Seriously Delicious Holiday Giveaway: Two Peter Luger Steaks
Today we're giving away a package of two prime, dry-aged ("longer than four weeks") porterhouse steaks, thanks to the generous folks at Peter Luger. These steaks are not small. Each weighs more than two pounds. The steaks come with two bottles of Peter Luger steak sauce and a bag of chocolate coins.
To win, just answer this in the comments below: What's your favorite cut of steak?
You have until noon ET tomorrow (Saturday, December 1) to enter. One winner will be chosen at random from among the commenters. The standard Serious Eats contest rules apply.
PS: If you just can't wait for this contest to be over and want to order steaks right now from Peter Luger, you may do so here. You will make any serious carnivores on your list very happy.
Comments are closed: 359 Comments:
How convenient. Porterhouse.
Mike Sula at 12:44PM on 11/30/07
New York Strip medium-rare!
Jennefur at 12:45PM on 11/30/07
porterhouse
chestnutflour at 12:46PM on 11/30/07
Ribeye, but I'll be happy to take those Porterhouses off your hands
Pupster at 12:46PM on 11/30/07
T-bone! Peter Luger's is my favorite place for steak. yummmm.
girlrobot at 12:48PM on 11/30/07
New York Strip, Medium. I love the filet as well, but not as much flavor as the strip.
Chris78 at 12:48PM on 11/30/07
Filet!
GoldenEel at 12:49PM on 11/30/07
Porterhouse of course.
aannaa at 12:49PM on 11/30/07
Ribeyeporterhousesirloinfiletmignonchickenfriedcubeflankstrip.
Is that cheating?
rps at 12:49PM on 11/30/07
seriouseats == psychic, my favorite cut is porterhouse!
damnlamb at 12:50PM on 11/30/07
Ribeye - somewhere between Bleu and Medium Rare :)
jpschust at 12:51PM on 11/30/07
I'm a porterhouse girl because of Peter Luger!
therealpotato at 12:52PM on 11/30/07
Filet.
EmilySC at 12:53PM on 11/30/07
Nothing creative here....porterhouse as well.
njt207 at 12:54PM on 11/30/07
A ribeye steak with a huge rib bone sticking out so I feel like a real carnivore.
iracane at 12:54PM on 11/30/07
I love a good bone-in ribeye, but there isn't really a bad cut.
TheJTrain at 12:56PM on 11/30/07
Porterhouse for the win.
Pezdro at 12:56PM on 11/30/07
Ribeye!!
danie1 at 12:56PM on 11/30/07
The steaks may not be small, but I am. But I still bet I can eat a whole one in one meal. My vote is Strip because that's what I usually order. People look at you strangely if you're a girl and you order a Porterhouse, then come the questions - are you really going to eat all that? I bet you won't be able to finish that. What, you? So small and ordering such a big steak? Yeah, just shut up and gimme the meat.
rockandroller at 12:56PM on 11/30/07
Ugg my stomach is growling!
angelaandmelos at 12:57PM on 11/30/07
Ribeye
aungeinphx at 12:58PM on 11/30/07
I actually like chuck because I love a good beef bourguignon made with one full bottle of wine.
mayam at 12:58PM on 11/30/07
The Porterhouse is where it's at.
jayfallon at 12:58PM on 11/30/07
Porterhouse!
robnolen at 12:58PM on 11/30/07
New York Strip - medium rare with a nice crusty sear. Mmmmm
jcleffie at 12:59PM on 11/30/07
I like a good Porterhouse, but filet mignon is the winner, hands down. I'll still take those Porterhouses off your hands though!
janjan at 1:00PM on 11/30/07
I'm going to be a weirdo- I really like flank steak.
negociants at 1:01PM on 11/30/07
Porterhouse
jebphillips at 1:01PM on 11/30/07
I second the vote for ribeyeporterhousesirloinfiletmignonchickenfriedcubeflankstrip
seyo at 1:01PM on 11/30/07
Ribeye. But I'll sheepishly admit I've never had a porterhouse :(
digitalburro at 1:02PM on 11/30/07
Bone-in ribeye, Fred Flintstone-sized!
Greyhoundgrrl at 1:04PM on 11/30/07
if I had to stake
my life on a steak
and not be a flake
make no mistake
what takes the cake
what makes me quake
and salivate
is nake-
d
rib
eye
Karen Resta at 1:04PM on 11/30/07
New York Strip, rare.
dadekian at 1:04PM on 11/30/07
Definitely the Porterhouse, served Pittsburgh style or Black and Blue and shared with good company.
OneEyedMan at 1:06PM on 11/30/07
Ribeye.
ConschBTJ at 1:06PM on 11/30/07
My favorite cut of steak is a medium rare (more on the rare side) filet, with crumbled blue cheese on the side.
malpal at 1:07PM on 11/30/07
ribeye
addROC at 1:08PM on 11/30/07
Porterhouse - medium rare
ayyappan at 1:09PM on 11/30/07
ribeye with the bone, rare
tenpointfarmer at 1:09PM on 11/30/07
A Cowboy Ribeye - Medium Rare. Delish!
AliKat at 1:11PM on 11/30/07
Ribeye, medium rare, no sauce or anything to interrupt the pure flavor of quality beef.
iWander at 1:11PM on 11/30/07
Porterhouse, mmm yeah
curmudgeon at 1:11PM on 11/30/07
Porterhouse.z
SelimaCat at 1:12PM on 11/30/07
The porterhouse is the best, but it's also expensive, so I usually go for ribeye.
threedogkitchen at 1:13PM on 11/30/07
Bone in ny strip.
ChiefHDB at 1:15PM on 11/30/07
New york strip...medium rare!
jknepfle at 1:15PM on 11/30/07
Ribeye, medium rare
bytemyfoot at 1:15PM on 11/30/07
Where's the love for neglected meats? I'll go with a hanger steak anytime (med-rare, of course).
glutton at 1:17PM on 11/30/07
if i'm cooking at home, i adore skirt or hangar. at a steakhouse, bring on the ribeye!
cybercita at 1:17PM on 11/30/07
i loooooooooooove dry age porterhouse steak!!!!!!
kkkookie at 1:17PM on 11/30/07
NY strip rare
JerzeeTomato at 1:18PM on 11/30/07
porterhouse
sodapopinski at 1:18PM on 11/30/07
filet all the way :)
talida at 1:19PM on 11/30/07
Ribeye
jboylee at 1:19PM on 11/30/07
A nice, medium-rare (more on the rare side) NY strip. Yum
sjpober
sjpober at 1:20PM on 11/30/07
ribeye!
deadhead22 at 1:21PM on 11/30/07
Filet, medium rare with melted blue cheese....but I love all steak (just not equally)
swimlej at 1:21PM on 11/30/07
Ribeye medium rare all the way!!!! makes my mouth water just thinkin about it!!!!!
bespo81 at 1:21PM on 11/30/07
Filet
Noodler at 1:22PM on 11/30/07
new york strip, medium rare
mrsbao at 1:22PM on 11/30/07
Ribeye in all it's fatty meaty flavorful glory!
orinky at 1:23PM on 11/30/07
filet medium rare
eel28 at 1:23PM on 11/30/07
Mmmm... definitely filet.
brandi at 1:24PM on 11/30/07
I love a great Ribeye!
sauerkrautball at 1:24PM on 11/30/07
Ribeye!
omnivore at 1:25PM on 11/30/07
Ribeye, medium rare!
brandonphx at 1:27PM on 11/30/07
Filet Mignon will always by my favorite cut of steak, But it has to be prepared right, and of course be Medium Rare!!
teeny at 1:27PM on 11/30/07
i don't have a favorite, i'm not picky when it comes to steak, i like it most any way it's served.
j at 1:27PM on 11/30/07
A Brazilian cut called Picana.
meredith at 1:27PM on 11/30/07
A big juicy ribeye, cooked no more than medium rare, with good char. I also love porterhouse but it's harder to find and more expensive. Mmmm!
Cindy at 1:28PM on 11/30/07
bone in rib eye
Alm25 at 1:28PM on 11/30/07
Filet medium rare, preferably bacon wrapped.
katalia at 1:29PM on 11/30/07
Bone-in ribeye
Catherine at 1:29PM on 11/30/07
Filet med-rare
kelboyd at 1:30PM on 11/30/07
another ribeye fan, though i wouldn't say no to a ny strip
disgustingfoodie at 1:31PM on 11/30/07
Onglet/hanger for me, please. Medium rare. With a side of frites.
wendywoowho at 1:31PM on 11/30/07
I'll have to let you know after you send me those steaks.
Heh heh heh.
jpolk at 1:32PM on 11/30/07
Ribeye, served medium, yum! Porterhouse is a very close second though. If more places could cook it properly I'd probably get it more often :-)
sylphon at 1:32PM on 11/30/07
Bone in ribeye, cooked over wood
ErikaK at 1:34PM on 11/30/07
Porterhouse, it's the carnivore's equivalent to a ménage à trois.
CVilleBilly at 1:34PM on 11/30/07
Bone in Ribeye, coarse salt and pepper, seared on the hottest piece of cast iron i can get, delicious and amazing.
Of course I wouldn't complain about porterhouses or really any cut of steak ;)
Leviticus at 1:37PM on 11/30/07
FIlet or marinated flank for me.
louweezy at 1:38PM on 11/30/07
Ribeye.
robotbill at 1:40PM on 11/30/07
Ribeye
mike777 at 1:41PM on 11/30/07
I love a rare porterhouse, but I sure wouldn't turn down a filet or ribeye.
Freyacat at 1:43PM on 11/30/07
it's lame, but i love a filet.
pfibiger at 1:43PM on 11/30/07
Definitely a porterhouse. Love it.
FoodBoy at 1:44PM on 11/30/07
Ribeye, for sure! Industrial size!
dallimomma at 1:45PM on 11/30/07
Mmmm...poooorterhouse....raaaaare
EmmaC at 1:46PM on 11/30/07
Ribeye, with the bone so I can gnaw on it like a troglodyte. Nice and crusty on the outside, with a warm pink center, topped with some sauteed mushrooms and some good blue cheese... arghhh, my stomach is rumbling!!
Welmoed at 1:46PM on 11/30/07
I love grilled flank steak. If I can't have that, my second choice would probably be a good ol rib eye.
lakeloverhh at 1:48PM on 11/30/07
Ribeye, rare
sjwoodin at 1:50PM on 11/30/07
First Porterhouse, then ny strip, then ribeye, then fillet, then the rest... medium rare of course.
garam_masala at 1:51PM on 11/30/07
New York strip, medium.
danwalk at 1:53PM on 11/30/07
If I have someone to share with porterhouse, all by myself ribeye. I love when there is slight charing on the outside and med-rare on the inside. mmmm mmmm good!
Sweetie at 1:54PM on 11/30/07
fillet, medium
mmiller at 1:54PM on 11/30/07
It's a tie between beef tenderloin and NY strip.
PattyCho at 1:55PM on 11/30/07
ribeye
Margherita at 1:56PM on 11/30/07
a steak haiku:
the perfect ribeye
blackened crust, ruby red meat --
i give a low moo of thanks
mightypow at 1:57PM on 11/30/07
dry aged NY strip a shade above rare GRASS FED if possible mmmmm
ayoungchef at 1:58PM on 11/30/07
I do love a fillet, but really I'm ordering a ribeye if I'm ordering a steak.
MissFive at 1:59PM on 11/30/07
T-bone has all the parts I love! A restaurant her in Portland (Toro Bravo) has a coppa steak that I am also enamored with but I'm not sure where he's exactly cutting that puppy off.
tastyvittles at 2:02PM on 11/30/07
ny strip
ceforrester at 2:04PM on 11/30/07
Bone in filet
thotfulspot at 2:04PM on 11/30/07
ribeye
rowenamontoya at 2:07PM on 11/30/07
A bone in ribeye medium rare. Oh that marbled fatty collar! I supose I could choke down a couple of those porterhouses though. Thanks for the chance!
Colorado Jim at 2:07PM on 11/30/07
bone in ribeye
intheyearofthepig at 2:09PM on 11/30/07
Hanger steak or flank steak
alternatekev at 2:11PM on 11/30/07
Can't go wrong with a medium rare ribeye!
pupilindenial at 2:11PM on 11/30/07
NY Strip, always, perfect balance of tenderness and flavor. Medium-rare. Yum.
jd7979 at 2:12PM on 11/30/07
test
badnewsbunny at 2:12PM on 11/30/07
Ribeye. However, Porterhouses aren't too shabby either.
chefuu at 2:13PM on 11/30/07
Bone in ribeye. Yum.
Library Lady at 2:13PM on 11/30/07
NY Strip - med rare. sorry, but I love it.
artybastard at 2:14PM on 11/30/07
Rib eye!
CheesePlease at 2:14PM on 11/30/07
flank!
gkang at 2:14PM on 11/30/07
New York Strip
tsegada at 2:15PM on 11/30/07
porterhouse!
hilarybrooke at 2:16PM on 11/30/07
porterhouse
chinois at 2:16PM on 11/30/07
I'll go with filet.
jlouise210 at 2:16PM on 11/30/07
mmm...flank or flatiron, grilled medium rare.
lemonnut at 2:16PM on 11/30/07
Ribeye!
etyper333 at 2:16PM on 11/30/07
It just depends on the beef. Really good, aged, well-marbled prime? New York Strip, all the time. Questionable, or lower-grade/less marbled beef? Filet mignon. It's just more dependable.
epicure at 2:18PM on 11/30/07
flank - grilled. in the summer!
eoporto at 2:18PM on 11/30/07
bone-in ribeye
maialisa at 2:19PM on 11/30/07
Filet.
mistyp at 2:22PM on 11/30/07
New York strip is the best!!
Lavendergirl at 2:24PM on 11/30/07
ribeye!
the_o at 2:24PM on 11/30/07
sirloin
dikaryon at 2:25PM on 11/30/07
Filet.
bobbob at 2:25PM on 11/30/07
Cowboy ribeye, bloody.
Chew that bugger right off the bone!
sheldel at 2:26PM on 11/30/07
porterhouse and new york strip.
miriamo at 2:28PM on 11/30/07
ribeye if I'm not buying. If I am buying I do love both the flat iron steak and the onglet.
arbeck at 2:28PM on 11/30/07
porterhouse - the best of both worlds.
modernemama at 2:28PM on 11/30/07
Bone-in Ribeye.....rare
Leann C at 2:28PM on 11/30/07
Post above me has it right!
cmballa at 2:29PM on 11/30/07
Ribeye, rare from Del Frisco's
salty_sticky at 2:29PM on 11/30/07
porterhouse. a little on the bloody side.
pdc at 2:29PM on 11/30/07
Dry aged bone-in ribeye. Medium rare. Healthy amount of charring. Well salted. Nothing else. Bone-in is key for the most flavor
chaevans at 2:30PM on 11/30/07
Boring, but filet for the win!
darth_kittius at 2:31PM on 11/30/07
porterhouse, just shy of medium rare.
skim at 2:32PM on 11/30/07
A rare-cooked rib steak, seared over the bbq.
thompsrr at 2:33PM on 11/30/07
porterhouse
greg24 at 2:34PM on 11/30/07
Ribeye
schopie1 at 2:36PM on 11/30/07
prime rib eye
casualpmc at 2:37PM on 11/30/07
medium rare
Jason L at 2:37PM on 11/30/07
Porterhouse! Woot!
Urbanaus at 2:38PM on 11/30/07
ribeye please...
meesh430 at 2:38PM on 11/30/07
Porterhouse
sgrodnick at 2:38PM on 11/30/07
Ribeye, medium rare.
ebraun at 2:40PM on 11/30/07
Thick cut rib eye!
kitchenninja at 2:43PM on 11/30/07
Skirt steak medium rare with salt and lots of black pepper!!
Michele817 at 2:44PM on 11/30/07
Rrrrribeye!
indiemaven at 2:45PM on 11/30/07
Filet Mignon-medium. But maybe thats because I haven't had a good porterhouse yet.
googy at 2:46PM on 11/30/07
bone-in ribeye
munkicat at 2:47PM on 11/30/07
bife de lomo!
emmettjez at 2:47PM on 11/30/07
a porterhouse that is still quivering.
Soup_Dumpling at 2:48PM on 11/30/07
Rare strip with blue cheese on top.
but...
Around our house with the budget in mind we all enjoy a *gulp* round steak baked in the oven with a tin of whole tomatoes poured on top.
Does round steak even really count?
Urban Mom at 2:48PM on 11/30/07
ribeye
tacopants at 2:49PM on 11/30/07
Porterhouse for two– for just me!
(still bleeding)
superdlux at 2:52PM on 11/30/07
ny strip
fleurdesel at 2:54PM on 11/30/07
Porterhouse -- rare.
KansasNate at 2:57PM on 11/30/07
Porterhouse. Or anything Kobe.
msecondo at 2:57PM on 11/30/07
bone-in rib-eye mmmmm
jjkim34 at 2:58PM on 11/30/07
T-bone
beanish at 3:00PM on 11/30/07
Ribeye medium-rare...but I'd love some porterhouse too!
annerska at 3:01PM on 11/30/07
Flank steak, stuffed and rolled and braised.
doglover at 3:01PM on 11/30/07
Without a doubt, ribeye. Medium rare. Perfect seasoned with only a little salt and pepper, but also great with a little melted butter and mushrooms. Or a red wine and shallot sauce. Mmmmm, steak...
ladyfunk25 at 3:03PM on 11/30/07
Filet mignon - medium well - but a nice marinated and grilled flank steak is great too!
risha109 at 3:03PM on 11/30/07
I really like a nice ribeye.
Bosmer at 3:05PM on 11/30/07
Filet mignon done medium
zekks at 3:07PM on 11/30/07
Mmmm, steak! I went there for my fiftieth birthday and survived the delicious porterhouse rare. I did skip the bacon appetizer, however.
My father was worried, since none of us wanted dessert, that they wouldn't be able to sing to me. Our server was up to the challenge -- brought a bowl of whipped cream with candles in it.
floretbroc at 3:07PM on 11/30/07
flank, grilled just for an instant!
kylad at 3:08PM on 11/30/07
Ribeye.
bluebird at 3:08PM on 11/30/07
Porterhouse from a chianina to make the most phenomenal bistecca alla fiorentina!!
linda at 3:12PM on 11/30/07
bone-in ribeye--medium
sixearls at 3:14PM on 11/30/07
Ribeye.
sarahinnewyork at 3:14PM on 11/30/07
NY Strip, rare.
sarajane at 3:15PM on 11/30/07
Ribeye, medium rare.
rachaeltb at 3:15PM on 11/30/07
Porterhouse
sln123 at 3:15PM on 11/30/07
I loves me some hanger.
meganfra at 3:20PM on 11/30/07
Porterhouse, rareish.
ajeys at 3:23PM on 11/30/07
Ribeye is the best.
daleyes at 3:24PM on 11/30/07
Hanger!! Rare of Course...
MikeR999 at 3:25PM on 11/30/07
Medium-rare ribeye
NSW at 3:26PM on 11/30/07
Ribeye
lavenhouse at 3:33PM on 11/30/07
Porterhouse:)
jhoefl88 at 3:34PM on 11/30/07
T-bone!
priscilla at 3:34PM on 11/30/07
flank steak - bloody on my plate! yum! :)
stephanieb at 3:38PM on 11/30/07
flank steak. or rib-eye
ntyracademy at 3:38PM on 11/30/07
rib-eye or skirt steak if im feeling cheap.
daryck at 3:44PM on 11/30/07
I like tri-tip because it is mysterious and elusive.
audrey at 3:48PM on 11/30/07
Ribeye, medium rare
Lyds1 at 3:50PM on 11/30/07
I'll third the ribeyeporterhousesirloinfiletmignonchickenfriedcubeflankstrip....
as rare as you can make it!
mepolo at 3:50PM on 11/30/07
I had a great flank steak once, properly marinated in a red wine/blue cheese marinade and done on a grill -- rare! Lovely eating with red wine.
hungrylikethewolf at 3:51PM on 11/30/07
ribeye, cooked medium-rare
katief at 3:51PM on 11/30/07
Gotta love the porterhouse
Eroca at 3:54PM on 11/30/07
Ribeye!
Bob Brooks at 3:56PM on 11/30/07
flank!
tortor at 3:56PM on 11/30/07
hanger steak, soaked in beer overnight and grilled rare, ummm steak
jamesl8n at 3:57PM on 11/30/07
Hanger.
stu_spivac at 3:57PM on 11/30/07
Ribeye
cupbaker at 3:57PM on 11/30/07
I'm a big ribeye fan myself...but porterhouse will do the trick in this case!
darronvigs24 at 3:58PM on 11/30/07
It feels so....typical. But I cannot tell a lie: I adore filet.
When filet doesn't fit into my budget, I go for the lesser-known baseball steak.
denaluna at 4:01PM on 11/30/07
I adore a tender filet. :)
feriorrenna at 4:02PM on 11/30/07
Porterhouse of course!
awtane at 4:02PM on 11/30/07
I love a good filet mignon, nice and thick and barely licked by a flame...
lo82070 at 4:04PM on 11/30/07
Porterhouse is the King of Steaks.
outsidecounsel at 4:04PM on 11/30/07
ribeye
mazzio at 4:05PM on 11/30/07
Prime aged Kansas City Strip Medium Rare. For those who have
ventured yet to Long Beach's 555 Steakhouse, this is a bone in
New York Strip. Nothing like it especially accompanied by a bottle
Silver Oak Cabernet Sauvingon.
hermanb at 4:05PM on 11/30/07
Filetttttttt -- but who can say no to Peter Luger??
kfarrel3 at 4:07PM on 11/30/07
Porterhouse.
jstanisic at 4:08PM on 11/30/07
Ribeye or New York Strip
gameport at 4:10PM on 11/30/07
Gotta go Poerhouse to share
stlyankfan at 4:11PM on 11/30/07
Bone-in ribeye.
ndg2008 at 4:13PM on 11/30/07
I like a good filet, medium rare, but my husband prefers the bone-in ribeye. There have been a few times that I've preferred his steak over mine :)
Jeana at 4:17PM on 11/30/07
onglet (hanger) steak
purpleceline at 4:18PM on 11/30/07
Strip. Medium rare with a great crust.
tkln at 4:19PM on 11/30/07
porterhouse, medium rare, with nothing but a little salt and pepper.
HillaryE at 4:21PM on 11/30/07
filet mignon, portherhouse
Marilyn at 4:22PM on 11/30/07
flank
0bs01337 at 4:24PM on 11/30/07
Filet Mignon for me - about 10 oz; ribeye for my darling wife Linda (31 yrs married - yes, I am OLD)
incipitur6 at 4:25PM on 11/30/07
gotta go with porterhouse
martyweiss at 4:29PM on 11/30/07
Porterhouse and NY Strip
rugbyspartan at 4:31PM on 11/30/07
Wow, those steaks look fabulous. Love sirloin medium /well on our grill, also filet (butterflied . We haven't had a porterhouse in ages, sure it would be g-r-e-a-t!
elaine nan at 4:32PM on 11/30/07
porterhouse
foodinmouth at 4:34PM on 11/30/07
Strip Steak - best mix of flavor and tenderness
thebigguy at 4:36PM on 11/30/07
Like the other weirdo I saw above, I like flank steak. I don't know why, but it always seems to come out great when I make it.
peachfish at 4:38PM on 11/30/07
my favorite is rib eye.
Sumintra at 4:38PM on 11/30/07
of course..porterhouse!..rare
reds at 4:45PM on 11/30/07
ribeye, medium rare, of course!
chairmantao at 4:45PM on 11/30/07
Porterhouse, always!
Michele811 at 4:46PM on 11/30/07
My favorite cut has to be ribeye.
philfna at 4:46PM on 11/30/07
Porterhouse
Belyna at 4:47PM on 11/30/07
Has to be bone-in ribeye
Tender, flavorful and delicious
kimblyl at 4:54PM on 11/30/07
The best steak I ever had was a flat iron.
palmsey at 4:55PM on 11/30/07
I have to admit that I've always liked Roumanian-style strip steak -- although I am also partial to ribeye and a nce sirloin. Filet Mignon is OK, but never seems to be as flavorful (hmmm, nice beefy yummyness!)
Stushi at 4:56PM on 11/30/07
Porterhouse.
schnitzel at 4:58PM on 11/30/07
Porterhouse
cannatar at 4:59PM on 11/30/07
Filet, baby...
film_score at 5:00PM on 11/30/07
bone in filet
SkinnyFatty at 5:05PM on 11/30/07
ribeye
chungle at 5:14PM on 11/30/07
porterhouse, two steaks in one.
logicalmind at 5:16PM on 11/30/07
New York Strip
alphabeta at 5:18PM on 11/30/07
How is this for original, Porterhouse medium rare! With nice age on it of course! Funk is a good thing.
baustin at 5:20PM on 11/30/07
Porterhouse. So it's not original. So sue me. But not until I've finished my steak.
cjstephens at 5:24PM on 11/30/07
Filet yo
JP001 at 5:29PM on 11/30/07
hanger steak, bloody
themanoffish at 5:33PM on 11/30/07
Ribeye, 2 inches thick, on the bone.
Oakland Aaron at 5:40PM on 11/30/07
New York strip, hands down.
billstickers at 5:42PM on 11/30/07
Definitely Rib-eye.
pemabuk at 5:47PM on 11/30/07
Bistecca Fiorentino Basically a porterhouse
vbm at 5:49PM on 11/30/07
NY Strip medium rare w/ crispy frites
jlipof at 5:51PM on 11/30/07
a nice 2" porterhouse. it is the best of both worlds!!
iguanablue at 6:02PM on 11/30/07
prime rib for me!!! yum
PoignantTuna at 6:03PM on 11/30/07
Ribeye. Pure deliciousness.
heartquake at 6:10PM on 11/30/07
Cow. Still mooing, please.
JohnGalt at 6:11PM on 11/30/07
Grilled flank steak - sliced thin.
gregsmom at 6:14PM on 11/30/07
Filet - but i have not tried a porterhouse
jenntx at 6:16PM on 11/30/07
ribeye
thegreatlumpia at 6:16PM on 11/30/07
Everyone agrees that Papaya King's hot dogs are tastier than filet mignon, but does anyone else admit that hanger steak is tastier than both? It's my favorite.
Lippy at 6:30PM on 11/30/07
Filet mignon, but I'm not really one to complain about the cut as long as it's juicy and flavorful!
bobcatsteph3 at 6:30PM on 11/30/07
New York Strip, please, yesss
beeje11 at 6:31PM on 11/30/07
A thick, juicy filet -- rare, please -- with just a pat of butter on top and a light sprinkling of kosher salt.
And can I just state for the record how thrilled I am that there have been no troglodytic mentions of "well-done" among the comments? Thank God!
sheeats at 6:32PM on 11/30/07
Filet Mignon
redrover at 6:36PM on 11/30/07
Bone in Strip Steak
Billf at 6:46PM on 11/30/07
Porterhouse, period.
toolminer at 6:50PM on 11/30/07
t-bone!
mozart23 at 7:03PM on 11/30/07
Porterhouse.
gscherr at 7:05PM on 11/30/07
porterhouse
GarrettL at 7:19PM on 11/30/07
rib-eye, for sure.
ag3208 at 7:29PM on 11/30/07
Tenderlion baby! Grilled medium with a blue cheese sauce or just salt and pepper!
rockymountainmarta at 7:31PM on 11/30/07
porterhouse, black and blue
malokd at 7:31PM on 11/30/07
I have to go with porterhouse... though a good rib roast comes a close second
promiscuouscitrus at 7:33PM on 11/30/07
The fillet portion of a porterhouse. It just tastes better when cooked on the bone.
jaybomb at 7:39PM on 11/30/07
rib-eye
izzy's mama at 7:44PM on 11/30/07
giant porterhouse!
salty at 7:45PM on 11/30/07
Ribeye or maybe a really good brisket.
Anomaly at 7:47PM on 11/30/07
ribeye, bone in cooked over charcoal till just medium rare.
barfly at 7:47PM on 11/30/07
Ribeye rare!
badgerfan at 7:56PM on 11/30/07
Ribeye.
wgsims at 8:01PM on 11/30/07
Rare, bone-in ribeye, please. Thank you.
SunnysideUp at 8:02PM on 11/30/07
ribeye medium rare ,preferably grilled over charcoal .
peticook at 8:02PM on 11/30/07
Please, sir, what's steak?
Alll we ever get is gruel.
Sure could go for some porterhouse!
Eliz. at 8:02PM on 11/30/07
Which ever one I happen to be eating at the time.
Ribeye would be my first choice though.
windjunkie at 8:05PM on 11/30/07
Filet mignon because it was served at the banquet at the centennial meeting of the American Ornithologists' Union, under the big blue whale in the Hall of Ocean Life at the American Museum of Natural History, and it was perfectly cooked and paired (tripleted?) with delicious broccoli and steamed rice and followed by a divine chocolate mousse and is one of my best food memories EVAR.
mcmvox at 8:09PM on 11/30/07
A nice dry aged NY Strip Steak grilled to perfection
...little slice of heaven
tomriddle at 8:09PM on 11/30/07
ny strip, mmmmmmmm
ptovsti at 8:12PM on 11/30/07
Ribeye
billygoat at 8:13PM on 11/30/07
Filet
cher48603 at 8:17PM on 11/30/07
New York Strip grilled medium, mmm.
dna90048 at 8:22PM on 11/30/07
ribeye
kathyvegas at 8:23PM on 11/30/07
RIBEYE
puppychao at 8:28PM on 11/30/07
Ribeye.
dande at 8:37PM on 11/30/07
Filet Mignon
BarracudaRon007 at 8:39PM on 11/30/07
Porterhouse please.
lisapeet at 8:43PM on 11/30/07
Porterhouse for two
gwcafe at 8:44PM on 11/30/07
filet!
altopower at 8:49PM on 11/30/07
Filet mignon.. mmm mmm mmm
iheartnitz at 8:52PM on 11/30/07
Porterhouse. If you've got the steak, I've got the grill!
alden at 9:07PM on 11/30/07
My favorite cut is a bone-in Rib-eye, cooked rare.
Scoggdog at 9:09PM on 11/30/07
New York Strip, medium rare. Beautifully done at the Ringside in Portland, OR.
looloopoopie at 9:26PM on 11/30/07
New York strip!
kmnola at 9:29PM on 11/30/07
ribeye~
wwlui at 9:40PM on 11/30/07
New York Strip with salt and pepper.
dksbook at 9:42PM on 11/30/07
filet mignon for me, husband likes the new york strip (medium, please)
Our grill has been in our dining room for over 2 months for a deck repair, so
this would be great for the celebration once we get our deck back (and my
dining room too!)
papermonkey at 9:59PM on 11/30/07
A New York Strip Steak charbroiled on the outside & medium rare on the inside
joeyvalley at 10:08PM on 11/30/07
In this case, size matters...a 2 lb 'der porterhouse to share with your sweetee -YESSSSSSSS! My favorite!
kgereg at 10:13PM on 11/30/07
Bone-in rib-eye, any day!
ngaloppo at 10:16PM on 11/30/07
I love a big ol' flank steak, rubbed, cooked medium rare with a good sear on the outside, sliced thin. In the summer, with grilled corn, of course. Hm....or grilled asparagus. Or both. Sauce--not needed, but I don't object to a good chimichurri now and then.
antrobin at 10:16PM on 11/30/07
Can I be the 290th to say Porterhouse?!?
ghinson at 10:36PM on 11/30/07
A thick ribeye, medium rare!
amylou61 at 10:46PM on 11/30/07
Ribeye
gooseman at 10:46PM on 11/30/07
ribeye, i can't resist the beautiful marbling. people slice away the fat, i think it's what gives the piece of meat some character!
uninorth at 10:47PM on 11/30/07
A bone in rib-eye, medium rare.
Rookiecook at 10:56PM on 11/30/07
a nice thick filet, medium rare
pezbabypez at 11:14PM on 11/30/07
Bone-in ribeye, cut from the center of the primal--but a nice porterhouse ain't half bad.
AHR at 11:16PM on 11/30/07
chateaubriand done medium rare, that is a real treat.
sflaherty at 11:19PM on 11/30/07
Gosh, every cut has it's merits.... I usually end up eating the "cheap" cuts, so I've never fixed my own porterhouse. :-(
Josh Baugher at 11:25PM on 11/30/07
Argh, I can't choose. Just give me beef!
cairech at 11:33PM on 11/30/07
Oh gorgeous, I have so many favorites. If it's aged well and from a good cow, I do love a filet. Too often they aretastelyess, though. A ribeye is reliably good. But I also dig the chewiness of skirt or flatiron steak. I'm complicated.
theunemployedcook at 11:36PM on 11/30/07
Filet mignon but we a more economical bi-monthly flank steak so it's a toss up!
janetmoga at 11:37PM on 11/30/07
Ribeye, seasoned for two days before you serve it to let it dry a bit... oh goodness... but i'll be very much happy with those porterhouses
bobfole at 11:50PM on 11/30/07
I can't afford filet mignon or porterhouse, so I guess my favorite is a well marinated and properly grilled top round served as london broil.
JacktheCat at 11:54PM on 11/30/07
Bone-in Ribeye
FoodBully at 12:07AM on 12/01/07
New York Strip, medium rare
Tres2006 at 12:42AM on 12/01/07
Porterhouse, cooked rare to medium rare.
Nicholas H at 12:52AM on 12/01/07
Ribeye, with the bone
jdestes at 1:00AM on 12/01/07
My favorite cut of steak has always been the porterhouse. I love filet mignon also (that would be my second favorite) but porterhouse is King. I have had the pleasure of eating at Peter Lugar's and I had one of the all time best meals of my life...Porterhouse Steak, of course.
kristinemorawietz at 1:02AM on 12/01/07
my favorite cut of steak is any steak that i have eaten!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
kravman at 1:06AM on 12/01/07
Chateaubriand served medium
ohnofullmoon at 1:11AM on 12/01/07
I love the flavor and texture combination of the NY strip, dry-aged, and cooked medium.
cosmic charlie at 1:24AM on 12/01/07
porterhouse!!!!
platecleaner at 1:50AM on 12/01/07
If I'm paying for it, ribeye. If someone else is (ahem), porterhouse!
nokrapt at 2:28AM on 12/01/07
Ribeye and Porterhouse
tennesseegirlie at 2:42AM on 12/01/07
Filet
alsek at 3:18AM on 12/01/07
Ribeye, medium rare!
sw8t at 4:43AM on 12/01/07
Bone in ribeye!
lliang at 5:43AM on 12/01/07
New York strip, medium. Boneless.
njsmitty at 5:48AM on 12/01/07
t-bone well done
beadin at 6:22AM on 12/01/07
Yum. Meat. I love the "Fred Flintstone" feeling I get when I eat a Porterhouse. Oh, so good.
stacylyn at 6:46AM on 12/01/07
hanger steak!!
JJofWianno at 7:16AM on 12/01/07
Bone in Ribeye, Black&blue
bessfour at 7:23AM on 12/01/07
Porterhouse for 2 as served by PL
mlzeats at 7:59AM on 12/01/07
filet, m/r please thx u
goodbyeohio at 8:18AM on 12/01/07
Onglet, of course
Sigma_Greg at 8:50AM on 12/01/07
Ribeye
msboma at 8:54AM on 12/01/07
Bone in ribeye, right between medium rare and rare.
jamiesonm at 9:03AM on 12/01/07
Porterhouse!
mh330 at 9:43AM on 12/01/07
Porterhouse, porterhouse, porterhouse.
gidget at 9:48AM on 12/01/07
Porterhouse!
smorgen at 10:03AM on 12/01/07
Porterhouse, medium rare!
EatingInNYC at 10:13AM on 12/01/07
Ribeye!
violette at 10:20AM on 12/01/07
Porterhouse
JustinP at 10:47AM on 12/01/07
Mostly to be original-Shoulder!
michichan at 11:02AM on 12/01/07
Porterhouse!
yiwern at 11:15AM on 12/01/07
baseball cut...
mforrest at 11:16AM on 12/01/07
porterhouse
leecarter at 12:00PM on 12/01/07
We have a winner!
And it's ... mmiller. Someone from Serious Eats will be contacting you shortly for shipping info.
Thanks to everyone who commented, and tune in again later today and throughout New Year's Day for a contest each day.
Adam Kuban at 12:02PM on 12/01/07