Seriously Delicious Holiday Giveaway: Two Peter Luger Steaks
Today we're giving away a package of two prime, dry-aged ("longer than four weeks") porterhouse steaks, thanks to the generous folks at Peter Luger. These steaks are not small. Each weighs more than two pounds. The steaks come with two bottles of Peter Luger steak sauce and a bag of chocolate coins.
To win, just answer this in the comments below: What's your favorite cut of steak?
You have until noon ET tomorrow (Saturday, December 22) to enter. One winner will be chosen at random from among the commenters. The standard Serious Eats contest rules apply.
PS: If you just can't wait for this contest to be over and want to order steaks right now from Peter Luger, you may do so here. You will make any serious carnivores on your list very happy.
Comments are closed: 833 Comments:
Ny strip, medium rare, bone in.
ChiefHDB at 12:01PM on 12/21/07
I'm a sucker for flank steak.
kylad at 12:02PM on 12/21/07
filet mignon
woodenspoon at 12:04PM on 12/21/07
i love marinated skirt steak in fajitas!
mayam at 12:05PM on 12/21/07
ribeye all the way
addROC at 12:06PM on 12/21/07
porterhouse
gordita88 at 12:07PM on 12/21/07
porterhouse
brooke29 at 12:07PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse
Cinzia at 12:09PM on 12/21/07
I like filet mignon. Yeah, yeah, its supposed to be not as good as other cuts, but taking a bite of melt-in-your-mouth rare filet is like taking a bite of heaven. Especially when paired with some sort of bleu cheese. Yum.
BestFriendBrit at 12:09PM on 12/21/07
rib-eye
msecondo at 12:11PM on 12/21/07
On the bone: ribeye. Off the bone: onglet.
hrobb at 12:13PM on 12/21/07
Rib-eye.
rffoodie at 12:14PM on 12/21/07
New York strip.
karen r at 12:16PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse
lindygirl at 12:17PM on 12/21/07
NY Strip
Littlebluesiren at 12:20PM on 12/21/07
ribeye
launate at 12:20PM on 12/21/07
it's been YEARS since I lasted tasted a Peter Luger steak (I no longer live in New York) - what great memories!
gorzd at 12:20PM on 12/21/07
ribeye for me, too.
calamityjake at 12:21PM on 12/21/07
New York Strip!
karenscribe at 12:22PM on 12/21/07
coincidentally, porterhouse.
hillearyo at 12:23PM on 12/21/07
bone in ribeye definitely
Alm25 at 12:23PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse!
daveg227 at 12:23PM on 12/21/07
T-bone, but I never met a cut I didn't like.
leegwebb at 12:24PM on 12/21/07
Ribeye!
AbbyF at 12:25PM on 12/21/07
Ribeye, without question.
gooseman at 12:25PM on 12/21/07
It's all about the porterhouse!
therealpotato at 12:25PM on 12/21/07
Filet Mignon
amysahba at 12:25PM on 12/21/07
filet mignon. as far as I know.
oneperfectegg at 12:26PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse, baby. King of Steaks
outsidecounsel at 12:26PM on 12/21/07
Cowboy Ribeye
hicoffice at 12:27PM on 12/21/07
bacon wrapped filet
Kimberly at 12:28PM on 12/21/07
New York strip medium rare, no doubt.
jcleffie at 12:30PM on 12/21/07
T-Bone (Thick Cut).
2qrs at 12:30PM on 12/21/07
Rib-eye!
Stefanie at 12:30PM on 12/21/07
ribeye.
doglover at 12:31PM on 12/21/07
skirt
carusoc at 12:31PM on 12/21/07
bacon-wrapped filet
Kimberly at 12:31PM on 12/21/07
You can't go wrong with the King and Queen of steaks all in one!!! The Porterhouse baby!!!
bespo81 at 12:31PM on 12/21/07
porterhouse for two
Mike5534 at 12:32PM on 12/21/07
Ribeye
bytemyfoot at 12:35PM on 12/21/07
Filet mignon plz.
robnolen at 12:36PM on 12/21/07
porterhouse
SelimaCat at 12:38PM on 12/21/07
NY strip.
billstickers at 12:38PM on 12/21/07
Okay, this time a Costanza shout-out to the t-bone....
curse at 12:40PM on 12/21/07
I love a well-marbeled ribeye, but a Porterhouse is the favorite of the friend who's sharing my holiday plans.
suegsf at 12:41PM on 12/21/07
porterhouse.
icecreamsandwich at 12:42PM on 12/21/07
ny strip medium rare.
provey at 12:43PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse - medium rare! Delish!
AliKat at 12:43PM on 12/21/07
I love a ribeye, medium-rare.
pianolady3 at 12:43PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse. That's why I love Luger's.
cjstephens at 12:46PM on 12/21/07
Skirt Steak, medium rare - ridiculously tasty
Ribeye, medium rare
chisai at 12:47PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse.
floretbroc at 12:47PM on 12/21/07
ribeye, bone in and rare please!
dConn at 12:47PM on 12/21/07
filet mignon, medium rare please :)
lesleyg456 at 12:48PM on 12/21/07
Brisket so many way to prepare this cut of meat......
Markbb at 12:48PM on 12/21/07
rib eye... nothing beats it
dewayne at 12:49PM on 12/21/07
Filet, all the way!
Kerosena at 12:49PM on 12/21/07
rib eye out, skirt at home
cybercita at 12:50PM on 12/21/07
put me down in the ribeye column
pointcarl at 12:50PM on 12/21/07
ribeye
Rick Kazmer at 12:52PM on 12/21/07
New York, medium rare
mlt43 at 12:53PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse. Luger Porterhouse.
potchkepix at 12:53PM on 12/21/07
porterhouse!
mepolo at 12:53PM on 12/21/07
Like to try the porterhouse
googy at 12:54PM on 12/21/07
Rib-eye.
craig_g at 12:55PM on 12/21/07
Filet Mignon!
jamiephoto at 12:55PM on 12/21/07
Nice thick NY strip, Pittsburgh style
JRN77 at 12:57PM on 12/21/07
rib eye
AnaisKoi at 12:58PM on 12/21/07
What's good is a prime rib.
Freddie at 1:00PM on 12/21/07
NY Strip
artybastard at 1:01PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse from Luger's -- there's a great start to a new year!
MDAccount at 1:02PM on 12/21/07
steak sandwich
j at 1:03PM on 12/21/07
porterhouse!
threedogkitchen at 1:04PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse
Jennalynn at 1:05PM on 12/21/07
Hanger Steak
justeatit at 1:05PM on 12/21/07
Filet mignon!
lizcha at 1:07PM on 12/21/07
filet mignon
agardener at 1:07PM on 12/21/07
Bone-in ribeye.
TheJTrain at 1:09PM on 12/21/07
Black&blue bone in ribeye
bessfour at 1:09PM on 12/21/07
RIbeye, definitely.
digitalfish at 1:10PM on 12/21/07
NY strip
omnivore at 1:12PM on 12/21/07
filet minon
capricornpig at 1:12PM on 12/21/07
NY Strip
jtennantwise at 1:14PM on 12/21/07
Hanger!
MerMade07 at 1:15PM on 12/21/07
porterhouse.
skim at 1:15PM on 12/21/07
Ribeye!
etyper333 at 1:18PM on 12/21/07
filet minon
EmilySC at 1:18PM on 12/21/07
NY Strip
jd7979 at 1:19PM on 12/21/07
RIBEYE!
sugarmeg at 1:20PM on 12/21/07
Ribeye. Dude. Yes.
EmmaC at 1:24PM on 12/21/07
hanger steak, no porterhouse, no hanger steak. This is tough
jellybean at 1:24PM on 12/21/07
I love New York strip.
Tellicherry at 1:26PM on 12/21/07
flank or skirt steak.
Shels01 at 1:27PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse.
schnitzel at 1:28PM on 12/21/07
Bone in ribeye.
jamiesonm at 1:28PM on 12/21/07
hanger steak!
arbeck at 1:32PM on 12/21/07
Cheap date - a sirloin, sliced thin, works for me.
gregsmom at 1:32PM on 12/21/07
Ribeye, cowboy-cut. Med-rare.
sallbritton at 1:34PM on 12/21/07
NY strip
tracyd at 1:34PM on 12/21/07
T-Bone or Porterhouse!!! Although I've never turned down ANY cut of red meat. (Prime rib as well)
Whatever it is it must be bloody with a warm, almost uncooked center and well- marbled.
RichardCrystal at 1:38PM on 12/21/07
Ribeye, medium.
nokrapt at 1:38PM on 12/21/07
Ribeye
pdxirishman at 1:39PM on 12/21/07
ribeye
maialisa at 1:39PM on 12/21/07
ribeye
feep at 1:40PM on 12/21/07
New York strip
GregWA at 1:44PM on 12/21/07
sirloin
jamike at 1:45PM on 12/21/07
bone-in filet
thotfulspot at 1:45PM on 12/21/07
flat iron
cgreggo at 1:46PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse and NY Strip
rugbyspartan at 1:51PM on 12/21/07
ny strip
ceforrester at 1:52PM on 12/21/07
porterhouse!
aannaa at 1:53PM on 12/21/07
Ribeye, rare.
Dave the Barbarian Chef at 1:53PM on 12/21/07
skirt steak
jamesl8n at 1:54PM on 12/21/07
New York Strip
JudyH at 1:56PM on 12/21/07
porterhouse
Mike Sula at 1:56PM on 12/21/07
Rib eye!
foodhuntress at 1:56PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse
CVilleBilly at 1:56PM on 12/21/07
Ah, porterhouse, yeah, that's the one.
Stushi at 2:00PM on 12/21/07
filet mignon
chconkl at 2:00PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse, please.
dimsumfan at 2:01PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse or a nice filet
chasgoose at 2:02PM on 12/21/07
ny strip
alphabeta at 2:04PM on 12/21/07
porterhouse
kevlney at 2:06PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse
Freyacat at 2:07PM on 12/21/07
NY strip
stlwaters at 2:07PM on 12/21/07
Kansas City Strip
hermanb at 2:09PM on 12/21/07
NY Strip
lotswife at 2:11PM on 12/21/07
new york strip, medium rare
mrsbao at 2:12PM on 12/21/07
Just like last time, a cowboy ribeye cooked medium, with garlic mashed potatoes, sauteed mushrooms, and a Manhattan. Followed up afterwards with a glass of absinthe and a cigar. Ah, to dream.
will_butler at 2:13PM on 12/21/07
porterhouse of course!!!
fseriouseats at 2:17PM on 12/21/07
rare ribeye
vixita at 2:22PM on 12/21/07
ribeye black n blue
AndreSala at 2:26PM on 12/21/07
garlic ribeye, barbequed to medium rare!
Dianalah at 2:28PM on 12/21/07
ribeye (bone-in), as usual. How 'bout some new questions?
Tactful_Cactus at 2:28PM on 12/21/07
filet mignon, medium-rare, sherried mushrooms....MMMMM
martinscot at 2:29PM on 12/21/07
Filet Mignon
Catharine56 at 2:29PM on 12/21/07
Ribeye. rare. good sear on the outside.
attgig at 2:30PM on 12/21/07
porterhouse
FTW
twhid at 2:31PM on 12/21/07
Hanger!
Scoggdog at 2:32PM on 12/21/07
portehouse
BSTAUSS at 2:33PM on 12/21/07
NY strip if I'm paying, porterhouse if I'm not
Chris78 at 2:36PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse for 2
mlzeats at 2:37PM on 12/21/07
Hanger Steak
MikeR99 at 2:38PM on 12/21/07
Filet mignon is my favortie cut of steak! yum!
laur_uic at 2:42PM on 12/21/07
Medium rare porterhouse. Crap, now I'm really hungry!
Wetware at 2:43PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse medium rare
edknees at 2:44PM on 12/21/07
Filet mignon, with porterhouse running a close second.
Cheran at 2:44PM on 12/21/07
Filet Mignon! No bones! I hate bones!
bethrossi at 2:47PM on 12/21/07
ribeye
llinda29 at 2:47PM on 12/21/07
sirloin
dikaryon at 2:50PM on 12/21/07
Ribeye, bone in with garlic and mushrooms!
tknodcmn at 2:50PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse
curmudgeon at 2:51PM on 12/21/07
Oh I love that ribeye!
berwyn at 2:52PM on 12/21/07
filet mignon
Urbanaus at 2:52PM on 12/21/07
Ribeye please!
mara26 at 2:53PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse, rare please.
sjwoodin at 2:55PM on 12/21/07
Seasons Greetings! My husband and teenage sons would say that it is
Ribeye most of the time! Thanks,Cindi
jchoppes[at]hotmail[dot]com
windycindy at 2:56PM on 12/21/07
ribeye
brunjaune at 2:57PM on 12/21/07
filet mignon butterflied!
judis121 at 2:57PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse
cgould4q07 at 2:58PM on 12/21/07
Ribeye...without a doubt! Delicious!
twoundertwo at 2:59PM on 12/21/07
flank steak, very thinly sliced.
gervitsd at 2:59PM on 12/21/07
I was raised on ribeye!
ilikecitylights at 3:01PM on 12/21/07
Ribeye is my favorite!
reveilletx at 3:02PM on 12/21/07
mmmm, filet mingon!
216amyc at 3:03PM on 12/21/07
Ribeye for me anyday!
hodges59102 at 3:03PM on 12/21/07
I like a New York Strip Steak
cmvitello at 3:03PM on 12/21/07
ribeye!
mizztara71 at 3:04PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse everytime.
joanne117 at 3:05PM on 12/21/07
Cowboy steak of any kind, prepared Alton Brown style in a sizzling cast iron pan that makes the fire department come round and bring oxygen masks to revive us from the smoke inhalation.
vermonted at 3:05PM on 12/21/07
Filet & Porterhouse. It's a tie.
jbfrommi at 3:06PM on 12/21/07
t-bone
dhunt at 3:06PM on 12/21/07
porterhouse
guido at 3:07PM on 12/21/07
Filet mignon
rachelkramerbussel at 3:07PM on 12/21/07
Ribeye
abfantom at 3:07PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse of course !
peachis31 at 3:08PM on 12/21/07
Bacon wrapped fillet cooked rare placed on a bed of roasted garlic mashed potatoes and grilled balsamic asperagus on the side - Yummy!!
balanese2001 at 3:08PM on 12/21/07
filet for sure!!
marlo1atchison at 3:09PM on 12/21/07
sirloin
bhjustice at 3:11PM on 12/21/07
I used to be a filet man but now I favor a good ribeye.
drmagazine at 3:11PM on 12/21/07
Chateaubriand.
annulla at 3:12PM on 12/21/07
rib-eye!
gdhaynie at 3:12PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse, por favor.
jayfallon at 3:13PM on 12/21/07
Nice Thick New York Strip
gratefulted at 3:13PM on 12/21/07
porterhouse
paryjeja at 3:14PM on 12/21/07
New York strip, charred on the outside, juicy pink on the inside.
aila11 at 3:14PM on 12/21/07
Filet, of course.
deedleweedle at 3:14PM on 12/21/07
It's Luger's! It's Porterhouse of course.
rothsteg at 3:15PM on 12/21/07
Filet medium
ladypawnbroker at 3:17PM on 12/21/07
Ribeye
SunnysideUp at 3:17PM on 12/21/07
T-BONE
JANEYATES at 3:17PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse plopped steaming hot onto a bed of bone-dry arugula so that it wilts.
Full-bodied red. Pile of butter-seared mushrooms cooked whole. Slimy, caramelized onions.
Eliz. at 3:17PM on 12/21/07
t-bone
jkuebler at 3:18PM on 12/21/07
New York Strip
KEFLON at 3:19PM on 12/21/07
I have to agree with the rib eye fans.
annpa at 3:19PM on 12/21/07
mmm.. I can be pretty specific here.. My favorite is a filet with extra thick or double (even triple) wrapped apple bacon (thickly sliced) i know its horribly bad for you..but its amazing.
angelaandmelos at 3:21PM on 12/21/07
NY Strip with a side of fried onions. Oh yes.
sixsonnets at 3:28PM on 12/21/07
Filet mignon is my favorite. Thank you for the chance to win.
maggie0352 at 3:29PM on 12/21/07
ribeye
kelboyd at 3:32PM on 12/21/07
filet mignon is awesome -- would be a fun CHRISTmas blessing here!!
forhisglory at 3:32PM on 12/21/07
still a T-Bone
DwayneW at 3:34PM on 12/21/07
bone-in ribeye,
please
thank you
intheyearofthepig at 3:34PM on 12/21/07
bone-in ribeye rubbed w/ salt, black pepper and garlic cooked rare.
slvance at 3:35PM on 12/21/07
Petite filet.
captunderp at 3:36PM on 12/21/07
Gotta go with the Filet Mignon.
scrunquist at 3:39PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse + Bloody Rare = Heaven
kcook84 at 3:40PM on 12/21/07
A good steak only needs a little salt and pepper-Filet Mignon
deesbree at 3:40PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse please...woohoo!
utahups at 3:40PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse is my absolute favorite
lduvall at 3:41PM on 12/21/07
bone-in ribeye, med-rare
dettling05 at 3:41PM on 12/21/07
NY strip
crawdaddy at 3:42PM on 12/21/07
delmonico...cracked pepper and a small pat of buttah. heaven.
sheldel at 3:42PM on 12/21/07
Filet Mignon
myfflyn at 3:43PM on 12/21/07
filet mignon
AlbinoRockstar at 3:44PM on 12/21/07
it used to be rib eye but i think strip is better
mverno at 3:44PM on 12/21/07
a Peter Luger Porterhouse.
If you've never had a steak a t Peter Luger's, trust me, you haven't tasted your best steak yet.
Beyond heaven.
gala2 at 3:47PM on 12/21/07
I grew up with Porterhouse- the very best cut
wanderingnana at 3:47PM on 12/21/07
Poterhouse
cgeo2000 at 3:49PM on 12/21/07
People think I am crazy but I love a good seven bone Chuck Steak. The more fat the better.
eyzofblu63 at 3:51PM on 12/21/07
I love Porterhouse...Great prize
trzzw at 3:56PM on 12/21/07
New York strip. That's my steak. Takes me back to old New York!!!!
Fletch at 3:58PM on 12/21/07
filet mignon
slb3334 at 3:59PM on 12/21/07
T-bone well done Please.
kygirl at 4:00PM on 12/21/07
Sirloin Steak Is The Best.
Mur6950 at 4:01PM on 12/21/07
NY Strip
jellosheriff at 4:02PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse
AICORP at 4:04PM on 12/21/07
I love a good ribeye!
jeepgirl42 at 4:05PM on 12/21/07
The Flat Iron steak. Almost as tender as tenderloin, but with more flavor.
petebia at 4:06PM on 12/21/07
Prime Rib- Walk it in!
AllenMcLeod at 4:09PM on 12/21/07
filet mignon
mkfadem at 4:09PM on 12/21/07
porterhouse
sln123 at 4:10PM on 12/21/07
filet, all the way!
piepie at 4:10PM on 12/21/07
Melt in your mouth Medallions.
eggplant43 at 4:12PM on 12/21/07
filet mignon
sstrudeau at 4:12PM on 12/21/07
For grilling, nothing beats Porterhouse. You get the best of both worlds, a bit of the Filet and a bit of Sirlion. That said, Seven Bone Chuck Steak is absolutely delicious as well and when I'm in the mood for something a little more rustic, a well-marinated flank steak is terrific. Rib eyes are nice but too much work, although perfect as a roast. Finally, I don't know what they are called but BJs sells a cut of meat that looks like it's a bit of the flank but it is super tender and grills up beautifully. Now if I am not grilling, then I like either a simple strip steak or a filet that I can finish in the oven. Or when it is snowing, nothing beats braising a nice thick chuck steak in beef consume and veggies. I'm not sure if it counts as "steak" but it is delicious.
iainswife at 4:13PM on 12/21/07
New york strip!
gladstone7272 at 4:14PM on 12/21/07
Ribeye
pippygirl at 4:14PM on 12/21/07
coincidentally, porterhouse
jbeckett at 4:15PM on 12/21/07
flank steak!
gkang at 4:15PM on 12/21/07
My favorite is filet mignon.
SeahorseLady at 4:16PM on 12/21/07
filet milon
lfosses at 4:16PM on 12/21/07
You know what, I'm going to up the ante here and add to my post that if we are voting for our dream steak, I'm going to still say Porterhouse but clarify it with....
Kobe Porterhouse.
iainswife at 4:16PM on 12/21/07
A real good petit filet
zazzie at 4:18PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse
cptmorgan70 at 4:20PM on 12/21/07
Ribeye. But recently had a flatiron that I loved!
tinbigd at 4:22PM on 12/21/07
I ADORE A GOOD FILET MIGNON
HOPE131 at 4:24PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse, yum!
Annek at 4:26PM on 12/21/07
filet / prime rib rare
waawab at 4:27PM on 12/21/07
Filet Mignon absolutely.
cme8397 at 4:27PM on 12/21/07
Well-marbled ribeye. Nothin' better...
cooksultant at 4:28PM on 12/21/07
Cowboy cut ribeye (bone in)
tripateam at 4:30PM on 12/21/07
filet mignon
kingsinister at 4:30PM on 12/21/07
I love a good porterhouse steak, medium rare.
jpq123 at 4:31PM on 12/21/07
NY strip medium!
dansan826 at yahoo
dansan826 at 4:32PM on 12/21/07
Yummy Porterhouse!!!
d32656 at 4:34PM on 12/21/07
done medium filet mignon-Merry Christmas!
stacy1955 at 4:34PM on 12/21/07
I loe steak
cindyb at 4:35PM on 12/21/07
Give me a rib eye any time.
tdark27 at 4:40PM on 12/21/07
New York steak, well done
cezovski at 4:41PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse
bojabb at 4:42PM on 12/21/07
porterhouse, two steaks in one.
logicalmind at 4:43PM on 12/21/07
filet or rib-eye
muchcat at 4:43PM on 12/21/07
Prime Rib
1LuckyLady at 4:45PM on 12/21/07
I love ribeyes and New York strips and porterhouses and T-bones!
leeleemac at 4:47PM on 12/21/07
T-Bones are my favorite! No matter how poor the quality of the meat, T-Bones are always tasty and tender!!!
lapkt at 4:50PM on 12/21/07
I love all steak favorite fillet on shick-a -bob
bwanas at 4:52PM on 12/21/07
Filet mignon, medium rare!!
anyang at 4:53PM on 12/21/07
Filet Mignon for me please...yummy
tiffginn21 at 4:53PM on 12/21/07
Beautifully grilled rare ribeye
cconaway at 4:54PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse
jkershen at 4:54PM on 12/21/07
Ribeye!
ejosef at 4:55PM on 12/21/07
Prime ribs
whyreg666 at 4:56PM on 12/21/07
Filet Mignon or marinated flat iron
bobcatsteph3 at 4:56PM on 12/21/07
Filet Mignon and lobster tails for me.
CarolHarrity at 4:57PM on 12/21/07
Tenderloin...I know it's probably not the most flavorful, but I love to put a bleu cheese topping on it.
zipporahs at 4:57PM on 12/21/07
I like prime rib best. The rarer the better. Just knock the horns off and run it past a fire and slap it on a plate. Thems good eats!
TrayMona at 4:57PM on 12/21/07
Give me a Porterhouse (medium rare) with sauteed mushrooms and onions on it, and I'm a happy girl!
dbaxgirl51 at 4:59PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse please!
someguy at 4:59PM on 12/21/07
can't go wrong with a porterhouse well done with a black pepper crust and a well done baked potato with all the fixins and a great glass of wine
oberhausen at 5:00PM on 12/21/07
London Broil
t1712mass at 5:00PM on 12/21/07
Prime rib, medium well can't be beat
alwena at 5:01PM on 12/21/07
T Bone can't be beat
angela8310 at 5:02PM on 12/21/07
I adore filet mignon - but Porterhouse has got it all. It's been years since I've tasted genuine dry-aged prime beef! Peter Lugar's prime steaks are second only to authentic Argentinian beef. (Note: if you are ever lucky enough to have a chance to eat at Peter Lugar's, remember that they do NOT accept credit cards - so bring cash, lots of it!)
Salleefur at 5:03PM on 12/21/07
Ribeye, medium rare
kzimostrad at 5:03PM on 12/21/07
NY strip, definitely!
dazdip at 5:04PM on 12/21/07
Filet Mignor and Porterhouse are probably tied but I do like K. City strip and T bone. (I really can't think of a cut of steak that I wouldn't eat)
forkmtn at 5:04PM on 12/21/07
porterhouse!!!
eugybetty at 5:05PM on 12/21/07
filet mignon.
RCF60527 at 5:07PM on 12/21/07
Ribeye is my favorite!
susanhales at 5:08PM on 12/21/07
filet mignon
diesel51 at 5:10PM on 12/21/07
Give me ribeye, filet mignon or most any kind of steak.
FIBERONE at 5:12PM on 12/21/07
Ribeye is the best!
flimsy at 5:13PM on 12/21/07
I love my Ribeye
ksbald2 at 5:16PM on 12/21/07
T-Bone for me!
tokenabc at 5:19PM on 12/21/07
Filet mignon just makes me sooo happy!
maryte at 5:19PM on 12/21/07
Although I will eat any kind of steak (its my favorite) Filet mignon is the best!
sweepsfairie at 5:20PM on 12/21/07
Ribeye, well done
john1948 at 5:21PM on 12/21/07
A nice juicy sirloin for me!
le14thom at 5:21PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse
Shaudius at 5:21PM on 12/21/07
I'm a sucker for a delicious and tender filet
sachidewey at 5:21PM on 12/21/07
Rib-eye, medium well. Yum!
braysgram at 5:24PM on 12/21/07
must be very very well done.
vboackle at 5:25PM on 12/21/07
I'll take any cut of good meat......but if I had to choose just one, I'd go for the NY Strip.
Stacy125300 at 5:25PM on 12/21/07
Oh I loves me some filet. Or tenderloin, or prime rib, or...ok just about ANY part of that cow.
cre8tveminde at 5:26PM on 12/21/07
rib eye's are the most decadent of all steaks and i so love them
cook eat FRET at 5:27PM on 12/21/07
T-Bone
crashers525 at 5:27PM on 12/21/07
ny strip
fleurdesel at 5:29PM on 12/21/07
filet mignon
tlak06 at 5:30PM on 12/21/07
Bone-in-Rib eye
smythbr at 5:31PM on 12/21/07
I love a good NY strip.
friedom at 5:34PM on 12/21/07
porterhouse for me! thanks for a great contest!
clallen at 5:34PM on 12/21/07
Ribeye is my favorite.
janetfaye at 5:36PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse!!
whippingwater at 5:36PM on 12/21/07
I am fan of Ribeye
Bandbabe at 5:37PM on 12/21/07
Definitely porterhouse.
kmg365 at 5:38PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse is great on the grill with a friend and a beer!
thundar at 5:38PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse is my fav!!
Now I've made myself hungry just thinking about it.
Guess I better go to the store and by me a steak to grill! :)
Thank you.
fluegas5 at 5:39PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse.
dlguss at 5:39PM on 12/21/07
PORTERHOUSE RARE PLEASE!!
ELYSESW at 5:40PM on 12/21/07
Filet mignon
PattyCho at 5:43PM on 12/21/07
Rib-eye
jdrtds at 5:44PM on 12/21/07
New York medium-rare - although a steak this good I might have to go rare with.
lo82070 at 5:45PM on 12/21/07
Peter Luger's marinated porterhouse is the best in the country. I happen to be assigned on a project just two miles away from the Brooklyn location and we try to eat lunch there at least twice a month.
medfordmike at 5:46PM on 12/21/07
Filet!
GoldenEel at 5:47PM on 12/21/07
It's a chuck-eye on the grill. Medium please!
anaheim at 5:55PM on 12/21/07
Skirt Steak
saturdaynightfever at 5:55PM on 12/21/07
filet mignon!
Happyhusky at 5:55PM on 12/21/07
It would have to be rib-eye....medium rare.
durberville at 5:56PM on 12/21/07
Good ol' porterhouse.
kangatron at 5:57PM on 12/21/07
I love a good Rib Eye steak!
ncchaos at 5:57PM on 12/21/07
Filet mignon.. mediun rare
parkercat at 5:59PM on 12/21/07
T-Bone Med rare please
poyntermichele at 6:01PM on 12/21/07
Ribeye
mattp at 6:02PM on 12/21/07
porterhouse
surfwithus at 6:04PM on 12/21/07
New York for me!
cranepuffin at 6:04PM on 12/21/07
New York these days really gets me going... Med Rare over a wood fired grill.
thaddius at 6:05PM on 12/21/07
Ribeye almost mooing!
Babydoe210 at 6:05PM on 12/21/07
Mmmmmm t-bone
bosslady2898 at 6:07PM on 12/21/07
Filet Mignon wrapped in Bacon
kcline at 6:08PM on 12/21/07
New York strip, rare, a little Bleu Cheese and a glass of Port.
peonynut at 6:09PM on 12/21/07
Tbone
cairech at 6:10PM on 12/21/07
Ribeye
roblyn66 at 6:10PM on 12/21/07
New York strip
shay77 at 6:10PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse.
edeliz at 6:12PM on 12/21/07
I adore a Porterhouse, medium rare....yum!!!
jkfreitag at 6:12PM on 12/21/07
Filet Mignon
cpom01 at 6:13PM on 12/21/07
One porterhouse and a sharp knife!
cornellfoodie at 6:16PM on 12/21/07
NY strip.
cbroth at 6:17PM on 12/21/07
Whatever my husband is making, or, if I have to choose, a NY strip.
churchka at 6:19PM on 12/21/07
ribeye is my all time favorite
marelsa at 6:20PM on 12/21/07
ribeye medium rare
donnac36 at 6:21PM on 12/21/07
ribeye medium rare
rainydaymeg at 6:23PM on 12/21/07
fliet mingon
bickesco at 6:24PM on 12/21/07
T-Bone
beanish at 6:26PM on 12/21/07
Filet Mignon
supermax at 6:26PM on 12/21/07
T-Bone is nice, but a thick porterhouse, cooked rare. Ahhhhh!
ruthem at 6:28PM on 12/21/07
T-Bone
mattnneb at 6:30PM on 12/21/07
The rib eye, but I've only tried a few different cuts so far.
motwell at 6:32PM on 12/21/07
Ribeye!
brandonphx at 6:33PM on 12/21/07
prime rib---yum
luvmymate at 6:34PM on 12/21/07
I only enjoy the cuts that are very tender, filet mignon is my choice.
sdadolf at 6:35PM on 12/21/07
prime rib would be awesome
thomasnneb at 6:37PM on 12/21/07
NY strip medium well(just a little pink) yummy!
SheilaBee at 6:39PM on 12/21/07
As long as it's steak, I'll take it anyway I can get it!
achnss at 6:41PM on 12/21/07
NY Strip would be good
takeitasumay at 6:42PM on 12/21/07
love a porterhouse but i'm going with the 'T-bone'
jffryclough at 6:43PM on 12/21/07
a nice rib-eye would suit me
nottieim at 6:44PM on 12/21/07
Ribeye
amylou61 at 6:44PM on 12/21/07
it's a toss up between t-bone and ribeye for all time favorite, but I love all cuts of steak.
tinkerbell5676 at 6:47PM on 12/21/07
T-bone
Traumajunky at 6:49PM on 12/21/07
NY Strip
cjnedrow at 6:49PM on 12/21/07
porterhouse
tracker at 6:49PM on 12/21/07
filet mignon, med well... so tender you can cut it with a butter knife
pamatmayo at 6:50PM on 12/21/07
That tenderloin piece on a porterhouse.
kattzzz at 6:50PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse of course
pcbdolphins at 6:52PM on 12/21/07
Filet Mignon is generally my favorite, but today porterhouse is my favorite.
marlmuck at 6:52PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse! Yummy!
Thanks
tmim123 at 6:52PM on 12/21/07
New York strip
sonyasparks at 6:55PM on 12/21/07
ribeye.
mango at 6:55PM on 12/21/07
Bring on the Porterhouse!
LINDALSHOT at 6:57PM on 12/21/07
Rib-Eye would be great.
jerry1335 at 6:57PM on 12/21/07
Filet Mignon - medium well, wrapped in bacon - mmmmmm
navywife at 6:58PM on 12/21/07
Filet mignon
Twipey at 7:02PM on 12/21/07
Ribeye.
chrissy75007 at 7:05PM on 12/21/07
all red meat!
yount at 7:05PM on 12/21/07
Rib eye
bigjay at 7:07PM on 12/21/07
Filet Mignon, but I'll eat any steak!
egreca at 7:07PM on 12/21/07
T-bone, rare, from good western beef.
rodeogranny at 7:07PM on 12/21/07
porterhouse
pammmywoo at 7:08PM on 12/21/07
Filet (w/ mushrooms)!
denyse at 7:11PM on 12/21/07
porterhouse
Rexthedog at 7:11PM on 12/21/07
t bone
chromiumman at 7:13PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse
jessejames819 at 7:14PM on 12/21/07
porterhouse
karen7854 at 7:19PM on 12/21/07
Tenderloin, rare.
kwils at 7:19PM on 12/21/07
Love T-bone!
ratgirl1204 at 7:22PM on 12/21/07
i can almost taste it
lainie2285 at 7:22PM on 12/21/07
I want a PORTERHOUSE
khawkwv at 7:24PM on 12/21/07
filet mignon
MajaMeza79 at 7:26PM on 12/21/07
New York - well done
opus12 at 7:28PM on 12/21/07
filet mignon
izackcarson at 7:29PM on 12/21/07
T-bone, rare. Yummy.
niceflamingo at 7:30PM on 12/21/07
filet mignon
megan1 at 7:35PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse is our favorite !! The taste and the flavor can't be beat !!!
Rose72 at 7:35PM on 12/21/07
porterhouse - medium rare
elkstorm at 7:36PM on 12/21/07
T-bone
tereza at 7:37PM on 12/21/07
Ribeye, well marbled, medium.
bhouse34 at 7:38PM on 12/21/07
Ribeye!
alegnahas3 at 7:39PM on 12/21/07
give me a good ribeye anyday
mav246 at 7:40PM on 12/21/07
I haven't met a cut I don't like...
catew at 7:41PM on 12/21/07
Rib eyes
luckyirene at 7:43PM on 12/21/07
Has to be Filet Mignon it is the best and most tender and also has the best flavor to me that is.
valerie46 at 7:43PM on 12/21/07
Wow, what a question to ask a carnivore! I'm crazy about a good ol' T-Bone, I even crave a Porterhouse now and then, but a Beef Wellington made with an eight or ten oz. fillet mignon is a heavenly delight.
Sylla Rynry at 7:44PM on 12/21/07
porterhouse
rosidentevil at 7:45PM on 12/21/07
RIBEYE!
gotrootdude at 7:45PM on 12/21/07
Rib-eye
ChristineW at 7:46PM on 12/21/07
I guess I am not picky- as long as it is tender, juicy and has flavor to it- medium well then I will eat it- hey that cow worked hard bulking up- try a little of it all before you say not- those tender cuts can be delicious even if they are the cheapest
BEARHUGS at 7:46PM on 12/21/07
filet mignon
umassfen at 7:50PM on 12/21/07
Ribeye...medium well
dentonzee at 7:51PM on 12/21/07
NY Strip
gunbuster at 7:51PM on 12/21/07
rib-eye fool
henry321 at 7:52PM on 12/21/07
Rib Eye Medium Raw
phoney2 at 7:53PM on 12/21/07
porterhouse well done
starbaby1066 at 7:54PM on 12/21/07
ribeye
mdv1410 at 7:54PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse. It has everything a perfect steak should have even a bone for the dog.
dmunson at 7:56PM on 12/21/07
filet or ribeye - medium rare - delish!
KrazyB at 7:57PM on 12/21/07
I love New York Strip. I think it has the most true beef flavor.
cdziuba at 7:59PM on 12/21/07
Skirt steak or black angus with blue cheese chunks
minimama509 at 8:01PM on 12/21/07
NY strip.
herrinfamily at 8:02PM on 12/21/07
Ribeye for me
betty at 8:02PM on 12/21/07
filet mignon
javal at 8:07PM on 12/21/07
ribeye
mbritt at 8:07PM on 12/21/07
Oh I Love Prime Rib and a bake potato and a salad and bread and then cheesecake for desert....count me in!
wmm792 at 8:09PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse
tyemom at 8:09PM on 12/21/07
Filet Mignon for me
pclarkaz at 8:09PM on 12/21/07
Filet Mignon.
HYDEIST at 8:10PM on 12/21/07
If I'm being decadent enough to eat beef, it's got to be filet mignon.
Devacat at 8:11PM on 12/21/07
NY Strip - Medium Rare
annemarie56 at 8:11PM on 12/21/07
Prime Rib, still mooing
24taz48 at 8:14PM on 12/21/07
T-Bone!
n_i_k at 8:18PM on 12/21/07
favorite cut... toss up between portrthouse and filet mignon. I love steak!
cmwarta10 at 8:19PM on 12/21/07
Strip med rare with peppercorns...yum
jasmall at 8:23PM on 12/21/07
a scrumptious porterhouse
patramey at 8:23PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse
ahelen at 8:27PM on 12/21/07
I have heard about Peter Luger's for a long time. Never had the opportunity to try for myself. Sounds like it would be a treat for the palate!
TULLFAN at 8:28PM on 12/21/07
T Bone w/ garlic butter some blue cheese and lemon
singermagic1 at 8:29PM on 12/21/07
porterhouse, medium rare
stacy7911 at 8:32PM on 12/21/07
I never met a steak I didn't like. Since I have to choose, give me a medium rare new york strip with mushrooms and onions and I'm a happy girl.
Lopro89 at 8:33PM on 12/21/07
T Bone. Thanks for the great and delicious contest.
peg42 at 8:36PM on 12/21/07
T-bone with lots of fried onions & butter.
JWILM at 8:38PM on 12/21/07
filet mignon
zekks at 8:39PM on 12/21/07
Rib eye is the favorite we choose.
pruyoung at 8:40PM on 12/21/07
FILET -MEDIUM RARE
ds605 at 8:41PM on 12/21/07
Its a toss up between the NY strip and the Porterhouse, so i will say..........Porterhouse is my Fav.
djt1992 at 8:42PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse
Catz314 at 8:42PM on 12/21/07
filet- medium/no blood
csb605 at 8:42PM on 12/21/07
filet mignon lean and tasty
bettylou15 at 8:44PM on 12/21/07
I like filet mignon.
arvard at 8:46PM on 12/21/07
Petite Sirloin
kktwins at 8:48PM on 12/21/07
a ribeye....medium rare (more rare) and not too thick. I like them cooked quickly on a really hot surface.
parker at 8:48PM on 12/21/07
My late Uncle, God rest his soul, got me hooked on medium rare New York strips with a baked potato dressed in nothing but sour cream and butter. Although I have to say, I had a Porterhouse this summer and that was some fine eatin', too!!!
wwaaww at 8:48PM on 12/21/07
A ribeye for sure!!
grammypennyann at 8:53PM on 12/21/07
Filet Mignon
kamewh at 8:55PM on 12/21/07
Only filet mignon for me!
smarthayo at 8:56PM on 12/21/07
Prime Rib
mcnerd at 8:58PM on 12/21/07
Hanger Steak has a certain magic.
kirillskok at 8:58PM on 12/21/07
ribeye!! Thanks
staceymoore at 8:59PM on 12/21/07
The Delmonico which is the same as the Ribeye is definitely my favorite!
cayoder at 8:59PM on 12/21/07
I'll randomly say my favorite cut of steak would be the prize being given away;Peter Luger's prime , dry-aged porterhouse.
tgr1104 at 9:00PM on 12/21/07
One piece of a dead cow's the same as any other piece of a dead cow.
treebe at 9:03PM on 12/21/07
A nice thick medium well porterhouse covered in heinz 57
rrussou812 at 9:04PM on 12/21/07
Filet Mignon!
borogirl at 9:04PM on 12/21/07
Ribeye for sure!
lvfordguy at 9:07PM on 12/21/07
Ribeye or filet.
Bunnylips at 9:10PM on 12/21/07
bacon-wrapped filet
redron at 9:14PM on 12/21/07
filet yum!
valerie2350 at 9:14PM on 12/21/07
filet mignon
sciencematt at 9:20PM on 12/21/07
T-bone, absolutely
Maytrarky at 9:21PM on 12/21/07
filet mignon
babycat1216 at 9:22PM on 12/21/07
I love a good filet mignon!
Mavisr at 9:30PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse, to me is the best and most versitile
windwhisper at 9:33PM on 12/21/07
Filet all the way !!!!!
bleweye at 9:34PM on 12/21/07
Filet mignot tops my list, but Porterhouse and ribeye cuts are awesome, too. Yum!!
Tanta at 9:35PM on 12/21/07
T-BONE MED RARE AND LOADED WITH SHROOMS
Hursty44 at 9:36PM on 12/21/07
Delmonico is my favorite with a lobster tail on the side.
tink2luv at 9:38PM on 12/21/07
T-bone for overall score, rib eye for flavor
ky2here at 9:44PM on 12/21/07
ny strip
tsegada at 9:44PM on 12/21/07
Rib steak is the best.
robkencod at 9:45PM on 12/21/07
ribeye, me for
wizzy at 9:46PM on 12/21/07
Ribeye
ch121 at 9:47PM on 12/21/07
porterhouse, all the way
sweetscove at 9:47PM on 12/21/07
ribeye for me.
fedguy at 9:49PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse...yum.
purpleshamrock at 9:50PM on 12/21/07
delmonico, rare
tracirick at 9:52PM on 12/21/07
A marinated flank steak. All taste, no guilt!
camptune at 9:52PM on 12/21/07
Porter? Porterhouse please! Medium rare. Does that sound like the best or what?
workintv at 9:55PM on 12/21/07
I'll eat them all. If you're going to make me pick one, I'll pick a filet mignon.
nqdenise at 9:55PM on 12/21/07
DElmonico is
DElicious!
troubles at 9:56PM on 12/21/07
Mmmm...a nice thick juicy T-bone!
jenzo at 9:59PM on 12/21/07
Ribeye, medium.
mikepaul at 9:59PM on 12/21/07
Rib eyes are the best.
bigfoot at 10:00PM on 12/21/07
I love a T-bone
cuddles115 at 10:03PM on 12/21/07
Strip Steak baby
mikebren at 10:05PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse.
Janetta at 10:06PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse
ghinson at 10:09PM on 12/21/07
Filet Mignon is the BEST !!!
rlawhorn at 10:11PM on 12/21/07
t-bone
mozart23 at 10:16PM on 12/21/07
Rib Eye is the best. thanks
toyota at 10:17PM on 12/21/07
Ny strip medium rare on the grill
judyshort at 10:18PM on 12/21/07
New York Strip Steak and not just because I am from New York!
laidbackguy7 at 10:19PM on 12/21/07
NY strip
genrefin at 10:20PM on 12/21/07
Delmonico I find to be the most tender and delicious
sheryl2059 at 10:21PM on 12/21/07
porterhouse...so this is perfect!
skalobster11 at 10:22PM on 12/21/07
tbone or poterhouse. is good..
patty716 at 10:28PM on 12/21/07
NY Strip steak is my favorite, but all the other cuts are my almost-favorites. I love steak!
Aisling at 10:31PM on 12/21/07
NY strip typically, but a porterhouse is sounding good at the moment. Yum.
cdsamford at 10:32PM on 12/21/07
Filet Mignon is my favorite.
mullin at 10:32PM on 12/21/07
I have to say that I love me a nice Filet Mignon!
cmiyake at 10:32PM on 12/21/07
ribeye
patti31556 at 10:33PM on 12/21/07
ribeye
sillelin at 10:35PM on 12/21/07
I love a New York strip steak seasoned with salt and pepper-maybe a little garlic powder and onion powder grilled to between medium rare and rare-Mmmmm-There's nothing like a good piece of meat!!
sandibert at 10:38PM on 12/21/07
Rib Steak is the only way to go.
EDRing at 10:38PM on 12/21/07
I absolutely Love!! churasco- all of our mouths water whenever we know that we will be having churasco for dinner!! it simply without a doubt is the best.
dxdua at 10:38PM on 12/21/07
Prime rib with au jus
Rozzie at 10:39PM on 12/21/07
T-Bone Medium Rare
drming5k at 10:39PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse!
havthat at 10:45PM on 12/21/07
Ribeye, please.
ceebeedubya at 10:45PM on 12/21/07
Ribeye!
storm5 at 10:54PM on 12/21/07
A filet mignon....thanks!
Ninacu at 10:54PM on 12/21/07
porterhouse
cylis9 at 10:54PM on 12/21/07
Ribeye!
tlcfromtn at 10:54PM on 12/21/07
Rib-Eye has always been a treat for me!
Dwood10322 at 10:55PM on 12/21/07
filet mignon
lilyrose63 at 10:58PM on 12/21/07
T Bone!!!
mcnaney at 11:03PM on 12/21/07
Nothing beats a good ribeye.
sherrap at 11:04PM on 12/21/07
My husbands steak ..lol
zoehunter at 11:04PM on 12/21/07
Ribeye
lindadm at 11:06PM on 12/21/07
I'm hungry!
frostycake at 11:10PM on 12/21/07
a WELL-marbled ribeye, especially the yummy, fatty outer part
surfer7382 at 11:15PM on 12/21/07
yummy :)
MsHalo6 at 11:15PM on 12/21/07
OOoooooooo Prime Rib
1LuckyLady at 11:17PM on 12/21/07
ribeye
surfer7382d at 11:18PM on 12/21/07
Any cut bone-in, but especially t-bone.
willitara at 11:19PM on 12/21/07
love the filet!
randio at 11:20PM on 12/21/07
filet
linda at 11:23PM on 12/21/07
PorterHouse! It's cheating but that way I get 2 steaks. Filet and strip.
robsterclaw at 11:26PM on 12/21/07
Ribeye cooked on a griddle.
wendym42 at 11:27PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse of course.
capwell at 11:27PM on 12/21/07
Hubby NY strip / me - rib eye
Both - prime ribs and/or beef ribs.
TES283 at 11:29PM on 12/21/07
Filet mignon for me
artmarcia at 11:29PM on 12/21/07
Ribeye.
madball911 at 11:30PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse..well done.
witchy64 at 11:30PM on 12/21/07
A nice thick Bacon-wrapped Filet.
schlomo1 at 11:34PM on 12/21/07
charbroiled porterhouse w/tail and fat around steak-no seasonings,served on a metal steak plate.
harborbeach55 at 11:37PM on 12/21/07
filet mignon
steevee at 11:39PM on 12/21/07
Filet mignon!!
fshapiro at 11:39PM on 12/21/07
Tenderloin!
x86cpu at 11:39PM on 12/21/07
rib eye, medium well
gorgor at 11:41PM on 12/21/07
Filet mignon... drool..........
shamrockin at 11:42PM on 12/21/07
I like the best the butterflied well done filet mignon
rosabarto at 11:42PM on 12/21/07
Filet Mignon
annette21 at 11:47PM on 12/21/07
ribeyes omg yummmmmm
jmh101377 at 11:47PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse! Yummy!!
dihahn at 11:48PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse!
mmd1027 at 11:50PM on 12/21/07
Porterhouse is the best!
nycphoto at 11:50PM on 12/21/07
T-Bone
pamoonbtc at 11:51PM on 12/21/07
my husband loves the porterhouse
peatheski at 11:52PM on 12/21/07
ribeye for I
Jaleigh78 at 11:54PM on 12/21/07
I love a good porterhouse or rib-eye steak, cooked on the grill. Thanks for having the contest!
brmetcalf at 11:55PM on 12/21/07
ribeye
applelane at 11:56PM on 12/21/07
Filet mignon
JOYVEN at 11:56PM on 12/21/07
A BIG Fat Ribeye
naynays1 at 11:57PM on 12/21/07
porterhouse
jashelep23 at 11:57PM on 12/21/07
it's a toss up between rib-eye and porterhouse. fat is baaaaad but it taste soooo good.
bambi4 at 11:57PM on 12/21/07
Truthfully, I like them all. However, if I have to choose, I would pick bacon wrapped filet mignon.
celticbikerbabe at 12:01AM on 12/22/07
I love Porterhouse!
lisalmg at 12:04AM on 12/22/07
porterhouse
rc45102 at 12:04AM on 12/22/07
MY FAVORITE STEAK IS--------
RIB EYE
routewrecker at 12:08AM on 12/22/07
T-bone, rare, rarer, rarest
joyja191 at 12:10AM on 12/22/07
T-Bone Steak. Love the flavor better than a filet mignon
Lindab401 at 12:14AM on 12/22/07
new york strip
patwait2 at 12:20AM on 12/22/07
Porterhouse- still moo'ing
freakdujour at 12:21AM on 12/22/07
New York Strip
zianac at 12:26AM on 12/22/07
ribeye.
jwoolley at 12:27AM on 12/22/07
t-bone med rare. (is prime rib a steak?) yum. thanks.
slehan at 12:28AM on 12/22/07
Rib eye is great but I sure won't turn up my nose to a T-bone, porterhouse, or filet mignon
lyonsksl at 12:28AM on 12/22/07
new york strip
chitsuen at 12:29AM on 12/22/07
T-BONE, not Coco, lol ;}
samanthapayntr at 12:29AM on 12/22/07
New York strip, medium rare
Quidnunc at 12:31AM on 12/22/07
Prime Boneless Ribeye! What Else!
rcstout12 at 12:31AM on 12/22/07
Ribeye...
Schlauberger at 12:36AM on 12/22/07
Flat iron of course, what a distinguished taste.
prplrush at 12:39AM on 12/22/07
Prime Rib is my favorite
Angelharts at 12:40AM on 12/22/07
Steak for 2... Porterhouse - M-RARE
ahorwitz at 12:43AM on 12/22/07
Thick, juicy, porterhouse steak, -cooked on the grill - slathered in ground pepper and garlic. Yum. Yum.
jrussell1308 at 12:44AM on 12/22/07
Rib Eye for sure!
sadiellen at 12:50AM on 12/22/07
ribeye
billwinsbig at 12:51AM on 12/22/07
strip steak. mmm.
grs100 at 12:52AM on 12/22/07
prime rib with HOT horseradish! Thanks for the contest!
lfern at 1:00AM on 12/22/07
Ribeye all the way!
yellowlabs at 1:00AM on 12/22/07
Bone-in Ribeye at least 20 oz.
FoodBully at 1:11AM on 12/22/07
I love a Delmonico medium rare,New York Strip , I also love a Porterhouse. To tell you the truth I am a big steak fan! I love all kinds and with all garnishes, onions, mushrooms,garlic, an aged bleu cheese, any cheese, chefs butter, and any of these in any and all combinations! I like my steak with just salt and pepper too. Yum!
sugarpaws at 1:13AM on 12/22/07
Rib eye is my favorite!
sfbuffalo at 1:15AM on 12/22/07
Filet Mignon medium rare.
hkhart at 1:17AM on 12/22/07
Haven't had any in WAY too long (drat this diet!), but Porterhouse. Yummmm! Medium, please. (I know, some of you are turning up your noses, but when I was a child, my mom always cooked steak (which only meant bottom round, unless something else was cheaper) well-done!) Throw on some mushrooms and serve it up with a good salad and a well baked potato.
lisaray at 1:20AM on 12/22/07
I would have to say my favorite is prime rib! YUM!
debswild at 1:24AM on 12/22/07
We buy a lot of rib eyes but nothing beats the combination of flavors one gets from a large aged prime porterhouse like these which can be cooked rare with a marbled red interior and a crusty grilled exterior and then carved so everyone can get a part of the three cuts that make up this great steak! And, our late Cocker Spaniel would go nuts waiting to nibble on the T bone! When choice Porterhouse Steak is on sale, I usually have the butcher cut me some three pounders! I dredge these with a product called "Char Crust" which seasons the steak and gives it a charred finish somewhat like the high temperature broilers in fine steak houses do! I have Lynx grill and like to use a third of a cup Jack Daniel's Whiskey barrel smoking pellets in the smoking tray to further emulate real steakhouse flavor.
jcpawlik at 1:25AM on 12/22/07
rare prime rib
azrosebud at 1:30AM on 12/22/07
porterhouse with a bottle of red wine. yum
raven27 at 1:35AM on 12/22/07
Filet Mignon. Ha! I want one now! With a nice crispy salad.
rubyneko at 1:37AM on 12/22/07
Porterhouse for me and mine
peaches41 at 1:37AM on 12/22/07
Perterhouse medium well.
janieluten49 at 1:38AM on 12/22/07
Porterhouse is the greatest
cjopperman at 1:47AM on 12/22/07
A well-marbled ribeye, without a doubt, is my favorite! Thanks for having this contest. Happy holidays to all.
bndraldy at 1:51AM on 12/22/07
Porterhouse is amazing, but I also like bacon-wrapped filet with sauteed mushrooms...and horseradish! Thanks for the offer!
geekbearinggifts at 2:02AM on 12/22/07
I love a grilled rib eye steak on the bone. Had one last week with melted gorgonzola. However, the mighty Porterhouse has the best of both worlds! Cooked well, but not charred--no pink!
beefitswhatsfordinner at 2:06AM on 12/22/07
porterhouse
blday50 at 2:16AM on 12/22/07
Porterhouse with the bone!!
Sistersis at 2:20AM on 12/22/07
Caberna drenched sirlon
revanche2 at 2:22AM on 12/22/07
I like Porterhouse
yadgirl at 2:24AM on 12/22/07
Ribeye (yum)!
gabrielj1 at 2:29AM on 12/22/07
Filet is my favorite.
silverbele at 2:39AM on 12/22/07
I love filet mignon. The portion size is perfect for me and its so tender and flavorful.
psipsina at 2:50AM on 12/22/07
Got to be RIBEYE
biggdogg5700 at 2:59AM on 12/22/07
filet- I can taste it now
Robert715 at 3:09AM on 12/22/07
Rare Ribeye yum
inkypleez at 3:11AM on 12/22/07
ribeye, at least the fatty part!
99paa at 3:28AM on 12/22/07
I love filet but any steak will make my day !
Hawthorne at 3:51AM on 12/22/07
Filet Mignon
dianerph at 3:56AM on 12/22/07
Porterhouse of course
morty63 at 3:58AM on 12/22/07
Ribeye is my favorite.
ladyt64 at 4:07AM on 12/22/07
skirt steak is my absolute fav!
minidoll at 4:10AM on 12/22/07
Filet Mignon is the best!
JoDanzer at 4:22AM on 12/22/07
Porterhouse!!
bkwrms78 at 4:30AM on 12/22/07
For me it would have to be the New work strip, medium. yum!
qtpiecny at 4:39AM on 12/22/07
Ribeye
net03 at 5:04AM on 12/22/07
Filet Mignon.
JANNET81888 at 5:11AM on 12/22/07
Filet mignon and Prime Rib.
schemme at 5:21AM on 12/22/07
Oh, yeah, porterhouse!
Gwenelle at 5:24AM on 12/22/07
prime rib baby!
lmsunshine at 5:29AM on 12/22/07
Bone-in rib steak, thick cut for me.
gperls at 5:35AM on 12/22/07
Either a Porterhouse or T-Bone. Yum. :)
misspita at 5:45AM on 12/22/07
Prime Rib!
merrylee147 at 5:49AM on 12/22/07
Love filet mignon or prime rib
sylmar at 5:49AM on 12/22/07
filet
intime at 5:54AM on 12/22/07
filet mignon
lindpatt at 5:54AM on 12/22/07
MMMM steak!! My favorite!!!
debiwelbon at 5:55AM on 12/22/07
rib eye......yum....on the grill.......with mushrooms
jklkj at 5:56AM on 12/22/07
I love rib eyes!!!!
debiwelbon at 5:57AM on 12/22/07
strip
architeuthis at 6:00AM on 12/22/07
Porterhouse for me
triceratops at 6:12AM on 12/22/07
Its a toss up between a ribeye and a T-Bone grilled to perfection.
Noggy at 6:19AM on 12/22/07
New York Strip
richtortora at 6:23AM on 12/22/07
New York Strip..........YUM.
ZETHRA at 6:25AM on 12/22/07
I would have to say Porterhouse.... though Ribeye is a close second
rsr1953 at 6:25AM on 12/22/07
My husband does something magical with plain old ordinary flank steak. Everyones just raves about it.
farmers13 at 6:39AM on 12/22/07
porterhouse
Nanny2Kara at 6:43AM on 12/22/07
filet mignon
asalerno at 6:48AM on 12/22/07
filet no bacon
bingsy at 6:50AM on 12/22/07
ribeye
darronvigs24 at 6:53AM on 12/22/07
7 inch rib cut, what a steak!
lejd5157 at 6:54AM on 12/22/07
My favorite cut is a sirloin steak with the pin bone included. This is rarely found now, but it used to be a common cut. It includes a piece of the filet. To me, the sirloin has the best flavor!
muprofeng at 6:56AM on 12/22/07
porterhouse
charles72 at 6:58AM on 12/22/07
Yum!!!
carscheles at 7:00AM on 12/22/07
I love sirloin!
carscheles at 7:01AM on 12/22/07
filet
Tandan at 7:03AM on 12/22/07
Rib roast
lsfish at 7:08AM on 12/22/07
sirloin
leach99 at 7:10AM on 12/22/07
Ribeye, medium
zeke5145 at 7:15AM on 12/22/07
filet mignon
tchoughtby at 7:17AM on 12/22/07
ribeye
rhuzzar at 7:20AM on 12/22/07
filet mignon.
hawkshoe at 7:23AM on 12/22/07
New York strip -- they are just right - favorful but not too much fat
bhoward626 at 7:27AM on 12/22/07
I would LOVE to be able to win this. My home was burglarized. The robbers took everything that was of any value on the streets. They even took the fillets and porterhouse steaks from our freezer leaving the chicken and cubed steak. High society robbers I guess. Good luck to all!
dukenurse at 7:29AM on 12/22/07
Filet minon topped with mushrooms.
rdoor at 7:31AM on 12/22/07
prime rib!
PoignantTuna at 7:37AM on 12/22/07
t bone medium rare
trudee at 7:37AM on 12/22/07
rib eye
maweisberg at 7:39AM on 12/22/07
porterhouse
mrsesquilo at 7:40AM on 12/22/07
For me it is is a toss up between Ribeye and Prime rib
irish51 at 7:43AM on 12/22/07
My favorite cut of steak is the one I'm eating at any given time.
maryofhs at 7:43AM on 12/22/07
A sirloin steak ground up into a big juicy patty !
NewEnglandBites at 7:45AM on 12/22/07
T-BONE
jamieh at 7:52AM on 12/22/07
Filet or Porterhouse
cev426 at 7:53AM on 12/22/07
A Ribeye is to die for.
stewcool at 7:56AM on 12/22/07
Filet Mignon wrapped in bacon, medium well done.
wdtipton at 7:57AM on 12/22/07
A nice medium rare rib eye.
wolff33166 at 8:00AM on 12/22/07
New York Strip for me!
jennireesa at 8:03AM on 12/22/07
Filet Mignon or Porterhouse for me!
ldrnc2000 at 8:05AM on 12/22/07
Filet mignon
djohnson21 at 8:05AM on 12/22/07
Porterhouse
Pamela937 at 8:05AM on 12/22/07
Porterhouse and Filet Mignon are my favorites
rdazer at 8:07AM on 12/22/07
Ribeye
ressiepooh at 8:09AM on 12/22/07
New York strip
overw8 at 8:10AM on 12/22/07
Porterhouse
elliej at 8:11AM on 12/22/07
I have eaten twice at this steak house and they have the best ribeye.
itaskah at 8:15AM on 12/22/07
Filet mignon has always been my favorite - thanks for this opportunity!
elsmarlouamrman at 8:15AM on 12/22/07
Prime Rib with au jus and horseraddish/sourcream sauce.
randycur0962 at 8:20AM on 12/22/07
filet mignon... nice & thick... grilled medium rare please... :)
debralu at 8:20AM on 12/22/07
ny strip
tiacarter at 8:23AM on 12/22/07
Ribeyes all the way. They are perfect.
NanaBear at 8:24AM on 12/22/07
medium rare serloin
52katein at 8:25AM on 12/22/07
porterhouse
thomasviggiano at 8:25AM on 12/22/07
ribeye
lilyk at 8:26AM on 12/22/07
porterhouse
justjunk9 at 8:27AM on 12/22/07
flank steak on the grill
anny31 at 8:28AM on 12/22/07
PORTERHOUSE
EMMAHORTON at 8:29AM on 12/22/07
Ribeye--but have never met a well-cooked steak that I didn't like!
clynsg at 8:31AM on 12/22/07
Ribeye medium rare with mushrooms!!
ladyvon5845 at 8:35AM on 12/22/07
RIBEYE
cathirushing at 8:36AM on 12/22/07
Porterhouse - Get 2 for 1, filet & strip
gpops44 at 8:36AM on 12/22/07
filet mignon - no bones, no gristle, medium rare - hmmmmm good!
wkosut at 8:40AM on 12/22/07
Porterhouse is my favorite.
caseycupcake at 8:48AM on 12/22/07
Porterhouse - two types in one.
defrostham at 8:56AM on 12/22/07
NY Strip, medium-rare. No sauce or other seasoning needed, but tender enough to thoroughly enjoy.
backmark at 9:00AM on 12/22/07
Porterhouse for sure
rickcc74 at 9:06AM on 12/22/07
tri-tip
mkloomi at 9:07AM on 12/22/07
I like filet and the husband likes porterhouse or prime rib
jamie2005 at 9:09AM on 12/22/07
Porterhouse!
hank19 at 9:11AM on 12/22/07
Porterhouse well done = Yum Yum !!
adonica at 9:14AM on 12/22/07
Ribeye, charred rare.
cookbot at 9:15AM on 12/22/07
Porterhouse
garrettsambo at 9:17AM on 12/22/07
Porterhouse, med rare, with some aged balsamic. YUM
PICK ME!!!
ChrissyGotay at 9:18AM on 12/22/07
Prime Rib is my all-time favorite, but I pretty much like any good cut of steak!
luckyme at 9:19AM on 12/22/07
Filet Mignon - Medium Rare, want it whispering, not talking
Faither at 9:22AM on 12/22/07
Filet Mignon - medium
iagirl at 9:25AM on 12/22/07
It's a big T-Bone all the way.
tgcaros1 at 9:29AM on 12/22/07
Filet Mignon - Medium Well
rainbow33161 at 9:30AM on 12/22/07
definately Prime Rib
etrnlone at 9:31AM on 12/22/07
Filet Mignon! Thank you for this giveaway!
dglitter at 9:32AM on 12/22/07
porterhouse-well done.
theolotto at 9:33AM on 12/22/07
T-Bone Medium
saxel at 9:33AM on 12/22/07
T-bone. Yum!
susanchester at 9:34AM on 12/22/07
Tenderloin cut! Medium rare.
kvelchoff at 9:35AM on 12/22/07
porter in the house!
GarrettL at 9:38AM on 12/22/07
T-bone. It's got two steak tastes and, when no one's looking, you get to do some happy gnawing.
brooklyndoughnut at 9:40AM on 12/22/07
NY Strip steak
patty4899 at 9:40AM on 12/22/07
sirlion rules--all the others are too expensive or too tough
lindoksu at 9:41AM on 12/22/07
Ribeye, medium rare and covered with salt!
Nesie at 9:42AM on 12/22/07
Beef tenderloin, medium rare. No matter how you cook it, it is fabulous!
Kilburd at 9:43AM on 12/22/07
Prime rib, filet mignon.
ruthing73 at 9:45AM on 12/22/07
Ribeye medium well done.
rainbow33161 at 9:45AM on 12/22/07
Filets. But really, I love it all! YUM.
jdawn at 9:46AM on 12/22/07
Boy, I 'm a Bklyn girl and I really miss this restaurant.
Sunshine37 at 9:46AM on 12/22/07
Porterhouse for me!
lkmalm at 9:47AM on 12/22/07
rib-eye medium rare
fostertam at 9:48AM on 12/22/07
Porgerhouse is my favorite!
maddgiggler at 9:49AM on 12/22/07
Medium t-bone grilled to perfection with just a touch of lea and perrins steak sauce and I would be in food dream heaven.
slcrose at 9:55AM on 12/22/07
Well-marbled T-bone, lightly marinated and BBQ'd on the grill. It's 9 a.m. and I'm already hungry for a good steak!
whirliebyrd at 9:56AM on 12/22/07
Rib eye is the best.
younguntwo at 9:58AM on 12/22/07
Steak! I LOVE steak! Fillet Mignon...Prime Rib...Porterhouse...Rib Eye...Shell Steak...Flank steak rolls...guess who's hungry!
karilly at 9:59AM on 12/22/07
Prime Rib, End cut MMMMM
suprizeme at 10:01AM on 12/22/07
Filet Mignon
pamcallahan at 10:08AM on 12/22/07
tenderloin
nancy1 at 10:08AM on 12/22/07
I couldn't turn down a good steak. I really love the filet mignon cut because it is so tender and so flavorful. Serve it medium rare, with a baked potato, and I'm at the table!
fatitalianbroad at 10:10AM on 12/22/07
Ribeye first, Tbone second.
AmyInCleburne at 10:10AM on 12/22/07
I love all steaks, but if I had to pick one, it would be Porterhouse.
kwenzel at 10:11AM on 12/22/07
ribeye
pantherpaw at 10:12AM on 12/22/07
I love the rib eye
lavatn at 10:13AM on 12/22/07
T-bone all the way.
JohnB at 10:14AM on 12/22/07
ribeye medium rare
ride&cook at 10:18AM on 12/22/07
filet mignon
hansenpj5 at 10:19AM on 12/22/07
Prime rib
taintnoflatlander at 10:20AM on 12/22/07
New York Strip is my favorite steak, with filet mignon a close second.
Quarryrat at 10:20AM on 12/22/07
New York Strip
Starshine3 at 10:23AM on 12/22/07
Filet Mignon
sharlen523 at 10:28AM on 12/22/07
Filet mignon with my special marinade, rare of course
nsunchaser at 10:29AM on 12/22/07
Porterhouse, please.
dimsumfan at 10:30AM on 12/22/07
filet mignon done medium rare with a bernaise sauce is to die for!
katmagick at 10:30AM on 12/22/07
Anything from a Kobe
dsja761 at 10:30AM on 12/22/07
Filet Mignon
timberlea at 10:33AM on 12/22/07
Filet mignon for me, Porterhouse for the hubby.
jcamp2020 at 10:34AM on 12/22/07
porter house
jtwark at 10:38AM on 12/22/07
A good Porterhouse is hard to beat!!
buck38 at 10:40AM on 12/22/07
Ribeye
jcool at 10:46AM on 12/22/07
I love a good porterhouse medium rare
jpark107 at 10:51AM on 12/22/07
PORTERHOUSE
sunlife9 at 10:53AM on 12/22/07
defintely filet!
sarahbethe at 10:53AM on 12/22/07
T bone well done
gjobanion at 10:53AM on 12/22/07
I'll go with New York Strip
BoPeep at 10:53AM on 12/22/07
Rib eye, Love that marbled fat!
portagerose at 10:56AM on 12/22/07
Center cut well done and lean
Robert Wall at 10:56AM on 12/22/07
Still a bone in rib eye, medium rare.
Rookiecook at 10:58AM on 12/22/07
i love prime rib!!!!>>> but it sounds like any Peter Luger steak would be wonderful!!!! Thank you for the contest and Happy Holidays to all!!
theflyingacc at 10:58AM on 12/22/07
porterhouse
jbernet at 11:01AM on 12/22/07
Porterhouse steak
toostressed at 11:04AM on 12/22/07
I like Porterhouse the best.
drala625 at 11:11AM on 12/22/07
bacon wrapped filet mignon
dakotamoon at 11:13AM on 12/22/07
New York Strip
QuantDug at 11:16AM on 12/22/07
Just thinking about Peter Luger's steaks makes my mouth water. What a great treat!
JMCilento at 11:21AM on 12/22/07
T-Bone that way I get 2 good cuts. Including the porterhouse.
vibrantfun at 11:21AM on 12/22/07
Ribeye-rare!
josiern at 11:22AM on 12/22/07
marbled ribeye smoked with pecan wood
pep007 at 11:22AM on 12/22/07
I think Ribeyes rock!!!!! I just love the taste of a ribeye steak with mushrooms and a big baked potato with butter and sour cream. This is the closest thing to heaven that I have experienced. I just love it but only get to indulge in this a few times annually.
kimber37 at 11:25AM on 12/22/07
Bone-in Rib Eye. Oh yes!
Tonecat at 11:27AM on 12/22/07
Porterhouse for me yumm!
judycc at 11:30AM on 12/22/07
I like a NY Strip, but those Porterhouses are making my mouth water.
htabony at 11:30AM on 12/22/07
Prime Rib when it's done to perfection. Second favorite is rib-eye. Thanks for the opportunity to win delicious Peter Luger steaks!! :-)
TNShadyLady at 11:31AM on 12/22/07
New York Strip, rare.
dadekian at 11:32AM on 12/22/07
Filet Mignon tops the list, but Filet Strips are delish as well.
pancak at 11:33AM on 12/22/07
Give me a medium rare ribeye any day!
babsysmithy at 11:34AM on 12/22/07
Fave has be aged filet....done up Ruths' Chris style......hands down the best
mkboldin at 11:34AM on 12/22/07
Steak - always a good choice not matter what the cut.
If I'm using the grill - I like to marinate rib eyes. If I'm
using the oven - the prime rib.
elizannsmith at 11:40AM on 12/22/07
Tenderloin filet browned in an iron skillet, then finished off in a hot oven. Yummy!
dolichosd at 11:42AM on 12/22/07
Grilled ribeye!!! : - )
mdashkin at 11:42AM on 12/22/07
My favorite is a medium rare porterhouse---nice and thick cooked over charcoal on the grill.
Suekey at 11:43AM on 12/22/07
NY Strip
ScotSpiwak at 11:52AM on 12/22/07
A medium filet mignon just hits the spot!
debwaits at 11:54AM on 12/22/07
NY STRIP
tisaynababae at 11:54AM on 12/22/07
New York Strip is tops but any steak that is cut/prepared well is just as yummy.
AmeRayn at 11:55AM on 12/22/07
peter luger was my favorite resturant when i was growing up. a nice thick new your strip was always my favorite. and stiil is.
bonnieann at 11:57AM on 12/22/07
bleu cheese stuffed, bacon wrapped filet mignon.
weeblet at 11:57AM on 12/22/07
porterhouse
tv8688 at 11:58AM on 12/22/07
Bacon wrapped filet migon with bearnaise sauce.On the rare side of course.
dove1960 at 11:58AM on 12/22/07
Porterhouser - RARE!!
spazgrrl at 12:00PM on 12/22/07
NY Strip Medium
lisacb at 12:01PM on 12/22/07
Filet Mignon
jplooster at 12:01PM on 12/22/07
Ribeye is so tasty!
poorkarla at 12:07PM on 12/22/07
My favorite is definately Bone-in Ribeye
thecrzygrk at 12:07PM on 12/22/07
Mama likes Prime Rib, Medium Rare, with horseradish.
redfantum at 12:07PM on 12/22/07
Porterhouse, medium rare
majorpj2 at 12:09PM on 12/22/07
Ny Strip
hoping4amiracle at 12:12PM on 12/22/07
NY strip
psychsarah at 12:13PM on 12/22/07
I would have to say that Porterhouse of T-bone are my all-time favorites. They are the best for grilling or broiling and if cooked a perfect medium rare, are unsurpassed in flavor!
kathyb53 at 12:14PM on 12/22/07
Filet mignon, rare. Yum.
mkmarl01 at 12:16PM on 12/22/07
It's got to be a Ribeye!
Risingstar at 12:22PM on 12/22/07
FILET MIGNON
lasky at 12:24PM on 12/22/07
PORTERHOUSE ALL THE WAY-OOOOOHH!
kellyc442 at 12:26PM on 12/22/07
I like ribeye
bison61 at 12:27PM on 12/22/07
filet mignon
SharonHauser at 12:57PM on 12/22/07
filet
leeann777 at 12:58PM on 12/22/07
strip, rare
winslow at 1:00PM on 12/22/07
We have a winner!
And it's ... PATTYCHO. Someone from Serious Eats will be contacting you shortly for shipping info.
Adam Kuban at 2:42PM on 01/02/08