander at 6:18PM on 12/26/07
A nice rare Porterhouse
fuzzy210 at 6:18PM on 12/26/07
New York strip - medium.
susanhales at 6:21PM on 12/26/07
love porterhouse. always my favorite
vlmolina at 6:23PM on 12/26/07
Gotta have a filet!
julierod at 6:24PM on 12/26/07
That would be Porterhouse of course.
capwell at 6:25PM on 12/26/07
Delmonico
inkypleez at 6:26PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse
jbeckett at 6:27PM on 12/26/07
T-BONE
anniehall4000 at 6:28PM on 12/26/07
Delmonico
sophiepa at 6:29PM on 12/26/07
My fav. cut is Flat iron
prplrush at 6:29PM on 12/26/07
Filet mignon. Thanks for the yummy contest!
RobsGirl123 at 6:29PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse
jpark107 at 6:31PM on 12/26/07
filet mignon - yum!
yankeesgal at 6:33PM on 12/26/07
T-Bone!
n_i_k at 6:35PM on 12/26/07
New York Strip---Yum!
ndbrit at 6:37PM on 12/26/07
Filet Mignon...salt and pepper...butter seared
suenardone at 6:40PM on 12/26/07
flank steak on the grill
anny31 at 6:43PM on 12/26/07
rib eye
phoney2 at 6:43PM on 12/26/07
Steak o' my heart!!
cechastain at 6:45PM on 12/26/07
porterhouse!
grapeisthejam at 6:46PM on 12/26/07
t-bone
jffryclough at 6:50PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse
Deeh69 at 6:53PM on 12/26/07
Can't beat a grilled Porterhouse.
LINDALSHOT at 6:57PM on 12/26/07
Give me something to grill
john1948 at 7:00PM on 12/26/07
Ribeye all the way!
flimsy at 7:01PM on 12/26/07
Filet is for me!
newsome815 at 7:04PM on 12/26/07
t bone
chromiumman at 7:04PM on 12/26/07
Ribeye is the most delicious.
carol1949 at 7:08PM on 12/26/07
N.Y. Strip
cgreggo at 7:09PM on 12/26/07
This contest is making my mouth water!!!
Caramelcafelatte at 7:10PM on 12/26/07
I love filet mignon
arvard at 7:11PM on 12/26/07
A sizzling outdoor grilled Porterhouse steak, medium rare. Topped with golden mushrooms with Sherry and topped with grilled onions.
bmanytimes at 7:12PM on 12/26/07
Ribeye, one inch thick, broiled medium in butter, topped with onions just barely sauteed.
bhouse34 at 7:13PM on 12/26/07
new york strip
chitsuen at 7:18PM on 12/26/07
New York Strip
sbrandsrud at 7:20PM on 12/26/07
Ribeye under the broiler and on the grill
RFerrer at 7:21PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse or T-bone, grilled to rare perfection!
cshli at 7:21PM on 12/26/07
strip
jasmall at 7:22PM on 12/26/07
Ribeye!
tbotzon at 7:22PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse is the only steak I crave. I can barely afford it...but it is so worth it!
gracepap at 7:23PM on 12/26/07
prime rib!
debswild at 7:23PM on 12/26/07
I love PRIMERIB
ckfrrt at 7:23PM on 12/26/07
I've always been happy with a porterhouse
selmayvonne at 7:23PM on 12/26/07
T=BONE FOR SURE
JANEYATES at 7:27PM on 12/26/07
Nothing like a porterhouse............and a nice piece of cheesecake afterwards
tsslug7 at 7:28PM on 12/26/07
Mmm. A tender filet mignon.
torrig at 7:31PM on 12/26/07
Beef....It's what's for dinner.
lvfordguy at 7:33PM on 12/26/07
filet
film_score at 7:35PM on 12/26/07
Tenderloin!
kvelchoff at 7:35PM on 12/26/07
Ribeye
gratton at 7:37PM on 12/26/07
You can't beat a porterhouse, 'cause it's a filet on one side of the T, and a New York strip on the other. Mmm... Thanks for the giveaway!
geekbearinggifts at 7:37PM on 12/26/07
Filet Mignon of course
pclarkaz at 7:37PM on 12/26/07
Mmmm... Delmonico
joni514 at 7:44PM on 12/26/07
Bone-in Ribeye at least 20 oz.
FoodBully at 7:46PM on 12/26/07
porterhouse
angel521 at 7:47PM on 12/26/07
Ribeye
foodhuntress at 7:49PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse.
muchcat at 7:49PM on 12/26/07
I've always been a New York Strip kinda guy myself, but the truth is you can't go wrong with a steak period ;-)
vincenzosi at 7:51PM on 12/26/07
Ribeye!
thecarol at 7:53PM on 12/26/07
filet mignon
cpom01 at 7:54PM on 12/26/07
rib eye
pcrackenhead at 7:57PM on 12/26/07
A medium rare Porterhouse.
steadier571 at 7:57PM on 12/26/07
filet mignon
piepie at 7:57PM on 12/26/07
mmm definately porterhouse or filet mignon! *drooling*
gamblerx17 at 7:58PM on 12/26/07
Well done ribeye
kygirl at 8:04PM on 12/26/07
bacon wrapped filet
denyse at 8:09PM on 12/26/07
My favorite cut of steak is ribeye. I like it cooked medium well.
thscar at 8:10PM on 12/26/07
MEDIUM RARE POTERHOUSE
CARLOSV1205 at 8:11PM on 12/26/07
bacon wrapped filet mignon - med rare
texasdeb at 8:11PM on 12/26/07
Ribeye
naynays1 at 8:11PM on 12/26/07
NY Strip
mindanyc at 8:11PM on 12/26/07
Filet Mignon, I'm hungry now.
ChefCate at 8:15PM on 12/26/07
filet mignon, well done please
t1712mass at 8:15PM on 12/26/07
Rib Eye is always #1
hues262 at 8:16PM on 12/26/07
T-Bone is a pretty funkalicious cut-o-cow.
louispound at 8:16PM on 12/26/07
t-bone
cairech at 8:18PM on 12/26/07
Yummy yummy filet
sachidewey at 8:18PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse is perfect for me!! :)
kybeauty at 8:18PM on 12/26/07
Ribeye, grilled to perfection by my hubby (I'm a lucky girl!!)
cath7227 at 8:18PM on 12/26/07
Cowboy Ribeye
pittypatty at 8:19PM on 12/26/07
Gotta have that T-bone.
ky2here at 8:22PM on 12/26/07
mmm filet mignon
jbear at 8:22PM on 12/26/07
porterhouse is the only way to go!
nimo1910 at 8:23PM on 12/26/07
Club, well done.
juedy at 8:24PM on 12/26/07
ribeye
surfer7382 at 8:26PM on 12/26/07
filet mignon
surfer7382d at 8:27PM on 12/26/07
Filet Mignon... but of course! =D
akovach at 8:28PM on 12/26/07
porterhouse
saphyress at 8:29PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse is the way to go for me.
FoodBoy at 8:30PM on 12/26/07
A full cut, well marbled, 1 inch thick Rib Steak. I'm sure my arteries hate it but my taste buds couldn't be happier!
ppekpb at 8:30PM on 12/26/07
steak in peppercorn sauce!
gsballance at 8:32PM on 12/26/07
A nice thick Ribeye is my favorite cut.
fangirl at 8:33PM on 12/26/07
porterhouse
mayam at 8:34PM on 12/26/07
poterhouse meduim well
blday50 at 8:38PM on 12/26/07
NY strip.
herrinfamily at 8:38PM on 12/26/07
Ribeye
mikepaul at 8:39PM on 12/26/07
Gotta be porterhouse, medium rare, Care to join me?
workintv at 8:40PM on 12/26/07
MMmmmm steak
laraedo at 8:40PM on 12/26/07
A FILET MIGNON
HOPE131 at 8:42PM on 12/26/07
Their marinated porterhouse is considered the best in the US. I am lucky enough to be assigned to a project less than a mile away from their Brooklyn location. Needles to say, I get there for lunch as often as I can and have the porterhouse (for two or four) medium rare.
medfordmike at 8:43PM on 12/26/07
New York Strip or Filet Mignon
sheilaco at 8:46PM on 12/26/07
sirlion
lisargold at 8:48PM on 12/26/07
I love New York Strip steaks done on the grill and grilled to perfection!!! Yum Yum Yum
lisacatron at 8:49PM on 12/26/07
prime rib. yummy
gorgor at 8:49PM on 12/26/07
filet mignon
Mavisr at 8:51PM on 12/26/07
t-bone
beanish at 8:52PM on 12/26/07
Filet Mignon ... cooked rare
JennyGirl04 at 8:53PM on 12/26/07
A porterhouse steak would taste great right now! Thanks for having the contest!
brmetcalf at 8:53PM on 12/26/07
A Nice 1 pound Blackened T-Bone med rare
Hursty44 at 8:54PM on 12/26/07
porterhouse!
kitnlov at 8:56PM on 12/26/07
Bone In Rib-eye, cooked rare.
Scoggdog at 8:57PM on 12/26/07
new york strip, medium rare
mrsbao at 8:57PM on 12/26/07
Nothing beats a bone-in rib eye steak done rare.
wolfmaam at 8:58PM on 12/26/07
t-bone
Traumajunky at 9:04PM on 12/26/07
I like ribeyes the best, but I haven't met too many steaks I don't like. Steaks rock!!!
kimber37 at 9:05PM on 12/26/07
thick t-bone
fedguy at 9:05PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse
steviegirl at 9:05PM on 12/26/07
Sirloin tips
lmiller71 at 9:07PM on 12/26/07
FILET
ds605 at 9:08PM on 12/26/07
Love 'em all, but Prime Rib is my favorite.
TULLFAN at 9:08PM on 12/26/07
filet mignon
csb605 at 9:09PM on 12/26/07
favorite cut of steak - across the grain!
Didn't I already answer this?
saxel at 9:09PM on 12/26/07
Ribeye for me!
tlcfromtn at 9:09PM on 12/26/07
ribeye
beej55 at 9:11PM on 12/26/07
strip
architeuthis at 9:16PM on 12/26/07
Flank steak
redfuzzycow at 9:16PM on 12/26/07
I LOVE a good Porterhouse steak and would LOVE to win this contest. Thanks!
sensitive at 9:17PM on 12/26/07
Ribeye!
grammypennyann at 9:18PM on 12/26/07
i love a good ole NY strip steak
scottr73 at 9:19PM on 12/26/07
Filet Mignon
ldobriko at 9:19PM on 12/26/07
porterlicious porterhouse with a greek salad on the side.
cloudtopper at 9:20PM on 12/26/07
porterhouse
peatheski at 9:22PM on 12/26/07
porterhouse
starbaby1066 at 9:23PM on 12/26/07
The steak I win.
bettylou15 at 9:25PM on 12/26/07
filet mignon
suemayer at 9:29PM on 12/26/07
A ribeye would really taste great after all the turkey and ham I have had over the holidays.
itaskah at 9:31PM on 12/26/07
filet mignon yummy
keeron at 9:32PM on 12/26/07
New York strip, rare
niceflamingo at 9:37PM on 12/26/07
Filet Mignon is my favorite steak.
mullin at 9:38PM on 12/26/07
New York strip
ny_carole at 9:39PM on 12/26/07
NY strip steak - medium rare.
annemarie56 at 9:40PM on 12/26/07
Ribeye
gracecchu at 9:41PM on 12/26/07
ribeye, rare
wwlui at 9:41PM on 12/26/07
Filet Mignon
gatorfanaticalex at 9:43PM on 12/26/07
28 oz. porterhouse
protouch1949 at 9:47PM on 12/26/07
gotta love the filet mignon.
cowleyh at 9:50PM on 12/26/07
Of course porterhouse! It's 2 steaks in 1
robsterclaw at 9:50PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse!!
ldrnc2000 at 9:51PM on 12/26/07
New York Strip
Terri52655 at 9:52PM on 12/26/07
Filet Mignon
cuddles115 at 9:52PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse
1LuckyLady at 9:57PM on 12/26/07
Rare, aged filet mignon for me.
lyonsksl at 9:59PM on 12/26/07
hangar
Mike5534 at 10:00PM on 12/26/07
Mmmmm Poterhouse baby.
roze at 10:02PM on 12/26/07
rib eye!
cybercita at 10:07PM on 12/26/07
Ribeye, please
tinkerbell5676 at 10:08PM on 12/26/07
My mouth is watering..................
filet mignon, med.rare please.
AylorCD at 10:10PM on 12/26/07
Filet mignon is my absolute favorite followed by prime rib with lots of horseradish!
soonergirl99 at 10:12PM on 12/26/07
delmonico
spookyone23 at 10:13PM on 12/26/07
Ribeye! Yummm!
kbama at 10:13PM on 12/26/07
porterhouse!!
mindyb at 10:18PM on 12/26/07
ny strip
BEARHUGS at 10:18PM on 12/26/07
filet
mutley at 10:19PM on 12/26/07
ribeye
applelane at 10:19PM on 12/26/07
filet mignon
lilyrose63 at 10:21PM on 12/26/07
Steaks are my favorite food. I like any kind that are good and tender !!!
kiser5 at 10:23PM on 12/26/07
Filet mignon. . . .
terlor97 at 10:23PM on 12/26/07
ribeye
stacy1955 at 10:24PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse
cindymcc at 10:24PM on 12/26/07
Ribeye
hominamad at 10:25PM on 12/26/07
What's not to love about any great cut of steak, but I'll vote for a Peter Luger porterhouse! (Excuse my drooling.)
Perkins10 at 10:26PM on 12/26/07
Boy do I love Peter Luger's! I love a NY Strip!
laidbackguy7 at 10:30PM on 12/26/07
ribeye yummy!
judycc at 10:31PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse.
Eliz. at 10:35PM on 12/26/07
porter house... yum
purpleshamrock at 10:35PM on 12/26/07
filet mignon
wendymeows at 10:36PM on 12/26/07
I love Ribeye
ScoobyPebb at 10:37PM on 12/26/07
filet mignon
sx2143 at 10:40PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse.
bigtim60 at 10:41PM on 12/26/07
Ribeye...cooked medium...yummy!
suzpman at 10:43PM on 12/26/07
Filet Mignon is hard to beat!
serenity447 at 10:44PM on 12/26/07
Filet Mignon....mmm!
pancak at 10:45PM on 12/26/07
Filet mignon
madeas at 10:45PM on 12/26/07
filet mignon -- woohoo
bobbob6996 at 10:47PM on 12/26/07
Ribeye mmm!
salmon42 at 10:47PM on 12/26/07
ternderloin
nancy1 at 10:49PM on 12/26/07
marinated sirloin tips
pushing60 at 10:51PM on 12/26/07
filet mignon
stacy7911 at 10:54PM on 12/26/07
Filet of course!!
angelaandmelos at 10:55PM on 12/26/07
i could eat a cow...
lkoneil at 10:57PM on 12/26/07
porterhouse
atreau at 10:59PM on 12/26/07
filet
linda at 11:03PM on 12/26/07
ribeye, yum!
Risingstar at 11:04PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse.
nycphoto at 11:05PM on 12/26/07
ribeye
billwinsbig at 11:08PM on 12/26/07
Ribeye!
yellowlabs at 11:09PM on 12/26/07
filet mignon
silvamint at 11:11PM on 12/26/07
Filet
ERhine at 11:13PM on 12/26/07
filet mignon (from Ruth Chris Steak House, I might add)
briguy2001 at 11:13PM on 12/26/07
It would have to be between filet or t-bone
24taz48 at 11:15PM on 12/26/07
filet
nvtribefan at 11:15PM on 12/26/07
Ribeye (from the Stockyards in OK City) is quite all right!
acraigjones at 11:17PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse
Pamela937 at 11:18PM on 12/26/07
Filet mignon
Elkaye at 11:21PM on 12/26/07
porterhouse
gkang at 11:22PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse!
lisalmg at 11:26PM on 12/26/07
New York Strip or Rib Eye. Lordy, just the thought is making me drool!!!!
wwaaww at 11:27PM on 12/26/07
Rib Eye
lorikmcc at 11:31PM on 12/26/07
filet mignon
steevee at 11:31PM on 12/26/07
Strip, NY or KC.
MrSalty at 11:36PM on 12/26/07
filet mignon!
forhisglory at 11:37PM on 12/26/07
Rib Eye is heavenly!
ugogirl at 11:38PM on 12/26/07
favorite cut is ribeye
spliffster at 11:39PM on 12/26/07
Porterhouse!
shenan at 11:39PM on 12/26/07
Prime Rib! no doubt
tomgrove at 11:40PM on 12/26/07
Love T-bone and prime rib!
ratgirl1204 at 11:40PM on 12/26/07
sweetheart steak
Tandan at 11:41PM on 12/26/07
Tbone
Anomaly at 11:42PM on 12/26/07
Well-marbled ribeyes!
cooksultant at 11:43PM on 12/26/07
Today, I'm in a flank steak mood.
GregWA at 11:44PM on 12/26/07
porterhouse
xalexx at 11:46PM on 12/26/07
filet, no seasoning, rare..yummmmmm
SandraLynn128 at 11:50PM on 12/26/07
porterhouse
rc45102 at 11:50PM on 12/26/07
NY Strip....mmmmmm
daniellejodi at 11:53PM on 12/26/07
Ribeye
mayatime at 11:55PM on 12/26/07
ribeye!!!!!
wwfchic at 12:00AM on 12/27/07
porterhouse
jmhender at 12:00AM on 12/27/07
porterhouse
legendj01 at 12:01AM on 12/27/07
T-Bone
pamoonbtc at 12:02AM on 12/27/07
Porterhouse, still moo-ing.
freakdujour at 12:02AM on 12/27/07
I like ribeye.
Bakersdozen at 12:04AM on 12/27/07
Ribeye
adc520 at 12:07AM on 12/27/07
Wow, pick one fave? That's really tough! No pun intended! :) Filet of course....Porterhouse comes in really close to it!
tiglesia at 12:07AM on 12/27/07
Ribeye (very well marbled) is my absolute favorite ~ Charred on the outside, medium rare on the inside. I cannot believe how wonderful all of your giveaways are.....they just keep getting better and better...
bndraldy at 12:12AM on 12/27/07
Prime ribeye, medium rare, and second choice, bacon-wrapped filet medium.
TamaraDLMerritt at 12:14AM on 12/27/07
filet butterflied!
dewer421 at 12:18AM on 12/27/07
T-Bone Steak, has always been my favorite :)
beetle259 at 12:24AM on 12/27/07
I love all steak but t-bone is a really special cut.
joyja191 at 12:26AM on 12/27/07
I have to say New York Strip is my favorite! Filet mignon comes close though :)
Redsnoopy1977 at 12:26AM on 12/27/07
Porterhouse, of course!!!
fseriouseats at 12:32AM on 12/27/07
cowboy
ashtonkorver at 12:35AM on 12/27/07
filet, ribeye, flat iron
feelgood at 12:35AM on 12/27/07
Filet
jayfr at 12:37AM on 12/27/07
Porterhouse. Who wins these contests, anyway?
dimsumfan at 12:39AM on 12/27/07
Porterhouse, thick-cut, with a nice filet section is definitely my fave. Skirt-steak, done churrasco-style, is a close second.
Julie at 12:41AM on 12/27/07
Ribeye
Schlauberger at 12:42AM on 12/27/07
porterhouse baby
allancarol at 12:43AM on 12/27/07
Porterhouse (med. well please.. YUM!)
LauraWilliamsMusings at 12:50AM on 12/27/07
I don't know my steaks very well... but I like almost all steak!
Brookelorren at 12:55AM on 12/27/07
filet mignon
laurenhenry at 12:58AM on 12/27/07
Filet mignon! Now I'm hungry...
christamt at 1:00AM on 12/27/07
a good thick ribeye. no question about it.
rachel tsunami at 1:05AM on 12/27/07
A thick, thick ribeye!
skullaria at 1:20AM on 12/27/07
filet or sirloin... mmmm steak!
Svera at 1:27AM on 12/27/07
Porterhouse!
arman52 at 1:36AM on 12/27/07
Love Porterhouse and Peter Lugers
tripletdad53 at 1:41AM on 12/27/07
Filet Mignon.
JANNET81888 at 1:47AM on 12/27/07
My hubbys steak
zoehunter at 1:48AM on 12/27/07
Thick, aged, porterhouse steaks like these are wonderful when cooked on the grill medium rare and then carved. We use a product called CHAR CRUST on our steaks. It gives the steaks a steakhouse char on the backyard grill. The marbled red interior is almost too beautiful to eat! And, our late dog would go nuts waiting for the T bone.
jcpawlik at 1:59AM on 12/27/07
Filet Mignon.
HYDEIST at 2:00AM on 12/27/07
Any steak is a good steak!
morty63 at 2:08AM on 12/27/07
I love a good bacon wrapped sirloin
dianerph at 2:09AM on 12/27/07
new york for me please. thanks!
clallen at 2:09AM on 12/27/07
Hmm Sirlon
revanche2 at 2:13AM on 12/27/07
Rib-eye
Bunnylips at 2:15AM on 12/27/07
Choose just one!!!...Cruel!...give me a NY Strip...a Porterhouse...or OOOh please I love them all!
sugarpaws at 2:20AM on 12/27/07
Ribeye,
janieluten49 at 2:22AM on 12/27/07
A rib-eye or Porterhouse steak. Thanks!
gracey at 2:23AM on 12/27/07
ribeye's are to drool for
ashadevine at 2:32AM on 12/27/07
Boneless rib, but Porterhouse is OK, too.
AHR at 2:34AM on 12/27/07
rare prime rib
azrosebud at 2:36AM on 12/27/07
love t-bone
Judyv12306 at 2:48AM on 12/27/07
I'm in the ribeye or porterhouse camp!
wypark at 2:50AM on 12/27/07
Filet Mignon
schemme at 2:52AM on 12/27/07
I love Sirloin.
belay55 at 2:54AM on 12/27/07
Porterhouse, please!
mrsesquilo at 2:57AM on 12/27/07
Porterhouse
elkstorm at 3:08AM on 12/27/07
T-bone
jkuebler at 3:11AM on 12/27/07
New York Strip
GinaE1980 at 3:12AM on 12/27/07
T-Bone
singermagic1 at 3:20AM on 12/27/07
porterhouse- med rare- burnt fat!
jinhee at 3:29AM on 12/27/07
A nice, thick filet mignon
RGPD911 at 3:54AM on 12/27/07
ribeye
jennifer57 at 3:58AM on 12/27/07
T-bone
sassy1 at 4:07AM on 12/27/07
filet
jmahurin40 at 4:29AM on 12/27/07
Ribeye!
gabrielj1 at 4:36AM on 12/27/07
I am a serious carnivore...a juicy, tender porterhouse is primo!
inthesticks at 5:09AM on 12/27/07
T-bone for me!
miriama59 at 5:14AM on 12/27/07
Porterhouse, yummy.
misspita at 5:14AM on 12/27/07
Rib-eye
TES283 at 5:31AM on 12/27/07
Rib eye is the best cut, as far as I am concerned
bigfoot at 5:41AM on 12/27/07
A rib-eye is the best!!
debiwelbon at 5:41AM on 12/27/07
T-bone please
bosslady2898 at 5:45AM on 12/27/07
t bone
thomasviggiano at 5:49AM on 12/27/07
Porterhouse
karlevans at 5:53AM on 12/27/07
Porterhouse
dlguss at 5:55AM on 12/27/07
delmonico
panzerschlep at 5:55AM on 12/27/07
T-Bone
net03 at 6:00AM on 12/27/07
Fillet minon with mushrooms.
rdoor at 6:03AM on 12/27/07
A tender filet is my first choice in steak, primarily because it is the perfect size and texture for me. Of course, having it wrapped in bacon is the ONLY way to prepare it, along with some delicious herb butter.....my mouth is watering at 6 a.m.
flabookworm at 6:12AM on 12/27/07
Ribeye!! mmmmm....
THELASTRESORT at 6:16AM on 12/27/07
Porterhouse!
josiern at 6:26AM on 12/27/07
It's New York Strip
bhoward626 at 6:38AM on 12/27/07
porterhouse
jean8 at 6:47AM on 12/27/07
A nice 37oz Dry aged Porterhouse Steak
Sistersis at 6:50AM on 12/27/07
Not a fair question..Take your Pick..Large Filet Mignon..Large Porterhouse..Large New York Strip...Hey I Love STEAK !!!!
Gunny at 6:51AM on 12/27/07
ribeye
sueburch4 at 6:53AM on 12/27/07
There is no question that Porterhouse is the best cut of steak. It offers a a good size steak with with a huge tender filet.
luckycool at 6:54AM on 12/27/07
Prime Rib
lsfish at 6:56AM on 12/27/07
porterhouse
triceratops at 6:59AM on 12/27/07
Ribeye has the best flavor
miatamike1991 at 7:03AM on 12/27/07
filet mignon
Devacat at 7:09AM on 12/27/07
Prime Rib roast please
nibot1946 at 7:12AM on 12/27/07
Ribeye
zeke5145 at 7:15AM on 12/27/07
Porterhouse. Yum.
littlecat123 at 7:15AM on 12/27/07
Prime rib
toughturtles at 7:16AM on 12/27/07
Definitely filet mignon
tjwor at 7:21AM on 12/27/07
ribeye
maweisberg at 7:21AM on 12/27/07
N Y Strip
oldseabee at 7:22AM on 12/27/07
Porterhous - medium rare
tauntonlake at 7:30AM on 12/27/07
Filet mignon is my favorite.
hawkshoe at 7:31AM on 12/27/07
ribeye
vboackle at 7:31AM on 12/27/07
Porterhous - medium rare
tlak06 at 7:32AM on 12/27/07
seriously sirloin!
trishden at 7:35AM on 12/27/07
Sirloin!
carscheles at 7:37AM on 12/27/07
Cowboy ribeye, rare!
vholdman at 7:38AM on 12/27/07
Tenderloin
dikaryon at 7:44AM on 12/27/07
filet mignon
tchoughtby at 7:46AM on 12/27/07
t-bone
KEFLON at 7:58AM on 12/27/07
ribeye
shell32467 at 8:03AM on 12/27/07
t-bone
dhunt at 8:03AM on 12/27/07
ribeye
nicnac at 8:07AM on 12/27/07
NY Strip
richtortora at 8:08AM on 12/27/07
ribeye
pantherpaw at 8:14AM on 12/27/07
NY Strip here too
cmvitello at 8:14AM on 12/27/07
Filet Mignon
216amyc at 8:19AM on 12/27/07
ribeye - the perfect steak
NanaBear at 8:21AM on 12/27/07
Prim rib.
ruthing73 at 8:23AM on 12/27/07
I love T-bone steak!!
mariana at 8:27AM on 12/27/07
filet but will try porter very very soon
bingsy at 8:32AM on 12/27/07
ribeye
jcool at 8:36AM on 12/27/07
porterhouse
guido at 8:37AM on 12/27/07
filet mignon
dorry at 8:39AM on 12/27/07
While I can't eat steak right now (pregnant and refuse to eat well-done steak at the moment) my husband can and he LOVES a good porterhouse.
MrsCa at 8:42AM on 12/27/07
Porterhouse is KING!!!
warbucksbg at 8:43AM on 12/27/07
prime rib
renemarie at 8:43AM on 12/27/07
My favorite is the strip or New York cut of beef rare of course..
bb97036 at 8:46AM on 12/27/07
rib eye
mwfernandez at 8:50AM on 12/27/07
ribeye
lilyk at 8:50AM on 12/27/07
Porterhouse
jmagloro at 8:51AM on 12/27/07
NY Strip... the best!!!
missdenisepa at 8:51AM on 12/27/07
Ribeye, porterhouse, filet mignon... they're all good!
lisab411 at 8:52AM on 12/27/07
filet
hsimone at 8:53AM on 12/27/07
Filet mignon for me.
SeahorseLady at 8:53AM on 12/27/07
NY strip baby!
mgaugert at 8:54AM on 12/27/07
Prime rib with horseradish sauce, although any well cooked steak is favorite food!
clynsg at 8:55AM on 12/27/07
flank steak sliced really thin.
gervitsd at 8:55AM on 12/27/07
Filet mignon
mkojulie at 8:55AM on 12/27/07
Ribeye
abfantom at 8:55AM on 12/27/07
Filet Mignon
egreca at 8:55AM on 12/27/07
filet mignon
mbritt at 9:00AM on 12/27/07
Deer Tenderloin - also known as the 'Backstrap' ummm, ummmm, good!
farmmonkey at 9:01AM on 12/27/07
filet mignon
katmagick at 9:06AM on 12/27/07
filet all the way !!!!!
mkboldin at 9:06AM on 12/27/07
Medium done Filet Mignon or Porterhouse "Do me do me do me" as Steve Tyler would say!
foontou at 9:07AM on 12/27/07
poterhouse
dolls123 at 9:09AM on 12/27/07
Long before it was being hailed as a "healthy" cut, I liked Filet Mignon. It doesn't matter to me how it is prepared, but as long as it is Filet, I'm good.
elsmarlouamrman at 9:13AM on 12/27/07
Ribeye
etyper333 at 9:16AM on 12/27/07
Filet mignon, of course.
timberlea at 9:18AM on 12/27/07
porterhouse or t-bone I love steak and I don't cook it that often
rewcath at 9:19AM on 12/27/07
Filet Mignon, please.
Loreli at 9:20AM on 12/27/07
I love a great big t-bone.
susanchester at 9:20AM on 12/27/07
Me, pick me. You can't gett good beef here in Florida!!!!
merrylee147 at 9:21AM on 12/27/07
Porterhouse
garrettsambo at 9:24AM on 12/27/07
NY Strip
jphite at 9:25AM on 12/27/07
Beef Tenderloin. A serious YUM.
cjoans at 9:25AM on 12/27/07
porterhouse, please!
michelle03 at 9:26AM on 12/27/07
Rib in bone. The flavor of the meat and bits of fat clinging to the bone is the best!
pixframe at 9:26AM on 12/27/07
rarely eat steak it too expensive :(
klp1965 at 9:28AM on 12/27/07
Filet mignon
jamie2005 at 9:29AM on 12/27/07
Ribeye
crown523 at 9:31AM on 12/27/07
Porter House
wolff33166 at 9:33AM on 12/27/07
Filet mignon
sdeas at 9:33AM on 12/27/07
I am a T-Bone kind of girl!!
alycep06 at 9:34AM on 12/27/07
Prime Rib rare with Horseradish!
tozier at 9:35AM on 12/27/07
porterhouse is the best!
caseycupcake at 9:35AM on 12/27/07
Filet or Ribeye
digigirl at 9:37AM on 12/27/07
Ribeye extra rare please
MoninGrammie at 9:45AM on 12/27/07
Filet mignon
asalerno at 9:47AM on 12/27/07
NY Strip steak on the rare side of medium rare
phaelon56 at 9:53AM on 12/27/07
porterhouse!
aannaa at 9:54AM on 12/27/07
Filet Mignon
ironcurtain at 10:03AM on 12/27/07
Flank steak
mooze55 at 10:07AM on 12/27/07
Delmonico!
chrislada at 10:11AM on 12/27/07
Porterhouse is great and probably my favorite. Filet mignon and NY strip are also great. I almost always get medium rare.
I_love_steak at 10:13AM on 12/27/07
Ribeye :0)
Bebemiqui at 10:14AM on 12/27/07
Filet Mignon for me!
gautinggirl at 10:14AM on 12/27/07
My favorite steak is a grilled T-bone!
LKB43 at 10:16AM on 12/27/07
porterhouse please.
skim at 10:16AM on 12/27/07
Make that a Porterhouse
toostressed at 10:18AM on 12/27/07
Prime Rib rare w/ lots of Au Jus!
freakshow1111 at 10:18AM on 12/27/07
Filet for me!!!
cdrury at 10:18AM on 12/27/07
Porterhouse is my fav!!!
Roseannk_99 at 10:20AM on 12/27/07
love bone in rib steak smothered with peter luger sauce!
pincus at 10:20AM on 12/27/07
I like Filet Mignon best.
CoCo61 at 10:21AM on 12/27/07
NY Strip, salt and peper-grilled to medium rare outside on the grill!!
sandibert at 10:21AM on 12/27/07
Funny how my favi=orite is Porterhouse and that's what you are going to give me. Thanks in advance.
superdlux at 10:22AM on 12/27/07
mine would have to be filet mignon
bockad at 10:28AM on 12/27/07
New York Strip
taxichick at 10:31AM on 12/27/07
Filet Mignon
imjasonc at 10:33AM on 12/27/07
tritip
ninasmom at 10:33AM on 12/27/07
RIbeye All The Way!!!
Dkillett at 10:35AM on 12/27/07
Filet mignon
greenwolf at 10:35AM on 12/27/07
Porterhouse :)
kaaas at 10:36AM on 12/27/07
Ribeye for me
Jaleigh78 at 10:36AM on 12/27/07
prime rib!
mbacher at 10:36AM on 12/27/07
rib eye!
99paa at 10:40AM on 12/27/07
I love new york strip!
cookiecutter72 at 10:44AM on 12/27/07
I'm a big guy with a big appetite.....I'll go with a porterhouse
john1228 at 10:45AM on 12/27/07
Make mine a ribeye. I can taste it now.
Lopro89 at 10:46AM on 12/27/07
Porterhouse- yum ^^
Starshine3 at 10:47AM on 12/27/07
porterhouse
rchung77 at 10:53AM on 12/27/07
Ribeye for me, thanks!
ladyt64 at 10:55AM on 12/27/07
Boneless rib eye
ruthlessu at 11:00AM on 12/27/07
Filet Mignon served HOT! I love it when restaurants serve you meat very hot!
jcamp2020 at 11:00AM on 12/27/07
Filet Mignon, esp. from Angus Barn in Raleigh
jdiprimo at 11:01AM on 12/27/07
My favorite is a medium Prime Rib Steak! ummmmmmm
radeni at 11:01AM on 12/27/07
porterhouse, two steaks in one
logicalmind at 11:01AM on 12/27/07
sirloin.
secreteater at 11:02AM on 12/27/07
Tender, slice like butter, filet mignon!
wisp3 at 11:02AM on 12/27/07
rib eye ~ great sweepstakes
cathirushing at 11:02AM on 12/27/07
Steak is my meat.
zolysr at 11:03AM on 12/27/07
Pan-seared, oven roasted, rubbed with oil, salt and pepper, ribeye
darronvigs24 at 11:04AM on 12/27/07
filet.
leeann777 at 11:05AM on 12/27/07
The humble flank steak, the way my husband cooks it. Marinated and cooked rare on the grill. It just melts in your mouth.
farmers13 at 11:08AM on 12/27/07
Still a nice thick New York Strip
gratefulted at 11:09AM on 12/27/07
ribeye
amylou61 at 11:10AM on 12/27/07
Porterhouse yumm
malleycc at 11:13AM on 12/27/07
Porterhouse, without a doubt. Haven't had one in a long while. :(
PerkyMac at 11:13AM on 12/27/07
Yum! Yum! Porterhouse.
daisia at 11:16AM on 12/27/07
ribeye!
mizztara71 at 11:17AM on 12/27/07
Make mine a ribeye, please!
drmagazine at 11:18AM on 12/27/07
Porterhouse has my vote then Rib-Eye then T-Bone and then there were none.
seben at 11:21AM on 12/27/07
filet mignon.
jennienelson at 11:25AM on 12/27/07
Porterhouse, with a fresh ground black pepper rub, seared on a super hot grill, flip it once and put it on a plate, rare, eat the rib eye and save the tenderloin for last.
tfitts1947 at 11:27AM on 12/27/07
New York Strip
jodyst at 11:29AM on 12/27/07
Porterhouse
purplepassion126 at 11:31AM on 12/27/07
It's been way too long (darn this diet) but I LOVE a Porterhouse, medium, with mushrooms and a baked potato. MMMM!
lisaray at 11:35AM on 12/27/07
Ribeye
nateandjared at 11:36AM on 12/27/07
Filet Mignon
justsmart at 11:38AM on 12/27/07
ribeye
bison61 at 11:40AM on 12/27/07
filet mignon with bleu cheese butter, or bearnaise, or au poivre, or just plain medium-rare!
HeyCarl at 11:43AM on 12/27/07
Nice tender Filet
buck38 at 11:48AM on 12/27/07
For more than 30 years my first choice is always Porterhouse, cut 1.5 inches thick
RushIt2Me at 11:49AM on 12/27/07
Porterhouse
bojabb at 11:51AM on 12/27/07
Filet mignon!
JDHutchins at 11:58AM on 12/27/07
Porterhouse always!
lanellie at 12:03PM on 12/27/07
Ribeye
dwhogan at 12:03PM on 12/27/07
Ribeye!
mrbillcoach at 12:06PM on 12/27/07
Porterhouse has always been my favorite!
poorkarla at 12:06PM on 12/27/07